Your Donations go to

Assist in the development aof programs to encourage a sustainable community

On this site you will find

Information on substance abuse, where to find help, street gangs, intel updates on the Mexican Drug Cartels, the most recent research and documents on multiple subjects as well as links to outside organizations and our partners along with much more.

December 2011
Meth in Mexico: A Turning Point in the Drug War?
December 22, 2011 | 1158 GMT
By Ben West | February 16, 2012
Security Weekly

Mexican authorities announced Feb. 8 the largest seizure of methamphetamine in Mexican history -- and possibly the largest ever anywhere -- on a ranch outside of Guadalajara. The total haul was 15 tons of pure methamphetamine along with a laboratory capable of producing all the methamphetamine seized. While authorities are not linking the methamphetamine to any specific criminal group, Guadalajara is a known stronghold of the Sinaloa Federation, and previous seizures there have been connected to the group.

Methamphetamine, a synthetic drug manufactured in personal labs for decades, is nothing new in Mexico or the United States. The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) has led numerous crusades against the drug, increasing regulations on its ingredients to try to keep it from gaining a foothold in the United States. While the DEA's efforts have succeeded in limiting production of the drug in the United States, consumption has risen steadily over the past two decades. The increasing DEA pressure on U.S. suppliers and the growing demand for methamphetamine have driven large-scale production of the drug outside the borders of the United States. Given Mexico's proximity and the pervasiveness of organized criminal elements seeking new markets, it makes sense that methamphetamine would be produced on an industrial scale there. Indeed, Mexico has provided an environment for a scale of production far greater than anything ever seen in the United States.

But last week's methamphetamine seizure sheds light on a deeper shift in organized criminal activity in Mexico -- one that could mark a breakthrough in the violent stalemate that has existed between the Sinaloa Federation, Los Zetas and the government for the past five years and has led to an estimated 50,000 deaths. It also reveals a pattern in North American organized crime activity that can be seen throughout the 20th century as well as a business opportunity that could transform criminal groups in Mexico from the drug trafficking intermediaries they are today to controllers of an independent and profitable illicit market.

While the trafficking groups in Mexico are commonly called "cartels" (even Stratfor uses the term), they are not really cartels. A cartel is a combination of groups cooperating to control the supply of a commodity. The primary purpose of a cartel is to set the price of a commodity so that buyers cannot negotiate lower prices. The current conflict in Mexico over cocaine and marijuana smuggling routes shows that there are deep rifts between rival groups like the Sinaloa Federation and Los Zetas. There is no sign that they are cooperating with each other to set the price of cocaine or marijuana. Also, since most of the Mexican criminal groups are involved in a diverse array of criminal activities, their interests go beyond drug trafficking. They are perhaps most accurately described as "transnational criminal organizations" (TCOs), the label currently favored by the DEA.

Examples from the Past

While the level of violence in Mexico right now is unprecedented, it is important to remember that the Mexican TCOs are businesses. They do use violence in conducting business, but their top priority is to make profits, not kill people. The history of organized crime shows many examples of groups engaging in violence to control an illegal product. During the early 20th century in North America, to take advantage of Prohibition in the United States, organized criminal empires were built around the bootlegging industry. After the repeal of Prohibition, gambling and casinos became the hot market. Control over Las Vegas and other major gambling hubs was a business both dangerous and profitable. Control over the U.S. heroin market was consolidated and then dismantled during the 1960s and 1970s. Then came cocaine and the rise in power, wealth and violence of Colombian groups like the Medellin and Cali cartels.

But as U.S. and Colombian law enforcement cracked down on the Colombian cartels -- interdicting them in Colombia and closing down their Caribbean smuggling corridors -- Colombian producers had to turn to the Mexicans to traffic cocaine through Mexico to the United States. To this day, however, Colombian criminal groups descended from the Medellin and Cali cartels control the cultivation and production of cocaine in South America, while Mexican groups increasingly oversee the trafficking of the drug to the United States, Europe and Africa.

The Mexican Weakness

While violence has been used in the past to eliminate or coerce competitors and physically take control of an illegal market, it has not proved to be a solution in recent years for Mexican TCOs. The Medellin cartel became infamous for attacking Colombian state officials and competitors who tried to weaken its grasp over the cocaine market. Going back further, Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel is thought to have been murdered over disagreements about his handling of the Flamingo Hotel in Las Vegas. Before that, Prohibition saw numerous murders over control of liquor shipments and territory. In Mexico, we are seeing an escalating level of such violence, but few of the business resolutions that would be expected to come about as a result.

Geography helps explain this. In Mexico, the Sierra Madre mountain range splits the east coast and the west from the center. The Gulf of Mexico and the Pacific Ocean coastal plains tend to develop their own power bases separate from each other.

Mexican drug traffickers are also split by market forces. With Colombian criminal groups still largely controlling the production of cocaine in jungle laboratories, Mexican traffickers are essentially middlemen. They must run the gauntlet of U.S.-led international interdiction efforts by using a combination of Central American traffickers, corruption and street-gang enforcers. They also have to move the cocaine across the U.S. border, where it gets distributed by hundreds of street gangs.

Profit is the primary motivation at every step, and each hurdle the Mexican traffickers have to clear cuts into their profit margins. The cocaine producers in Colombia, Peru and Bolivia can play the Sinaloa Federation and Los Zetas (as well as others) off of each other to strengthen their own bargaining position. And even though keeping the traffickers split appears to create massive amounts of violence in Mexico, it benefits the politicians and officials there, who can leverage at least the presence of a competitor for better bribes and payoffs.

For Mexican drug traffickers, competition is bad for the bottom line, since it allows other actors to exploit each side to get a larger share of the market. Essentially, everyone else in the cocaine market benefits by keeping the traffickers split. The more actors involved in cocaine trafficking, the harder it is to control it.

The Solution

Historically, organized criminal groups have relied on control of a market for their source of wealth and power. But the current situation in Mexico, and the cocaine trade in general, prevents the Mexican groups (or anyone) from controlling the market outright. As long as geography and market forces keep the traffickers split, all sides in Mexico will try to use violence to get more control over territory and market access. We assume that Mexico's geography will not change dramatically any time soon, but market forces are much more temporal.

Mexican criminal organizations can overcome their weakness in the cocaine market by investing the money they have earned (billions of dollars, according to the most conservative estimates) into the control of other markets. Ultimately, cocaine is impossible for the Mexicans to control because the coca plant can only grow in sufficient quantity in the foothills of the Andes. It would be prohibitively expensive for the Mexicans to take over control of coca cultivation and cocaine production there. Mexican criminal organizations are increasing their presence in the heroin market, but while they can grow poppies in Mexico and produce black-tar heroin, Afghanistan still controls a dominant share of the white heroin market -- around 90 percent.

What Mexicans can control is the methamphetamine market. What we are seeing in Mexico right now -- unprecedented amounts of the seized drug -- is reminiscent of what we saw over the past century in the infancy of the illegal liquor, gambling, heroin and cocaine markets: an organized criminal group industrializing production in or control of a loosely organized industry and using that control to set prices and increase its power. Again, while illegal methamphetamine has been produced in the United States for decades, regulatory pressure and law enforcement efforts have kept it at a small scale; seizures are typically measured in pounds or kilograms and producers are on the run.

Mexican producers have also been in the market for a long time, but over the past year we have seen seizures go from being measured in kilograms to being measured in metric tons. In other words, we are seeing evidence that methamphetamine production has increased several orders of magnitude and is fast becoming an industrialized process.

In addition to the 15 tons seized last week, we saw a record seizure of 675 tons of methylamine, a key ingredient of methamphetamine, in Mexico in December. From 2010 to 2011, seizures of precursor chemicals like methylamine in Mexico increased 400 percent, from 400 tons to 1,600 tons. These most recent reports are similar to reports in the 1920s of U.S. liquor seizures going from barrels to shiploads, which indicated bootlegging was being conducted on an industrial scale. They are also eerily similar to the record cocaine seizure in 1984 in Tranquilandia, Colombia, when Colombian National Police uncovered a network of jungle cocaine labs along with 13.8 metric tons of cocaine. It was the watershed moment, when authorities moved from measuring cocaine busts in kilograms to measuring them in tons, and it marked the Medellin cartel's rise to power over the cocaine market.

A True Mexican Criminal Industry?

Anyone can make methamphetamine, but it is a huge organizational, financial and legal challenge to make it on the industrial level that appears to be happening in Mexico. The main difference between the U.S. labs and the Mexican labs is the kind of input chemicals they use. The U.S. labs use pseudoephedrine, a pharmaceutical product heavily regulated by the DEA, as a starting material, while Mexican labs use methylamine, a chemical with many industrial applications that is more difficult to regulate. And while pseudoephedrine comes in small individual packages of cold pills, methylamine is bought in 208-liter (55-gallon) barrels. The Mexican process requires experienced chemists who have mastered synthesizing methamphetamine on a large scale, which gives them an advantage over the small-time amateurs working in U.S. methamphetamine labs.

Thus, while methamphetamine consumption has been steadily growing in the United States for the past two decades -- and at roughly $100 per gram, unpure methamphetamine is just as profitable on the street as cocaine -- it is even more profitable for Mexican traffickers. Methamphetamine does not come with the overhead costs of purchasing cocaine from Colombians and trafficking valuable merchandise through some of the most dangerous countries in the Western Hemisphere. Precursor materials such as methylamine used in methamphetamine production are cheap, and East Asian producers appear to be perfectly willing to sell the chemicals to Mexico. And because methamphetamine is a synthetic drug, its production does not depend on agriculture like cocaine and marijuana production does. There is no need to control large swaths of cropland and there is less risk of losing product to adverse weather or eradication efforts.

For the Mexican TCOs, industrializing and controlling the methamphetamine market offers a level of real control over a market that is not possible with cocaine. We expect fighting over the methamphetamine market to maintain violence at its current levels, but once a group comes out on top it will have far more resources to expel or absorb rival TCOs. This process may not sound ideal, but methamphetamine could pick the winner in the Mexican drug war.
December 22, 2011 | 1158 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: The Disinformation Continues in Tamaulipas

CJNG: Regional Threat with a National Reach?


On Dec. 13, unknown gunmen in Ecuandureo, Michoacan state, ambushed another criminal group (some media agencies have reported that the targeted group was from La Familia Michoacana). The ambushed group’s leader reportedly was killed in the attack, and the assailants are said to have fled the scene after the assault. Mexican military personnel and federal police were deployed to the area. Additional security personnel were sent to border crossings between Michoacan and Jalisco states.
Authorities later detained five individuals near the scene of the attack. One detainee reportedly confessed to being a member of the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG), a Sinaloa Federation enforcer group from Jalisco state. Authorities also seized three AK-47s with 480 rounds of ammunition, two AR-15s with 690 rounds of ammunition, five pistols with 41 rounds of ammunition and various unidentified tactical gear. Two vehicles — a truck and an SUV — were also seized. The vehicles were reportedly armored, though the level of armor is not known and some media reports indicate only one vehicle was armored.
That authorities deployed to the Michoacan-Jalisco border in response to the attack suggests that they suspected the attackers might attempt to cross into Jalisco. That fact, combined with the suspect’s confessed membership in Jalisco-based CJNG, indicates a connection between the attack and the arrests, though media reports did not link the two.
If CJNG were responsible for the Dec. 13 ambush, it would mean that the group is expanding its geographic reach. CJNG obviously has been active in Jalisco, and its subgroup, known as the “Matazetas,” or Zeta killers, has claimed the killing of dozens of suspected Zetas in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state. (CJNG not only struck Los Zetas on their home turf in Veracruz, but remained there for an extended period of time.) Now, with the possible CJNG attack in Michoacan, it seems CJNG is evolving from a regional organization into a hit squad with a national reach.

Shallow Graves in Jalisco State


A man and four University of Guadalajara students were found dead in Jalisco state Dec. 14-15. Media reports vary widely in describing the sequence of events, the cause of death, the number of casualties and other details — while new details emerge every day. What statements from the Jalisco state attorney general do make clear is that the victims were found buried in shallow graves in the courtyard of the Federation of Guadalajara Students’ (FEG) headquarters.
Originally a student organization at the University of Guadalajara, the FEG is one of many informal groups at Mexican universities that extort money from food and drink vendors in exchange for the right to sell goods on and around campuses. The FEG no longer has any formal ties to the university and instead operates with high schools affiliated with the university. There are no prior reports of the group engaging in this degree of violence.
According to reports, a fried-dough vendor named Armando Gomez, his son and three other University of Guadalajara students went to FEG headquarters Dec. 9 to complain about the amount of protection money the FEG was charging them. Family members of Gomez and of the students reported that the victims never returned home after the confrontation. On Dec. 14, three bodies were found at the FEG headquarters, and the remaining two bodies were found nearby the following day. According to the attorney general, the families identified the bodies as those of Gomez and the students. The Jalisco Institute of Forensic Science reported that Gomez and his son died of gunshot wounds to the head, while the remaining three victims had been stabbed.
The events do not necessarily portend an overall escalation of violence in the Jalisco capital, nor do they suggest a growing trend within the FEG. More importantly, the killings serve as a reminder that drug cartels, while responsible for an overwhelming amount of crime and death in Mexico, are not the only ones capable of crime and violence.




Dec. 13


  • Gunmen driving in two vehicles ambushed a government convoy in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state. The city clerk of Gran Morelos, Chihuahua state, was killed, and the head of the Public Security Secretariat in Chihuahua state was wounded. All of the gunmen managed to escape.
  • Gunmen murdered the prison director of the Centro de Readaptacion Social at an intersection in Saltillo, Coahuila state.
  • A criminal cell was ambushed by gunmen in Ecuandureo, Michoacan state, resulting in the deaths of the cell’s leader, Javier Guerrero, and three of his men.
  • Five members of the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG) were arrested as a result of a Mexican military operation in Ecuandureo, Michoacan state. Authorities seized five rifles and five pistols as well as 27 kilograms (about 60 pounds) of marijuana.

Dec. 14


  • Gunmen ambushed a convoy of police vehicles in Tepic, Nayarit state, that was carrying the state’s attorney general. Some of the gunmen reportedly were wounded in the ensuing clash, but all of them escaped.
  • Police in Tijuana, Baja California state, arrested two Sinaloa Federation operators, who confessed to working in a cell led by a man known as El Neto.
  • Gunmen opened fire on the main entry of a hospital in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. No one was wounded in the shooting and no arrests were made.

Dec. 15


  • Mexican authorities discovered the body of Juan “El Juancho” Guzman Rocha, cousin of Sinaloa Federation leader Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, on the side of a highway in Aguaruto, Sinaloa state. Guzman Rocha’s body was bound, bore signs of torture and had sustained multiple gunshot wounds.
  • Nine gunmen and one soldier were killed in a confrontation between the Mexican military and an armed group in Saltillo, Coahuila state.

Dec. 16


  • Members of the Sinaloa Federation attacked municipal police and civilians who were thought to be Zetas drug distributors in the cities of Fresnillo, Jerez, Rio Grande, Sombrerete and Zacatecas, Zacatecas state. Four individuals were killed and eight were wounded in the attacks. After the confrontation, gunmen went to a hospital and removed three of the wounded who had been admitted in the aftermath of the attack.

Dec. 17


  • Mexican authorities arrested eight members of the Knights Templar in Leon, Guanajuato state. Two kidnapped individuals were rescued as a result of the operation.
  • The Mexican military seized a weapons cache in Tayahua, Zacatecas state, and arrested one individual connected to the seizure. Among the weapons seized were various assault rifles, magazines, ammunition, high-caliber rifles and a grenade launcher.
  • Thirty-six gunmen attacked Mexican military personnel in Caracuaro, Michoacan state. Six gunmen died and two soldiers were injured.

Dec. 18


  • The Mexican military rescued 21 undocumented Central Americans who had been kidnapped from a safe house in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state. Authorities also detained three armed individuals.
Give us your thoughts on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on other reports

Reader Comments

December 12, 2011
Raul Fernandez, a leader of the Zetas drug cartel, was captured Dec. 12 by Mexico’s navy, Reuters reported, citing President Felipe Calderon’s Twitter account. Fernandez, also known as “El Lucky,” operated in the Gulf state of Veracruz, the southern state of Oaxaca and the central state of Pueblo, Calderon said.
December 8, 2011 | 1217 GMT

Zetas Narcomanta Challenges the Government


Mexican media began reporting Dec. 2 of a narcomanta attributed to Miguel “Z-40” Trevino Morales, the overall No. 2 leader of Los Zetas, that appeared in an as yet undisclosed city in Mexico. In a clear threat to Mexican authorities, the banner read, “The special forces of Los Zetas challenge the government of Mexico.” The banner went on to say that “Mexico lives and will continue under the regime of Los Zetas. Let it be clear that we are in control here and although the federal government controls other cartels, they cannot take our plazas … Look at what happened in Sinaloa and Guadalajara.” The last sentence is a reference to the mass killings and body dumps attributed to the Zetas in Culiacan and Guadalajara discovered Nov. 23.
The language used in the banner is intriguing; never before has a cartel referred to itself as a “regime,” and such brazen, adversarial terminology directed against the Mexican government is uncommon. It is difficult to imagine a drug cartel with a pedigree as violent as the Zetas wanting to assume governmental duties. Historically, while cartels have exerted influence over portions of Mexico, they have not sought to actually govern. Instead they use corruption or fear to ensure an unrestricted ability to conduct their criminal operations.
Though it specifically references the incidents in Culiacan and Guadalajara, there is no way to verify that Trevino actually commissioned the banner. Trevino has commissioned banners in the past, and, given his predilection for violence, his underlings would be unlikely to author something on his behalf without his approval. The fact that the message in this banner is so out of character suggests the possibility that it is a disinformation campaign directed against Los Zetas. If this is indeed a disinformation effort, the Sinaloa Federation, which, as the other pre-eminent cartel in Mexico, has the most to gain from increased government action against the Zetas, cannot be ruled out.
What is more interesting than the content of the banner is how little is known about its origins. No media agency has definitely stated where the banner was found — or if there were others like it. Narcomantas are prevalent in Mexico, and details of their appearances are not hard to come by in the media. Also, major messages are frequently left with the bodies of mutilated enemies to prove bona fides. But for whatever reason, no agency has been able to ascertain the location of this banner (a rumor surfaced that it appeared in Ciudad Victoria in Zetas territory, but that rumor remains unconfirmed). That six days have passed without any indication of the location suggests the Mexican government, which is constantly attempting to maintain an image of control in the war on drugs, is taking the threat seriously and is disallowing the details of the banner’s location to come out.

More Victims in Veracruz


Seven bodies were found Dec. 4 in the Adolfo Lopez Mateo neighborhood of Veracruz, Veracruz state. All of the bodies were bound and gagged, and some of them bore signs of torture. The cause of death is unconfirmed, but from photographs of the scene it appears that many were shot. As many as five of the seven bodies had their faces completely covered by their shirts, which had been pulled over their heads and fastened to their necks with duct tape. Uncorroborated witness statements said members of the state police had executed the victims.
On the surface, the location in which the bodies were dumped seems notable. The Adolfo Lopez Mateo neighborhood lies just 2 miles from Boca del Rio, where the bodies of around 35 alleged Zetas members were dumped in September. (Less than a week later, another 32 bodies were found in stash houses in the same neighborhood.) At that time, STRATFOR predicted that the Zetas would carry out reprisals in Veracruz; the forecast was accurate, but the location was not. On Nov. 23, the Zetas dumped 24 bodies in Culiacan, Sinaloa state, and 26 bodies in Guadalajara, Jalisco state, the following day. Based on the messages left at the scenes, these two events — not the Dec. 4 incident — were revenge killings for the Boca del Rio incident in September.
Notably, the Dec. 4 victims were killed in a different manner than the September victims (who were suffocated), and there were no messages left at the scene to suggest the killings were in fact reprisals. This, coupled with the unconfirmed statements suggesting state police involvement in the killings, presents a few possible explanations.
Given the long-term control the Zetas have maintained in Veracruz and the possibility that that control included coercion of or collaboration with the state police, the victims may have been connected to the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG) and/or the Matazetas, who are believed to have been responsible for the September killings. With such control, it is possible that the state police acted on orders of the Zetas to kill the seven victims discovered Dec. 4.
Alternatively, Los Zetas may have killed the seven victims directly. If this were the case, they likely would have left a message with the bodies claiming retribution or providing some kind of explanation or threat. In either case, the time elapsed between the September killing of Zetas members and this possible retribution is not unreasonable; the Zetas would need time to investigate and track down the perpetrators.
There is the potential that the seven dead were members of Los Zetas and that this was a continuation of the September killings. But because the modus operandi was so different — specifically, there was no writing on the bodies or other written messages to indicate an affiliation of the victims with any group — it is unclear which cartel is responsible. What is clear is that the two mass-killing events in Boca del Rio in September were not isolated events. Rather, STRATFOR sees this series of events as an escalation of the cycle of retributive violence in Veracruz — in scale if not in frequency.
Whichever explanation is correct, it is clear that the struggle between Los Zetas and the CJNG in Veracruz is continuing, and more violence can be expected in the important port city.




Nov. 29


  • Mexican authorities discovered the remains of three dismembered bodies in Xochitepec, Morelos state, after receiving an anonymous tip.
  • Mexican marines arrested Ezequiel Cardenas Rivera, the son of former Gulf cartel leader Antonio Ezequiel “Tony Tormenta” Cardenas Guillen, at a residence in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state.
  • The prison director and twenty other officials at the San Pedro Cholulu prison in Puebla state were arrested in connection with the Nov. 27 prison escape of Los Zetas cartel members.
  • Four banners appeared in various areas of Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, addressing Mexican President Felipe Calderon and linking the president to supporting Sinaloa Federation leader Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera. The banners were signed, “The United Citizens of Juarez and Mexico.”

Nov. 30


  • Mexican authorities seized more than 3.9 metric tons of marijuana from a drug tunnel in Tijuana, Baja California state, running under the U.S.-Mexico border.
  • A narcomanta left with the body of an elderly man in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, mentioned the theft of $5 million and the name “Tono” Pena.

Dec. 1


  • Mexican authorities seized a synthetic drug lab in Culiacan, Sinaloa state, that housed various precursor chemicals for methamphetamine. No arrests were made.
  • Mexican authorities seized more than 550 kilograms (about 1,213 pounds) of methamphetamine in a drug lab in Zapotlanejo, Jalisco state.

Dec. 2


  • A narcomanta signed by the Knights Templar was posted on a bridge in Morelia, Michoacan state. The banner stated that the Knights Templar is not a criminal group and encouraged citizens to enjoy the “December holiday.”
  • After a two-month operation, the Mexican military dismantled Los Zetas communications networks in the states of Nuevo Leon, Coahuila, San Luis Potosi, and Tamaulipas.
  • A radio host was murdered at a nightclub in Chihuahua, Chihuahua State. Witness reports claim the murderer was wearing military-style clothing.

Dec. 3


  • Mexican authorities arrested 22 police officers throughout Tabasco state for connections to Los Zetas.

Dec. 4


  • The bodies of five executed individuals were discovered in Sinaloa Municipality, Sinaloa state.
  • Gunmen fired at the house of the mayor of Montemorelos, Nuevo Leon state.

Dec. 5


  • Federal Police arrested six members of the Independent Cartel of Acapulco in Acapulco, Guerrero.
  • Gunmen shot and killed the police chief of Saltillo, Coahuila state, and his 11-year-old son.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

December 6, 2011
Mexican federal police arrested alleged independent Cartel of Acapulco leader Gilberto Morales Castrejon, alias Commander Gil, and five associates in Acapulco on Dec. 6, In Sight Crime reported.
December 1, 2011 | 1308 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Authorities Arrest Suspected Zetas Paymaster

Body Dumps in Western Mexico


Twenty-four bodies were found Nov. 23 in Culiacan, the capital of western Mexico’s Sinaloa state. The next day, 26 bodies were discovered in Guadalajara, Jalisco state, about 610 kilometers (380 miles) away, along with a narcomanta signed by Los Zetas saying the Zetas were in Jalisco state and would not leave. They claimed that the Sinaloa Federation and Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG) — a group believed to have been behind the killing of 35 Zetas in Veracruz in September — worked with the governments in Jalisco and Sinaloa as well as with the United States, which, they said, was the cause for the low levels of violence in those areas. “Open your eyes, the Sinaloa Cartel and the Jalisco Cartel are history. They can’t even control their plazas,” the narcomanta read.
Jalisco and Sinaloa states are Sinaloa Federation territory, and Guadalajara is a key stronghold of CJNG. (Recent signs indicate the CJNG may have struck an alliance with the Sinaloa Federation.) While the presence of Los Zetas has been confirmed in several western Mexican states, these two recent incidents appear to be part of a major move into Sinaloa territory by the Zetas. If Los Zetas are in fact bringing the fight to Sinaloa turf, then territory that previously had been relatively stable, including the entire northwest of Mexico, is likely in for a significant spike in violence.
Very few details about the incident in Culiacan have been released, but 19 of the victims from Guadalajara have been identified. Most of the known victims were males in their 20s who were employed in a wide variety of professions. A few of the identified victims had criminal records, thus making their possible connection to organized crime more likely. But the absence of a history of crime does not preclude the other victims from having been involved in low-level organized crime. They could have worked for the cartels as lookouts (“halcones”), support personnel or suppliers. Of course, it is also possible that the victims were not working for Sinaloa, but this is unlikely considering that there is no evidence of Zetas killing random innocents to serve as bodies in their messages to rival cartels.
Although violence is not new to Mexico’s Pacific coastal states, these mass killings are highly significant — and not only because of the number of victims involved. First, if the bodies were indeed rival cartel members, such an operation by the Zetas would have taken a considerable amount of time to carry out. The Zetas had to set up logistics and security, insert personnel and/or buy the loyalty and silence of local residents, and set up a secure location to hold the victims for several days — a number of the identified victims in the Guadalajara mass killing went missing as early as Nov. 21, but, according to media reports, all were killed on Nov. 24, indicating the Zetas had the capacity to hold the victims for at least three days. Additionally, several weeks or even months of surveillance would have to be conducted to identify all of the targets (assuming the victims were actually involved with the cartels).
What this means is that Los Zetas, perhaps with their allies in the Milenio cartel, may have demonstrated the intent and capability to strike Sinaloa and CJNG assets in the heart of those cartels’ territories. More violence in the Pacific coastal states, as well as reprisal attacks directed at the Zetas in their areas of control, can thus be expected.

Houston Shooting


On the afternoon of Nov. 21, an unknown number of individuals in Stratfor three SUVs “cut off” a tractor-trailer transporting about 136 kilograms (300 pounds) of marijuana in north Houston, Texas. The suspects shot and killed the driver of the truck, who happened to be a confidential informant working with police as part of a controlled delivery operation, before engaging in a gunbattle with the plainclothes officers who had been shadowing the truck. Though not yet confirmed, sources indicate the tractor-trailer and its contraband cargo came from the Mexican border, probably the Lower Rio Grande Valley area, but possibly from the Laredo area.
Two of the SUVs escaped the scene while the third — a stolen Lincoln Navigator, according to unconfirmed information from a STRATFOR source — stayed behind. Four suspects claiming to be members of Los Zetas were arrested. Very little additional information is available on the suspects, though it is known that one is from Rio Bravo, Texas, a town south of Laredo, Texas, and that three of them who are believed to be Mexican nationals requested Mexican consular services.
The case is curious to say the least. Mexican cartels are known to operate in the United States, but they tend to be discreet and do not often involve themselves in daytime shootings in heavily populated areas of U.S. cities. The two most obvious explanations for this case are that it was a botched load theft or a hit on the driver. After considering the available facts of the case, it is still unclear which explanation is true.
Before going into the details of the Nov. 21 incident, an explanation of controlled deliveries is warranted. A controlled delivery is an operation conducted by law enforcement — usually initiated by state or federal law enforcement — in which contraband is allowed to be delivered to its intended recipient with preplaced surveillance and plainclothes officers shadowing the delivery vehicle. When the transaction has been initiated, law enforcement personnel activate and attempt to capture all criminal parties involved in the delivery. Sometimes the individual delivering the contraband has been persuaded to cooperate, but sometimes the delivery is allowed to run its course without the driver’s knowledge.
The size or type of contraband involved, its destination or the identities of the people or organization expected to receive the shipment determine whether a controlled delivery is conducted. The contraband must be easily accessible for a controlled delivery to be possible; law enforcement must be able to swiftly find the load without compromising the concealment method. If removal of the contraband from its load vehicle requires destruction of the concealment location — for instance, if the contraband was welded or sealed into the structure of the vehicle — then a controlled delivery will be difficult or impossible to execute because of the obvious damage done when the narcotics were accessed by law enforcement.
Based on available photographic and video evidence of the Houston incident, it appears the tractor-trailer came to a rest at the entrance to a subdivision. It is unclear if this was the destination or if the driver was forced off its route by the gunmen.
One possible theory for the ambush is that the gunmen intended to steal the load. If the above details are correct, the assailants may have decided to shoot the driver when he resisted or when law enforcement personnel showed up. (As an aside, 136 kilograms of marijuana are probably not worth the effort invested by the attackers. However, they may have received faulty information regarding the load quantity or drug type that led them to attempt the theft in spite of the immense risks.)
Another possible explanation is that the attackers were simply targeting the driver. However, given the long history of how Los Zetas handle individuals who betray them, this seems unlikely. In the United States the Zetas typically will abduct the victim and dispose of him or her quietly, rather than chase them down and kill them in public outside a subdivision. But in either scenario, the gunmen likely were unaware of the presence of undercover law enforcement personnel. When law enforcement officers unexpectedly entered the picture immediately after the ambush, it very likely turned an intended strong-arm action into the deadly gunfight it became.
As for whom the marijuana load belonged to, that may be ascertainable once it is clear where the load originated. For instance, if the shipment crossed the border through Nuevo Laredo — a Zetas stronghold — it likely belongs to them. If the marijuana entered the United States via ports of entry at Reynosa or Matamoros, however, that would indicate that it belonged to either the Gulf or Sinaloa cartels. Determining who owned the load of marijuana will help determine if the attack was an attempted theft of a rival group’s load or the elimination of an asset who had been compromised.



Nov. 15


  • In Fresnillo, Zacatecas state, a confrontation between the military and gunmen left approximately 20 individuals dead. It is unclear how many of those casualties were suffered on each side. The confrontation was the result of a military operation that led to roughly 20 arrests.
  • Mexican authorities seized approximately 1.5 metric tons of marijuana in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.
  • Gunmen in two vehicles fired on the El Siglo de Torreon newspaper building in Torreon, Coahuila state. The gunmen left one of the vehicles burning in front of the building.
  • Gunmen murdered a bouncer of a bar in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. The gunmen left a narcomanta, but its contents have not been disclosed.
  • The Mexican military arrested Alfredo Aleman Narvaez, also known as “El Comandante Aleman,” at a ranch in Fresnillo, Zacatecas state. Aleman Narvaez was a Zetas plaza boss in Zacatecas.

Nov. 16


  • Gunmen murdered a federal prosecutor in Torreon, Coahuila state, as he was leaving his residence.
  • A narcomanta was posted on the wall of a kindergarten in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state. The banner said police were protecting cartels in the region and accused a recently killed criminal leader of belonging to the New Juarez cartel.
  • The Mexican military seized 970 kilograms of clorazepate monopotassium, a precursor chemical used to produce heroin, at a loading zone of a train station in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.

Nov. 17


  • Mexican soldiers uncovered a drug lab in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. Soldiers seized 746 kilograms of solid methamphetamine, 953 liters (252 gallons) of liquid methamphetamine and various precursor chemicals.
  • Three Gulf cartel operators, including a plaza leader, were arrested in Cuernavaca, Morelos state.

Nov. 18


  • Gunmen attacked the director of police operations for Guadalajara outside his residence in Guadalajara, Jalisco state. The director survived the attack but his bodyguards reportedly sustained injuries.
  • The bodies of four individuals were recovered from a parked vehicle in Nezahualcoyotl, Mexico state. All four bodies had suffered gunshot wounds and had plastic bags over their heads.
  • A narcomanta was left with the bodies of 13 decapitated dogs in Iguala, Guerrero state. The message stated that traitors would find a similar fate as the dogs.

Nov. 19


  • The director of the State Investigation Agency of Nayarit was unharmed when gunmen attacked him as he traveled along a highway in El Refilon, Nayarit state.
  • A narcomanta signed by the Matazetas was left with three bodies in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state. The message identified the bodies as Los Zetas members.
  • A Los Zetas communication hub was dismantled at a residence in Torreon, Coahuila state.

Nov. 21


  • Mexican authorities arrested a Public Security Secretariat officer in Pachuca, Hidalgo state, for allegedly recruiting fellow officers to work for Los Zetas.

Nov. 22


  • Mexican soldiers seized more than $15 million from a vehicle in Tijuana, Baja California state. The money is believed to belong to the Sinaloa cartel.
  • A tunnel connecting a residence in Nogales, Sonora state, with a residence in Nogales, Ariz., was discovered.
  • Three police officers were found executed in Ciudad Acuna, Coahuila state.

Nov. 23


  • Twenty-four individuals were executed in various areas of Culiacan, Sinaloa state. At least nine of the bodies had been burned.
  • Mexican authorities announced the arrests of 20 members of La Familia Michoacana, including Jose Edgardo Lemus Barcenas, also known as “El Culebra,” a La Familia plaza boss operating around Toluca, Mexico state.

Nov. 24


  • The bodies of 26 individuals were recovered from vehicles in Guadalajara, Jalisco state. A message signed by Los Zetas was left with the bodies. It said the Sinaloa cartel could not protect its own territory and works for Americans.
  • Mexican authorities seized roughly 246 kilograms of solid methamphetamine, 176 liters of chemical methamphetamine and precursor chemicals in Culiacan, Sinaloa state.

Nov. 26


  • Mexican authorities arrested Francisco Javier Marquez de la Rosa, also known as “El Pancho,” a distribution leader for Los Zetas, in Torreon, Coahuila state.

Nov. 27


  • A narcomanta was left with a dismembered male body in Taxco, Guerrero state. The message — signed by “El Fantasma and El Chiquilin, the arm of La Empresa” — warned potential traitors that a similar fate awaited them.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


November 2011
November 30, 2011 | 1357 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

Vice President of Intelligence Fred Burton examines the recent murder allegedly committed by Mexican cartel members and the complexity faced by law enforcement agencies when cross-border violence occurs.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


In this week’s Above the Tearline, we are going to look at an incident that appears to be a Mexican cartel-related murder in Texas.
Last Monday, in the Houston area, several undercover officers from a High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas Task Force (known as a HIDTA) were following a tractor-trailer from south Texas transporting drugs in an undercover operation. Four suspects ambushed the truck, firing shoulder weapons, shooting and wounding a task force police officer and killing the driver, who media have identified as an undercover government informant.
The true motive for the attack is unclear. There has been speculation in the media that the suspects attacked the truck to steal the marijuana, with others speculating the real target was the undercover informant. It is unknown if the shooters were aware that undercover police officers were surveilling the drug load. We have heard through our law enforcement contacts the suspects may be linked to the violent Zeta cartel organization. The brazen nature of the ambush certainly fits their m.o., but killing government informants in the U.S. is something the cartels have typically tried to avoid. The pressure the feds can place on the cartels disrupts their supply chain and causes the cartels to lose money.
The DEA has taken the lead investigative role, which is a positive step, assisted by the Houston Police Department Homicide Division and the local sheriff’s department. However, behind the scenes, other state and federal agencies are also assisting the DEA, to include the Texas DPS, ATF and the FBI. Three of the four suspects are allegedly Mexican nationals, so the State Department and ICE will interface with our Mexican counterparts, and an investigation will be conducted in Mexico to determine if the suspects are connected to a drug trafficking organization. At the national level, traces will also be conducted on the suspects through the entire U.S. intelligence community. As you can see, a lot is taking place behind the scenes.
What is the Above the Tearline aspect of this video? The DEA needs to determine whether or not a cartel source sold out the details of the undercover operation to the bad guys. If so, the internal leak needs to be found before other drug operations are jeopardized.


Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

November 29, 2011
Ezequiel “El Junior” Cardenas Rivera, the son of former Gulf drug cartel boss Antonio Ezequiel Cardenas Guillen, was detained Nov. 25 in Matamoros, Mexico’s Navy Secretariat said Nov. 29, Fox News reported. Four Gulf associates were also arrested, including suspected cartel boss Jose de Jesus Garcia Hernandez, accountant Rene Alberto Munguia Elizondo, money man Javier Enrique Farias Garcia, and Erasmo Garcia Galvan, who specialized in smuggling drugs into the United States. The arrests were made utilizing a tip and naval intelligence work, officials said, adding no shots were fired in the operation.
November 17, 2011

Readers Comment on STRATFOR Reports

By Karen Hooper
Guatemalan President-elect Otto Perez Molina told Mexican newspaper El Universal on Nov. 9 that he plans to engage drug cartels in a “full frontal assault” when he takes office in 2012. The former general said he will use Guatemala’s elite military forces, known as Los Kaibiles, to take on the drug cartels in a strategy similar to that of the Mexican government; he has asked for U.S. assistance in this struggle.
The statements signal a shifting political landscape in already violent Central America. The region is experiencing increasing levels of crime and the prospect of heightened competition from Mexican drug cartels in its territory. The institutional weakness and security vulnerabilities of Guatemala and other Central American states mean that combating these trends will require significant help, most likely from the United States.

From Sideshow to Center Stage


Central America has seen a remarkable rise in its importance as a transshipment point for cocaine and other contraband bound for the United States. Meanwhile, Mexican organized crime has expanded its activities in Mexico and Central America to include the smuggling of humans and substances such as precursor chemicals used for manufacturing methamphetamine. Substantial evidence also suggests that Central American, and particularly Guatemalan, military armaments including M60 machine guns and 40 mm grenades have wound up being used in Mexico’s drug conflict.
From the 1970s to the 1990s, Colombian cartels transited directly to Miami. After U.S. military aerial and radar surveillance in the Caribbean effectively shut down those routes, Mexico became the last stop on the drug supply chain before the United States, greatly empowering Mexico’s cartels. A subsequent Mexican government crackdown put pressure on Mexican drug trafficking organizations (DTOs) to diversify their transit routes to avoid increased enforcement at Mexico’s airstrips and ports. Central America consequently has become an increasingly significant middleman for South American suppliers and Mexican buyers of contraband.
The methods and routes for moving illicit goods through Central America are diverse and constantly in flux. There is no direct land connection between the coca-growing countries of Colombia, Peru and Bolivia. A region of swampy jungle terrain along the Panamanian-Colombian known as the Darien Gap has made road construction prohibitively expensive and thus barred all but the most intrepid of overland travelers. Instead, aircraft or watercraft must be used to transport South American goods north, which can then be offloaded in Central America and driven north into Mexico. Once past the Darien Gap, the Pan American Highway becomes a critical transportation corridor. Honduras, for example, reportedly has become a major destination for planes from Venezuela laden with cocaine. Once offloaded, the cocaine is moved across the loosely guarded Honduran-Guatemalan border and then moved through Guatemala to Mexico, often through the largely unpopulated Peten department.
Though precise measurements of the black market are notoriously difficult to obtain, these shifts in Central America have been well-documented — and the impact on the region has been stark. While drug trafficking occurs in all Central American countries to some extent, most violence associated with the trade occurs in the historically tumultuous “Northern Triangle” of Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras. No longer receiving the global attention they did when the United States became involved in their Cold War-era civil wars, these countries remain poverty stricken, plagued by local gangs and highly unstable.
The violence has worsened as the drug traffic has increased. El Salvador saw its homicide rate increase by 6 percent to 66 per 100,000 inhabitants between 2005 and 2010. At the same time, Guatemala’s homicide rate increased 13 percent, to 50 per 100,000 inhabitants. Meanwhile Honduras saw a rise of 108 percent, to 77 per 100,000 inhabitants. These are some of the highest homicide rates in the world.
In comparison, the drug war in Mexico caused murder rates to spike 64 percent, from 11 to 18 deaths per 100,000 between 2005 and 2010. Conservative estimates put the number of dead from gang and military violence in Mexico at 50,000. These numbers are slightly misleading, as Mexican violence is concentrated in scattered pockets where most drug trafficking and competition among drug traffickers occurs. Even so, they demonstrate the disproportionate impact organized criminal groups have had on the societies of the three Northern Triangle countries.

Guatemala’s Outsized Role


Increased involvement by Mexican cartels in Central America inevitably has affected the region’s politico-economic structures, a process most visible in Guatemala. Its territory spans Central America, making it one of several choke points on the supply chain of illicit goods coming north from El Salvador and Honduras bound for Mexico.
Guatemala has a complex and competitive set of criminal organizations, many of which are organized around tight-knit family units. These family organizations have included the politically and economically powerful Lorenzana and Mendoza families. First rising to prominence in trade and agriculture, these families control significant businesses in Guatemala and transportation routes for shipping both legal and illicit goods. Though notorious, these families are far from alone in Guatemala’s criminal organizations. Major drug traffickers like the well-known Mario Ponce and Walther Overdick also have strong criminal enterprises, with Ponce reportedly managing his operations from a Honduran jail.
The relationship of these criminal organizations to Mexican drug cartels is murky at best. The Sinaloa and Los Zetas cartels are both known to have relationships with Guatemalan organized criminal groups, but the lines of communication and their exact agreements are unclear.
Less murky, however, is that Los Zetas are willing to use the same levels of violence in Guatemala to coerce loyalty as they have used in Mexico. Though both Sinaloa and Los Zetas still need Guatemalan groups to access high-level Guatemalan political connections, Los Zetas have taken a particularly aggressive tack in seeking direct control over more territory in Guatemala.
Overdick facilitated Los Zetas’ entry into Guatemala in 2007. The first indication of serious Los Zetas involvement in Guatemala occurred in March 2008 when Leon crime family boss Juan Leon Ardon, alias “El Juancho,” his brother Hector Enrique Leon Chacon and nine associates all died in a gunbattle with Los Zetas, who at the time still worked for the Gulf cartel. The fight severely reduced the influence of the Leon crime family, primarily benefiting Overdick’s organization. The Zetas most flagrant use of force occurred in the May 2011 massacre and mutilation of 27 peasants in northern Guatemala intended as a message to a local drug dealer allegedly tied to the Leon family; the Zetas also killed and mutilated that drug dealer’s niece.

MS-13 and Calle 18


In addition to ramping up relationships with powerful political, criminal and economic players, Sinaloa and Los Zetas have established relationships with Central American street gangs. The two biggest gangs in the region are Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13) and Calle 18. The two groups are loosely organized around local cliques; the Mexican cartels have relationships at varying levels of closeness with different cliques. The U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime estimates that there are 36,000 gang members in Honduras, 14,000 in Guatemala and 10,500 in El Salvador.
They were formed by Los Angeles gang members of Central American origin whose parents had immigrated to the United States to escape the region’s civil wars. After being arrested in the United States, these gang members were deported to Central America. In some cases, the deportees spoke no Spanish and had no significant ties to their ancestral homeland, encouraging them to cluster together and make use of the skills learned on the streets of Los Angeles to make a living in Central America via organized crime.
The gangs have multiplied and migrated within the region. Many have also returned to the United States: U.S. authorities estimate that MS-13 and Calle 18 have a presence in as many as 42 states. Though the gangs are truly transnational, their emphasis is on controlling localized urban turfs. They effectively control large portions of Guatemala City, Guatemala; Tegucigalpa, Honduras; and San Salvador, El Salvador. Competition within and among these gangs is responsible for a great deal of the violence in these three countries.
In a March statement, Salvadoran Defense Minister David Munguia Payes said his government had evidence that both Sinaloa and Los Zetas are active in El Salvador, but that he believes MS-13 and Calle 18 are too anarchic and violent for the Mexican cartels to rely on heavily. According to Honduran Security Minister Pompeyo Bonilla, Mexican cartels primarily hire members of these gangs as assassins. The gangs are paid in drugs, which they sell on the local drug market.
Though limited in their ties to the Mexican cartels, the prevalence of MS-13 and Calle 18 in the Northern Triangle states and their extreme violence makes them a force to be reckoned with, for both the cartels and Central American governments. If Central American street gangs are able to better organize themselves internally, this could result in closer collaboration, or alternately serious confrontations with the Mexican cartels. In either case, the implications for stability in Central America are enormous.

The U.S. Role


The United States has long played an important, complex role in Latin America. In the early 20th century, U.S. policy in the Western Hemisphere was characterized by the extension of U.S. economic and military control over the region. With tactics ranging from outright military domination to facilitating competition between subregional powers Guatemala and Nicaragua to ensuring the dominance of the United Fruit Company in Central American politics and business, the United States used the first several decades of the century to ensure that Central America — and by extension the Caribbean — was under its control. After World War II, Central America became a proxy battleground between the United States and the Soviet Union.
On a strategic level, Central America is far enough away from the United States (thanks to being buffered by Mexico) and made up of small enough countries that it does not pose a direct threat to the United States. U.S. interest in the region did not end after the Cold War, however, as it is critically important to the United States that a foreign global competitor never control Central America or the Caribbean.
The majority of money spent combating drug trafficking from South America to the United States over the past decade has been spent in Colombia on monitoring air and naval traffic in the Caribbean and off the Pacific coasts, though the U.S. focus has now shifted to Mexico. Central America, by contrast, has languished since the Reagan years, when the United States allocated more than $1 billion per year to Central America. Now, the region has been allocated a total of $361.5 million for fiscal years 2008-2011 in security, economic and development aid through the Merida Initiative and the Central America Regional Security Initiative (CARSI). The Obama administration has requested another $100 million for CARSI. Of this allocated funding, however, only 18 percent has been dispersed due to failures in institutional cooperation and efficiency.
The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) has facilitated most U.S.-Central American security cooperation. The DEA operates teams in the Northern Triangle that participate in limited counternarcotic operations. They are also tasked with both vetting and training local law enforcement, a particularly tricky — and most likely doomed — task. As the failure of Guatemala’s highly vetted and lauded Department of Anti-Narcotics Operations shows, preventing local law enforcement from succumbing to the bribes and threats from wealthy and violent DTOs is a difficult, if not impossible, task.
The DEA’s limited resources include five Foreign-deployed Advisory and Support Teams worldwide. These are the agency’s elite operational teams that are equipped to train foreign law enforcement and military personnel and to conduct support operations. Originally established to operate in Afghanistan exclusively, the teams have been deployed to several countries in Central America, including Guatemala and Honduras. These teams are designed to be flexible, however, and do not represent the kind of long-term commitment that would likely be necessary to stabilize the region.

Central America’s Challenge


Central America has no short-term escape from being at the geographical center of the drug trade and from the associated violence. Unless and until technologies shift to allow drugs to flow directly from producer to consumer via ocean or air transport, it appears likely that Central America will only become more important to the drug trade. While the drug trade brings huge amounts of cash (admittedly on the black market) into exceedingly capital-poor countries, it also brings extreme violence.
The billions of dollars drugs command create an insurmountable challenge for the regional counternarcotic campaigns. The U.S. “war on drugs” pits the Guatemalan elite’s political and financial interests against their need to retain a positive relationship with the United States, which views the elites as colluding with drug organizations to facilitate the free passage of drugs and key figures in the drug trade.
For the leaders of Central America, foreign cartel interference in domestic arrangements and increasing violence is the real threat to their power. It is not the black market that alarms a leader like Perez Molina enough to call for greater involvement by the United States: It is the threat posed by the infiltration of Mexico’s most violent drug cartel into Guatemala, and the threat posed to all three countries by further Central American drug gang destabilization, which could lead to even more violence.

Looking Forward


The United States is heavily preoccupied with crises of varying degrees of importance around the world and the significant budget-tightening under way in Congress. This makes a major reallocation of resources to Guatemala or its Central American neighbors for the fight against Mexican drug cartels unlikely in the short term. Even so, key reasons for paying close attention to this issue remain.
First, the situation could destabilize rapidly if Perez Molina is sincere about confronting Mexican DTOs in Guatemala. Los Zetas have proved willing to apply their signature brutality against civilians and rivals alike in Guatemala. While the Guatemalans would be operating on their own territory and have their own significant power bases, they are neither technologically advanced nor wealthy nor unified enough to tackle the challenge posed by heavily armed, well-funded Zetas. At the very least, such a confrontation would ignite extremely destabilizing violence. This violence could extend beyond the Northern Triangle into more stable Central American countries, not to mention the possibility that violence spreading north could open up a new front in Mexico’s cartel war.
Second, the United States and Mexico already are stretched thin trying to control their shared 2,000-mile land border. U.S. counternarcotic activities in Mexico are limited by Mexican sovereignty concerns. For example, carrying weapons and operating independent of Mexican supervision is not allowed. This hampers the interdiction efforts of U.S. agencies like the DEA. The efforts also are hampered by the United States’ unwillingness to share intelligence for fear that corrupt Mexican officials would leak it.
Perez Molina’s invitation for increased U.S. participation in Guatemalan counternarcotic operations presents a possibility for U.S. involvement in a country that, like Mexico, straddles the continent. The Guatemalan choke point has a much shorter border with Mexico — about 600 miles — in need of control, and is far enough north in Central America to prevent insertion of drug traffickers into the supply chain between the blocking force and Mexico. While the United States would not be able to stop the illicit flow of cocaine and people north, it could make it significantly more difficult. And although significantly reducing traffic at the Guatemalan border would not stop the flow of the drugs to the United States, it would radically decrease the value of Central America as a trafficking corridor.
Accomplishing this would require a much more significant U.S. commitment to the drug war, and any such direct involvement would be costly both in money and political capital. Absent significant U.S. help, the current trend of increased Mexican cartel influence and violence in Central America will only worsen.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
November 16, 2011 | 1929 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: AFO Continuing To Lose Power in Tijuana

Zetas Paymaster Apprehended


After receiving a tip about suspicious activity Nov. 11 in the Hacienda Las Palmas area of Escobedo, Nuevo Leon state, Mexican marines arrested five suspected members of Los Zetas. Among those arrested was Juan Carlos “El Charly” Morales Magallanes, a high-ranking financial operator who, according to the Navy Secretariat, is believed to be responsible for preparing and disbursing the Zetas’ payroll in multiple cities across Nuevo Leon state, including Cienega de Flores, China, Santiago, Monterrey, Villa Garcia, Escobedo, Allende, Marin, Apodaca, Montemorelos and others.
Given the illicit nature of the cartels’ businesses and the propensity toward violence, it can be easy to forget that drug cartels and other criminal organizations are bound by many of the same business practices as legitimate enterprises. Like licit businesses, these organizations have bills to pay and records to maintain. They have cash inflows and cash outflows, and whoever is tasked with the flow of money must ensure that all “accounts” are reconciled. This includes doling out salaries to “employees” — from street-level informants to high-level assassins to corrupt police officers and politicians.
If the Navy Secretariat’s description is accurate, Morales had a unique position within his organization: As a paymaster, he paid salaries, procured weapons and bought everything from vehicles to cellphones. He thus would have keen insight into whom the cartel employs in his region — atypical for someone in a criminal organization that takes steps to minimize its members’ knowledge of its various branches. Most important, however, is that his arrest and the search of the location where he was arrested could lead authorities to financial information on the Zetas that can and likely will be exploited. It also could lead them to other cartel targets.
As a general rule, a criminal organization’s survival depends upon a high degree of compartmentalization. Low-level informants or operatives who provide around-the-clock surveillance of street corners, blocks or neighborhoods report only to their boss; they know which organization they work for and, likely, who that organization’s leader or leaders are, but they have little knowledge as to the criminal operations, money flows and movement of people of the group. The prevailing wisdom is that the less the various members of an organization know about other compartments, the less valuable they are to law enforcement. Thus, criminal organizations such as the Zetas maintain dozens of layers between a low-level corner lookout and overall leader Heriberto Lazcano Lazcano.
Law enforcement officials therefore place great value on the paymasters of illicit enterprises. They are singular points of failure, whereby the capture of one can compromise many aspects of the organization’s structure or, in the case of the Zetas, the structure of a particular region. Nuevo Leon state, where Morales was arrested, is the Zetas’ largest territory, and Morales’ capture potentially opens up to law enforcement the single most vulnerable component of the organization in that region: money, and the knowledge of where and to whom that money goes.
Morales may or may not cooperate with the authorities. If he does provide the authorities with actionable intelligence — and if the authorities quickly follow up on the intelligence he provides — the damage to Los Zetas in Monterrey and central Nuevo Leon state may be profound and extensive. This is especially true if he can provide them with information that could allow the authorities to seize accounts or shut down funding channels of Los Zetas, a top priority for the Mexican government.

Sinaloa Federation Lieutenant Captured


Mexican authorities on Nov. 9 arrested a senior member of the Sinaloa Federation in what has been described as a well-planned and well-executed military raid in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. Believed to be part of Sinaloa leader Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera’s inner circle, Ovidio Limon Sanchez reportedly oversaw the purchase, transportation and distribution of cocaine and other drugs to the United States, mainly to Los Angeles and other parts of Southern California. Limon had been wanted for extradition to the United States, which had placed a $5 million reward on his capture.
His arrest has precipitated a number of theories in the mainstream media, the most striking of which is that in retaliation the Sinaloa Federation commissioned the assassination of Mexican Interior Minister Francisco Blake Mora, who died in a helicopter crash four days after Limon’s arrest.
STRATFOR considers this story unlikely. To mobilize an assassination against an official as high-ranking as the interior minister (or Mexican President Felipe Calderon, who reportedly was supposed to fly later that day in the same helicopter that crashed) would require unmatched intelligence, planning, and logistical and operational capabilities. Sinaloa would have to activate, and perhaps pay up front, multiple operatives with the skill set to conduct such an attack. It would also require knowledge of the helicopter flight schedule and the president’s and interior minister’s travel itinerary. In short, there are too many working parts to successfully plan and execute this kind of sophisticated plot in a mere 100 hours.



Nov. 8


  • At least 10 gunmen ambushed Alejandro Higuera Osuna, the mayor of Mazatlan, Sinaloa state, while he was traveling along the Autopista del Pacifico. Higuero survived the ambush unharmed.
  • A firefight between the Mexican army and gunmen took place in Saltillo, Coahuila state. Three unidentified individuals were killed and two soldiers were injured.
  • Mexican authorities announced the capture of Alejandro “El Alex” Chavez Moreno, identified by authorities as the leader of Los Mano con Ojos. Chavez is believed to be responsible for more than 70 executions.

Nov. 9


  • Federal police arrested three members of La Familia Michoacana in Chalco, Mexico state.
  • Unidentified gunmen killed the manager of a hardware store in Chihuahua, Chihuahua state.

Nov. 10


  • Five gunmen were killed in two separate shootouts with the Mexican military in Ramos Arizpe, Coahuila state.
  • Mexican authorities announced the seizure of a training camp near Madero, Chihuahua state. Authorities seized assault rifles, ammunition, grenades and vehicles.
  • Police discovered a residence used by a criminal organization in Marin, Nuevo Leon state. Authorities discovered the burned bodies of two men inside the residence.
  • Gunmen opened fire on a gas station in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state, killing a 16-year-old boy.
  • The Mexican army seized more than 9 tons of marijuana from four vehicles in Culiacan, Sinaloa state.

Nov. 11


  • Mexican authorities arrested five Los Zetas operators in Escobedo, Nuevo Leon state, two of whom were financial operators for the criminal organization.
  • Mexican authorities discovered the decapitated bodies of a man and a woman in a taxi in Acapulco, Guerrero state.

Nov. 12


  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of Samuel Reynoso Garcia, also known as Inocencio Carranza Reynoso, a senior member of the Knights Templar. Directly linked to the leader of the Knights Templar, Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez, Reynoso Garcia was arrested with nine accomplices.

Nov. 13


  • Gunmen ambushed agents from Durango state’s bureau of investigations in Santiago Papasquiaro, Durango state. One agent was wounded in the ambush.

Nov. 14


  • Mexican authorities arrested Rigoberto “Comandante Chapparo” Zamarripa Arispe, a Zetas plaza boss in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

November 15, 2011
The Mexican army captured Juan Gabriel Orozco Favela, a leader of the Knights Templar cartel, in Morelia, Mexico, the Mexican attorney general said Nov. 15, AFP reported. Orozco, nicknamed “El Gasca,” was wanted in connection with the abduction and murder of 21 people in Michoacan state. He was plaza leader for the cartel in Morelia.
November 10, 2011 | 1319 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: March 2, 2009

AFO Lieutenant Arrested


Mexican authorities arrested a senior member of the Arellano Felix Organization (AFO) on Nov. 5 in Tijuana, Baja California state. According to a statement from the Mexican Defense Ministry, Juan Francisco “La Rueda” Sillas Rocha, the AFO’s top enforcer, who is believed to have reported directly to current AFO leader Fernando Sanchez Arellano, was arrested after shooting and wounding two rival cartel members near Insurgentes Boulevard. An army spokesman said Sillas was captured after police and soldiers cordoned off the area immediately following the attack.
In 2007, the Sinaloa Federation encroached on the AFO’s long-held territory in Baja California, prompting an all-out turf war between the groups. AFO leader Luis Fernando “El Ingeniero” Sanchez Arellano, a nephew of the cartel’s founders, allegedly ordered Sillas to regain Tijuana from rival Teodoro “El Teo” Garcia Simental, who had defected from the AFO and joined ranks with Sinaloa. As a result, Tijuana was extremely violent from 2007 to 2009, with decapitations, hangings and daylight shootouts becoming common occurrences. The violence subsided after Garcia was arrested and after Sinaloa absorbed AFO’s territory, relegating Sanchez Arellano’s organization, which was severely damaged by the war and unable to resist, to a reluctant vassal that paid Sinaloa for the right to exist.
Sillas’ arrest furthers the trend of cartel dynamics in the area. Any push from the AFO to regain territory lost to Sinaloa likely would have been conducted by Sillas. Though the AFO has not been eliminated completely, the arrest of Sillas means that the AFO’s chances of countering Sinaloa and regaining power in Tijuana are diminishing. Likewise, as the AFO’s power continues to wane, the Sinaloa Federation’s grip on territory along Mexico’s Pacific coast only strengthens.

Mayor Killed in Michoacan


While distributing campaign material for Michoacan state gubernatorial candidate Luisa Mario Calderon Hinojosa, Ricardo Guzman, the mayor of La Piedad, Michoacan state, was shot and killed Nov. 3 by an unidentified gunman in a black SUV bearing Jalisco state plates. According to reports, Guzman died as he was being transported to a hospital by ambulance.
With the presence of multiple drug cartels, including Los Zetas, the Knights Templar, remnants of La Familia Michoacana and the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion, Michoacan public officials on all levels are vulnerable to competing cartel pressure. Candidates from all three major Mexican political parties reportedly have been threatened during the recent campaign season in Michoacan, and six municipal police chiefs have been killed in the state in 2011 alone.
Mayors and other local officials are particularly susceptible to cartel pressure. Unlike governors or presidents — but like cartels — mayors must operate in their local environments (state and federal officials are by no means insulated from cartel machinations, but they are further removed from the warlike environments found in some of these locations). If such officials are perceived to favor a cartel, they will be attacked by a rival cartel. If they refuse to work for a specific cartel, that organization will attack them in retribution. If they have no support from any cartel, they are vulnerable to attack by all.
For mayors and other local officials, consorting with criminal groups often is a matter of necessity, and since they generally have security inferior to that of presidents and governors, they often fall victim to attacks or pressure. In fact, 25 mayors have been killed throughout Mexico since 2006. The timing of this incident, however, is notable, as are those involved.
The candidate for whom Guzman was campaigning is the sister of current Mexican President Felipe Calderon. Like her brother, she is a member of the National Action Party (PAN), as was Guzman, who, according to Calderon Hinojosa’s campaign manager, had received threats prior to the shooting. The campaign manager did not give any specifics as to why or by whom the threats were made, and at present there is no hard evidence to suggest the killing was a targeted political assassination. The possibility cannot be ruled out, however. Neither can it be ruled out that Guzman was attacked to send Calderon Hinojosa or her brother a message.
There is another line of investigation into the murder. According to media reports, Guzman is rumored to have issued permits that would grant casinos authorization to operate in La Piedad. Authorities are looking into this theory, as it suggests an element of corruption in Guzman. But even though casinos and organized crime often are intimately linked, any concrete connection tying Guzman to organized crime remains unconfirmed. Of course, the attack could be personal and completely unrelated to his position as mayor.
Whatever the precise motive behind Guzman’s killing, the timing of the attack serves as a reminder that politicians are not immune to cartel operations; in fact, they are often the targets of such operations. Politicians can guarantee key access and cover for cartels looking to operate in a number of arenas, including money laundering and entering legitimate businesses. They also are limited to serving only one term, so they are somewhat expendable. The gubernatorial elections in Michoacan are the final elections in Mexico before the presidential election takes place in 2012. In light of the Nov. 3 attack, STRATFOR will be watching the lead-up to the presidential election carefully for signs of cartel influence.



Nov. 1


  • The bodies of two men shot multiple times were discovered in an SUV in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state. Their hands were bound.
  • Mexican authorities raided a Gulf cartel safe-house in Temixco, Morelos state. An unidentified number of Gulf cartel lookouts were arrested in the raid.
  • Mexican authorities arrested 21 municipal police officers in the cities of Pesqueria, Linares and Mina, Nuevo Leon state, for their connections with criminal organizations.

Nov. 2


  • Gunmen attacked Mexican soldiers as they raided a safe-house in Xochitepec, Morelos state. One gunman was killed and three others were arrested.
  • Federal police rescued at least eight kidnapping victims from a safe-house in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.
  • Two criminal groups engaged in a firefight in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state. Gunmen used public and private transit vehicles to block several roads in the city.
  • Mexican military forces seized four residences in Xochitepec, Morelos state, used by a criminal organization. During the operation, authorities seized weapons, chemical precursors and surveillance equipment used to monitor pedestrians entering and exiting an adjacent airport.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a Federal Ministerial Police commander in Saltillo, Coahuila state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed Ricardo Guzman Romero, the mayor of La Piedad, Michoacan state.

Nov. 3


  • Mexican military forces engaged in a firefight with unidentified gunmen while on patrol in Tantoyuca, Veracruz state. One of the gunmen was arrested, though the rest escaped.
  • Federal police arrested Hector Russel “El Toro” Rodriguez Baez, a leader of La Familia Michoacana, in Chalco, Mexico state.

Nov. 4


  • Mexican military forces engaged in a firefight with gunmen while on patrol in Mocorito, Sinaloa state. All of the gunmen escaped.
  • Unidentified gunmen executed 15 individuals in various areas of Culiacan, Sinaloa state.

Nov. 6


  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of Victor Manuel “El Gordo” Rivera Galeana in Mexico state. Rivera was a founder and leader of La Barredora, a criminal organization operating in Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • A narcomanta signed by La Familia Michoacana was left with a dead body in Chalco, Mexico state.
  • Armed men executed a man at a bar in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. All gunmen escaped before the police arrived.
  • Mexican authorities seized 2,913.4 kilograms (6,422.9 pounds) of marijuana stored in a warehouse in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state.
  • Gunmen entered the offices of El Buen Tono news agency in Cordoba, Veracruz state, destroying computers and other equipment before setting an office on fire.

Nov. 7


  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of Juan Francisco “La Rueda” Sillas Rocha, a lieutenant of Arellano Felix Organization leader Luis Fernando Sanchez Arellano. Sillas was arrested over the previous weekend in Tijuana, Baja California state.
  • Mexican authorities discovered two bodies in Mexico City with a narcomanta signed by La Mano con Ojos and The New Administration organization.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

November 7, 2011
Mexican authorities arrested top Arellano Felix cartel member Juan Francisco Sillas Rocha, also known as “The Wheel,” on Nov. 5, a Mexican Defense Ministry spokesman announced Nov. 7, CNN reported. According to Defense Ministry statement, Sillas was a key lieutenant in a war with the Sinaloa Cartel. An army spokesman said Sillas reported directly to the cartel’s leader, Fernando Sanchez Arellano, AP reported.
November 3, 2011 | 1319 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Gulf Faction Leader Arrested in Texas

‘El Junior’ Caught by U.S. Authorities


U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents on Oct. 26 announced that Stratfor Rafael “El Junior” Cardenas Vela was arrested Oct. 20 after a traffic stop near Port Isabel, Texas, while on his way to a residence he reportedly owns on nearby South Padre Island. Cardenas Vela, believed to be the leader of one faction vying for power within the Gulf cartel, was accompanied by three bodyguards and had in his possession at the time of the stop an authentic Mexican passport and U.S. entry visa in a fraudulent identity.
According to a STRATFOR source, the traffic stop was initiated after an anonymous tip provided U.S. authorities with Cardenas Vela’s location. Because of his role as head of the “Los Rojos” faction of the Gulf cartel, the tip may have come from Cardenas Vela’s rivals in the Gulf cartel known as the “Los Metros” faction. This would be even more evidence of the internal fight that has consumed the cartel in recent months.
Cardenas Vela is the nephew of former Gulf cartel leader Osiel Cardenas Guillen, who was arrested in 2003 and succeeded by his brother, Antonio “Tony Tormenta” Cardenas Guillen, and Eduardo “El Coss” Costilla Sanchez — the current leader of the Los Metros faction — as co-leaders of the Gulf cartel. After Antonio was killed in November 2010, Costilla Sanchez became sole leader of the cartel, though Cardenas Vela felt that as a blood relative of longtime Gulf leader Cardenas Guillen, he should be the cartel’s leader.
This leadership dispute was the seed of the current infighting. The struggle appears to have intensified in recent weeks, with the Los Rojos faction loyal to Cardenas Vela believed to be responsible for the killing of Costilla Sanchez’s second-in-command Sept. 3. As long as the factions of the Gulf cartel are caught up fighting among themselves, the group is in a weakened state and other cartels can be expected to take advantage of the situation. The Los Metros faction thus has a strong incentive to take out the Los Rojos leaders and is in a good position to have or acquire information, such as Cardenas Vela’s whereabouts and the locations of his likely hideouts. Cartels usually try to avoid conducting hits on U.S. soil, which may explain why Costilla Sanchez’s faction may have tipped off U.S. authorities instead of killing him.
There has not been any confirmation that Los Metros was responsible for the tip to U.S. authorities, but even if it was not, it will benefit from the hit taken by its intra-cartel rivals with the loss of their leader. It appears Costilla Sanchez has already begun efforts to consolidate power before the Los Rojos faction has a chance to reorganize and name a new leader. Such efforts will likely include putting out orders to kill other Los Rojos faction leaders, which may explain why Jose Luis “Comandante Wicho” Zuniga Hernandez, believed to be Cardenas Vela’s deputy and operations leader of the Matamoros plaza, reportedly turned himself in to U.S. authorities without a fight near Santa Maria, Texas, on Oct. 28. The Los Metros faction will try to move quickly before the Sinaloa cartel or Los Zetas conclude that now is the time to make a move to seize control of the Gulf cartel’s territory.

Spike of Violence in Baja California Sur


The small coastal city of Cabo San Lucas experienced an unusual surge of violence during the previous week. On Oct. 25, police commander Martin Marquez Ruiz was shot to death by gunmen. Three days later, state police and military forces reportedly searching for Marquez Ruiz’s killers raided a home in Brisas del Pacifico and were engaged by gunmen in a lengthy gunfight around midnight. Witnesses reported hearing grenade explosions, and the battle left one Mexican marine and two gunmen dead. The following day, on Oct. 29, municipal police confronted gunmen at the Plaza Sendero retail mall after the gunmen entered the shopping complex hoping to evade capture. Some reports indicate that a two-hour firefight took place and that the gunmen took hostages, though these reports were later denied by Mexico’s Defense Ministry.
It is unclear if the gunfights on Oct. 28 and Oct. 29 were connected, but the fact that they took place at all is notable. For the last two years, Baja California Sur has been one of Mexico’s least violent regions due to the Sinaloa cartel’s undisputed control over the area as well as the territory’s relative undesirability because it lacks commercial ports that facilitate the importing and exporting of drugs and precursor chemicals. Consisting mainly of quiet coastal fishing villages and lacking significant transportation corridors, the resorts and tourism sector are the main generators of economic activity.
It is highly unlikely that another cartel would be attempting to challenge Sinaloa’s hold on the territory through the recent wave of violence, and the rapid succession of incidents may have simply been a coincidence. However, there are a few other potential explanations.
The most likely of these is that local street gangs involved in the retail drug market, mainly selling their product to tourists, ran afoul of local authorities and decided to retaliate against the police commander. If these small drug organizations are not outright controlled by Sinaloa, they are almost certainly buying their drugs from Sinaloa to resale to tourists, and thus the cartel will be able to curtail this behavior if it wishes simply by not selling drugs to the gangs or by standing aside and allowing the police to wipe them out.
Another potential cause could be that a local subgroup within the Sinaloa cartel attempted to assert its independence by taking on the authorities. (Because the cartel has coexisted for some time with and is known to have infiltrated police and security forces in Baja California, it would have little reason to upset this dynamic by attacking security forces.) In this circumstance, we would expect Sinaloa to quickly deal with this situation and bring any independent elements back under control by allowing local police to handle the matter in a similar manner to the street gangs or by taking out the wayward cartel members themselves.



Oct. 25


  • Mexican authorities arrested Carlos Arturo “El Bam Bam” Pitalua Carrillo, Los Zetas’ plaza boss of Veracruz, Veracruz state, in that city. Five other Zetas members were detained with Pitalua Carrillo.
  • Two dismembered bodies were discovered in a taxi in Acapulco, Guerrero state, with a narcomanta purportedly signed by the Independent Cartel of Acapulco.

Oct. 26


  • Mexican authorities discovered several secret graves after receiving an anonymous tip in Cuauhtemoc, Chihuahua state. Authorities have not released details on the number of bodies found.
  • The body of a decapitated male was discovered in a vehicle in Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • Customs officials seized 491 kilograms (1,082 pounds) of marijuana destined for El Paso, Texas, at a customs checkpoint in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.

Oct. 27


  • Mexican authorities seized 4.1 kilograms of heroin from an individual at Mexico City International Airport. The individual was detained before boarding a flight to Paris.

Oct. 28


  • The newly established Civil Force of Nuevo Leon arrested five individuals and freed a kidnapping victim from a residence in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Mexican soldiers raided a reported cartel base near Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state. No individuals were arrested but weapons, ammunition, vehicles and 1 kilogram of marijuana were seized.
  • Gunmen killed two municipal police officers in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, while the officers were traveling in a vehicle.

Oct. 29


  • Mexican authorities seized 1.3 kilograms of heroin from an individual traveling from Huatabampo, Sonora state, to Nogales, Sonora state. The individual was transporting the heroin in his shoes.
  • Mexican authorities conducted a raid on a residence in Cabo San Lucas, Baja California Sur state, following the killing of police commander Martin Marquez Ruiz in the city on Oct. 24. During the raid, gunmen engaged the authorities in a firefight that left one Mexican marine and two gunmen dead.
  • Authorities in Guadalajara, Jalisco state, discovered two severed pig heads in ice coolers with narcomantas allegedly directed at the Jalisco state Public Security Secretariat. The contents of the message have not been released.

Oct. 30


  • A group of gunmen attacked the Veracruz-Boca del Rio Intermunicipal Police Station in Veracruz, Veracruz state. Three gunmen were killed after being pursued by police.

Nov. 1


  • Several gunbattles occurred in Saltillo, Coahuila state, beginning at about 2 p.m. In one firefight, rival groups of gunmen from the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas drove through neighborhoods on the east side of the city, during which one unidentified individual was killed. The fighting took place in the neighborhoods of Los Cerritos, Praderas, Magisterio, Los Maestros and Guanajuato. The inter-cartel battles triggered responses from local and federal authorities. Another gunbattle occurred in the immediate vicinity of the Instituto Tecnologico de Saltillo campus between a group of gunmen and Mexican marines. Fighting spread through the east and north-central portions of Saltillo over several hours, with two police officers and one gunman being killed and several state or federal police officers wounded.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

November 2, 2011

Readers Comment on STRATFOR Reports


By Scott Stewart
The online activist collective Anonymous posted a message on the Internet on Oct. 31 saying it would continue its campaign against Mexican criminal cartels and their government supporters despite the risks.
The message urged inexperienced activists, who might not be practicing proper online security measures, to abstain from participating. It also urged individuals associated with Anonymous in Mexico not to conduct physical pamphlet drops, participate in protests, wear or purchase Guy Fawkes masks, or use Guy Fawkes imagery in their Internet or physical-world activities. Guy Fawkes was a British Roman Catholic conspirator involved in a plot to bomb the British Parliament on Nov. 5, 1605. The British celebrate the plot’s failure as Guy Fawkes Day each Nov. 5. In modern times, the day has come to have special meaning for anarchists. Since 2006, the style of the Guy Fawkes mask used in the movie “V for Vendetta” has become something of an anarchist icon in the United Kingdom and elsewhere.
It was no coincidence, then, that in an Oct. 6 video Anonymous activists set Nov. 5 as the deadline for Los Zetas to release an Anonymous associate allegedly kidnapped in Veracruz. The associate reportedly was abducted during an Anonymous leaflet campaign called “Operation Paperstorm.”
The Oct. 31 message acknowledged that the operation against Los Zetas, dubbed “Operation Cartel,” would be dangerous. It noted that some members of the collective would form a group of trusted associates to participate in a special task force to execute the operation. It asked supporters to pass information pertaining to drug trafficking to the Operation Cartel task force for publication on the Internet via a software tool developed by Anonymous that permits the anonymous passing of information.
When discussing Anonymous, it is important to remember that Anonymous is not a hierarchical organization, but rather a collective of activists. Individuals who choose to associate themselves with the collective frequently disagree over issues addressed by the collective and are free to choose which actions to support and/or participate in.
With Nov. 5 approaching, and at least some elements of Anonymous not backing down on their threats to Los Zetas, we thought it would be useful to provide some context to the present conflict between Anonymous and Los Zetas and to address some of its potential implications.

Context


The Mexican port city of Veracruz has been the epicenter of this event. Veracruz has been a busy place over the past few months in terms of Mexico’s cartel wars. The port serves as a critical transportation hub for Los Zetas narcotics smuggling. Because of this, STRATFOR has identified Veracruz as a bellwether for determining Los Zetas’ trajectory in the coming months.
In a major recent development in Veracruz, the Sinaloa cartel began an offensive into the Zetas stronghold using the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG), which, under the name “Matazetas” (Spanish for “Zeta killers”), conducted high-profile body dumps of more than 50 alleged low-level Zetas operatives on Sept. 20 and Sept. 22. On Oct. 25, Mexican marines arrested Carlos Arturo Pitalua-Carillo, also known as “El Bam Bam,” who was the Zetas’ plaza boss in Veracruz. The Zetas in Veracruz thus are feeling pressure from both the Mexican government and the CJNG.
The Anonymous Internet collective entered this dynamic in August with its activities in Veracruz. It is common knowledge that members of local, state and federal governments in Mexico support various cartel groups. In the state of Veracruz, it is generally believed that some members of the state government support Los Zetas, the dominant cartel there. In response to this corruption, some who have associated themselves with Anonymous launched Operation Paperstorm. These activists distributed leaflets throughout Veracruz denouncing the state government for supporting Los Zetas. They conducted leaflet distributions Aug. 13, Aug. 20 and Aug. 29. They also released videos on the Internet on Aug. 26 and Aug. 29 condemning the Veracruz state government.
Activities outside Veracruz also played a part in setting the stage. On Sept. 13, the bodies of two people who had been tortured and killed were hung from a pedestrian overpass in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state. Signs left with the bodies said Los Zetas had killed the pair because they had posted information pertaining to the Zetas on blogs that specialize in reporting on the Mexican cartels. On Sept. 26, the decapitated body of Marisol Macias Castaneda was found in a park in Nuevo Laredo. Macias, who worked for a local newspaper, allegedly posted on cartel blogs using the nickname “Laredo Girl.” A message found with her body said the Zetas killed her due to her online activities.
Following the death of Laredo Girl, Anonymous claimed responsibility for a distributed denial of service attack against the official website of the state of Veracruz. Although her murder occurred outside of the state, Anonymous said its attack on the Veracruz website was in response to Laredo Girl’s death. This indicates that activists understand that Los Zetas are active in both areas and suggests that Veracruz state-based activists are driving the Anonymous campaign against Los Zetas.
Significantly, some individuals associated with Anonymous already were unhappy with the state of Veracruz over its decision to prosecute two individuals who had posted kidnapping reports on Twitter on Aug. 25 that proved false. According to the reports, a group of children had been abducted from a Veracruz school. The inaccurate reports allegedly caused some two dozen traffic accidents as terrified parents rushed to the school to check on their children. The so-called Twitter terrorists initially were charged with offenses that could have carried a 30-year sentence. Some associated with Anonymous, which has absolute freedom of speech on the Internet as one of its foundational principles, took umbrage at the prospect of such stiff penalties — especially given the stark contrast with the impunity enjoyed by many cartel figures in Mexico.
STRATFOR began to focus on the story following the Oct. 6 release of the video in which Anonymous activists threatened to release information about individuals cooperating with Los Zetas if the Zetas did not release the Anonymous activist kidnapped during Operation Paperstorm. In light of the approaching Nov. 5 deadline, we published an analysis of the topic on Oct. 28; the topic subsequently received a great deal of media coverage.
This publicity has generated a very interesting response from Anonymous that emphasizes that it is a collective, not an organization. Some Anonymous activists began to back off the issue, erasing online user accounts formerly associated with the campaign, suggesting the operation against Los Zetas had been a hoax and claiming that no activist had been kidnapped. Other activists suggested that the campaign was dangerous, ill-advised and should be suspended. Still other activists became more strident and determined in their posts, urging that the campaign continue. As noted, Anonymous’ collective nature means activists can select the actions they participate in, including Operation Cartel. It would only take one dedicated individual to continue the operation.
The will to continue was manifested Oct. 29 with the hacking of the personal website of Gustavo Rosario Torres, the former attorney general of the Mexican state of Tabasco. The site was defaced with a message from Anonymous Mexico stating that Rosario is a Zeta. Rosario has long been accused in the Mexican and international media of protecting Los Zetas, and videos long have circulated on YouTube making the same charge. The hacking of his website thus did not provide any startling revelation; Anonymous will have to uncover and publish original and timely information if it hopes to do much damage to Los Zetas.
The determination by some activists to continue the operation against Los Zetas also was reflected in the tone of the Oct. 31 message. Some activists associated with Anonymous clearly feel compelled to continue with the campaign over what they have characterized as an outpouring of public support in the wake of the media coverage. According to their Oct. 31 video statement:

“We received many expressions of support and solidarity as well as the voices of people crying for help. We must remember that we are on the side of the people, and we cannot let down the people, especially in critical moments like the one they currently live in.”
We therefore anticipate that some Anonymous activists will continue the campaign. We also believe that Los Zetas will respond.

Blowback


Mexico’s various cartels long have used the Internet to trumpet their triumphs on the battlefield and to taunt and even degrade their enemies. The cartels have posted videos of the torture, execution and desecration of the corpses of rivals. They also frequently monitor narcoblogs and sometimes even post on them. As demonstrated by the September blogger killings in Nuevo Laredo, Los Zetas appear to possess at least some rudimentary capability to trace online activity to people in the physical world. They are known to employ their own team of dedicated cyber experts and to have sources within the Mexican government.
In addition to technical intelligence, the Zetas can use old-fashioned human intelligence to track down their online enemies. People sometimes discuss their online identities with family and friends, and such information can be overheard and passed to Los Zetas in return for money. This danger was recognized in the Oct. 31 video from Anonymous that urges participants in their campaign not to discuss their activities with anyone.
In past Anonymous actions, like the December 2010 attack against PayPal after the WikiLeaks scandal broke, the U.S. and British governments arrested numerous individuals associated with Anonymous who allegedly participated in the attacks. In June 2011, Turkey arrested dozens of activists associated with Anonymous actions conducted against the Turkish government in response to its plan to establish a national Internet-filtering system. This indicates that some activists associated with Anonymous are not nearly as anonymous as they would like to be. Every action on the Internet leaves some sort of trail, making it very difficult to be truly anonymous.
Like other Mexican cartels, Los Zetas do not take affronts lightly. Even if Anonymous cannot provide information that damages Los Zetas smuggling operations, the very fact that the collective has decided publicly to challenge Los Zetas will result in some sort of response. The big question is whether the Zetas possess the capability to trace the organizers of the Anonymous action?
One challenge with tracking an entity such as Anonymous is that it is intentionally amorphous. It is also as transnational as the Internet, and it would be unsurprising if many of those chosen to participate in the operation against Los Zetas are located in the United Sates, Europe and other areas that are outside the Zetas’ immediate reach.
The amorphous nature of Anonymous can also cut the other way, however. If Los Zetas abduct and execute random patrons at an Internet cafe, behead them and place Guy Fawkes masks on their heads, it will be very difficult to prove that they were not associated with Anonymous. Los Zetas also could execute random people and claim they had provided Anonymous with information in order to intimidate people from actually cooperating with Anonymous. As Anonymous noted in its Oct. 31 video, this is dangerous business indeed.

The Big Picture


How the Mexican public reacts to the Anonymous operation must be watched. The criminal cartels and their violence have deeply affected many people in Mexico’s middle and upper classes. STRATFOR talks to many people in Mexico who fear that they or a family member will be kidnapped. In many communities, especially places like Ciudad Juarez, Torreon, Monterrey and Veracruz, businessmen find themselves in a terrible bind. They face ever-increasing extortion demands from the cartels while their business revenues dwindle because the violence associated with those same cartels has frightened people into not going out. This is forcing many small businesses to close. It also is creating a great deal of frustration and resentment.
At the same time, Mexico has become one of the most dangerous countries in the world for journalists, and many media organizations practice heavy self-censorship to protect themselves. In the wake of the September blogger killings, some of the narcoblogs, like Blog del Narco, have exhibited strong signs of self-censorship inspired by fear. As a result, many Mexicans believe the mainstream media are not of any real assistance in the face of cartel violence.
Mexican citizens also are frustrated with their government, which, as noted, is well-known for corruption. This sentiment is feeding Anonymous’ original campaign in Veracruz. This frustration even has led some people to begin discussing the creation of vigilante groups to fight the cartels — though this has been attempted before in Mexico. As we saw in the case of La Familia Michoacana, which began as such a vigilante group, vigilantism frequently does not end well.
This is where Anonymous may fit in. With Mexican citizens unable to rely on their government, the media or even armed vigilante groups for assistance, they may embrace Anonymous, coming to view its form of cybervigilantism as an outlet for their frustration. If Anonymous is perceived as a safe way to pass information pertaining to cartel activities, we may see people from all over the country begin to share intelligence. Such human intelligence could very well prove to be far more damaging to the cartels than any information Anonymous activists can dredge up electronically. As this operation is becoming more widely publicized, the pool of people outside Mexico who might wish to participate will likely grow. The number of people inside Mexico who wish to provide information might grow as well.
Anonymous has taken on many powerful entities in the past, such as major transnational corporations and governments. But the repercussions from participating in such operations were never as grave for online activists as they are in this case. Being identified and detained by Scotland Yard or the FBI is a far different situation than being identified and detained by Los Zetas.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
November 1, 2011 | 2040 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

Tactical Analyst Ben West discusses online activists Anonymous’ continued efforts against Mexican drug cartels and the cartels’ responses.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


A member of the online activist group, Anonymous, released a video statement October 31 stating that it will continue to search for and publicize sensitive data about Mexican criminal organizations despite the physical threat of doing so.
Based upon past examples, the latest Anonymous campaign against Los Zetas could spill over into the real world, resulting in violence and deaths as Los Zetas target a new group.
Online media has been in conflict with Mexican criminal and drug organizations for some time now. Journalists are known to be targets of the cartels and plenty have been killed in the past.
Bloggers are also included in the online media campaign against the cartels, but they have typically not been targeted as much — likely because the information they post has not had as much of an impact on cartel operations as the journalists have.
However, that could be changing with the addition of Anonymous to the anti-cartel online media campaign in Mexico.
Throughout August and September of this year four people with connections to anti-cartel blog websites have been attacked.
· Two individuals killed and hung from a bridge in Nuevo Laredo with signs warning not to post on blogs.
· A girl found beheaded in Nuevo Laredo who had contributed to anti-cartel blogs in the past.
· Additionally, an Anonymous member claimed that a volunteer was abducted by Los Zetas while distributing pamphlets in Veracruz.
Anonymous has conducted successful Distributed Denial of Service Attacks on institutions such as Visa and MasterCard and has stolen sensitive information from HB Gary Federal in 2011 and subsequently publicized internal emails from that group. It brings together a group of individuals with a higher skill-set and sense of operational security than the less savvy anti-cartel bloggers already active in Mexico.
This higher skill-set means that Anonymous could contribute to the effectiveness of the online struggle against the cartels or at least bring more publicity to the issue. It’s important to remember that the U.S. has been engaging in its own electronic observation of the Mexican cartels for years. Anonymous likely won’t be able to turn up more information than the U.S. government already has, but they are able to publicize more information than the U.S. government can.
If Anonymous is able to increase the effectiveness of online operations seeking to expose cartel activities then that makes them and other anti-cartel bloggers in Mexico much higher profile targets than before.
Anonymous is not an organization. It’s important to remember, it is a loose association of individuals. It’s not the group itself then, but the individuals involved, who become targets of the cartels.
We have seen reports that Los Zetas are deploying their own teams of computer experts to track those individuals involved in the online anti-cartel campaign, which indicates that the criminal group is taking the campaign very seriously. Those individuals involved face the risk of abduction, injury and death — judging by how Los Zetas has dealt with threats in the past.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


This report may be forwarded or republished on your website with attribution to www.stratfor.com
October 2011
October 28, 2011
STRATFOR received information Oct. 28 that a gunbattle between cartel elements and the Mexican military is taking place in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico. Reports indicate that a high-value target is involved and is possibly wounded or captured. The gunbattle reportedly occurred following planned operations by the Mexican military.
October 27, 2011 | 1948 GMT

Vice President of Tactical Intelligence Scott Stewart discusses the arrest of Rafael Cardenas Vela and what it means for the Gulf Cartel and for security in Mexico’s northeast.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


On Oct. 26, U.S. authorities announced they had arrested Rafael Cardenas Vela in a traffic stop in Port Isabella, Texas on Oct. 20. The arrest of Cardenas, who is also known as “El Junior,” is significant because he was one of the leaders of two factions that are currently fighting for control of the Gulf Cartel. The struggle among these differing Gulf Cartel factions could have a significant impact on the security situation in Mexico’s northeast.
Rafael Cardenas Vela is the nephew of Osiel Cardenas Guillen, former leader of the Gulf Cartel. Osiel Cardenas Guillen was convicted in a U.S. court in 2010 and sentenced to serve 25 years, which he is currently serving in the Supermax prison in Florence, Colo. Following the arrest of Osiel Cardenas Guillen, control of the Gulf Cartel was handed to his brother, Antonio Ezequiel Cardenas Guillen, also know as “Tony Tormenta,” as well as Jorge Eduardo Costilla Sanchez, who is know as “El Coss.”
That arrangement seemed to work fairly well for several years, but it broke apart following the death of Tony Tormenta in November 2010. This led to a rift in the Gulf Cartel between a faction of those members of the cartel who are loyal to the Cardenas family and a section of the cartel that is loyal to El Coss. In recent months, we’ve been watching as that friction and tension have increased and it appears currently that it’s on the verge of breaking into an all-out war.
In early September, we saw one of El Coss’s major lieutenants, Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borego, get assassinated in northern Mexico. And this was one of the signs that tensions were increasing between the two factions. We believe that it’s very likely that the arrest of El Junior is connected to this inter-factional fighting between the Gulf Cartel, and it’s quite possible that the information that led to his arrest was leaked to U.S. authorities by El Coss, his primary rival for control of the Gulf Cartel.
The fact that Cardenas was in U.S. custody for several days before his arrest was announced is very interesting. It indicates to us that he was likely cooperating with U.S. authorities. So we’re going to be watching this Gulf Cartel infighting very carefully for signs that it’s going to weaken these various cartel factions enough that other organizations can move into their areas of operation. In this case of the Gulf Cartel, we have both Los Zetas, who used to be the enforcer group of the Gulf Cartel before splitting from them in January 2010 and are now bitter rivals with the Gulf Cartel, and of course their allies, the Sinaloa Cartel.
Over time, the Sinaloa Cartel has shown that it is very aggressive at moving into and taking territory from its former allies like we saw in Tijuana and in Juarez. So it would not be surprising for them to try to make a move in the northeast to take control of Matamoros. And it’s going to be important to watch the area around Matamoros to see if the areas that are controlled currently by the Gulf Cartel fall to one of these other very powerful cartel organizations.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


This report may be forwarded or republished on your website with attribution to www.stratfor.com
October 27, 2011

Will Libya Again Become the Arsenal of Terrorism?


By Scott Stewart
Early Oct. 20, a small sedan apparently filled with cartel gunmen rapidly pulled in front of a military vehicle, drawing the military patrol into a car chase in downtown Monterrey, Mexico. After a brief pursuit, the vehicle carrying the cartel gunmen turned at an intersection. As the military vehicle slowed to negotiate the turn, an improvised explosive device (IED) concealed in a parked car at the intersection detonated. The incident appears to have been intended to lure the military patrol into a designated attack zone. While the ambush did not kill any soldiers, it did cause them to break off their chase.
Though this IED ambush is interesting in itself for a number of reasons, we would like to use it as a lens to explore a deeper topic, namely, how STRATFOR analyzes a tactical incident like this.

Why We Look at an Incident


Hundreds of violent incidents take place every day worldwide, from fuel depot explosions in Sirte, Libya, to shootings in southern Thailand to grenade attacks in Nairobi, Kenya — just a few of the things that happened on a single day this week. Indeed, a typical day sees dozens of incidents in Mexico alone, from shootings and beheadings to kidnappings and cargo theft. Unless one has a method to triage such incidents, they quickly can overwhelm an analyst, dragging him or her down into the weeds struggling to understand the tactical details of every one. This can result in information overload. The details of so many incidents simply overwhelm the analyst’s ability to understand them and place them in a context that allows them to be compared to, and perhaps linked with, other incidents.
STRATFOR’s methodology for placing items in context begins with our interrelated array of net assessments and forecasts. Net assessments are high-level overviews of the significant issues driving the current behavior of nations, regions and other significant international actors. Forecasts can be drawn from these baseline assessments to predict how these actors will behave, and how that behavior will impact regional dynamics. In this way, net assessments and forecasts provide a strategic framework of understanding that can be used to help create assessments and forecasts for tactical-level items.
In the case of Mexico, we have long considered the country’s criminal cartels significant tactical-level actors, and we have established an analytical framework for understanding them. We publish this framework in the form of our annual cartel report. The higher-level framework generally shapes such tactical-level analyses, but at times the analyses can also contradict and challenge the higher-level assessments. We also maintain a regular flow of tactical analyses such as the weekly Mexico Security Memo, which serves to explain how events in Mexico fit into our analytical framework. The items we select as bullets for the second section of the Mexico Security Memo are significant and further the analytical narrative of what is happening in Mexico but do not require deeper analysis. This helps our readers cut through the clutter of the reporting from Mexico by focusing on what we find important. We also strive to eliminate the bias so prevalent in today’s media landscape. Our readers frequently tell us they find this analytical winnowing process quite valuable.
Based upon this tactical framework, we then establish intelligence guidance. This lays out tripwire events that our analysts, regional open-source monitoring team and even our on-the-ground sources are to watch for that either support or refute our forecast. (In STRATFOR’s corporate culture, challenging an assessment or forecast is one of the most important things an employee can do. This ensures we stay intellectually honest and on target. There is nothing more analytically damaging than an analyst who falls in love with his own assessment, or a team of analysts who buy into groupthink.)
When an event, or a combination of events, occurs that does not fit the analytical framework, the framework must undergo a rigorous review to ensure it remains valid. If the framework is found to be flawed, we determine if it needs to be adjusted or scrapped. Due to the rapid shifts we have seen on the ground in Mexico in the past two years in terms of arrests and deaths of major cartel leaders and the emergence of factional infighting and even new cartel groups, we have found it necessary to adjust our framework cartel report more than just annually. In 2011, for example, we have felt compelled to update the framework quarterly.
And this brings us back to our IED attack in Monterrey. When we learn of such an event, we immediately apply our analytical framework to it in an effort to determine if and how it fits. In this case, we have certainly seen previous IED attacks in Mexico and even grenade attacks in Monterrey, but not an IED attack in Monterrey, so this is clearly a geographic anomaly. While we don’t really have a new capability, or a new actor — Los Zetas were implicated in a command-detonated IED attack in January in Tula, Hidalgo state — we do have a new location in Monterrey. We also have a new tactic in using a vehicle chase to lure a military vehicle into an IED ambush. Past IED ambushes in Juarez and Tula have involved leaving a cadaver in a vehicle and reporting it to the authorities.
Some early reports of the Monterrey incident also indicated that the attack involved a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device (VBIED). If true, this would contradict our assessment that the Mexican cartels have refrained from employing large IEDs in their attacks.
Also, according to our analytical framework and the intelligence guidance we have established, Monterrey is a critical Zeta stronghold. We already have asked our tactical analysts to keep a close eye on activity there and the patterns and trends represented by that activity for indications that Los Zetas might be losing control of the city or that other cartels are establishing control there.
Because of all these factors, the Monterrey attack clearly demanded close examination.

How We Look at an Incident


Once we decide to dig into an incident and rip it apart analytically, we task our analysts and regional open-source monitors to find everything they can about the incident. At the same time, we reach out to our network of contacts to see what they can tell us. If we have employees in the city or region we will rely heavily on them, but when we do not, we contact all the relevant sources we have in an area. Depending on the location, we will also talk to our contacts in relevant foreign governments with an interest in the incident. Of course, like open-source reports, information we receive from contacts must be carefully vetted for bias and factual accuracy.
As information begins to flow in following an incident, there are almost always conflicting reports that must be reconciled. In the Monterrey case, we had reports from sources such as the Mexican newspaper El Universal saying the IED had been hidden in a vehicle parked beside the road, while The Associated Press ran a story noting that the car being pursued exploded. In some cases, news stories can even seemingly contradict themselves. In the above-mentioned AP story, the author noted that the vehicle containing the IED almost completely disintegrated, but then added that the bombing caused no other damage. It is rare that an IED large enough to disintegrate a car would cause no other damage. We have found that most journalists do not have much experience dealing with explosives or IEDs, as their reporting often reflects.

Dissecting a Mexican Cartel Bombing in Monterrey
Scene of the Oct. 20 improvised explosive device ambush in Monterrey
Such conflicting accounts highlight the importance of photographs and video when analyzing an attack. Photos and videos are no substitute for investigating the scene firsthand, but traveling to a crime scene takes time and money. Moreover, gaining the kind of crime scene access STRATFOR employees enjoyed when they worked for a government is tough. That said, an incredible amount of information can be gleaned from some decent photos and videos of a crime scene.
In the Monterrey attack, the first thing the photos and video showed us is that the vehicle containing the explosive device had not completely disintegrated. In fact, the chassis of the vehicle was mostly intact. It also appeared that the fire that followed the explosion rather than the explosion itself caused much of the damage to the vehicle. The explosive damage done to the vehicle indicated that the main charge of the IED was relatively small, most likely less than 5 pounds of military-grade high explosive. Some media reports said a fragmentation grenade thrown from the vehicle being pursued caused the explosion, but the damage to the car appeared quite a bit greater than would be expected from a hand grenade. Also, no apparent fragmentation pattern consistent with what a grenade would cause was visible in the metal of the car or on the smooth, painted walls of the auto repair shop the car had been parked near.
The lack of fragmentation damage also made it apparent that the bombmaker had not added shrapnel such as ball bearings, nails or nuts and bolts to enhance the device’s destructiveness. Also, while the repair shop’s garage door did have a hole punched through it, the hole appears to have resulted from part of the car having been propelled through it. The door does not display any significant damage or disfiguration from the blast effect. The painted walls do not either, though they do show some signs from the high heat of the explosion and resulting vehicle fire. This is another indication that the blast was fairly small. Finally, that the bulk of the significant damage to the car is in the rear end of the vehicle makes it appear that the small IED had been placed either in the vehicle’s trunk or perhaps on the vehicle’s backseat.
After analyzing such photos and video, our tactical analysts contact other experienced blast investigators and bomb technicians to get their impressions and ensure that their analysis is not off track. Like doctors, investigators frequently chat with other knowledgeable investigators to confirm their diagnoses.
Of course, the process described above is how things happen in an ideal situation. Frequently, reality intrudes on the ideal and the process can get quite messy— especially in the middle of a large ongoing situation like the 2008 Mumbai attacks. Taming the chaos that tends to reign during such a situation is difficult, and we sometimes have to skip or repeat steps of the process depending on the circumstances. We run a postmortem critique after each of these crisis events to determine what we did well and what we need to do better as we strive for excellence.

Piecing It All Together


When we looked at all the pieces of the Monterrey incident, we were able to determine that due to the location and execution of the incident, Los Zetas most likely were behind the attack. It was also clear that the device was a well-constructed, command-detonated IED and that the Mexican troops were drawn into a carefully executed ambush. From the size and construction of the device, however, it would appear the operational planner of the ambush did not intend to kill the soldiers. Had that been the objective, more explosives would have been used in the IED. (Commercial explosives are cheap and plentiful in Mexico.) Alternatively, the same smaller quantity of explosives could have been fashioned into an improvised claymore mine-type device intended to hurl shrapnel at the military patrol — something likely well within the skill set of a bombmaker capable of building and employing an effective command-detonated IED.
The small explosive charge and lack of fragmentation, then, indicates the ambush was intended more to send a message than to cause a massacre. The Mexican cartels have a history of kidnapping, torturing, and murdering Mexican military personnel, so they normally are not squeamish about killing them. This brings us back to our analysis regarding the cartels’ use of IEDs, and our conclusion that the Mexican cartels have intentionally chosen to limit the size of explosive devices they employ in Mexico.
This incident may also be consistent with our analysis that Los Zetas are feeling pressured by the increased military presence in Mexico’s northeast. The message this incident may have been intended to convey is that the military needs to back off. At the very least, at the very lowest tactical level, it will certainly give the Mexican military second thoughts the next time they consider pursuing apparent cartel vehicles in Zeta territory.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
October 26, 2011 | 1244 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Replacing Zetas Leadership

An IED Attack in Monterrey


On Oct. 20, as a Mexican military patrol chased a vehicle carrying suspected cartel gunmen through the streets of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, an unidentified party remotely detonated an improvised explosive device (IED) placed in a parked car moments before the patrol passed by it. There were no reported deaths or injuries from the blast, but all of the gunmen in the vehicle escaped. Though this is the first IED attack Monterrey has witnessed, Mexico Security Memo there have been other such attacks in Mexico within the past year or so. In July 2010, La Linea, the enforcement arm of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes cartel, set off an IED in a car in Ciudad Juarez, killing four people; between August and December 2010, the Gulf cartel deployed as many as six IEDs throughout Tamaulipas state; and in January 2011, a small IED detonated in Tula, Hidalgo state, injuring four people.
In the aftermath of such attacks, it is tempting for observers and the mainstream media to assume cartel violence in Mexico has reached an unprecedented level of escalation, and that an increased use of IEDs is all but certain. However, the Oct. 20 ambush, sophisticated though it was, actually showed some degree of restraint on the part of the planners, as did the IED attacks of the past year elsewhere in Mexico. Given the psychological impact and tactical effectiveness of IED use in a combat environment — and cartel personnel armed with the knowledge to construct sophisticated explosive devices — perhaps more astonishing than the occurrence of IED attacks is the fact that cartels do not conduct them with more regularity or on a greater magnitude than they have. That the cartels choose not to do so illustrates a calculated strategy aimed at staving off further American involvement and limiting negative domestic public opinion against them.

Mexico Security Memo: Restrained IED Attacks a Necessary Tactic For Drug Cartels
A Mexican soldier stands near the site of the Oct. 20 Monterrey blast
Military grade explosives are very easy to acquire on the black market in Mexico. More readily available and cheaper than guns, they are routinely confiscated by security forces. In fact, the army has made notable seizures as recently as the past week. On Oct. 18, the Mexican army seized around 20 kilograms (about 45 pounds) of C4 in or around Mexico City, capable of producing an explosion 10 times larger than that of the Monterrey blast. Later on Oct. 20, the army seized some 45 blocks of C4, as well as detonators, weapons, and cell phones, in Coatzacoalcos, Veracruz state.
The prevalence of individuals practiced at constructing explosive devices adds to the issue. Many cartels employ ex-military personnel as enforcers. Los Zetas, for example, were founded by defectors from the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group and originally served as the enforcement arm of the Gulf cartel before embarking on their own narcotics trafficking operations. These individuals learned the intricacies of demolitions as part of their military training, and they are now in a position to deploy — or train others to deploy — IEDs across the country.
However, former members of the military are not the only ones in Mexico who know how to make bombs. The country’s mining sector has given many people an expertise in the use of explosives and has contributed to cartel inventories. Industrial hydrogel explosives have been used in some IEDs, notably in an attempt made in Juarez in August 2010. They also have been seized in cartel munitions caches in large enough quantities to bring down buildings.
Despite the availability of explosives and the prevalence of people who know how to manipulate those explosives, large IEDs have yet to be deployed in Mexico. This dynamic has been very different from what we have seen in places like Colombia in the 1980s and 1990s. The reason for this is simple. The leaders of Mexico’s various cartels conduct business based on the principle that if they can stand to benefit from something — an assassination, extortion or even a licit activity — they will do it; if not, it will be avoided. The use of large IEDs would create substantial domestic pressure and compel the Mexican government to come down hard on the cartels — much harder than Mexican President Felipe Calderon’s administration has demonstrated to date.
More important, cartels cannot afford direct and heavy-handed interdiction from the U.S. government aimed at their total dismantlement. The use of large, powerful IEDs would lead the Mexican government to designate the cartels as terrorist organizations. Such a designation would allow U.S. law enforcement easier access to their finances and operation, something the cartels want to avoid at every cost. It could also lead to dramatically increased U.S. involvement in the fight against the Mexican criminal cartels.
Mexico’s drug cartels must weigh the tactical benefits of using IEDs with the strategic need to keep the U.S. government off their backs. Intermittent IED attacks can be expected in the future, but those attacks will continue to utilize small amounts of explosives to mitigate the risk of U.S. involvement — or political crisis in Mexico. This dynamic could possibly change should one of the criminal cartels become desperate and believe they have nothing to lose, but as we saw in the case of La Linea in Juarez, the group did not follow through on their threat to employ a 100-kilogram vehicle-borne IED even when heavily pressed.



Oct. 19


  • The Mexican military seized a drug lab in Zapopan, Jalisco state. Approximately 27 metric tons of chemical precursors were discovered.
  • Mexican authorities seized a heroin and cocaine processing lab in Xochitepec, Morelos state. Two individuals were detained in the operation.

Oct. 20


  • An improvised explosive device in a vehicle exploded Oct. 20 as a Mexican military convoy passed by it in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, while pursuing gunmen. All the gunmen escaped.
  • A police radio operator was killed by gunmen in a security hut in Veracruz city, Veracruz state. The operator was involved in an ongoing operation in Los Volcanes neighborhood. Police pursued the gunmen afterwards, killing one gunman and injuring another.
  • The Mexican military detained five alleged Los Zetas members in Coatzacoalcos, Veracruz state. Among the five was Rodrigo Herrera Valverde, a nephew of the former Veracruz state governor, Fidel Herrera Beltran.

Oct. 21


  • A confrontation in Tancitaro, Michoacan state, between gunmen and the Mexican military left one soldier and three gunmen dead.
  • Three individuals were executed in Apatzingan, Michoacan state. Their bodies were left with a narcomanta signed by the Knights Templar stating that the individuals died because of their behavior.

Oct. 22


  • Police seized 42 kilograms of cocaine from a tractor-trailer near Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.
  • Police arrested four suspected La Barredora members in Acapulco, Guerrero state.

Oct. 23


  • A convoy of gunmen executed three individuals in Villa Ocampo, Durango state. The same convoy was reported driving through Las Nieves, Durango state, prior to the executions.
  • Soria “El Hongo” Adrian Ramirez, leader of Cartel del Centro, was arrested in Ojo de Agua, Mexico state. Cartel del Centro is reportedly in territory disputes with the Knights Templar, La Familia Michoacan and La Mano Con Ojos.
  • A confrontation between Mexican authorities and gunmen in Doctor Gonzalez, Nuevo Leon state resulted in the death of a Los Zetas plaza boss and the capture of three Los Zetas members. The plaza boss, Gabriel “El Cochiloco” Hernandez Hernandez, was responsible for the municipalities of La Laja and El Oregan in Nuevo Leon state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 26, 2011
Imprisoned Gulf cartel leader Osiel Cardenas Guillen’s nephew, Rafael Cardenas Vela, was arrested in South Texas on Oct. 26, Houston Chronicle reported. Police had been tipped by federal agents as to Cardenas’ location, and he was stopped by police while driving to South Padre Island. Cardenas admitted to bringing drugs into the United States and is cooperating with federal authorities, according to an affidavit.
October 25, 2011 | 1154 GMT
Mexican Drug Wars Update: Targeting the Most Violent Cartels
Editor’s Note: Since the publication of STRATFOR’s 2010 annual Mexican cartel report, the fluid nature of the drug war in Mexico has prompted us to take an in-depth look at the situation more frequently. This is the third product of those interim assessments, which we will now make as needed, in addition to our annual year-end analyses and our weekly security memos.
While there has been a reshuffling of alliances among Mexican drug cartels since our July cartel update, the trend discussed in the first two updates of the year continues. That is the polarization of cartels and associated sub-groups toward the two largest drug-trafficking organizations, the Sinaloa Federation and Los Zetas. Meanwhile, the three primary conflicts in Mexico’s drug war remain cartel vs. cartel, cartel vs. government and cartel vs. civilians. Operations launched by the military during the second quarter of 2011, primarily against Los Zetas and the Knights Templar, continued through the third quarter as well, and increasing violence in Guerrero, Durango, Veracruz, Coahuila and Jalisco states has resulted in the deployment of more federal troops in those areas.
The northern tier of states has seen a lull in violence, from Tijuana in Baja California state to Juarez in Chihuahua state. Violence in that stretch of northern Mexico subsided enough during the third quarter to allow the military to redeploy forces to other trouble spots. In Tamaulipas state, the military remains in charge of law enforcement in most of the cities, and the replacement of entire police departments that occurred in the state during the second quarter was recently duplicated in Veracruz following an outbreak of violence there (large numbers of law enforcement personnel were found to be in collusion with Los Zetas and were subsequently dismissed).
The battles between the Gulf Cartel (CDG) and Los Zetas for control over northeastern Mexico continue, though a developing rift within the CDG leadership may complicate the cartel’s operations in the near term. While Gulf remains a single entity, we anticipate that, absent a major reconciliation between the Metros and Rojos factions, the cartel may split violently in the next three to eight months. If that happens, alliances in the region will likely get much murkier than they already are.
In central and southern Mexico, fighting for control of the major plazas at Guadalajara, Acapulco, Chilpancingo and Oaxaca continues to involve the major players — Sinaloa, Los Zetas and the Knights Templar — along with several smaller organizations. This is particularly the case at the Jalisco and Guerrero state plazas, where there are as many as seven distinct organizations battling for control, a situation that will not likely reach any level of stasis or clarity over the next three to six months.
Though our last update suggested the potential for major hurricanes to complicate the drug war in Mexico, the region has avoided the worst of the weather so far. Though the hurricane season lasts until the end of November, the most productive period for major storms tends to be September and early October, so the likelihood of any hurricanes hitting Mexico’s midsection is fairly remote at this point.
Looking ahead toward the end of 2011, STRATFOR expects high levels of cartel violence in the northeastern and southern bicoastal areas of Mexico to continue. The military has deployed more troops in Guadalajara for the Pan-American Games, which run Oct. 14-30, as well as in Veracruz and Coahuila, and any flare-up of violence in those areas will likely be influenced by the military’s presence.



Current Status of the Mexican Cartels


Sinaloa Federation


Over the past four months, the Sinaloa cartel, under the leadership of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, has continued to control the bulk of its home state of Sinaloa, most of the border region in Sonora state and the majority of Chihuahua and Durango states. The cartel continues to pursue its strategic goals of expansion into or absorption of neighboring cartel territories and to import precursor chemicals, mostly from China, for its methamphetamine production in Sinaloa, Nayarit, Guanajuato, Aguascalientes and Jalisco states. These shipments typically are received in the Pacific coast port cities of Lazaro Cardenas and Manzanillo.
In addition to marijuana, Sinaloa is known to be smuggling high-value/low-volume methamphetamines, domestically produced heroin and Colombian cocaine into the United States via the plazas it directly controls at Tijuana, Mexicali, Nogales, Agua Prieta, Columbus and Santa Teresa (both in New Mexico), Rio Bravo, El Porvenir and Manuel Ojinaga as well as the Gulf-controlled plazas at Ciudad Mier, Miguel Aleman, Diaz Ordaz, Reynosa and Matamoros.
As we will further discuss in a separate section below, it appears that Sinaloa recently managed to co-opt the formerly independent Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG), which until early September was believed to be strongly distrustful of El Chapo. It is clear that dynamic has changed. Regarding Sinaloa’s running battles to subdue the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes cartel (VCF, aka the Juarez Cartel) and take control of the Juarez plaza, the slow, long-term strangulation of the VCF remains in progress.
Sinaloa recently took two significant hits to its leadership when regional chief Jose Carlos Moreno Flores was captured by military forces in Mexico City in mid-September and Noel “El Flaco Salgueiro” Salgueiro Nevarez, leader of Sinaloa’s enforcer arm Gente Nueva, was captured in Culiacan, Michoacan state, in early October.
According to information released by Mexico’s Defense Secretariat, Moreno Flores ran Sinaloa’s Guerrero state operations in the cities of Chilpancingo, Jaleaca de Catalan, Izotepec, Pueblo Viejo, Buena Vista, Tlacotepec and Leonardo Bravo. He also controlled agricultural drug operations in Izotepec, Tlacotepec, Chichihualco and Chilpancingo.
Salgueiro Nevarez reportedly founded Gente Nueva and had led it since 2007. Also under his control were the Juarez street gangs Los Mexicles and Los Artistas Asesinos, which conduct operations against the Juarez cartel and its allies Los Aztecas. Salgueiro Nevarez also ran operational cells in Guerrero and Durango states. His removal may adversely affect Gente Nueva’s operational cohesion, though it is not yet clear whether he had a trusted lieutenant in the wings to replace him.

Gulf Cartel


In the last four months, it has become apparent that a schism within the CDG over divided loyalties may be evolving into a split with large and violent consequences. As discussed in the 2009 and 2010 annual cartel reports, CDG leader Osiel Cardenas Guillen continued to run the cartel from his federal prison cell in Mexico after his capture in March 2003. He was subsequently extradited to the United States, where he was convicted. Currently, he resides in the U.S. Penitentiary Administrative Maximum Facility in Florence, Colorado, where tight security measures make it difficult for him to maintain any control over his organization.
Following his removal from power-by-proxy, Osiel Cardenas Guillen was replaced as leader of the organization by a pair of co-leaders, his brother Antonio Ezequiel “Tony Tormenta” Cardenas Guillen and Jorge Eduardo “El Coss” Costilla Sanchez. This arrangement shifted when Antonio Cardenas Guillen was killed in a six-hour standoff with Mexican military forces in November 2010.
The split within the CDG that we are now watching began to a large extent with the death of Antonio Cardenas Guillen. At the time, it is believed that Rafael “El Junior” Cardenas, the nephew of Osiel and Antonio Cardenas Guillen, expected to replace his uncles as leader of the CDG. Instead, Costilla Sanchez assumed full control of the organization. The schism became wider as two factions formed, the Metros, which were loyal to Costilla Sanchez, and the Rojos, which were loyal to the Cardenas family.
While government operations against the CDG resulted in the capture of several plaza bosses over the last three months — Abiel “El R-2” Gonzalez Briones, Manuel “El Meme” Alquisires Garcia, Ricardo Salazar Pequeno and Jose Antonio “El Comandante” Martinez Silva — internal violence brought down one of the factional leaders. On Sept. 3, 2011, the body of Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borrego was found by authorities in Reynosa. Flores Borrego had been the trusted lieutenant of Costilla Sanchez and served as his second in command as well as Reynosa plaza boss. These two men were at the top of the Metros faction.
Then on Sept. 27, in a rather brazen hit on U.S. soil, gunmen in an SUV opened fire on another vehicle traveling along U.S. Route 83 east of McAllen, Texas. The driver, Jorge Zavala from Mission, Texas, who was connected to a branch of the Gulf Cartel, was killed. Though his role in the cartel is unclear, he is rumored to have been close to a senior Gulf plaza boss, Gregorio “El Metro 2” Sauceda Gamboa, who was arrested in April 2009. As indicated by his “Metro” nickname, Sauceda had been aligned with the faction of the Gulf cartel that supports Costilla Sanchez.
On Oct. 11, the Mexican navy reported that the body of Cesar “El Gama” Davila Garcia, the CDG’s head finance officer, was found in the city of Reynosa, Tamaulipas. According to a statement from the Ministry of the Navy, the body was found in a home, dead of a gunshot wound. El Gama had been Antonio Cardenas Guillen’s accountant, but after the 2009 death of Tony Tormenta, El Gama was made plaza boss of CDG’s port city of Tampico for a period of time, then placed back in Matamoros as the chief financial operator for the cartel. Many questions arise from this killing, but it could be another indication of internal CDG conflict.
Though the CDG split has been quietly widening for two years, the apparent eruption of internally focused violence during the past quarter indicates the division may be about to explode. The consequences of a violent rupture within the CDG likely include moves by Los Zetas and Sinaloa to take advantage of the situation and grab territory. This would further heighten violence beyond the already volatile conditions created by the three-way battle between Los Zetas, the CDG and government forces for control of Mexico’s northeast.

Arellano Felix Organization


Little has changed in the Arellano Felix Organization (AFO) since July’s update on cartel activity in Tijuana, Baja California. The AFO (aka the Tijuana Cartel) is widely considered to be operating by permission of the Sinaloa cartel, an agreement suggested by a drop in the turf-war homicide rate in Tijuana. According to the Mexican federal government, deaths by homicide statewide in Baja California from January through August 2011 numbered 464, compared to 579 for the same period in 2010.
In mid-August, Mexican authorities arrested AFO member Juan Carlos Flores “El Argentino” in Tecate, Baja California. Carlos Flores indicated that he was subordinate to a man known only as “El Viejon,” who is second in command of the AFO, which is led by Fernando “El Ingeniero” Sanchez Arellano. On July 9, Mexican authorities arrested Armando “El Gordo” Villarreal Heredia, an AFO lieutenant who reported to Sanchez Arellano. Any significant gains or losses for the AFO have gone largely unnoticed since the cartel effectively operates as a Sinaloa vassal organization.
For the near term we do not expect significant changes within or related to the AFO, although given the cartel’s continued but discrete interaction with Los Zetas, we believe there will probably be a resurgence of open hostility by the AFO at some point to regain control of its plazas.

The Opposition


Los Zetas


Los Zetas continue to fight a large, multi-front war across Mexico. They are combatting the CDG, Sinaloa and Mexican government forces in the northeast while assisting the Juarez Cartel in holding Sinaloa forces back in Chihuahua state. Los Zetas are also taking control of additional territory in Zacatecas, pushing into Jalisco, Nayarit, Guerrero and Mexico states and battling Sinaloa in the southern states of Oaxaca and Chiapas. The organization is being hit hard by the Mexican military in its home territories in Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas, Coahuila and Veracruz states and fighting to hold the crucial plazas at Monterrey and the port of Veracruz against incursions by Sinaloa, CDG and CJNG.
Certainly, Los Zetas are being pressed on every side. What we find telling is that despite significant challenges to their ownership of Monterrey and Veracruz, Los Zetas do not appear to have been displaced, though we do expect violence to increase significantly in the near term as rival groups openly push into both cities. While Los Zetas have withdrawn from territory before — Reynosa in the spring of 2010 being a prime example — the loss of that plaza was not detrimental overall to the cartel’s operations, given its control of other plazas in the region and in Nuevo Laredo. However, we expect to see Los Zetas ramp up defensive efforts in Monterrey and Veracruz, two cities that have great strategic value for the cartel.
From July to mid-October, federal operations against Los Zetas in Veracruz, Zacatecas, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas, San Luis Potosi and Quintana Roo states netted 17 cell leaders and plaza bosses, including Angel Manuel “Comandante Diablo” Mora Caberta in Veracruz, Jose Guadalupe “El Dos” Yanez Martinez in Saltillo and Carlos “La Rana” Oliva Castillo, reported to be the third in command of Los Zetas, in Saltillo. During a two-month operation in Coahuila, government forces also reportedly seized caches of weapons, ammunition, tactical gear and 27 tons of marijuana and freed approximately 97 kidnapped migrants.
Over the past four months, questions have emerged in the U.S. and Mexican security communities about the strength, cohesion and capabilities of Los Zetas. At times, information from open sources, government reports and confidential STRATFOR sources on both sides of the border has been contradictory — which tends to be the norm given the exceptionally fluid nature of the drug war. The question of whether Los Zetas are weakening has many factors, including leadership losses, gains or losses in territorial control, increases or decreases in apparent smuggling activities (which directly tie to revenue) and the quality and quantity of human resources.
As we discussed in July, the estimated 30 deserters from the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group (GAFE) who originally formed the core cadre of Los Zetas have been shrinking in number. On July 3, one of the remaining 11 “Zeta Viejos” at large, Jesus Enrique “El Mamito” Rejon, was apprehended by Mexican Federal Police in Atizapan de Zaragoza, Mexico state. In the past decade, 15 members of the original core group have been reported captured and imprisoned and nine have been reported killed. It is not realistic to assume, however, that the organization has lost the specialized skillsets, training and knowledge that those particular individuals possessed.
When evaluating reports of captured or killed Zeta leaders and the effects those losses might have on the organization, it is important to consider what leaders remain, the size of the manpower pool (both in terms of trained foot soldiers and potential recruits) and the existence of training programs and infrastructure for the rank and file.
First, unlike the more traditional Mexican drug cartels, which tend to be family-centric, the Los Zetas organization is more of a meritocracy, and a number of later recruits have risen to leadership positions. Prime examples are Miguel “Z-40” Trevino Morales, who was recruited roughly two years after the group’s 1998 founding and has risen to No. 2 in the organization, and Carlos “La Rana” Oliva Castillo, reported to be the regional boss over the states of Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas and Coahuila, who joined Los Zetas in 2005 and was captured the first week of October 2011. In recent media reports of his capture, Oliva Castillo is described as the No. 3 leader in the organization behind Trevino Morales. While STRATFOR has yet to corroborate Oliva Castillo’s position in the cartel, if he did in fact replace captured third-in-command Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon, neither part of the founding group.
Second, it is known that Mexico’s Defense Secretariat “lost track” of as many as 1,700 special operations soldiers over the past 10 years, according to documents obtained from the Federal Institute for Access to Information by the Mexican newspaper Milenio. A March 8 Milenio article indicated that at least 1,680 Special Forces Airmobile Group (GAFE) soldiers had deserted in the past decade, including trained snipers, infantrymen and paratroopers with advanced survival and counternarcotics training.
It is not reasonable to assume that all of the GAFE deserters over the last decade went to work for Los Zetas or any of the other drug-trafficking organizations. However, it is reasonable to expect that, in an environment where cartels have had a wide presence and a demonstrated willingness to pay handsomely for highly skilled soldiers, a significant proportion of the GAFE deserters would sell their skills to the highest bidder and many would gravitate toward Los Zetas. If even one-third of the GAFE deserters chose to join any of Mexico’s cartels, there are likely dozens of highly skilled soldiers already in positions of authority or working their way up the Zeta organizational ladder (along with recruits from other Mexican military branches and law enforcement agencies).
While the organization long has recruited predominantly from military and law enforcement pools, which means most new recruits are already able to use basic firearms and understand fundamental tactics, the strength of Los Zetas comes from structured training in small-unit combat tactics at facilities modeled after GAFE training camps. According to STRATFOR sources with access to seized training materials, Zeta training includes basic marksmanship, fire-team drills and room-clearing techniques.
The thoroughness of Zeta training depends on the tempo of the drug war. Prior to about May 2010, Zeta camps in Tamaulipas, Nuevo Leon and elsewhere operated with sufficient space and freedom for recruit training to last as long as six months. When the Mexican government and the CDG, Sinaloa and La Familia Michoacana (LFM) cartels began to press them on every side, Zeta recruit training was reduced. According to a captured Zeta foot soldier, basic training in early 2011 involved two weeks of boot camp in which rudimentary firearms skills were taught. The recruits were then mobilized to gain additional training on the battlefield. The net effect has been seen in such “loose cannon” events as the Falcon Lake shooting in September 2010 and the Mexican Drug Wars botched carjacking attack on U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents travelling through San Luis Potosi in February 2011. Nevertheless, we expect that Los Zetas will ramp up training whenever possible since their continued success depends upon it.
What we find important in these dynamics is that Los Zetas have taken several big hits in the past several months but have managed to absorb the losses without any overall diminution of the organization’s size or reach, even though the persistent pressure has reduced the capabilities of rank-and-file Zeta operatives. The net effect has been the organization’s fairly static condition. Peripheral Zeta losses on the outskirts of Monterrey and Veracruz have been offset by recent gains in Zacatecas state and elsewhere. It certainly is possible, however, that the last months of 2011 may see an overall degradation of Los Zetas if CJNG and Sinaloa are successful in making inroads into Monterrey and Veracruz, and we expect the military to continue its operations against Los Zetas as well.

Cartel Pacifico Sur


Since the last cartel update, we have seen little activity by Cartel del Pacifico Sur (CPS). The cartel has suffered no significant arrests, and any violence associated with group has gone unnoticed in contested areas. This lack of reported losses and gains for CPS may be due to its alliance with Los Zetas, which attracts most of the media attention. There also is the possibility that, while Sinaloa and the Mexican government focus their efforts on Los Zetas, CPS is taking advantage of a lull in territorial battles to concentrate on smuggling activities and rejuvenate its revenue streams. We do not consider CPS to be marginalized at this point and will be watching for signs of activity during the last quarter of this year.

Vicente Carrillo Fuentes Organization


Although constriction of the VCF continues, the cartel retains the loyalty of the approximately 8,000-member Azteca street gang, which has helped it hold on to Juarez and maintain control of the three primary ports of entry into the United States, all of which feed directly into El Paso, Texas. STRATFOR sources recently indicated that the VCF also retains supply lines for its marijuana and cocaine shipments and continues to push large quantities of narcotics across the border.
On July 29, Mexican authorities captured Jose Antonio “El Diego” Acosta Hernandez, the top leader of La Linea, the VCF’s enforcement arm. His position in the VCF hierarchy makes him difficult to replace. For the cartels, there is never a good time to lose an important figure, but the loss is felt even more acutely when the figure is the leader of a cartel’s armed wing and he is removed from the mix during a heated and prolonged battle for survival.
The whereabouts of Vicente Carrillo Fuentes and his closest lieutenants are unknown. At the beginning of 2011 there was an expectation that the level of violence associated with Sinaloa operations against the VCF would continue to escalate, given the indicators seen at the time. However, over the last eight to nine months we have seen cartel-related homicides drop significantly. It appears now, though, that violence again is on the rise in Juarez. Gun battles and targeted killings are increasing in the city, and STRATFOR sources in the region expect the current trend to continue through the end of 2011.

La Resistencia


La Resistencia was originally a confederation between enforcers from Guadalajara-based affiliates of the Sinaloa Federation, the Milenio Cartel and Ignacio “Nacho” Coronel’s faction, along with enforcers from the Gulf Cartel and LFM. The organization was intended to fight against Zeta incursions into Jalisco and Michoacan. Following the July 2010 death of Coronel, the alliance splintered as the LFM made a push to take over Guadalajara and Coronel’s followers blamed Sinaloa leader El Chapo Guzman for Nacho Coronel’s demise.
In the melee that followed, the Milenio Cartel was badly damaged by the arrests of high-profile leaders and by battles with the strongest of the splinter groups from Coronel’s organization, CJNG. Remnants of the Milenio Cartel have continued to use the La Resistencia name. Although La Resistencia was originally formed to combat Los Zetas, it recently announced an alliance with the group. If there is an alliance forming, it could help explain why CJNG, the enemy of La Resistencia, recently traveled across Mexico to target Zeta operatives in the port city of Veracruz.
La Resistencia has been hit hard by CJNG and the Mexican government, but an apparent alliance with Los Zetas raises questions regarding the transfer of skills and the potential for a significantly increased Zeta presence in La Resistencia’s area of operations. We will be watching this situation closely, since the dual dynamic of a Zeta-La Resistencia alliance and CJNG’s cross-country operation lead us to expect elevated violence over a substantial part of Mexico’s bi-coastal midsection.

Independent Operators


La Familia Michoacana


LFM continues to suffer losses at the hands of the Knights Templar and the Mexican government. On Oct. 5, LFM leader Martin Rosales Magana “El Terry” was captured in Mexico state, the most significant hit to the cartel’s leadership since Jesus “El Chango” Mendez’s fall in July. The Mexican Federal Police claims that the La Familia structure is disintegrating and the cartel no longer has much access to essential precursors in the production of methamphetamines. The continued losses indicate that LFM as an organization is nearing its end. However though LFM’s losses have hurt the organization, the cartel continues to show activity. In a raid in July, U.S. law enforcement agencies arrested 44 individuals in Austin, Texas, who allegedly were LFM members, though it remains unclear whether the cell in Austin worked for LFM or the Knights Templar.
There have been indications that remnants of LFM are continuing to seek an alliance with Los Zetas. Narcomantas signed by the Knights Templar were intended to send a message to El Terry, blaming him for aligning with Los Zetas. Following his arrest in early October, Mario Buenrostro Quiroz, the alleged leader of a Mexico City drug gang known as “Los Aboytes,” claimed in an on-camera interview that El Terry had sought an alliance with Los Zetas prior to his arrest. This claim followed reports that Jesus “El Chango” Mendez was also seeking an alliance with Los Zetas before being arrested. While the Mexican government denies LFM has achieved an alliance with Los Zetas, LFM will likely continue pressing for any advantage to stay alive as the Knights Templar continue trying to eradicate it.

The Knights Templar


One question that emerged over the last quarter is whether the Federal Police will increase its focus on Knights Templar operations. With LFM’s organizational decline, Federal Police will have more resources to target the Knights Templar in Michoacan and Mexico states. Federal Police Commissioner Facundo Rosas has suggested an imminent end to LFM and a shift in operations against the Knights Templar.
The Knights Templar have taken hits from Mexican federal forces, but there have been no indications that the group’s organizational structure has been seriously impacted. Arrested in September was one of the group’s principal members, Saul “El Lince” Solis Solis, the highest-level Knights Templar leader to fall in the third quarter. A number of other Knights Templar leaders were arrested in the third quarter, including Bulmaro “El Men” Salinas Munoz and Neri “El Yupo” Salgado Harrison. The effect of these arrests on the group’s operations remains unclear.
The Knights Templar continue to display narcomantas in Michoacan and Mexico states. In September, the cartel offered monetary rewards for information leading to the capture of certain individuals named on the banners (known LFM members who the Knights Templar claimed were aligned with Los Zetas).
The early October arrest of Los Aboytes gang leader Buenrostro Quiroz has raised questions about Knights Templar leadership. In the video of Buenrostro Quiroz being questioned by authorities, he said he met with Knights Templar leaders approximately a month before he was captured. He further claimed that Nazario “El Mas Loco” Moreno Gonzalez is still alive and heading the Knights Templar with Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez, former LFM plaza boss, as second in command. There has been no evidence supporting Buenrostro Quiroz’s claims, although Moreno Gonzalez’s body was never found when he was reported dead in December 2010. The prospect of Moreno Gonzales, the ideological founder of LFM, still being alive would explain to a large extent LFM’s immediate decline following the emergence of the Knights Templar in March.
The Knights Templar will continue to target LFM members in Michoacan and Mexico states, and as it takes over La Familia’s turf it will likely increase its methamphetamine production operations. Regardless of whether an alliance exists between LFM and Los Zetas, we anticipate increasing conflict between the Knights Templar and Los Zetas in the coming months due to both groups’ territorial aspirations.

Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion


When we began discussing Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion in the last quarterly update, we included it in the “Independent Operators” section. We took the cartel at its word, which had been made clear its publically released videos, that CJNG had declared war on all other cartels. The organization, based in Guadalajara, consists primarily of former Sinaloa members who had worked for Nacho Coronel and who believe that Nacho was betrayed by Sinaloa leader El Chapo Guzman Loera. However, recent activities by CJNG have greatly muddied our take on the group.
Between Sept. 20 and the first week in October, at least 67 bodies labeled as Zetas were dumped in Boca del Rio, a wealthy southern suburb of Veracruz. The first batch of 35 bodies was dumped in a busy traffic circle in broad daylight during afternoon rush hour. All of the killings were claimed by CJNG. We find this odd for two reasons: While it is not surprising that CJNG would go after Los Zetas, Veracruz is very much outside of CJNG’s home territory in Guadalajara, and CJNG appears to have conducted these operations in cooperation with the Sinaloa Federation. Therefore, it seems as though CJNG may have been co-opted by Sinaloa (though Sinaloa has not confirmed this).
However, as discussed in the Sinaloa and La Resistencia sections above, such a restructuring of affiliations makes sense, and we anticipate that CJNG’s links to other cartels will become increasingly clear over the next quarter.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 20, 2011
An explosive device in a stationary car detonated Oct. 20 south of Monterey, Mexico, when military personnel passed the vehicle while pursuing a separate vehicle with armed subjects, El Diario reported. No injuries were reported, but the explosion broke windows and damaged a mechanic shop. The vehicle used in the attack was destroyed, but authorities will investigate what type of explosive material was used, a government spokesman said.
October 20, 2011 | 1216 GMT
Zetas Leadership Takes Another Hit


On Oct. 12, Mexican authorities arrested Carlos “La Rana” Oliva Castillo, purported to be the No. 3 overall leader of Los Zetas, in Saltillo, Coahuila state. Allegedly in charge of the cartel’s operations in Tamaulipas, Coahuila and Nuevo Leon states, Oliva is believed to have authorized the mass killing of Guatemalan immigrants in May and the attack on Monterrey’s Casino Royale in August that killed 52 people. Oliva surrendered quietly without firing a single shot, though many of his subordinates reportedly engaged in firefights with authorities throughout the city to divert the soldiers’ attention away from Oliva’s safe-house so that he could escape. This is a tactic we have seen Mexican cartels and Los Zetas in particular frequently employ when a high-value target is in jeopardy.
Two days later, the Mexican military and federal police arrested Marco “El Chabelo” Garza de Leon Quiroga, also known as Jose Andres Mireles Quiroz, a Zetas member reportedly in charge of several municipalities, such as Sabinas Hidalgo and Vallecillos Agualeguas, Nuevo Leon state, as well as part of Coahuila state. At least nine people were killed in the shootout leading to his arrest, and 10 other cartel members, including Jorge “El Exterminador” Gamiz Vega, were arrested with Garza.
The arrests are part of a continuing trend in the Mexican government’s assault against what most observers perceive to be the most violent cartels operating in the country, Los Zetas in particular. While the government has conducted successful operations against Zetas territory in the Yucatan and Veracruz of late, it has been more active over the past three months in the cartel’s strongholds in the northeast.
In June, military operations in Coahuila state led to the seizure of a large amount of narcotics and weaponry belonging to the Zetas. According to a Mexican military spokesman, a law enforcement offensive that began in August in the three northern states has resulted in 724 arrests, the freeing of 36 kidnapping victims and the seizure of 1,629 guns, 165 grenades and more than 27.5 tons of marijuana. As recently as Oct. 16, the Mexican military freed 61 men outside Piedras Negras, Coahuila state, who were being held captive by the Zetas for forced labor. That operation also uncovered 6 tons of marijuana.
In addition to these setbacks in inventory, Zetas’ leadership has also been facing heavy losses, as has the group’s general membership. The arrest of Zetas founding member Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon hurts the cartel, as does the arrest of Oliva, who is behind only Heriberto Lazcano Lazcano and Miguel Trevino in the cartel’s power structure. As the government continues to damage the Zetas operationally and kill or arrest many of their senior leaders, the cartel increasingly will need to replenish its ranks. This raises the question of how and with whom the Zetas will replace their losses in personnel.
Such losses, compounded by the fact the Zetas are fighting a war on multiple fronts against the military and cartel rivals, are difficult for any group to overcome. At present, the Zetas are not in any real danger of dissolving, but there are rumors of fracturing within the organization. How long the group can endure the pressure it is under will be contingent upon its ability to replace its personnel.

Limitations in Finding Replacements


On Oct. 13, Colombian police arrested four Colombian citizens suspected of having ties to Los Zetas. The individuals reportedly were part of a cocaine trafficking ring that smuggled its product by sea to Central America, North America and Europe. According to reports, the Colombians were former military personnel used to train Zetas recruits.
Formed by defectors from the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group, Los Zetas have enjoyed strong, capable and organized leadership, especially at the senior level. But in light of the Mexican military’s operational successes over the past year, Los Zetas’ leadership is becoming depleted — only six of the founding members remain at large. In the past, attempts to repopulate the group’s ranks have led the Zetas to turn to the Mexican military as well as outside military entities for recruitment and training. Replacing soldiers with members of these groups is a logical move, given that defections from the military are commonplace. But it is very difficult to replace top-tier leaders with members of foreign militaries due to several limitations.
That is not to say recruiting outside personnel, such as Colombian military personnel or the oft-used Guatemalan Kaibiles, is without utility. Such groups or individuals are indeed useful for training purposes, protective detail or assassination squads, and they make for good operatives in locations where a cartel wants to expand. Kaibiles, for example, are effective proxies for Zetas operations in Guatemala because they are native to the area, have pre-existing support networks and blend in with the population. Colombians have long been smuggling cocaine into Mexico and are thus more practiced in that process (Mexico is not a producer of coca). Zetas from Mexico possess none of these advantages when operating in Guatemala or Colombia.
However, foreign military personnel have limited value in other capacities when used in Mexico. As assassins operating inside Mexico, their utility is mitigated by virtue that they are foreign; in other words, they stand out among the local population, making them easy for Mexican authorities and rival cartels to identify. Moreover, they lack the understanding of the areas in which they operate, whereas natives are more attuned to the culture and geography of the city or region — a critical advantage when smuggling narcotics or plotting cartel-related attacks. This makes it extremely difficult for a foreigner to operate freely or become a plaza boss in Mexico, at least overtly.
As key members of the Zetas leadership continue to fall, finding suitable replacements is all the more critical if the group wants to continue to enjoy its successes of the past. Ideally, replacements would come from the same source of talent the original members came from — Mexican special operations forces. Forces from foreign militaries may be an attractive option, but it is an option beset by limitations.


Oct. 11


  • Mexican authorities arrested 35 individuals with alleged links to Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal during a raid at a nightclub in Mexico City.
  • Four decapitated bodies were found in the cities of Acapulco and Atoyac de Alvarez, Guerrero state, with narcomantas at the scenes. Signed “El Chapo,” the nickname of Sinaloa Federation leader Joaquin Guzman Loera, the narcomantas denounced extortionists.
  • A video released on the Internet by the hacker group Anonymous threatened Mexican criminal cartels by releasing the identities of police officers, journalists and taxi drivers who collude with cartels. The video mentions that Los Zetas had kidnapped a member of their group and demanded his return. The video also mentions possible consequences for the cartels on Nov. 5.

Oct. 12


  • Cesar “El Gama” Davila Garcia, Gulf cartel plaza boss for Tampico, Tamaulipas state, was found dead by Mexican authorities in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.
  • Mexican authorities in Saltillo, Coahuila state, arrested Los Zetas No. 3 Carlos “La Rana” Oliva Castillo.
  • A group of gunmen with assault rifles killed the municipal police commander in Navolato, Sinaloa state.
  • Gunmen killed three state prosecutors in front of a school in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.

Oct. 13


  • A three-hour confrontation between police and gunmen left five gunmen dead and several injured in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state.

Oct. 14


  • Mexican authorities arrested 11 municipal police officers during a shift change in Sabinas Hidalgo, Nuevo Leon state.
  • A police officer was killed when a group of gunmen in multiple vehicles attacked three police officers on a street in San Nicolas de los Garza, Nuevo Leon state.

Oct. 15


  • A prison riot in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, left 20 dead and 12 injured.
  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of Jose Andres Mireles Quiroz, alias Marco “El Chabelo” Garza de Leon Quiroga, a Zetas plaza boss for multiple cities within Nuevo Leon and Coahuila states.

Oct. 16


  • Mexican authorities announced the recovery of 61 kidnapped victims in Piedras Negras, Coahuila state. The victims were being held in a safe-house by Los Zetas for use in forced labor.

Oct. 17


  • Addressed to Mexican President Felipe Calderon, a narcomanta was hung from a bridge in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, asking which group was responsible for the massacre in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 17, 2011
Two retired captains and two non-commissioned officers from the Colombian Army Special forces are advising and training the Los Zetas Mexican cartel, El Tiempo reported Oct. 17.
October 13, 2011
The Mexican army captured Carlos Oliva Castillo, known as “La Rana,” for allegedly ordering a casino blaze in Nuevo Leon that killed 52 people, Reuters reported Oct.13. Castillo was the third highest-ranking member of Los Zetas and headed operations in Coahuila, Tamaulipas and Nuevo Leon, authorities said. He was captured in Saltillo on Oct. 12 after a shootout between soldiers and the Zetas that lasted several hours. Castillo was brought before the Defense Ministry headquarters in Mexico City.
October 12, 2011
The Gulf Cartel’s Chief Financial Officer Cesar Davila Garcia was found dead in a home off Calle Colinas del Sol in Reynosa on Oct. 12, Valley Central reported. Marines received a tip about the body, the Mexican Navy (SEMAR) said, adding that Garcia appeared to have been killed by a 9mm handgun found at the scene. Garcia was previously the personal accountant for Antonio Ezequiel Cardenas-Guillen, a Gulf Cartel leader nicknamed “Tony Tormenta,” who was killed in a gun fight with marines in November 2010. Garcia became the Gulf Cartel plaza boss for Tampico after Cardenas-Guillen’s death, but was moved to Matamoros to become chief finance officer, SEMAR said.
October 12, 2011 | 1332 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

Vice President of Intelligence Fred Burton examines two recent violent incidents in Mexico City that could indicate a tactical shift in cartel strategy.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


In this week’s Above the Tearline, we are going to examine two recent brutal events in Mexico which could mean that the cartels are taking the fight to Mexico City.
We’ve been following cartel violence for quite some time at STRATFOR and it’s very easy to become numb to the levels of brutality that we see. From body dumps in Veracruz, to firefights across from Roma, Texas, with incursions into the United States.
However, there have been two recent events in Mexico City that give us cause to re-evaluate what could be occurring here and they are the murder of the two female journalists that were found naked, bound and gagged and their bodies dumped in a park in Mexico City. And most recently two severed heads were found on Oct. 3 in close proximity to the Mexican military office Sedena in Mexico City. These two recent brutal events are unusual in that it happened in Mexico City, which has historically been spared the levels of violence we have seen elsewhere throughout Mexico. The signal resonates with the murder of the journalists, which is a very powerful example to others who may be writing about cartel activity inside of Mexico, and now with the severed heads being found in close proximity to the Mexican military office, this is also a very powerful signal to the Mexican military from the cartels that anybody is accessible in Mexico.
In doing assessments of countries or monitoring the scope of violence that could be occurring, you’re consistently looking for tripwires that are crossed or anomalies which are outside the norm, and those are incidents such as what we have seen unfold here.
The Above the Tearline with this video is the tactical shift that could be taking place here with the cartels striking inside the Mexican capital, specifically targeting journalists and the Mexican military. The symbolism resonates, and it also clearly shows that the cartels are very capable of reaching out and targeting whoever they want throughout the country, even in the capital city of Mexico.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 12, 2011 | 1231 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: La Familia Operating in Austin, Texas?

La Familia Michoacana’s Presence in Austin


On Oct. 8, the Austin American-Statesman published a report on the presence of a Mexican drug cartel operating within the city. According to the report, the La Familia Michoacana (LFM) cartel has strong ties to Austin, Texas, because of a sizable contingency of expatriates from Luvianos, a city located in Mexico’s Michoacan state from which the cartel originated and took its name.
The presence of Mexican cartels in the United States understandably represents a serious concern for U.S. citizens, and is an issue STRATFOR and the U.S. mainstream media follow closely. A grasp on cartel origins and relationships is vital to understanding the Mexican cartel landscape, and we believe we can provide some clarity to help address the issue posited by the report: Does LFM actually operate in Austin? Essential to addressing that question is a cursory explanation of how LFM has evolved and how it currently exists.
LFM began as a vigilante group that sought to protect the citizens of Michoacan state from encroaching cartels. At some point in the mid-2000s, they began engaging in their own drug trafficking operations, adopting a quasi-religious, cult-like ideology. In 2009, then-Mexican Attorney General Eduardo Medina Mora labeled LFM the most violent organized criminal group in Mexico, a statement that was made amid an offensive against Los Zetas, LFM’s archrival at the time.
The organization began to experience serious setbacks in December 2010, when the Mexican government announced the death of LFM leader Nazario “El Mas Loco” Moreno Gonzalez. Then in March 2011, banners appearing in the Michoacan cities of Morelia, Zitacuaro and Apatzingan said an LFM offshoot calling itself the Knights Templar would replace its predecessor as the dominant cartel in the area. Notably, the Knights Templar also adopted a quasi-religious ideology, even issuing a comprehensive code of conduct for its members. The splintering of LFM and the Knights Templar resulted in all-out war between the two, with LFM on the losing side. The LFM lost multiple leaders, including Mexico Security Memo Jose “El Chango” Mendez Vargas, who led the LFM faction after the original group broke apart. Between the Knights Templar and the Mexican government, the LFM faction has been decimated. The government has gone so far as to say the original LFM has effectively ceased to exist.
At present, the Knights Templar are faring much better than LFM in the struggle. They are demonstrably the stronger and more capable of the two. But the distinction between the two often goes unnoticed in or is otherwise not clearly delineated by the mainstream media. Therefore, if a cartel from Michoacan state is operating in Austin, it is likely the Knights Templar, as LFM is in disarray and probably lacks the resources to traffic large quantities of narcotics on its own.
That is not to say it is impossible for LFM to be operating in the Texas capital, as the Austin American-Statesman article suggests. The fact that LFM is losing the battle against the Knights Templar has given rise to rumors that the former has sought an alliance with the Zetas. (Mexican government officials have said any alliance between the two has fallen through.) If the smaller LFM faction of the original group is operating in Austin and if the rumors of the alliance are true, then the Zetas are likely working closely with the faction to move narcotics in and through the Texas capital.

Continued Threat of Paramilitary Groups


The recent killings in Veracruz, including the dumping of some 35 alleged members of Los Zetas on a main road in the city, has garnered a great deal of attention from the media, which subsequently have labeled the group that claimed responsibility for the killings — the Matazetas, or Zetas killers — a “paramilitary group.” Indeed, many in the media have characterized such paramilitary groups as an emerging threat in Mexico.
The existence of paramilitary groups in Mexico is nothing new, and there appears to be a misconception as to what qualifies as a paramilitary group. STRATFOR has long considered several groups in Mexico to be paramilitary groups, which, broadly speaking, can be defined as groups that utilize military-grade weaponry and maintain a military-style hierarchy but are not part of the country’s formal military.
In this context, Los Zetas, the Matazetas (the enforcement arm of the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion), Los Pelones and La Gente Nueva (both enforcers for the Sinaloa Federation) all are paramilitary organizations. The Sinaloa Federation recruited from the Mexican military to create La Gente Nueva. When the Gulf and Sinaloa cartels were avowed enemies from 1998 to 2010, the Gulf cartel leadership sought to build a similar organization and began specifically recruiting from the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airborne Group, which became Los Zetas.
By the broadest definition of paramilitary, all armed, organized and hierarchically structured cartels and crime groups in Mexico can be referred to as paramilitary groups. They all possess and use a wide variety of weaponry, the bulk of which is considered military-grade, and they all have been conducting armed operations against a ruling power — the Mexican military and federal police — and/or against an occupying power — rival cartels.
Mexico has seen multiple paramilitary groups for over a decade. The acts of the Metazetas, while sensational in their violence, do not represent a growing trend; they represent a continuing trend.



Oct. 4


  • Mexican special operations forces captured Noel “El Flaco” Salgueiro Nevarez, founder and leader of La Gente Nueva, in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. La Gente Nueva is an armed branch of the Sinaloa Federation operating primarily in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.
  • Mexican authorities captured six members of Los Zetas in Jalisco state.

Oct. 5


  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of Martin “El Terry” Rosales Magana, a founder of La Familia Michoacana. Rosales was arrested in Las Juntas, Mexico state.
  • Mexican soldiers and customs agents seized about $915,000 from a vehicle at a checkpoint near the U.S. border in Tijuana, Baja California state.
  • Gunmen attacked a family in their home in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, leaving four dead and three injured. Among the dead was a two-year-old child.

Oct. 7


  • A decapitated body was found with a narcobanner in Ciudad Altamirano, Guerrero state. The banner was addressed to political leaders, including President Felipe Calderon. The message threatened the families of political leaders who support La Barredora, a criminal organization aligned with the Sinaloa Federation. The message also blames La Barredora for extorting teachers in Guerrero state.
  • Mexican authorities seized a camp in Vallecillo, Nuevo Leon state, used by drug traffickers. Approximately 40 individuals fled the camp as the authorities entered. At the camp, authorities discovered camouflage military uniforms and Mexican marine insignias, along with communication equipment.
  • Mexican marines arrested 20 individuals thought to be members of criminal organizations in Veracruz. Eight of the individuals belonged to Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion, and twelve belonged to Los Zetas.

Oct. 8


  • A firefight between the Mexican military and gunmen erupted in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state. It was reported that Juan Reyes “R1” Mejia Gonzalez, a Gulf cartel leader, was among those killed.
  • Ten bodies were discovered in two locations in Veracruz state. Seven bodies were discovered in a truck in Laguna Real, while three bodies were discovered on a road in Colinas de Sante Fe.

Oct. 10


  • Gunmen shot and killed six police officers as they rode in a vehicle to Valparaiso, Zacatecas state. The police officers were returning from a party.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 6, 2011 | 1205 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Los Zetas Take a Hit

Alleged Gulf Cartel Member Killed


Around 2 a.m. Sept. 27, gunmen in an SUV opened fire on another vehicle traveling along U.S. Route 83 east of McAllen, Texas. The driver was hit multiple times, lost control and crashed his vehicle. The driver died, while law-enforcement sources say a passenger accompanying him was wounded and remains in serious condition.
The driver of the vehicle, identified as Jorge Zavala from Mission, Texas, was reported by Mexican and U.S. media outlets to be connected to a branch of the Gulf cartel, which is currently experiencing an internal power struggle between rival claimants for leadership. Zavala’s role in the cartel is unclear, but he is rumored to have been close to a senior plaza boss who was arrested in 2009 by Mexican authorities. U.S. investigators have said the shooting was not a random act. Given Zavala’s apparent connection to the cartel, it is possible that the gunmen responsible were acting on behalf of a rival faction.
The shooting reportedly took place minutes after Zavala was seen leaving a strip club in Edinburg, Texas. According to witnesses at the club quoted by local media, the suspected perpetrators were also at the club and may have followed him out. After attacking Zavala’s vehicle, the gunmen are believed to have crossed into Mexico.
Zavala is believed to have been associated with Gregorio “El Metro 2” Sauceda Gamboa, a Gulf plaza boss arrested in April 2009. Before his arrest Sauceda was aligned with the faction of the Gulf cartel that supports Eduardo “El Coss” Costilla Sanchez, the current leader of the group, against Rafael “Junior” Cardenas, the nephew of former Gulf cartel leader Osiel Cardenas Guillen. After Osiel was captured in 2003, his brother Antonio Cardenas Guillen took over co-leadership of the group with Costilla. Following Antonio’s death in November 2010, Costilla became the Gulf cartel’s sole leader. The recent killing of Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borrego, the cartel’s second in command and a Costilla ally, on Sept. 3 was likely part of the same internal fight and further evidence of a split between the two factions.
Rafael Cardenas felt that as a blood relative of Osiel he was the rightful leader of the group. Tensions between those loyal to him and those loyal to Costilla have caused a growing rift within the cartel. Whoever shot Zavala may have known of his association with Sauceda and extrapolated from this that he was also part of the cartel faction loyal to Costilla. This would point to gunmen loyal to Cardenas’ faction as the parties likely responsible for Zavala’s shooting.

What Constitutes Cross-Border Violence?


The killing of Zavala, a suspected cartel operative, on the U.S. side of the border provides a good opportunity to examine how cross-border violence is defined — a question with different answers, depending on who one asks.
Technically speaking, the incident would appear to match most definitions. While in the United States, suspected Mexican cartel gunmen, acting at the direction of their leaders or autonomously, targeted an individual believed to be connected to a rival group, attacked him and then reportedly returned to Mexico. Those in the law enforcement community define as cross-border violence any incident of violence perpetrated by the cartels or by independent smuggling organizations operating in the trans-border region — whether the targets are civilians, authorities or rival cartel members.
These authorities use this definition for two main reasons. The first is to raise awareness about the threat posed by cartels and to educate the public on how to take precautions and instill proactive behavior in areas where cartels are known to be active. The second, more pragmatic, reason is to draw attention to the heavy security burden placed on law enforcement authorities on the border. By defining activity as cross-border violence, law enforcement authorities can solicit more funding from local, state and federal governments to redress the problem. Some politicians, especially at the state level and in the U.S. Congress, also tend to categorize cross-border violence in this manner, as seen in the recently released report by retired U.S. generals Barry McCaffrey and Robert Scales — a report commissioned by the Texas state government.
However, other politicians — especially at the county and municipal government levels — and businesses are often more reluctant to describe incidents like the one detailed above as cross-border violence. As with law enforcement authorities, money is also a central concern for these actors, albeit for a different reason. Local governments and businesses have an interest in downplaying the threat posed by cartels because it can scare off tourists or commercial opportunities. In addition, outspoken citizens and business owners may fear to discuss these issues because of the threat of retaliation. When attacks involve only cartel members, politicians and businesses can make the case that only those involved somehow in the drug trade are being subjected to violence and that uninvolved civilians have little reason to be concerned. Some of these authorities can and do pressure law enforcement officers to downplay any reference of cross-border violence.
There are exceptions to these general stances on the definition of cross-border violence — tourist destinations do advise visitors on taking safety precautions, and law enforcement authorities have downplayed the threat when appropriate to avoid causing an inordinate amount of worry on the part of the public — but each side typically does define cross-border violence in a way that safeguards its own interests.
The reality of the situation is that the border is an artificial line. Any place where drugs are shipped across borders is likely to experience a higher level of this kind of violence than somewhere more distant from drug-trafficking routes. For the most part, the cartels appear to avoid targeting U.S. citizens and law enforcement for fears of drawing a harsh response from the United States. However it is defined, cross-border violence has not reached the level where it is prompting the U.S. federal government to use more drastic measures to thwart it.



Sept. 27


  • Matazetas, the armed wing of Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion, released a video statement recorded Sept. 24, denouncing Los Zetas and stating that the Matazetas sole purpose was to eradicate the group.
  • Gunmen launched a grenade at a state police building in San Bernabe, Nuevo Leon state, leaving two bystanders injured.

Sept. 28


  • Mexican authorities in San Luis Potosi detained eight Los Zetas members, including three women.

Sept. 29


  • Banners left in undisclosed locations in Santiago, Nuevo Leon state, threatened to attack schools in the area with grenades.
  • Narcomantas signed by the Knights Templar were posted in Zihuatanejo, Guerrero state, announcing their presence in the area. The banners stated the Knights Templar would not allow extortion or kidnapping in the area.

Sept. 30


  • Mexican marines arrested approximately 50 police officers in various municipalities. The municipalities include Acultzingo, Ciudad Mendoza, Nogales and Rio Blanco.
  • Mexican authorities in Zapopan, Jalisco state, arrested a member of Los Zetas allegedly involved in the Casino Royale attack in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.

Oct. 1


  • A battle between armed groups occurred in the evening in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state. Witnesses in the area claimed the armed groups used machine guns in the fight.
  • Two men in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state, disappeared after refusing to pay extortion fees demanded by state and municipal police officers.
  • Federal police seized 882 kilograms (about 1,900 pounds) of marijuana from a vehicle with Texas license plates in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state.

Oct. 2


  • Armed men in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, attacked a family of four traveling in a truck with Texas license plates. Three of the family members were killed.
  • A mother, two children, and an unidentified woman were gunned down at an intersection in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.

Oct. 3


  • Three unidentified men in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, were executed behind a grocery store. The victims were pulled out of their vehicles and lined up along the wall of the store before being executed.
  • Three decapitated bodies were discovered in Torreon, Coahuila state. The victims’ heads were located approximately 100 meters (330 feet) away from the bodies.
  • Two human heads were discovered along a road in Mexico City.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 5, 2011
Mexican police captured Martin Rosales Magana, one of the last major leaders of the La Familia Michoacana cartel (LFM), and three associates, AP reported Oct. 5. The head of the federal police anti-drug unit said Rosales Magana was trying to ally with Los Zetas to revive LFM.
October 3, 2011 | 1203 GMT
Mexican Cartels, Crime and the Pan American Games
Security is a constant concern at any major sporting event. The upcoming Pan American Games — to be held in Mexico’s second-largest city and Jalisco state capital, Guadalajara — are no exception. The foremost security concerns for the games arise from the wars between criminal cartels, especially since Guadalajara is highly coveted by the cartels.
According to a security assessment by the U.S. State Department’s Overseas Security Advisory Council (OSAC), approximately 100,000 visitors and as many as 5,500 athletes are expected to attend the events in the city of 4.4 million. STRATFOR, too, has examined current conditions in the region and their possible impact on the safety of the athletes, spectators, sponsors and dignitaries who will be in attendance.

The Games


Guadalajara is actually set to host two major international sporting events: the Pan American Games from Oct. 14 to Oct. 30 and the Parapan American Games from Nov. 12 to Nov. 20. We will focus on the higher-profile Pan American Games. Though the overall visitor presence in the region will be smaller for the Parapan American Games, the same venues will be used and the same dynamics will be in play.
Athletes from 42 countries will compete in 46 sporting events in Guadalajara and several outlying venues. The opening and closing ceremonies will be held Oct. 14 and Oct. 30, respectively, in Omnilife Stadium, adjacent to the athletes’ village in northeast Guadalajara.

Mexican Cartels, Crime and the Pan American Games
Athletes’ village with Omnilife Stadium in background
Several athletic complexes, stadiums and clubs in greater Guadalajara will host the bulk of the competitions. Those events will include nearly all of the track and field competitions; basketball; softball; swimming, synchronized swimming, and diving events; gymnastics; field hockey; martial arts; boxing; weight lifting; Greco-Roman wrestling; handball, squash, badminton, racquetball and tennis; archery; cycling; bowling; football (aka soccer); rugby; and Basque pelota, a traditional Latin American game.
Venues on the Pacific coast in Puerto Vallarta will host the triathlon, sailing, beach volleyball and open-water swimming events. Three venues northwest of Guadalajara will host the modern pentathlon, stadium equestrian competition, equestrian three-day eventing (a combined competition of stadium jumping, dressage and cross-country) and the shooting competition. The mountain bike circuit venue is south of Guadalajara in Tapalpa, while the lake venue for rowing, kayaking and canoeing events is Ciudad Guzman. Finally, the baseball competition will be held northeast of Guadalajara in the industrial city of Lagos de Moreno.



The Cartel Wars


As laid out in our 2010 Cartel Annual Report, and in the first quarter and second quarter updates for 2011, the cartel wars have been escalating across the length and breadth of Mexico, increasing in complexity over the last year and a half. Guadalajara and Jalisco state play a key role in that struggle, as they occupy a strategic location offering control of both north-south and east-west smuggling routes, proximity to huge opium poppy and marijuana growing regions (and thereby control of access to those regions) and access to the huge domestic drug market of Guadalajara itself.
Smuggling has long been a lucrative source of income along the U.S.-Mexican border, whether it was alcohol during the Prohibition era in the 1920s or guns, narcotics or illegal immigrants today. The flow of South American cocaine that shifted to Mexico after interdiction efforts in the Caribbean were ramped up in the 1980s dramatically increased this profitability. The Mexican smugglers who benefited most from this shift included Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo, Ernesto Fonseca Carrillo and Rafael Caro Quintero, who would go on to form a Guadalajara-based organization known as the Guadalajara cartel. This group became the most powerful narcotics-smuggling organization in the country and perhaps the world, controlling virtually all of the narcotics being smuggled into the United States from Mexico.
The Guadalajara cartel was dismantled after the United States and Mexico reacted to the group’s 1985 kidnapping, torture and murder of U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration special agent Enrique Camarena. From the remnants of the Guadalajara cartel, however, emerged smaller organizations that would become the Arellano Felix Organization (aka Tijuana cartel), the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (aka the Juarez cartel), the Gulf cartel and the Sinaloa cartel. The large number of major cartel organizations that grew out of the Guadalajara cartel demonstrates the immense power and geographic reach the group once wielded.
Even after the demise of the Guadalajara cartel, the city of Guadalajara remained important for drug smuggling operations due to its location in relation to Mexico’s highway and railroad systems and its proximity to Mexico’s largest port in Manzanillo. The port plays an important role in cocaine smuggling and has become a very important point of entry for precursor chemicals used in the manufacture of methamphetamine. For many years, the Sinaloa cartel faction headed by Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal was in charge of the Guadalajara plaza. Although Guadalajara and the state of Jalisco continued to be an important component of the cocaine trade, El Nacho became known as “the king of crystal” due to his organization’s heavy involvement in the methamphetamine trade.
Until July 2010, Guadalajara was relatively stable and prosperous under the control of the Sinaloa cartel and El Nacho, who directly ran that region of western Mexico. Violence began to escalate sharply as factions within the Sinaloa organization fought to take control when El Nacho’s killing that month left a power vacuum. Along with the opium and marijuana farm assets in the region, large methamphetamine production, operations and distribution networks have been based in many portions of Jalisco state, including within the city of Guadalajara. El Nacho’s nephew Martin Beltran Coronel took over operations in the region on behalf of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, the leader of the Sinaloa cartel.
Transitions in the narcotics world rarely go smoothly, and indeed at least five other cartels and organizations are fighting to wrest control from Sinaloa (and everyone else). They are La Resistencia and the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion, both based in Guadalajara; Los Zetas; the Knights Templar; and Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS).



There is a high probability that conflict will continue between the players involved, with or without the additional element of Mexican forces. Even so, some diminution in the overall violence is likely in the Greater Guadalajara area during the games, due to greatly increased security efforts by the state and federal government. Though STRATFOR by no means expects a complete cessation of violence, we do not expect to see any direct attacks upon, or intended disruptions of, the Pan American Games, as criminal organizations in Mexico have no motivation to conduct major operations that would harm their interests.
As the games commence, we will be monitoring two main issues pertaining to the cartel wars that may impact visitors and competitors during the games. The first is the possibility of actions by Sinaloa operators directly in association with the games — paralleling an event when President Felipe Calderon visited Acapulco earlier this year and dismembered bodies were placed in high-visibility areas near where Calderon was speaking. The perpetrators apparently intended to signal that they, not Calderon, were in control of the city. STRATFOR suspects a similar event, or series of events, could occur in Guadalajara during the Pan American Games. Should something of this nature occur, it probably would be coordinated with Calderon’s presence, likely during the day of the opening ceremony. The presence of so many members of the international media and authority figures would magnify such a message.
The second issue of concern during the Pan American Games is that attendees could happen to find themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time, for instance getting caught in the crossfire of running gunbattles. Some areas of the city are far more prone to such incidents than others. Within Guadalajara itself, the sports venues are situated in the northern (generally more upscale) half of the city. Except to make use of the airport, which is at the southern end of the city, there is no reason for game attendees to stray into the southern half of the city, the area most affected by cartel violence and gunbattles.
Another facet of the same “wrong place, wrong time” threat should be addressed: namely, the risks associated with traveling between Guadalajara and outlying venues. Conditions along the 320-kilometer (200-mile) mountainous drive between the city and coastal venues in Puerto Vallarta will be impossible for security forces to monitor and control effectively. Of the six organizations mentioned above, Los Zetas, Sinaloa and the CPS have demonstrated highly effective ambush skills and tactics. Again, the likelihood of spectators or competitors being targeted directly is low, but cartel operations in the region intended to net opposition fighters could unintentionally impact visitors. As we have mentioned in other security pieces, the cartels consistently have displayed a complete disregard for the presence of bystanders once gunbattles are under way.

Crime


As always, when traveling in Mexico, it is important for visitors to maintain good situational awareness and to take precautions in order to reduce the threat of becoming a victim of a crime. In most cases, visitors will be more vulnerable to criminals out to make a quick buck than to cartel violence. Pickpockets, muggers, counterfeit ticket scalpers and express kidnappers will all be looking for easy targets during the games, so security precautions need to be taken.
Guadalajara, as all of Mexico, has a declining security environment. According to the OSAC’s 2011 Guadalajara crime and security report, crimes of all types have increased in Guadalajara over the past year, including both violent and petty crime. Mexico has a problem with corruption, especially at lower levels of their police forces, something that must be taken into account when dealing with police officers.
Criminals will consider the Pan American Games a target-rich environment. They will assume security at the venues will be high, although pickpockets and other petty criminals will be working the crowds. Most security measures at the venue will be for major crimes, and professional thieves will have little trouble blending in. Criminals will be even more active on public transportation, around tourist hot spots and restaurants and bars.
Criminals in Mexico are usually looking for the easiest way to make money. They will therefore look for signs that a potential target is wealthy and displays low situational awareness. In Mexico, foreigners are perceived as being wealthy — if they were not, they would not be traveling. Some indicators of a person of means include expensive clothing or accessories, especially watches and shoes. Cellphones, nice wallets and large amounts of cash also catch the attention of criminals, and purses or bags left on the ground or hanging off chairs are easy targets. Criminals also look for backpacks or other bags not strapped across the chest. A common technique is to use a razor blade to slice open the bag and remove its contents when the victim is distracted. The easiest place for this type of criminal to operate is on public transportation or in crowds because of the compact nature of the setting and the inability of victims to identify who stole their items.
Some criminals will loiter around money exchange operations. To exchange money, one must of course bring the money into sight, and thieves can see how much a victim has and where he or she keeps it. Such criminals will sometimes use weapons, although it is typically unnecessary in such a target-rich environment as the Pan American Games. As evidenced through Mexico’s drug war, it should be assumed that a criminal who draws a weapon intends to use it.
Thieves and kidnappers also target ATMs that are not inside a bank, hotel lobby or other secure location. They can set up “dummy” ATMs, typically putting a false front on top of the actual ATM, or a smaller external card reader devices on top of the existing card slot, that will read and store the card’s data as it passes through to the ATM’s functioning card reader. They then use either a camera hidden behind the ATM or a scanner to capture the PIN number of the credit or debit card. This procedure is known as “skimming.”
Some taxi drivers are criminals or are working with criminals involved in kidnappings, theft or worse. At minimum, a driver could take a visitor to a dangerous part of town and blackmail him to return home. At worst, the driver could become violent or assist in a kidnapping.
Kidnappers also conduct surveillance near ATMs, watching for potential targets of express kidnappings. Criminals will typically seize and hold the victim until bank accounts are emptied, which can sometimes take several days. The kidnappers may also want a ransom to be paid, which of course makes the situation more complicated. The victim is in many cases released, but not always. There will be many executives in attendance at the games who are directly involved as representatives of the large multinational corporate sponsors of the Pan American Games. While these individuals will have protective details with them, some of the kidnapping-for-ransom organizations in Mexico may be watching for opportunities to snatch high-value targets — and not just at the public venues.
Criminals find inebriated victims easy prey. It is very common for Mexican thieves to target local nightspots known for attracting tourists. Date rape drugs can be used not only for rape but for robbery as well. In such scenarios, criminals typically watch for someone to stop paying attention to his or her drink, at which point they slip the pill in the bottle or cup and wait. Criminals also seek people who are alone or who display poor awareness, especially at night. If a potential target is listening to headphones or otherwise not paying attention to their surroundings, they are more inviting for criminals. Criminals also will look for targets who are isolated, away from public view or in a location where there is little or no chance of escape.

The Terrorist Threat


STRATFOR does not expect any large-scale terrorist attacks from Islamist or jihadi groups for several reasons. First, the games are not being held in the United States or another Western country where jihadist terrorist groups tend to seek targets. Second, because there is an existing cartel war, security for the Pan American Games will be as tight as the host and guest countries can make it. Also, the jihadist threat today in the Western Hemisphere predominantly emanates from grassroots cells and lone actors. Such operatives are unlikely to attack a highly secured target. Third, while press from across the world will be covering the events, there will be few viable targets within the demonstrated preferences for Islamist groups. As for other special-interest terrorist groups, we see a low likelihood for the appearance of anti-technology, animal rights, earth-rights or Marxist groups — however, they cannot be ruled out. In August, an anti-nanotechnology group sent two parcel bombs to two universities in Mexico City. One of the explosive devices seriously injured two professors. The same group claimed responsibility for a third parcel that was not ever found or reported as having detonated. The bottom line is that while there is the potential for one or more small-scale attacks, terrorist attacks as a whole are rather unlikely.

Miscellaneous Security Issues and Disaster Response


One element of the overall security environment facing the competitors, spectators and officials attending the Pan American Games is not of human making or intent. Guadalajara sits just east of a significant and rather active tectonic subduction zone. The western coastal region within 320 kilometers of Guadalajara has been hit four times by earthquakes over magnitude 7.5 in the last 80 years — two in June 1932, one in September 1985 and most recently in January 2003.
Because of that potential, and the desire to entice future tourism with demonstrated security and precautions, the government of Mexico probably will have a relatively decent earthquake response program in place. It is likely that visitors will see many well-placed placards in the venues, in multiple languages, offering earthquake safety information. Following the instructions found there would be wise in the event of a significant earthquake during the games.
Fire is also a serious concern in the developing world, and visitors to Guadalajara staying in hotels need to ensure that they know where the fire exits are located — and that those fire exits are not blocked or locked.
First-time visitors to Mexico will find that the traffic in Mexico’s cities is terrible — and Guadalajara is no exception. More often than not, there is little regard given to traffic lanes, traffic signals, stop signs or other standard traffic laws that are commonly conformed to in the West. Traffic congestion and traffic accidents are quite common.
Visitors to Mexico also need to be mindful of the poor quality of the country’s water and the possibility of contracting a waterborne illness from drinking water or from eating improperly prepared food. Privately operated medical facilities in Mexico are well-equipped for all levels of medical care, and foreign visitors should choose private over public (government-operated) health care facilities. Private medical services can also stabilize a patient and facilitate a medical transfer to another country (such as the United States), should the need arise.

Security Preparation


According to media and U.S. State Department sources, Mexican authorities are coordinating security for the Pan American Games with federal police forces, Jalisco state police, municipal police and elements of both the naval and army branches of the Mexican military. Mexico will provide some 10,000 security personnel (5,000 of whom will be federal police) and will be responsible for securing the competition venues as well as increasing the presence of law enforcement in tourist areas and around hotels and the airport. Military assets will be patrolling the roads and probably providing supplemental forces in the largest venues as well as those in the outlying municipalities where there may be less of a police presence.
According to STRATFOR sources in the Mexican media, the Jalisco state government allocated 100 million pesos ($7.26 million) to augment security in the metropolitan area. The funding covered the additional manpower needed and the acquisition of security equipment such as metal detector portals, drug and explosives detection equipment, and vehicles and special uniforms for the security forces. Sources also indicated that canine units will be on patrol, along with airborne assets providing coverage with Blackhawk and Colibri helicopters. All ground and air security assets will be networked, and federal elements will have a real-time connection with the Federal Command Center in Mexico City. The overall security program is reported to cover all pertinent areas: sports venues, hotels, airports, highways, training facilities and host cities. Additionally, as some of the sports delegations were expected to ship their equipment by sea, security will be augmented at the ports of Manzanillo and Veracruz.
The construction of the Pan Am athletes’ village, recently completed, includes perimeter security walls and a controlled entry, as seen in the architect’s rendering.

Mexican Cartels, Crime and the Pan American Games
Bird’s eye view of Pan Am athletes’ village
Entry to the venues will require possession of a ticket, successful screening through security and metal detectors and a security search of bags and pockets. Additionally, for the purposes of security and to mitigate traffic congestion, there will not be any parking available close to any of the venues, according to media reports. In all cases, there will be guarded shuttle buses to transport spectators between venues. Furthermore, there will be about 210 kilometers of dedicated lanes on the major thoroughfares, including the route between the airport and the northern sector of the city as well as between the venues. The dedicated lanes will be reserved for moving Pan American officials, competitors, judges, security personnel and dignitaries. The lanes will be accessible by all motorists but, in the same fashion that drivers must move aside to allow emergency vehicles to pass, all motorists must yield their use of the lane to the “accredited vehicles.” Heavy fines will be imposed upon drivers who fail to yield. The designated Pan Am lanes will begin operation on Oct. 9 and will continue through the two weeks of the games.
Contact information for spectator services at the Pan American Games in Guadalajara may be found on the official website — included are phone numbers for law enforcement, fire services, tourist services and emergency response services.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

October 2, 2011
Guerrero state police said Oct. 2 that the bodies of seven men who appear to have been shot to death have been found at a downtown bus stop in the resort city of Zihuatanejo, AP reported. Signs found with the bodies appear to be signed by the Knights Templar, police said.
September 2011
September 28, 2011
Mexican President Felipe Calderon’s administration said Sept. 28 that it is sending troops and federal police to reinforce operational and intelligence work in the state of Veracruz, federal security representative Alejandra Sota said, AP reported. Sota said Veracruz’s government asked federal prosecutors to take over the investigation of last week’s dumping of 35 bodies.
September 29, 2011

Libya After Gadhafi: Transitioning from Rebellion to Rule


By Scott Stewart
The 2011 Pan American Games will be held in Guadalajara, Mexico, from Oct. 14 through Oct. 30. The games will feature 36 different sports and will bring more than 6,000 athletes and tens of thousands of spectators to Mexico’s second-largest city. The Parapan American Games, for athletes with physical disabilities, will follow from Nov. 12 to Nov. 20.
Like the Olympics, the World Cup or any other large sporting event, planning for the Pan American Games in Guadalajara began when the city was selected to host them in 2006. Preparations have included the construction of new sports venues, an athletes’ village complex, hotels, highway and road infrastructure, and improvements to the city’s mass transit system. According to the coordinating committee, the construction and infrastructure improvements for the games have cost some $750 million.
The preparations included more than just addressing infrastructure concerns, however. Due to the crime environment in Mexico, security is also a very real concern for the athletes, sponsors and spectators who will visit Guadalajara during the games. The organizers of the games, the Mexican government and the governments of the 42 other participating countries also will be focused intensely on security in Guadalajara over the next two months.
In light of these security concerns, STRATFOR will publish a special report on the games Sept. 30. The report, of which this week’s Security Weekly is an abridged version, will provide our analysis of threats to the games.

Cartel Environment


Due to the violent and protracted conflicts between Mexico’s transnational criminal cartels and the incredible Stratfor levels of brutality that they have spawned, most visitors’ foremost security concern will be Mexico’s criminal cartels. The Aug. 20 incident in Torreon, Coahuila state, in which a firefight occurred outside of a stadium during a nationally televised soccer match, will reinforce perceptions of this danger. The concern is understandable, especially considering Guadalajara’s history as a cartel haven and recent developments in the region. Even so, we believe the cartels are unlikely to attack the games intentionally.
Historically, smuggling has been a way of life for criminal groups along the U.S.-Mexico border, and moving illicit goods across the border, whether alcohol, guns, narcotics or illegal immigrants, has long proved quite profitable for these groups. This profitability increased dramatically in the 1980s and 1990s as the flow of South American cocaine through the Caribbean was sharply cut due to improvements in maritime and aerial surveillance and interdiction. This change in enforcement directed a far larger percentage of the flow of cocaine through Mexico, greatly enriching the Mexican smugglers involved in the cocaine trade. The group of smugglers who benefited most from cocaine trade included Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo, Ernesto Fonseca Carrillo and Rafael Caro Quintero, who would go on to form a Guadalajara-based organization known as the Guadalajara cartel. That cartel became the most powerful narcotics smuggling organization in the country, and perhaps the world, controlling virtually all the narcotics smuggled into the United States from Mexico.
The Guadalajara cartel was dismantled during the U.S. and Mexican reaction to the 1985 kidnapping, torture and murder of U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration Special Agent Enrique Camarena by the group. Smaller organizations emerged from its remains that eventually would become the Arellano Felix Organization (aka the Tijuana cartel), the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes Organization (aka the Juarez cartel), the Gulf cartel and the Sinaloa Federation. The sheer number of major cartel organizations that came out of the Guadalajara cartel demonstrates the immense power and geographic reach the group once wielded.
Even after the demise of the Guadalajara cartel, Guadalajara continued to be an important city for drug smuggling operations due to its location in relation to Mexico’s highway and railroad system and its proximity to Mexico’s largest port, Manzanillo. The port is not just important to cocaine smuggling; it also has become an important point of entry for precursor chemicals used in the manufacture of methamphetamine. For many years, the Sinaloa Federation faction headed by Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal was in charge of the Guadalajara plaza. Although Guadalajara and the state of Jalisco continued to be an important component of the cocaine trade, Coronel Villarreal became known as “the king of crystal” due to his organization’s heavy involvement in the meth trade.
Guadalajara remained firmly under Sinaloa control until the Beltran Leyva Organization (BLO) split off from Sinaloa following the arrest of Alfredo Beltran Leyva in January 2008. This caused the Beltran Leyva Organization to ally itself with Los Zetas and to begin to attack Sinaloa’s infrastructure on Mexico’s Pacific coast. In April 2010, Coronel Villarreal’s 16-year-old son Alejandro was abducted and murdered. Like the murder of Edgar Guzman Beltran, the son of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, the BLO and Los Zetas were thought to have been behind the murder of Coronel Villarreal’s son. In July 2010, Coronel Villarreal himself was killed during a shootout with the Mexican military in Zapopan, Jalisco state.
Coronel Villarreal’s death created a power vacuum in Guadalajara that several organizations attempted to fill due to the importance of Guadalajara and Jalisco to the smuggling of narcotics. One of these was La Familia Michoacana (LFM). LFM’s attempt to assume control of Guadalajara led to the rupture of the alliance between LFM and Sinaloa. (LFM has since fractured; the most powerful faction of that group is now called the Knights Templar.) The group now headed by Hector Beltran Leyva, which is called the Cartel Pacifico Sur, and its ally Los Zetas also continue to attempt to increase their influence over Guadalajara.
But the current fight for control of Guadalajara includes not only outsiders such as the Knights Templar and the CPS/Los Zetas but also the remnants of Coronel Villarreal’s network and what is left of the Milenio cartel (also known as the Valencia cartel) which has historically been very active in Guadalajara and Manzanillo. One portion of the former Milenio cartel is known as “La Resistencia” and has become locked in a vicious war with the most prominent group of Coronel’s former operatives, which is known as the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG). CJNG appears to have gotten the better of La Resistencia in this fight, and La Resistencia has recently allied itself with Los Zetas/CPS out of desperation.
In July, CJNG announced it was moving some of its forces to Veracruz to attack Los Zetas’ infrastructure there. This CJNG group in Veracruz began to call itself “Matazetas,” Spanish for “Zeta killers.” It is believed that the CJNG is responsible for the recent killings of low-level Zeta operators in Veracruz. Taken with the Los Zetas/La Resistencia alliance, the CJNG offensive in Veracruz means that if Los Zetas have the ability to strike against the CJNG infrastructure in Guadalajara, they will do so. Such strikes could occur in the next few weeks, and could occur during the games.
As illustrated by the recent body dumps in Veracruz, or the bodies dumped in Acapulco during Mexican President Felipe Calderon’s visit to that city in March, the Mexican cartels do like to perform a type of macabre theater in order to grab media attention. With the attention of the press turned toward Guadalajara, it would not be surprising if one or more cartel groups attempted some sort of body dump or other spectacle in Guadalajara during the games.
And given the ongoing fight for control of Guadalajara, it is quite likely that there will be some confrontations between the various cartel groups in the city during the games. However, such violence is not likely to be intentionally directed against the games. The biggest risk to athletes and spectators posed by the cartels comes from being in the wrong place at the wrong time; the cartels frequently employ fragmentation grenades and indiscriminate fire during shootouts with the authorities and rival cartels.

Crime


One of the side effects of the Mexican government’s war against the cartels is that as some cartels have been weakened by pressure from the government and their rivals, they have become less capable of moving large shipments of narcotics. This has made them increasingly reliant on other types of crime to supplement their income. Crime always has been a problem in Mexico, but activities such as robbery, kidnapping and extortion have gotten progressively worse in recent years. According to the U.S. State Department’s 2011 Crime and Safety report for Guadalajara, crimes of all types have increased in the city. Indeed, due to the high levels of crime present in Mexico, athletes and spectators at the Pan American Games are far more likely to fall victim to common crime than they are to an act of cartel violence.
The Mexican government will employ some 10,000 police officers (to include 5,000 Federal Police officers) as well as hundreds of military personnel to provide protection to the athletes and venues associated with the Pan American Games. But when one considers that the Guadalajara metropolitan area contains some 4.4 million residents, and that there will be thousands of athletes and perhaps in excess of 100,000 spectators, the number of security personnel assigned to work the games is not as large as it might appear at first glance. Nevertheless, the authorities will be able to provide good security for the athletes’ village and the venues, and on the main travel routes, though they will not be able to totally secure the entire Guadalajara metropolitan area. Places outside the security perimeters where there is little security, and therefore a greater danger of criminal activity, will remain.
When visiting Guadalajara during the games, visitors are advised to be mindful of their surroundings and maintain situational awareness at all times in public areas. Visitors should never expose valuables, including wallets, jewelry, cell phones and cash, any longer than necessary. And they should avoid traveling at night, especially into areas of Guadalajara and the surrounding area that are away from the well-established hotels and sporting venues. Visitors will be most vulnerable to criminals while in transit to and from the venues, and while out on the town before and after events. Excessive drinking is also often an invitation to disaster in a high-crime environment.
As always, visitors to Mexico should maintain good situational awareness and take common-sense precautions to reduce the chances of becoming a crime victim. Pickpockets, muggers, counterfeit ticket scalpers, and express kidnappers all will be looking for easy targets during the games, and steps need to be taken to avoid them. Mexico has a problem with corruption, especially at lower levels of their municipal police forces, and so this must be taken into account when dealing with police officers.
While traditional kidnappings for ransom in Mexico are usually directed against well-established targets, express kidnappings can target anyone who appears to have money, and foreigners are often singled out for express kidnapping. Express kidnappers are normally content to drain the contents of the bank accounts linked to the victim’s ATM card, but in cases where there is a large amount of cash linked to the account and a small daily limit, an express kidnapping can turn into a protracted ordeal. Express kidnappings can also transform into a traditional kidnapping if the criminals discover the victim of their express kidnapping happens to be a high net worth individual.
It is also not uncommon for unregulated or “libre” taxi drivers in Mexico to be involved with criminal gangs who engage in armed robbery or express kidnapping, so visitors need to be careful only to engage taxi services from a regulated taxi stand or a taxi arranged via a hotel or restaurant, but even that is no guarantee.

Miscellaneous Threats


In addition to the threats posed by the cartels and other criminals, there are some other threats that must be taken into consideration. First, Guadalajara is located in a very active seismic area and earthquakes there are quite common, although most of them cannot be felt. Occasionally, big quakes will strike the city and visitors need to be mindful of how to react in an earthquake.
Fire is also a serious concern, especially in the developing world, and visitors to Guadalajara staying in hotels need to ensure that they know where the fire exits are and that those fire exits are not blocked or locked.
The traffic in Mexico’s cities is terrible and Guadalajara is no exception. Traffic congestion and traffic accidents are quite common.
Visitors to Mexico also need to be mindful of the poor water quality in the country and the possibility of contracting a water-borne illness from drinking the water or from eating improperly prepared food. Privately operated medical facilities in Mexico are well-equipped for all levels of medical care, and foreign visitors should choose private over public (government-operated) health care facilities. Private medical services can also stabilize a patient and facilitate a medical evacuation to another country (such as the United States) should the need arise.
In conclusion, the most dangerous organizations in Mexico have very little motivation or intent to hit the Pan American Games. The games are also at very low risk of being a target for international terrorism. The organizing committee, the Mexican government and the other governments that will be sending athletes to the games will be coordinating closely to ensure that the games pass without major incident. Because of this, the most likely scenario for an incident impacting an athlete or spectator will be common crime occurring away from the secure venues.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
September 29, 2011 | 1158 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Congressman Killed in Guerrero State

Body Dumps of Zetas Members in Veracruz


The bodies of nearly 50 people with suspected ties to Los Zetas, including 35 dumped in one location along a main road, have been found since Sept. 20 throughout Veracruz, Veracruz state. The discovery of the bodies comes only a few weeks after the Mexican navy dismantled a large Zetas communications network Sept. 8 in Veracruz state.
Though it is not clear at this point who was responsible for the body dumps, these incidents indicate that the cartel war is intensifying in Veracruz and that the Zetas are taking the brunt of the action from both other cartels and Mexican authorities.
On Sept. 20 around 5 p.m., two flatbed trucks with 35 bodies (23 men and 12 women) were left on a roundabout near Manuel Avila Camacho Boulevard in Boca del Rio, a southern suburb of Veracruz. Most of the bodies were piled in the trucks, with a few surrounding the vehicles. Photos of the incident indicated the victims had been dead for some time. It is believed almost all of the victims were killed by suffocation.



Some of the dead were reported to be escaped inmates from three jails in Veracruz who had broken out between 2:30 and 4 a.m. on Sept. 19, although Mexican authorities have not confirmed that any of the bodies were escaped inmates. A narcomanta left at the scene stated, among other things, “To the people of Veracruz, don’t pay extortion.” It was reportedly signed “G.N.,” although this was not seen in photos of the banner nor has it been confirmed by authorities.
On Sept. 22, 14 bodies were found in various locations in the greater Veracruz metro area. The cause of death of the majority of the victims was also suffocation and, just as in the first incident, the bodies were marked with “Por Z,” which has been interpreted to mean the bodies were “for the Zetas” or “for being a Zeta.” No narcomantas have been reported found near any of the bodies discovered Sept. 22, although the banner left Sept. 20 at the other location warned there were more bodies to come.
It is still not clear who carried out the killing of the nearly 50 people, but there are clues that point to the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG), which previously declared war on all cartels but now is rumored to be aligned with the Sinaloa Federation. The narcomanta ordering citizens not to pay extortion is obviously an attempt by the perpetrators of these killings to announce they are on the side of the people of Veracruz. The idea that the Zetas are the most violent cartel is partially due to the perceived threat they pose to civilians. If the attackers could be seen as supporting the people against the Zetas, similar to what the Knights Templar have attempted, it could help minimize public sentiment against the group or even gain them public favor and further undermine the Zetas’ position.
In a video released Sept. 24, the CJNG stated it would not extort, kidnap or otherwise harm innocent civilians, fitting with the message left on the narcomanta. The CJNG also stated in the video its intention to destroy the Zetas, calling its members “Matazetas,” or Zeta killers. Although the group did not specifically claim responsibility for the Sept. 20 and Sept. 22 body dumps, the message of supporting the public and a desire to crush Los Zetas is consistent with other videos and messages from the group. In fact, they have reportedly handed out business cards to locals in Guadalajara with a phone number to call if a citizen is being blackmailed or harassed by other gangs so that they can kill the offenders.
Another party that may have been responsible for the killings is La Gente Nueva, the enforcement arm of the Sinaloa Federation. The Sinaloa Federation does not officially permit its members to extort civilians — although unauthorized extortion certainly happens at the street level — because, as the most powerful cartel in Mexico holding the most valuable territory, Sinaloa does not need the revenue stream from extortion. Although they are extremely violent, their violence is usually directed at other cartels and the Mexican authorities, not civilians. If the attacks were carried out by La Gente Nueva, this would be the first time they have been seen or identified this far east or in Veracruz.
It is possible the Gulf cartel was responsible for these attacks, mainly because it has a stake in the battle for Veracruz, but it is not certain the Gulf cartel has the ability to pull off such brazen attacks — they have been on the defensive since losing the plaza to the Zetas in early 2010.
Regardless of whether the murders were carried out by the CJNG unilaterally or on behalf of the Sinaloa Federation, they will help Sinaloa. Attacking the Zetas could allow Sinaloa to gain a foothold in Veracruz, an important smuggling hub for drugs and people and a major port of entry for precursor chemicals used in the production of methamphetamine. It would also be a significant move by the Sinaloa Federation into the eastern half of the country, which is traditionally Gulf or Zetas territory. If the Sinaloa Federation believes it is strong enough in relation to Los Zetas to make this move deep in Zetas turf, it could be a sign the Zetas are weakening.
The Zetas are fighting in a substantial number of locations and with numerous enemies. STRATFOR sources also indicate they are having problems with internal fracturing as different factions fight over territory and money. The dumping of bodies is a clear sign that whoever carried out the attacks does not believe the Zetas can retaliate in force, and the next few weeks will show whether this is true. If the Zetas are unable to strike back hard to prove they can protect their territory and personnel, the competing cartels will perceive weakness and move in to crush them.



Sept. 20


  • During the celebration of the 415th anniversary of the founding of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, gunmen scattered the remains of Topo Chico prison guards in Monterrey. A narcomanta was left with one of the bodies, but authorities have not released the contents of the message.
  • Mexican authorities arrested 10 federal police officers for extortion in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. The arrest came after a tip by a junkyard owner who stated the police officers threatened to force him to transport drugs if he did not pay them $3,000 within a year.
  • Mexican authorities announced the arrest of a high-level leader of the Knights Templar, Saul “El Lince” Solis Solis. The leader was arrested a day prior in Nueva Italia, Michoacan state.
  • The bodies of at least 40 alleged Los Zetas members were dumped near a major road in Veracruz. Some of the bodies were suspended from a post along the road while the rest were either in two flatbed trucks or nearby on the road. A narcomanta displayed between the two trucks denounced extortion and the killing of innocent people.
  • The Mexican military arrested 19 Los Zetas members in Anahuac, Nuevo Leon state. All were shown to the public wearing camouflage uniforms.

Sept. 21


  • In four separate attacks, gunmen attacked three police stations, injuring six police officers, in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. After one of the attacks, gunmen launched another attack against federal police sent to reinforce one of the attacked police stations.
  • Approximately 30 gunmen in five to seven vehicles assisted in the escape of two people who had been detained in a juvenile detention facility on the Zacatecas-Guadalajara highway in Zacatecas state.
  • Gunmen attempted to kidnap the Benito Juarez municipal police chief in Paseos Kabah, Quintana Roo state.

Sept. 22


  • Fifteen executed bodies were placed in various locations in Pedro I Mata, Zaragoza and Vista Hermosa, Veracruz state. The bodies were semi-nude and showed signs of torture.

Sept. 24


  • An enforcer wing of the CJNG, the Matazetas, released a video wherein they stated their intent to eradicate Los Zetas. The video states they do not intend to harm innocent individuals or interfere with the Mexican government. The video statement explained security concerns for several areas within Veracruz state.
  • An execution video was released of two individuals who claimed to be halcones for the Sinaloa Federation. In the video, the individuals were interviewed by the executioners and then beheaded with a chainsaw and a butcher knife.
  • Three narcomantas signed by the New Juarez Cartel were placed in various areas of Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state. The message was directed threats towards Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera and Ismael “El Mayo” Zambada Garcia, leaders of the Sinaloa Federation.
  • A woman was found decapitated in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, along with a narcomanta apparently written by Los Zetas. The message blames the woman’s death on negative statements she posted on social networking website Nuevo Laredo en Vivo.

Sept. 26


  • Four individuals were wounded when a grenade was thrown at a bar in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.
  • At least five narcomantas were displayed in Coatzacoalcos, Veracruz state, denouncing Mexican senators and the Mexican military for the lack of help in the disappearance of innocent people. The banners were signed “Desperate Society.”
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

September 22, 2011 | 2037 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Congressman Assassinated in Guerrero

Possible Cartel Hit on a Federal Lawmaker


On Sept. 17, the bodies of Mexican federal legislator Moises Villanueva de la Luz and his driver were found along a riverbank below a bridge in Huamuxtitlan, Guerrero state. The men had been missing since Sept. 4, when they disappeared following an Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) political event Villanueva de la Luz attended in his congressional district.
Shortly before his disappearance, Villanueva de la Luz had submitted a proposal to Mexican President Felipe Calderon and Attorney General Marisela Morales asking them to establish a special commission to investigate crimes against migrants, probably triggered by the discovery of several mass graves of migrants across Mexico and neighboring Guatemala over the past year. Though Mexican law enforcement authorities have not speculated on suspects in the case, and though his death may have been the result of some sort of personal or political dispute unrelated to the proposed migrant crimes commission, the cartels have been known to traffic and forcibly recruit (or sometimes kill) migrants, and may have been involved in Villanueva de la Luz’s killing in response to his attempt to investigate those crimes.
A report from the coroner’s office indicated that the men were executed by gunshots to the temple, and the bodies were found with no signs of torture. From the severe level of decomposition, the two men were likely killed shortly after they were kidnapped — they were also found wearing the same clothes they wore the day they disappeared. The location where they were discovered, on a riverbank below a bridge, could indicate that they were killed somewhere else and their bodies were quickly dumped from a vehicle off the bridge. According to the Guerrero state attorney general’s office, investigators have ruled out a kidnapping for ransom as the motive because Villanueva de la Luz’s family was never contacted about ransom demands.
Establishing a commission to investigate the abuse of migrants, a known cartel activity, may have been cause enough for Villanueva de la Luz to be targeted, but cartels have been known to attack lawmakers for a variety of reasons. In some instances, the cartels have tried to kill lawmakers known to be on the payroll of a rival drug cartel, or who have refused to cooperate with a cartel after being approached.
One other theory on Villanueva de la Luz’s death bears mentioning — though at this point it seems very unlikely. The PRI chapter in Guerrero state sent an official letter to local authorities suggesting the murder may have been politically motivated and demanded rural development secretary Socorro Sofio Ramirez Hernandez of the Democratic Revolutionary Party (who previously had held Villanueva de la Luz’s congressional seat) be detained for questioning. The PRI party chief said Ramirez had unsuccessfully pressured Villanueva de la Luz in the past to “subordinate him to his personal interests,” but provided no specifics. Given the ambiguity of the accusation from a single source, the relatively rare political violence between parties in Mexico and the fact that the state attorney general has said there is no evidence indicating Ramirez was involved, this seems an unlikely explanation for the congressman’s death.
If the killing was orchestrated by the cartels, there are a number of potential suspects. Los Zetas, due to their well-known role in trafficking migrants and sometimes forcibly recruiting them into their ranks, would be among the most hostile to an investigative body examining and publicizing their activities. Besides the large drug cartels, other, smaller criminal groups have been known to target migrants and would not have welcomed Villanueva de la Luz’s proposed commission. A STRATFOR source in U.S. federal law enforcement said that remnants of the defunct Beltran Leyva Organization are believed to be connected to the killing. One of those remnant groups, La Barredora, has been very active in nearby Acapulco, making statements threatening state-level political leaders in Guerrero state. It is also known to have connections to the Sinaloa Federation, currently Mexico’s most powerful drug-trafficking organization. The ties to Sinaloa mean La Barredora may act at the behest of the larger group and can easily take actions outside of the typical activities of the small-time gangs, like kidnappings for ransom, though Mexican authorities have already eliminated that as a possibility in this case.
Regardless of which cartel or criminal organization was responsible, the congressman’s death could have a chilling effect on other Mexican lawmakers with intentions to investigate anti-migrant crimes.

Teachers Killed in Guerrero State


Reports emerged Sept. 18 that a vehicle carrying four teachers was stopped and fired upon by gunmen in the town of Puerto Rico del Sur, Guerrero state. Three of the people in the car were killed, and the fourth was wounded. (A separate, conflicting story described the victims as three people, only one a teacher, who were attacked driving in a pickup truck in a nearby municipality.) The attack coincides with the closure of elementary and high schools across the state since the beginning of September after extortion letters were sent to school administrators.
The letters demanded the names, addresses, phone numbers, voter registration information and district payroll records for all teachers being paid more than 20,000 pesos (about $1,400) per month. It said that by Oct. 1, all teachers making more than that amount would be required to forfeit half of their monthly salary to the extortioner as well as half of their annual bonus, and threatened unspecified but “severe” consequences for noncompliance. According to a Mexican media report, the teachers’ union has said the teachers in the closed schools will not return to work until the government guarantees their safety.
While the extortion letter’s deadline has not arrived, it is possible that teachers refused to allow their information to be passed to the extortion group (the extortion letter demanded administrators provide the names of any teachers who refused and that they would address the matter). If all the occupants in the car were teachers, it seems unlikely that they were the victims of a random act of violence, and if the gunmen were connected to the extortion letter, they may have attacked the teachers before the deadline to reinforce fear and ensure compliance by the appointed time.
The Guerrero state prosecutor’s office reportedly denied any connection between the attack on the teachers and the known extortion threat, though it would obviously be reluctant to confirm a connection, given the potential for an attack against teachers to cause a panic and exacerbate the situation. Most cartels, and many of the smaller criminal organizations, have proven well to the Mexican population that threats rarely are hollow; intimidation related to the extortion threat appears to be the motive for the attack.



Sept. 12


  • Three “narcomantas,” or banners posted by drug cartels, were posted in Chihuahua, Chihuahua state, and signed by the Carrillo Leyva brothers. The banners criticized the Mexican government and invited citizens to join the Juarez cartel.
  • Mexican authorities arrested an individual for smuggling 102 pellets of cocaine weighing a total of about 1.14 kilograms (2.5 pounds), in his stomach at the Mexico City International Airport. The individual had flown to Mexico City from Cancun, Quintana Roo state, and was destined for Spain.
  • Mexican authorities arrested seven members of the Gulf cartel in San Cristobal de la Barranca, Jalisco state.

Sept. 13


  • Narcomantas signed by Los Zetas were left with two bodies hanging from a bridge in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state. The messages threatened anyone who uses social media networks to report on Mexican cartel activity.

Sept. 14


  • Gunmen attacked the State Investigation Agency office in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. The gunmen used high-powered rifles and at least one grenade.
  • About 70 Gulf cartel members entered Juchipila, Zacatecas state, in 22 trucks and stopped at the municipality’s headquarters. The members stayed in the area for approximately five hours, carrying rifles, grenades and grenade launchers. The Gulf members stated to observers they were in the area to “do a good cleaning.”

Sept. 15


  • Gunmen in two separate incidents in Apodaca, Nuevo Leon state, attacked five transit officers. The attacks resulted in the deaths of three police officers and the kidnapping of another.
  • A bomb in a vehicle was detonated on a street in Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas state. No deaths were reported from the explosion.
  • Members of Knights Templar handed out flyers to citizens in Apatzingan, Michoacan state, warning of upcoming attacks by Los Zetas.

Sept. 16


  • At least thirty narcomantas were posted in at least 10 municipalities of Michoacan state signed by the Knights Templar. The banners denounced Los Zetas and claim that the Knights Templar are protecting the citizens of Michoacan. Some of the cities with banners include Apatzingan, Morelia and Quiroga.
  • The Mexican military dismantled a drug lab in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. The military seized approximately 60 kilograms of methamphetamine, 2 liters (about half a gallon) of liquid methamphetamine, and chemical precursors.

Sept. 17


  • Gunmen kidnapped a PRI party member in front of his home in Jose Azueta, Veracruz state. The individual was a leader of a municipal committee.
  • The body of PRI federal legislator Moises Villanueva de la Luz, was discovered in Huamuxtitlan, Guerrero state. The congressman and his driver had been missing since Sept. 4.

Sept. 18


  • Mexican authorities captured six Los Zetas members in Santa Catarina, Nuevo Leon state. One of the members was allegedly a lookout for the Casino Royale attack in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon.
  • Three men were arrested in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, while attempting to post narcomantas. The contents of the banners were not released.
  • A member of the Sinaloa Federation, Jesus Hernandez Valenzuela, was arrested at a safe house in Tijuana, Baja California state.

Sept. 19


  • A confrontation between rival criminal groups left at least eight dead in Nocupetaro, Michoacan state.
  • Mexican authorities discovered the bodies of five executed individuals in Ixtapaluca, Mexico state. Left with the body was a narcomanta signed by La Familia Michoacana, which claimed ownership of the area.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

September 21, 2011 | 1326 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

Vice President of Intelligence Fred Burton examines the emerging threat against journalists covering Mexican cartel violence along the border and the challenges of corroborating source information.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


As a forecasting company, we try to look at emerging threats. Intelligence surfaced this week over concerns for border violence against journalists that cover cartel violence from Mexico. In this week’s Above the Tearline, we’re going to examine the challenges of making sense of this kind of emerging threat, as well as how we go about attempting to corroborate or refute the information.
Being a journalist or an investigative reporter in Mexico is an extremely dangerous job. Organizations like Reporters Without Borders reports that there’s been 80 journalists killed in Mexico since 2000, and recently we had two female journalists found naked, bound and killed in Mexico City. The intelligence we received this week is from a very reliable source of STRATFOR that expressed very specific concern for this emerging threat against journalists inside the United States, especially those in close proximity to the border.
When STRATFOR receives a report like this from a reliable contact, we take great strides to attempt to corroborate or refute the data point, meaning we go about contacting our other sources in state and local and federal law enforcement, as well as foreign police, in this case, Mexico, in an effort to see what they may know about this concern and to seek out their assessment as to whether or not this could be a viable threat. One of the things that we did to connect the dots is, we have had over the years anecdotal information from various media contacts and investigative journalists of the exact same fear. We’ve had reports of journalists being relocated out of concerns surrounding this exact issue, and in essence protective security measures being taken by various media outlets to protect themselves from this kind of issue.
One of the other things we do in an effort to corroborate or refute a source report is, we’ll gather together the tactical team that puts together the Mexico Security Memo and discuss in great detail whether or not we think this is a viable threat and will unpack that threat to see if it makes sense or if it’s something that just is totally off the wall.
The Above the Tearline aspect with this video is the fear that the cartels have the capability to suppress the open source as to what’s taking place in Mexico or along the border and in essence shape the perception of what the cartels are doing. We have already seen this happen inside of Mexico. There has been a reduction of investigative journalists, we’ve had numerous killed and intimidated and if this threat is now coming across the border, this is an issue that most of us have to look at very closely and think about the ramifications of the spillover effect and the ability of the cartels to shape the news inside the United States.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

September 13, 2011 | 1527 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Violence Shows Strategic Value of Torreon, Acapulco

Zetas Communications Network Disrupted in Veracruz


The Mexican navy on Sept. 8 dismantled a communications network used by Los Zetas throughout Veracruz state. Among the equipment seized were mobile radio transmitters, computers, radio scanners, encryption devices, solar power cells and as many as seven trailers that served as base stations, according to media reports. A spokesman for the Mexican navy said some 80 individuals have been arrested over the past month in connection with the operation, itself the result of months of work by naval intelligence officers.
Los Zetas have been known to utilize more sophisticated communications networks than other cartels, due in large part to the organization’s origins in military special operations. The Zetas needed to augment sparse communications in some areas they control, and the Veracruz network likely was for the purpose of “off the grid” communications. Since cellphones are relatively easy for authorities to monitor, Los Zetas have sought to diversify their telecommunications capabilities, a fact of which Mexican authorities are aware.
It is possible that the seizure of this communications equipment means the navy is preparing to launch operations to push the Zetas out of the Veracruz port region. Indeed, a navy spokesman said the immediate result of the operation was the disruption of the Zetas’ “chain of command and tactical coordination.” If the navy is about to engage the Zetas in Veracruz, dismantling the Zetas’ communications network would be one of the first moves it would make.
There is not yet enough evidence to conclude with certainty that an operation is in the works, but STRATFOR will continue to watch for signs of increased military operations against the Zetas in Veracruz.

Hand Grenade Attacks in Rio Bravo


On Sept. 10, armed men in an SUV and an accompanying car reportedly threw five hand grenades at two businesses in Rio Bravo, Tamaulipas state, killing two people. Beginning at 2:30 p.m., the assailants lobbed three grenades at a bar on the city’s east side, an unnamed police official said; one of the grenades failed to detonate. A few minutes later, unidentified men threw two grenades at a strip club in downtown Rio Bravo, causing the building to catch fire and injuring three people.
It is unclear who conducted the attacks, but they are believed to be the work of Los Zetas, who are engaged in a turf war with the Gulf cartel in the wider region. At present the Gulf cartel controls the Rio Bravo plaza, but Los Zetas have been known to “heat up” a plaza — increase attacks to soften their target — prior to an offensive, as was the case in Matamoros in mid-June.
The targets are significant in that they are “legitimate” businesses. Businesses can serve as money-laundering hubs for cartels and thus are not immune to attack. Also significant is that the attacks occurred during daylight hours. While violence in Mexico is unpredictable and by no means limited to nighttime hours, there is a general sense that the goings-on of a normal day are spared from targeted violence. Incidents such as the Sept. 10 grenade attacks show that this is not always the case.
If the Zetas did not conduct the attacks, they could be a symptom of infighting within the Gulf cartel. The recent death of Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borrego, the Gulf cartel’s Reynosa plaza boss and overall No. 2, suggests rifts are forming within the cartel. Rio Bravo can expect to see reprisal attacks regardless of who is responsible.

U.S. Citizens as Couriers for Money, Guns


Mexican authorities arrested seven individuals Sept. 7 in Piedras Negras, Coahuila state, and confiscated firearms, ammunition, radio communication equipment, two vehicles and the equivalent of $600,000. The Ministry of National Defense has not disclosed the identities or nationalities of those arrested, but local and state media have reported that they are all U.S. citizens.
It is not uncommon for a cartel to use individuals with U.S. citizenship as couriers. These individuals have unfettered access to the United States and, while highly visible due to their frequent border crossings, they may receive less scrutiny from border security. Therefore, U.S. citizens are useful in moving guns and money south into Mexico (but they are less useful coming north, as security checks are more robust when coming from Mexico to the United States). This is particularly true in an area such as Coahuila state, where authorities have recently uncovered several large weapons caches.
The corridor of Piedras Negras and its sister city in the United States, Eagle Pass, thus is valuable not as a route to smuggle drugs north but as a route to move guns and money south. (A lack of drug-smuggling routes makes the area desirable territory, so the Zetas are the only ones operating there.) As recently as Sept. 7, in a separate incident from the seven arrests, Texas law enforcement stopped a van with Texas license plates that was carrying 14 assault rifles, a sniper rifle and more than 500 assault rifle magazines.
But the incident in which seven U.S. citizens were arrested, if true, is interesting because those arrested reportedly only had enough weaponry to protect the money they were transporting. This means they were not moving guns but cash, most likely proceeds from drug sales in the United States, the beneficiaries of which are Los Zetas.



Sept. 5


  • The Mexican military dismantled a drug lab in Culiacan, Sinaloa state, containing 1 kilogram (2.2 pounds) of methamphetamines and chemical precursors.
  • Mexican authorities attempted to stop a stolen vehicle traveling on a road in Cadereyta municipality, Nuevo Leon state. The vehicle, along with two accompanying vehicles, refused to stop, leading authorities on a chase that turned into a gunfight in which four gunmen were killed.

Sept. 6


  • Gunmen in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, shot and killed two women traveling in a vehicle with Texas license plates. The four-year-old daughter of one of the women survived the attack.
  • Federal police arrested four members of Los Aztecas in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, including a leader of the group.
  • A criminal group sent a message to the Department of Education in Acapulco, Guerrero state, demanding a percentage of the salaries of teachers who matched certain criteria. The message also demanded identification information on teachers in the city.
  • Gunmen attacked a deputy traveling in his vehicle in Lagos de Moreno, Jalisco state. During the attack, the deputy left his vehicle and was subsequently hit by a semitrailer.
  • Mexican authorities arrested a U.S. citizen in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state. The individual was charged with trafficking weapons from the United States for the Sinaloa cartel.

Sept. 7


  • Three members of Los Zetas were arrested in a neighborhood of Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state, while attempting to kidnap an individual. One of the members arrested was in charge of the “halcones” (Zetas lookouts) in Nuevo Leon.
  • The Mexican Attorney General’s Office identified 18 Los Zetas operators who were involved in the attack on the Casino Royale in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, that killed 52 people. The Mexican government is offering a reward of 15 million pesos ($1.2 million) for information leading to the arrest of each individual.
  • Mexican soldiers seized approximately 2.5 tons of marijuana after receiving a tip on the existence of a drug camp in Cerro del Borbollon, Durango state. Soldiers also found a vehicle with Baja California license plates.

Sept. 8


  • Federal police killed seven gunmen during a firefight in Villanueva, Zacatecas state. A conflict with the gunmen had erupted earlier when two federal police officers were kidnapped in the area.
  • Authorities announced that an operation conducted throughout Veracruz state resulted in the dismantling of a Los Zetas telecommunications network. More than 80 members of the cartel were arrested, and a variety of communications equipment was seized, including solar power cells, high-powered transmitters, encryption devices and secure radio communication systems.

Sept. 9


  • A drug courier transporting 1 kilogram of cocaine was arrested at Mexico City International Airport after authorities discovered the drugs. The individual’s itinerary indicated he was flying to Rome via Madrid.
  • The Knights Templar posted a narcomanta over a bridge in Zamora, Michoacan state, offering a 500,000-peso reward for information leading to the location of the Los Zetas members listed on the banner.
  • The Mexican military seized approximately 9 tons of marijuana, 51 firearms and 8,000 rounds of ammunition hidden in a cave near Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.

Sept. 10


  • Unidentified men threw five hand grenades in two separate locations in Rio Bravo, Tamaulipas state. The first incident involved gunmen traveling in a vehicle who threw three grenades at bar, and the second attack involved an individual who tossed two grenades at a strip club. The attacks killed two people.

Sept. 11


  • The Mexican military captured Veronica Mireya “La Vero” Moreno Carreon, Los Zetas’ plaza boss for San Nicolas de los Garza, Nuevo Leon state. Also know as “La Flaca,” she was discovered to be the plaza boss after she was arrested while traveling in a stolen vehicle.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

September 7, 2011 | 1205 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: April 5, 2011

‘El Metro 3’ Killed


Mexican authorities found the body of senior Gulf cartel member Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borrego on Sept. 3 in a pickup truck along a highway between Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, and Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. According to media reports, the Reynosa plaza boss and No. 2 leader was shot and killed, and his body was discovered with that of Eloy Lerma Garcia, a high-ranking police official from Diaz Ordaz, Tamaulipas state, who was also reportedly shot and killed.
The Gulf cartel has been engaged in a bloody turf war with Los Zetas, its former enforcement arm, since violence broke out between the two groups in February 2010. As such, each group routinely inflicts casualties on the other. At this point, however, Flores’ death appears to be the result of developments within his own organization rather than the result of a targeted assassination by Los Zetas.
Los Zetas certainly had cause to kill Flores. In fact, he was widely regarded as the primary reason behind the two groups’ extremely violent split; some Mexican authorities and elements within Zetas leadership believe Flores gave the order to kill senior Zetas member Sergio “Concord 3” Pena Mendoza in January 2010. Los Zetas demanded that Flores be killed, but Gulf cartel head Osiel Cardenas Guillen refused, and open warfare between the two groups erupted shortly thereafter.
It is possible that the Gulf cartel sacrificed one if its own as a means to placate the Zetas and end or ease the ongoing feud between the two groups. But available evidence suggests otherwise. Since Flores’ death, the dismembered bodies of two unidentified men were found on Morelos street in Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas state; a message at the scene signed by the Zetas claimed the victims were members of the Gulf cartel. If Flores’ death was intended to be an appeasement, the Zetas either did not receive or did not accept the gesture. In all likelihood, too much time has passed and too many people have been murdered for the rift to be mended with a belated, symbolic killing.
According to media reports, the conditions in which Flores was found suggest he was executed, but, aside from the gunshot wounds, his body was more or less intact. This would be atypical of the Zetas, who, as a means of intimidation, mutilate or torture their victims. It is likely that they would have done so with a high-ranking cartel member such as Flores — particularly given the accepted perception of his involvement in Pena’s death. So far, they have not even claimed responsibility for his death.
In addition, it is rumored that Flores’ body was found with its pants down around the ankles — in Mexico, the bodies of those believed to be informants are often found with their pants down. If this rumor is true, it raises the possibility that Flores was providing information to Mexican authorities. That Lerma was found with Flores gives some degree of credibility to this theory. Prior to joining the Gulf cartel, Flores worked as a law enforcement official with Lerma in Tamaulipas state, and if Flores was providing information to the authorities, his relationship with Lerma is the logical connection — though this may or may not be the case. Notably, Flores’ brother allegedly is in custody and is rumored to be in talks with government officials. Flores’ death, and the manner in which he was left, could be a retaliatory move for his brother’s perceived cooperation.
Other rumors suggest Flores was killed over internal disagreements within his organization, but so far STRATFOR has yet to verify those rumors. While Zetas involvement in Flores’ death cannot be completely ruled out, given their propensity for violence, and while an internal disagreement could have prompted his death, a more likely explanation is that elements within the Gulf cartel executed Flores in the belief he was cooperating with the government.

Flores’ Replacement


On Sept. 2, only hours after Mexican authorities confirmed the death of Flores, the Gulf cartel installed Mario Armando “Pelon” Ramirez Trevino as the new Reynosa plaza boss. Ramirez previously served under Flores as his second in command, and the U.S. State Department has an outstanding reward of $5 million for Ramirez’s capture.
The speed with which Flores was replaced following his death is unsurprising, given that there was already a second in command in place to succeed him. This also underscores the belief that Flores’ death was an inside job and that a succession plan was in place. What is unclear is whether Ramirez will serve purely on an operational level as the Reynosa plaza boss, or if he, like Flores, will simultaneously serve as the cartel’s overall No. 2.
Gulf cartel enforcer units have been hard hit in the past year. Antonio Ezequiel “Tony Tormenta” Cardenas Guillen was killed in November 2010, and now with Flores’ death the Gulf cartel has sustained another major blow. Ramirez is rumored to a tough leader, a trait he will need to fully utilize as he fends off Los Zetas in Reynosa.


Aug. 29


  • Five members of Los Zetas were arrested in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, in connection with the Casino Royale fire in the city.
  • Mexican authorities arrested Abiel “R-2” Gonzalez Briones, a leader of the Gulf cartel, was arrested in Camargo, Chihuahua state, along with other Gulf cartel members after their vehicles were spotted by aerial reconnaissance.

Aug. 30


  • A seafood restaurant in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state, was set on fire by a group of gunmen early in the morning. Approximately two hours later, another group of gunmen set fire to a moving truck in the city.
  • Mexican authorities announced a reward of 500,000 Mexican pesos (about $40,000) for information leading to the arrest of a 14-year-old assassin in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state. The teenager is allegedly responsible for the Aug. 26 murder of a Municipal police officer.
  • Three decapitated bodies were discovered in a parked minivan in Emiliano Zapata, Morelos state. Two narcomantas were left with the bodies signed by “Comando Del Diablo,” a gang affiliated with ongoing violence in Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • A grave was discovered in Norogachi, Chihuahua state, containing seven bodies. Six of the victims appeared to have been asphyxiated.

Aug. 31


  • Two decapitated bodies were found in Tizapan el Alto, Jalisco state. The bodies were left with a message stating a bomb had been placed in the nearby area, but reports said no bomb was found.
  • An explosive device on a street in Veracruz City, Veracruz state, left two individuals dead.
  • The bodies of two kidnapped female journalists were found in Iztapalapa, Distrito Federal.

Sept. 1


  • A group of armed men shot and killed Mario Martin Favela Portillo, a police captain in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. Narcomantas issued prior to Portillo’s killing had directed death threats against him.

Sept. 2


  • Samuel “El Metro 3” Flores Borrego, the second in command of the Gulf cartel, was found dead Sept. 2 outside Reynosa, Tamaulipas state. A police official was also found dead at the scene.

Sept. 3


  • Multiple banners displayed throughout Acapulco, Guerrero state, signed by “United Families of Acapulco,” asked Mexican President Felipe Calderon for support in ending the violence in the city. The banners single out La Barredora and Comando Del Diablo as the gangs responsible for the violence. They also detail where the two gangs operate and its members.

Sept. 4


  • Six individuals, including three police officers, were killed in two shootings outside the Territorio Santos Modelo sports complex in Torreon, Coahuila state, and a highway near the city. Both shootings began when gunmen engaged in a firefight with police patrols.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 2011
August 30, 2011 | 1813 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Extortion in Acapulco School District

Extortion in Acapulco School District


Reports surfaced Aug. 23 that an unnamed cartel sent an extortion letter to a financial administrator of the Acapulco public education system. In the letter, the sender demands the names, locations and telephone numbers for teachers earning between 20,000 pesos and 50,000 pesos per month (about $1,000-$4,000) as well as voter registration cards and a copy of the district’s payroll. Effective Oct. 1, those within the designated salary range will forfeit to the cartel 50 percent of their monthly salary and annual bonus, the letter said. The letter threatened those who might refuse to pay the “derecho de piso,” or tax, prompting more than 600 teachers in more than 140 elementary and middle schools to close their classrooms.
Extortion is a common occurrence in Mexico — even extortion of this type is not unprecedented, occurring most recently in San Luis Potosi. But while no one has claimed responsibility, the threats contained in the Acapulco extortion letter are considered more credible than those of San Luis Potosi, as Acapulco is a particularly violent city, and the threats in San Luis Potosi went largely unenforced. The timing of this instance of extortion suggests that cartels operating in the area are in need of cash and will resort to alternative means to replenish lost funds.
Acapulco is home to a number of cartels, but it is believed that the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA) and La Barredora, a CIDA offshoot, are responsible for much of the extortion in the city. Media reports suggest that the teacher extortion is the work of Comando del Diablo and Los Calentanos, both of which work for La Barredora.
The incident is likely the result of the proliferation of independent, low-level cartel members feeling the financial effects of inter-cartel warfare and government interdiction. Indeed, all cartels are seeing a disruption in their cash flows due to cartel wars, but the smaller organizations lack the financial wealth of the larger rivals. Bloody turf wars and battles with the government have left some groups, who cannot or do not pay their low-ranking members as well as they did during times of relative prosperity, looking for alternative sources of revenue to finance their drug-trafficking operations; extortion is one such source.
The Mexican government’s increased operations against the country’s cartels have given rise to increased instances of extortion. In Acapulco, the extortion is clearly affecting the lives of the city’s children, seen by many as a significant affront. In the wake of the deadly Aug. 25 fire in Juarez, public opinion has been rising against the cartels, and if these criminal groups continue to threaten the safety of children in Mexico, that public opinion could reach a critical mass.

Knights Templar Diversifying Tactics?


The Knights Templar, an offshoot of La Familia Michoacana (LFM), distributed “narcomantas” — banners inscribed with messages from drug cartels — throughout Michoacan state from Aug. 26 to Aug. 28. The messages offered a 500,000-peso reward for information leading to the location of Martin “El Terry” Rosales, a presumed plaza boss for Los Zetas, as well as a number of other alleged Zetas members.
Cartels tend to use whatever means available to achieve their goals — some overemphasize the use of violence, while others employ a combination of methods, such as bribery and extortion, to retain power. Violence is rarely, if ever, abandoned, but cartels may use it in concert with these other tools as the situation demands.
It is through this context that the situation in Michoacan must be viewed. The distribution of narcomantas offering monetary reward is atypical of the Knights Templar. The group, since their inception, has been notoriously violent, usually opting to achieve its goals through murder or intimidation. But the banners show a different tactic: In this instance, the group is trying to co-opt the citizenry of Michoacan through financial incentives.
It is unclear whether this is an isolated incident or a philosophical shift in the group’s tactics. One instance does not constitute a trend, but the possibility that the Knights Templar are using this tactic as a means of gaining ground on the Zetas cannot be ruled out. LFM, the group from which the Knights Templar split, began as a vigilante, albeit violent, group whose intent was to protect the people of Michoacan from cartel gunmen. As such, they enjoyed strong support from many elements within Michoacan society.
The Knights Templar’s distributing of narcomantas could indicate that the group has exhausted other means of combating the Zetas or that it is refocusing efforts on widening their support base in the population to gain better cooperation from the people — something that seemed to benefit LFM. STRATFOR will continue to look for indications that the group will continue to diversify its tactics to gain public support or resume its violent behavior.



Aug. 22


  • Guerrero state Attorney General Alberto Lopez Rosas asked that the criminal groups in Acapulco call a truce.
  • A confrontation between armed men and the Mexican army left two gunmen and one soldier dead in Jalpa, Zacatecas state.

Aug. 23


  • A narcomanta, signed by La Linea and directed against the Drug Enforcement Administration, said that an individual named “El Gato” was the new leader of La Linea.

Aug. 24


  • El Comando del Diablo, a criminal group operating under La Barredora, sent a message to Mexican media accepting a truce proposed by the state’s attorney general on the condition that the state governor publicly confirms or denies his alleged family links to the Independent Cartel of Acapulco.
  • A group of armed men opened fire on parents outside an elementary school in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. One individual was killed and five were wounded.
  • The Knights Templar distributed narcomantas in the cities of Patzcuaro, Santa Clara del Cobre, Quiroga and Zirahuen, Michoacan state, offering a reward for information on two members of Los Zetas.
  • Mexican authorities seized approximately 18 tons of chemical precursors used for manufacturing illicit drugs in the port of Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan state. The chemical precursors were found in 80 barrels, and the shipment originated in India and were en route to Guatemala.

Aug. 25


  • The Casino Royale in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, was set on fire by a unidentified group of attackers. As many as 61 individuals inside the building were killed.
  • The body of missing journalist Humberto Millan Salazar was found with gunshot wounds in Culiacan, Sinaloa state.
  • A narcomanta signed by La Linea on Aug. 25 denied reports that it had made threats against the Drug Enforcement Administration in previous narcomantas found in Ciudad Juarez.
  • Three gunmen were killed in a confrontation with the Mexican army in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state. Mexican authorities reported after the confrontation that Los Zetas leader “El Loko” was among those killed.
  • Mexican authorities seized more than 2.1 million psychotropic pills at an airport in Tijuana, Baja California state. The pills were found on an Aeromexico flight that originated in India.

Aug. 26


  • Mexican authorities discovered the remains of five bodies in Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas state. A message signed by Los Zetas was left at the scene, identifying the victims as Gulf cartel members.

Aug. 27


  • The Knights Templar continued distributing more narcomantas throughout Michoacan state requesting information on Los Zetas figures Martin “El Terry” Rosales and Silvestre Cano “El Chomino” Guzman.

Aug. 29


  • Nuevo Leon state Gov. Rodrigo Medina announced the arrest of five Los Zetas members allegedly involved in the attack on the Casino Royale in Monterrey.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 27, 2011
Soldiers and federal agents raided five Monterrey casinos starting Aug. 26, AP said, citing an official of Mexico’s Attorney General’s Office. Federal police guard the casinos during the raids. Police spokesman Juan Carlos Buenrostro said Aug. 27 that more agents would be deployed to Monterrey.
August 26, 2011 | 2045 GMT
In Monterrey, A Casino Attack to Disrupt Cartel Finances
Firefighters outside Casino Royale in Monterrey, Mexico, on Aug. 25
Summary
Unidentified attackers set fire to the Casino Royale in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, on Aug. 25. The incident was likely the result of cartel rivalries in the city, rather than an intentional act of terrorism, and it serves as an example of how cartels will attempt to disrupt their rivals’ sources of revenue. Moreover, the high death toll suggests that the removal of cartel leadership with military training is adversely affecting the cartels’ operational ability.
Analysis
An unknown number of attackers set fire Aug. 25 to the Casino Royale in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, leaving 53 people dead, according to Nuevo Leon Gov. Rodrigo Medina. Reports indicated that 12 people were injured, and Attorney General Leon Adrian de la Garza said more victims could be forthcoming. The Mexican government announced a deployment of 500 soldiers to catch the perpetrators. Stratfor A video account shows a number of individuals exiting vehicles at approximately 3:30 p.m. before entering the casino, and smoke was seen emanating from the building minutes later. The attackers allegedly ordered everyone out of the building before dousing it in gasoline and setting it on fire, and conflicting reports suggest they used Molotov cocktails, guns and/or hand grenades in the attack.
Mexican cartels value casinos as a means to launder money and generate revenue through legal gambling practices. Because of this value, casinos are obvious targets for cartels attempting to disrupt the financial operations of their rivals. STRATFOR believes this is the most likely motive behind the attack, rather than retaliation meant to inflict mass casualties. Moreover, the sloppiness with which it was conducted indicates a decreased operational ability in drug cartels whose highly trained leaders have been killed or arrested.
Reports that the attackers ordered the building to be evacuated are significant. Such an order suggests the casino itself was the target. If the attackers intended to cause mass casualties, they would not have given the warning and would have used another method to maximize casualties, such as a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device or even small arms fire. Most of the victims had reportedly run upstairs or locked themselves in bathrooms instead of fleeing. The emergency exits were also reportedly locked, meaning those trying to flee through alternative exits were trapped, resulting in the high casualty count.
Attacks on infrastructure are common tactics for the Gulf and Zetas cartels, which are actively fighting for territorial control of important hubs for drug- and-human smuggling operations — Monterrey is one such hub. Interestingly, simultaneous grenade attacks took place on casinos in Saltillo, Coahuila state, and Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, on Aug. 24. The attacks are believed to be the work of Los Zetas. According to information obtained by STRATFOR, businessman and former Tijuana Mayor Jorge Hank Rhon and the Caliente Group operate all three of the casinos that have been attacked. Therefore, the possibility that one cartel is conducting a coordinated campaign to disrupt revenue flows for its competitor cannot be ruled out. By instilling fear and lowering the number of patrons that visit these establishments, they could adversely affect the controlling cartel, especially at a time when any disruption to capital is a major problem for them.
The attack on the Casino Royale illustrates just how chaotic the situation in Mexico has become. This sort of attack suggests cartel leaders are losing control of their subordinates and supports our assessment that the loss of leaders with military training and experience, especially in the case of Los Zetas, is creating a more unstable and violent environment. If the attackers intended to minimize casualties, this attack shows poor planning by cartel management or poor operational tactics by the gunmen who carried out the attacks. Sophisticated operators would have known that the emergency exits were locked and that people would panic and run away from the attackers, who would have been the most obvious threat. If the attackers were unconcerned about casualties, or if they intended to kill as many innocent people as possible, then this attack could be another step in the devolution of the violence in Mexico.
The cartel responsible for the attack can expect blowback from Mexican security forces, the general public and from a rival cartel. If the attackers did not follow the plan laid out by their superiors, they could be killed for the high death toll. If this is the case, the cartel will want to publicize the fact that they have taken care of the perpetrators and let it be known that innocent civilians are not targeted for attack.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 25, 2011
Armed men set fire to a casino in northern Mexico, killing at least 20 people, Reuters reported Aug. 25. A survivor told Milenio TV that a group of masked armed men entered the Casino Royale building in Monterrey, threatened gamblers and set fire to the place. Monterrey Mayor Fernando Larrazabal told a news conference that more than 20 people died in the blaze and that rescue efforts are ongoing. Initial reports said the armed men had thrown grenades into the building, but local media later retracted those reports.
August 25, 2011
Mexican police arrest Nery Salgado Harrison, who they say was in charge of synthetic drug production for a gang in the state of Michoacan.
August 17, 2011

The Buffer Between Mexican Cartels and the U.S. Government


By Scott Stewart
It is summer in Juarez, and again this year we find the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (VCF), also known as the Juarez cartel, under pressure and making threats. At this time in 2010, La Linea, the VCF’s enforcer arm, detonated a small improvised explosive device (IED) inside a car in Juarez and killed two federal agents, one municipal police officer and an emergency medical technician and wounded nine other people. La Linea threatened to employ a far larger IED (100 kilograms) if the FBI and the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) did not investigate the head of Chihuahua State Police intelligence, whom the VCF claimed was working for the Sinaloa Federation.
La Linea did attempt to employ another IED on Sept. 10, 2010, but this device, which failed to detonate, contained only 16 kilograms of explosives, far less than the 100 kilograms that the group had threatened to use.
Fast-forward a year, and we see the VCF still under unrelenting pressure from the Sinaloa Federation and still making threats. On July 15, the U.S. Consulate in Juarez released a message warning that, according to intelligence it had in hand, a cartel may be targeting the consulate or points of entry into the United States. On July 27, “narcomantas” — banners inscribed with messages from drug cartels — appeared in Juarez and Chihuahua signed by La Linea and including explicit threats against the DEA and employees of the U.S. Consulate in Juarez. Two days after the narcomantas appeared, Jose Antonio “El Diego” Acosta Hernandez, a senior La Linea leader whose name was mentioned in the messages, was arrested by Mexican authorities aided by intelligence from the U.S. government. Acosta is also believed to have been responsible for planning La Linea’s past IED attacks.
As we have discussed in our coverage of the drug war in Mexico, Mexican cartels, including the VCF, clearly possess the capability to construct and employ large vehicle-borne improvised explosive devices (VBIEDs) — truck bombs — and yet they have chosen not to. These groups are not averse to bloodshed, or even outright barbarity, when they believe it is useful. Their decision to abstain from certain activities, such as employing truck bombs or targeting a U.S. Consulate, indicates that there must be compelling strategic reasons for doing so. After all, groups in Lebanon, Pakistan and Iraq have demonstrated that truck bombs are a very effective means of killing perceived enemies and of sending strong messages.
Perhaps the most compelling reason for the Mexican cartels to abstain from such activities is that they do not consider them to be in their best interest. One important part of their calculation is that such activities would remove the main buffer that is currently insulating them from the full force of the U.S. government: the Mexican government.

The Buffer


Despite their public manifestations of machismo, the cartel leaders clearly fear and respect the strength of the world’s only superpower. This is evidenced by the distinct change in cartel activities along the U.S.-Mexico border, where a certain operational downshift routinely occurs. In Mexico, the cartels have the freedom to operate far more brazenly than they can in the United States, in terms of both drug trafficking and acts of violence. Shipments of narcotics traveling through Mexico tend to be far larger than shipments moving into and through the United States. When these large shipments reach the border they are taken to stash houses on the Mexican side, where they are typically divided into smaller quantities for transport into and through the United States.
As for violence, while the cartels do kill people on the U.S. side of the border, their use of violence there tends to be far more discreet; it has certainly not yet incorporated the dramatic flair that is frequently seen on the Mexican side, where bodies are often dismembered or hung from pedestrian bridges over major thoroughfares. The cartels are also careful not to assassinate high-profile public figures such as police chiefs, mayors and reporters in the United States, as they frequently do in Mexico.
The border does more than just alter the activities of the cartels, however. It also constrains the activities of U.S. law enforcement and intelligence agencies. These agencies cannot pursue cartels on the Mexican side of the border with the same vigor that they exercise on the U.S. side. Occasionally, the U.S. government will succeed in luring a wanted Mexican cartel leader outside of Mexico, as it did in the August 2006 arrest of Javier Arellano Felix, or catch one operating in the United States like Javier’s oldest brother, Francisco Arellano Felix. By and large, however, most wanted cartel figures remain in Mexico, out of the reach of U.S. law.
One facet of this buffer is corruption, which is endemic in Mexico, reaching all the way from the lowest municipal police officer to the presidential palace. Over the years several senior Mexican anti-drug officials, including the nation’s drug czar, have been arrested and charged with corruption.
However, the money generated by the Mexican cartels has far greater effects than just promoting corruption. The billions of dollars that come into the Mexican economy via the drug trade are important to the Mexican banking sector and to the industries in which the funds are laundered, such as construction. Because of this, there are many powerful Mexican businessmen who profit either directly or indirectly from the narcotics trade, and it would not be in their best interest for the billions of drug dollars to stop flowing into Mexico. Such people can place heavy pressure on the political system by either supporting or withholding support from particular candidates or parties.
Because of this, sources in Mexico have been telling STRATFOR that they believe that Mexican politicians like President Filipe Calderon are far more interested in stopping drug violence than they are in stopping the flow of narcotics. This is a pragmatic approach. Clearly, as long as there is demand for drugs in the United States there will be people who will find ways to meet that demand. It is impossible to totally stop the flow of narcotics into the U.S. market.
In addition to corruption and the economic benefits Mexico realizes from the drug trade, there is another important element that causes the Mexican government to act as a buffer between the Mexican cartels and the U.S. government — geopolitics. The Mexico-U.S. relationship is a long one that has involved considerable competition and conflict. The United States has long meddled in the affairs of Mexico and other countries in Latin America. And from the Mexican perspective, American imperialist aggression, via the Texas War of Independence and the Mexican-American War, resulted in Mexico losing nearly half of its territory to its powerful northern neighbor. Less than a century ago, U.S. troops invaded northern Mexico in response to Pancho Villa’s incursions into the United States.
Because of this history, Mexico — as with most of the rest of Latin America — regards the United States as a threat to its sovereignty. The result of this perception is that the Mexican government and the Mexican people in general are very reluctant to allow the United States to become too involved in Mexican affairs. The idea of American troops or law enforcement agents with boots on the ground in Mexico is considered especially threatening from the Mexican perspective.

A Thin Barrier


While Mexican sovereignty and international law combine with corruption and economics to create a barrier to assertive U.S. intervention in Mexico’s drug war, this barrier is not inviolable. There are two distinct ways this type of barrier has been breached in the past: by force and by consent.
An example of the first was seen following the 1985 kidnapping, torture and murder of U.S. DEA special agent Enrique Camarena. The DEA was not able to get what it viewed as satisfactory assistance from the Mexican government in pursuing the case despite the tremendous pressure applied by the U.S. government. This prompted the DEA to unilaterally enter Mexico and snatch two Mexican citizens connected to the case. Because of his involvement in the Camarena case, Honduran drug kingpin Juan Matta-Ballesteros was also rendered from his home in Honduras by U.S. government agents.
As a result of the U.S. reaction to the Camarena murder, the Guadalajara Cartel, Mexico’s most powerful criminal organization at the time, was decapitated, its leaders — Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo, Ernesto Fonseca Carrillo and Rafael Caro Quintero — all arrested and convicted for their part in ordering the killing. The tremendous pressure applied to Mexican authorities by the U.S. government to arrest the trio, coupled with the fear that they too might be rendered, ultimately led to their detention, although they did maintain sufficient influence to ensure that they were not extradited to the United States.
The Guadalajara Cartel also lost its primary connection to the Medellin cartel (Matta-Ballesteros) as a result of the Camarena case, and the cartel was eventually fractured into smaller units that would become today’s Sinaloa, Juarez, Gulf and Tijuana cartels. The Camarena case taught the Mexican cartel bosses to be careful not to provoke the Americans to the point where it will bring the full power of the U.S. government to bear upon their organizations (a lesson recently demonstrated by the unilateral U.S. operation to kill Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad, Pakistan).
But in addition to unilateral force, sometimes the U.S. government can be invited into a country despite concerns about sovereignty. This happens when the population has something it fears more than U.S. involvement, and this is what happened in Colombia in the late 1980s. In an effort to influence the Colombian government not to cooperate with the U.S. government and extradite him to the United States, Colombian drug lord Pablo Escobar, leader of the Medellin Cartel, resorted to terrorism. In 1989 he launched a string of terrorist attacks that included the assassination of one presidential candidate, the bombing a civilian airliner in an attempt to kill a second presidential candidate and several large VBIED attacks, including the detonation of a 1,000-pound truck bomb in December 1989 targeting the Colombian Administrative Department of Security (DAS, Colombia’s primary national intelligence and security service) that caused massive damage in the area around the DAS building in downtown Bogota. These attacks had a powerful impact on the Colombian government and Colombian people and caused them to reach out to the United States for increased assistance despite their concern about U.S. power. The increased U.S. assistance eventually led to the death of Escobar and the systematic dismantling of his organization.
The lesson in the Escobar case was: Do not push your own government or population too far or they will turn on you and invite the Americans in.

Full Circle


So, in looking at the situation in Mexico today, there are indeed cartel organizations that have been hit hard. Over the past few years, we have seen groups such as the Beltran Leyva Organization, the Arellano Felix Organization, the VCF and Los Zetas heavily damaged. Many of these groups, particularly the VCF, the Arellano Felix Organization and Los Zetas, have been forced to resort to other criminal activity such as kidnapping, extortion and human trafficking to fund their operations. However, they have not yet undertaken large-scale terrorist attacks. The VCF tiptoed along that line last year, with La Linea’s small-scale IED attacks, as did the Gulf cartel, but these groups were careful not to use IEDs that were too large, and La Linea never employed the huge IED it threatened to. In fact, the overall use of IEDs is down dramatically in 2011 compared to the same period last year — despite the fact that explosives are readily available in Mexico and the cartels have the demonstrated capability to manufacture and employ them.
It is also important to recognize that in the past couple of years, when the United States has become heavily interested in attacks linked to the Mexican cartels, the cartel figures believed to be responsible for these actions have been arrested or killed. This has happened in cases such as the March 2010 murders of three people with ties to the U.S. Consulate in Juarez, the September 2010 murder of David Hartley on Falcon Lake, the February 2011 murder of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Special Agent Jaime Zapata, and even the previously mentioned July 27 threats against U.S. interests in Juarez. This means that the chances of a cartel such as the VCF getting the United States directly involved without the cartel being directly impacted are probably quite slim. In other words, if the VCF attacks the U.S. Consulate in Juarez, it can expect to be targeted directly by the U.S. and Mexican governments, instead of the governments focusing on other cartel players in the city, such as the VCF’s rival, the Sinaloa Federation.
As noted in our last cartel update, we anticipate that in the coming months the Mexican government campaign against Los Zetas will continue to impact that group, as will the attacks against Los Zetas by the Gulf cartel and its criminal allies. We also anticipate that the aforementioned Sinaloa pressure against the VCF in Juarez will not diminish. Nor will Mexican government pressure: We have seen reports that Luis Antonio Flores (also known as El Comen 2 or El Tarzan), El Diego’s replacement as the leader of La Linea, was arrested Aug. 16. However, we have seen nothing that would indicate that this pressure will cause these groups to lash out in the form of large-scale terrorist attacks like those associated with Pablo Escobar. Even when wounded, these Mexican organizations have shown that they seek to maintain the buffer protecting them from the full power of the U.S. government.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
August 17, 2011 | 1158 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Striking Los Zetas in the Northeast

Alleged Cartel Leader Arrested


On Aug. 11, Mexican federal authorities arrested a man they claim is the leader of La Mano con Ojos, a drug cartel operating in Mexico City and Mexico state. Much is still unknown about Oscar Osvaldo “El Compayito” Garcia Montoya and his organization. In fact, authorities are unsure how many members the group comprises, but it is widely believed that it controls retail drugs sales in parts of Mexico City and Mexico state. Garcia was arrested in Tlalpan, a neighborhood in southern Mexico City.
It is not yet clear that Garcia is the cartel’s leader, but his apprehension and subsequent video-recorded interrogation suggest that he is no mere foot soldier. His success in evading arrest — and in remaining relatively unknown — makes his apprehension more significant, especially if factors other than good police work were at play. Whatever led to his arrest, authorities will now have the opportunity to investigate an alleged criminal about whom they previously knew little.
Garcia reportedly is a former Mexican marine. During his stint in the armed forces, he allegedly received counterinsurgency training from the Guatemalan military. He worked as an enforcer for Edgar ” La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal, who was the head of the Beltran Leyva Organization enforcer unit Los Negros. Garcia joined Valdez after the latter split with Hector Beltran Leyva following the death of Arturo Beltran Leyva in December 2009. When La Barbie was captured in August 2010, Garcia formed his own organization based on his nickname (El Compayito refers to a Mexican puppet character that is a hand with eyes, and Garcia’s group’s name, La Mano con Ojos, means “the hand with eyes”).
What distinguishes La Mano con Ojos from other groups operating in the capital region is its ruthlessness. It is not uncommon for newly formed drug cartels that began as enforcement arms to be especially cutthroat because they lack the business savvy and decision-making experience of their former parent group. (Look no further than Los Zetas as evidence.) According to media reports, Garcia has been involved in as many as 900 homicides. In April 2010, the dismembered bodies of alleged Los Zetas members were found near a chapel, an incident that many thought was the handiwork of Garcia’s group. Though La Mano con Ojos’ involvement in the incident was never proven, such stories add to the lore of the group’s perceived barbarity.
Now that Garcia has been Mexico Security Memo captured and interrogated, Mexican authorities will be better able to investigate the group under his purported command. And as intelligence comes to light — if it comes to light — the government will be able to know whom they are dealing with and engage the group accordingly. Indeed, four additional members of the gang were arrested Aug. 15.
Garcia’s alleged counterinsurgency training gives added significance to his arrest. Such training would render Garcia a formidable adversary because he would be equipped with knowledge common street thugs do not possess. Garcia has been able to evade arrest for at least the better part of a decade. It is certainly possible that good police work led to his arrest, but it is equally possible that a rival cartel, threatened by the growing notoriety of a relatively new and violent faction, provided information about his whereabouts. Regardless of how he was arrested, any intelligence authorities are able to obtain from the alleged leader may help bring clarity about the group and its operations.

Massive Cocaine Seizure in Yucatan State


On Aug. 12, the Mexican navy seized 500-560 kilograms (about 1,100-1,200 pounds) of cocaine from a Liberian-flagged commercial vessel at a port in Progreso, Yucatan state. Sailing from Lima, Peru, the ship took a somewhat circuitous route on its way to its destination city of Cancun. (Progreso is further east along the coast of the peninsula, meaning the ship had to double back to Cancun.)
The Yucatan Peninsula is under almost undisputed Zetas control, and it is a significant entry point for cocaine into Mexico. The seizure marks a huge blow to the Zetas, especially at a time when they face threats on many fronts and by many actors, including the government and rival cartels.
That the Zetas were comfortable bringing in a shipment of that size — more than half a ton — in one haul indicates that they were likely very confident in their security on the peninsula. Until the navy interdicted, the Zetas’ confidence was justified: Operations against the cartel usually occur on the east coast of the country in territory disputed by Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel. The military is assigned where the violence is, and since violence along the east coast is more common than it is on the Yucatan Peninsula, interdictions on the peninsula are rare. However, the seizure could change this trend.
The seizure is a significant loss for the Zetas. Fighting rival cartels is adding to the already steep price the group pays in its war against the government. They need large shipments such as the one confiscated in Progreso to help finance that war. It is significant that this blow was dealt on the supply side of their operations — rather than on the military side — because it cuts into the funds that the Zetas need for gunmen and supplies.

Tourists as Collateral Damage


One man was killed and three people — a woman and two children — were wounded Aug. 14 when unidentified gunmen threw a grenade out of their escape vehicle while fleeing from police in Veracruz, AP reported, citing a statement from the office of the Veracruz governor. The report did not say whether the victims were local citizens or tourists, but the area in which the grenade was thrown — near the city’s aquarium — suggests they may have been tourists. Neither did it indicate who the gunmen were, but given the area and the type of weaponry used, it is safe to assume that the gunmen were members of Los Zetas.
The incident serves as a reminder for those who choose to spend time in Mexico that although tourists are not often specifically targeted by drug cartels, they can fall victim to collateral violence caused by those cartels. Violence between rival cartels and government forces is indiscriminate and can occur in almost any part of the country. While the cartels have not consciously targeted tourists or other innocent bystanders, they have also not gone out of their way to avoid hurting them. Cartel gunmen will shoot or throw grenades whenever they deem necessary without thought for the welfare of others, and this fire can and does hit bystanders.



Aug. 9


  • An improvised incendiary device was thrown at a plaza in Tuxpan, Veracruz state, injuring one woman.
  • Authorities arrested Dolly Cifuentes “La Meno” Villa, a money launderer for the Sinaloa Federation, in Medellin, Colombia. Cifuentes was responsible for 32 businesses in Colombia and 17 businesses outside Colombia.
  • Raul “El Sureno” Garcia Rodriguez, Los Zetas’ plaza boss for San Nicolas de los Garza, Nuevo Leon state, was detained by the Mexican army in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.

Aug. 10


  • Mexican federal police arrested Victor Chavez “El Ruso” Gomez, a leader for the Knights Templar drug cartel, in Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan state. Chavez had participated in a July 7 attack on the federal police in Apatzingan, Michoacan state.

Aug. 11


  • Oscar Osvaldo “El Compayito” Garcia Montoya, the alleged leader of La Mano con Ojos, was detained in Tlalpan, a neighborhood in Mexico City. Garcia reportedly is a former Mexican marine who also received training from the Guatemalan military.
  • Jose Ruvalcaba Plascencia, a former police chief in Ciudad Juarez, was shot and killed in Chihuahua, Chihuahua state.

Aug. 12


  • Mexican police discovered an incomplete tunnel used for smuggling drugs in Tijuana, Baja California state, and arrested 10 individuals they found excavating the tunnel.
  • The Mexican navy seized approximately half a ton of cocaine on board a Liberian-flagged commercial shipping vessel in Progreso, Yucatan state. The ship reportedly had come from Lima, Peru.

Aug. 14


  • Cristina Guadalupe “La Cris” Iniestra Medina, a financial operator for the Knights Templar, was detained in Zitacuaro, Michoacan state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 10, 2011
The Los Zetas leader of San Nicolas de los Garza plaza, Raul “El Sureno” Garcia Rodriguez, was arrested by the Mexican army in Monterrey, Excelsior reported Aug. 10. San Nicolas de los Garza, a suburb of Monterrey, is considered one of the richest areas in Mexico.
August 9, 2011 | 1153 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: La Linea Leader Captured

Operation Northern Lynx


On Aug. 5, the Mexican government concluded Operation Northern Lynx, a military action targeting the leadership, operations and logistics structures of cartels and criminal gangs in the northeastern states of San Luis Potosi, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon and Tamaulipas. The operation began July 16 and involved 4,000 Mexican military personnel, 722 vehicles and 23 aircraft across the four states. According to the Mexican military, the operation resulted in the release of 12 kidnapping victims, the arrest of 196 people with suspected cartel ties and the seizure of 1,217 weapons, 3.3 tons of marijuana, 260 vehicles and 188 communications devices. The three-week-long operation also resulted in a notable number of important Los Zetas leaders killed or captured.
Northern Lynx is consistent with the Mexican government’s recent focus on specifically targeting the most violent criminal groups and drug cartels — the Los Zetas in the northeast but also La Familia Michoacana and the Knights Templar elsewhere in the country. An increase in cooperation, especially on intelligence gathering, between the United States and Mexico may have enhanced the effectiveness of this operation. This cooperation garnered a great deal of attention after an Aug. 6 report by The New York Times, citing the Mexican ambassador to the United States and a number of unnamed U.S. officials, characterized the collaboration as a relatively new development, having only coalesced for a few weeks. In fact, the collaboration has a much longer history. It has included intelligence gathering by U.S. security personnel posted at an undisclosed Mexican military base (among other places), and the training of Mexican military and law enforcement personnel at facilities in the United States and in Mexico. Although Operation Northern Lynx did not force Los Zetas to surrender territory, the losses sustained by their leadership and their logistics infrastructure will not be easily replaced. If U.S. cooperation on intelligence gathering with the Mexican military continues, Los Zetas may be forced to pull back from certain areas.
At least 30 Zetas were killed during the course of the operation, the most prominent being Jorge Luis “El Pompin” de la Pena Brizuela, the purported leader of Los Zetas in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, just across the border from Laredo, Texas. De la Pena Brizuela was killed Aug. 2. On the same day, the army detained Valdemar “El Adal” Quintanilla Soriano, the suspected No. 2 financial operator for Los Zetas, and his assistant Jose Guadalupe “El Dos” Yanez Martinez, in Saltillo, Coahuila state. Yanez Martinez was in possession of more than 6 million pesos ($512,800) at the time of his capture. In the capital city of San Luis Potosi, two more leading Zetas were captured — Rafael “El Iguano” Salmeron Rodriguez, the reported leader of San Luis Potosi plaza, and Jose Angel “El Cheche” Zapata Pantoja, the reported head of administrative activities in the state.
The number of ordinary foot soldiers killed during this operation was not particularly high. However, the elimination of so many leaders, especially as Los Zetas are fighting on multiple fronts against other cartels and the military, will be difficult for the group to replace (particularly in light of their other losses over the past two years). Most of the original Zetas — founded by former Mexican special operations forces — have already been captured or killed. While Los Zetas still actively recruit soldiers from the Mexican and Guatemalan military, they have not been able to do so at the rate they are losing them. According to information drawn from the Mexico Security Memo interrogation of Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon after the senior Zeta member’s July 3 arrest, Los Zetas are also having a difficult time acquiring weapons, which, if true, could be extremely damaging to the group’s long-term survival.
Los Zetas are under pressure, but this has not prevented the group from attempting to expand its reach. They continue to push into areas not under their control such as in Pedro Escobedo, Queretaro state, where they are believed to have left a narcomanta stating “We have arrived” signed “Z” on July 31. However, this outreach may actually have been an attempt to take some of the pressure off of their home base by diverting the resources and attention of rival cartels and the government. If the group continues sustaining losses as they did during Operation Northern Lynx and if they continue to have problems recruiting and training new gunmen, they will likely be forced to start making decisions on which areas to drawdown their thinly-stretched forces.

U.S. Involvement in the Cartel War


The United States has long assisted the Mexican government by sharing the intelligence it acquires on the cartels, but more recently it has expanded this role to include intelligence gathering and helping plan countercartel operations with Mexican authorities. Although U.S. officials declined to provide specifics on their activities, the unit stationed on the Mexican base (it is unclear which one) reportedly consists of U.S. military personnel, CIA operatives and Drug Enforcement Administration agents. This unit has been compared to “intelligence fusion centers” that the United States operates in Afghanistan and Iraq which monitor militant groups and support the host country’s security forces. Past reports have identified similar bi-national fusion centers in Mexico City and Juarez. However, this physical presence is only one part of the assistance provided by the United States. It has also been providing tactical and intelligence training to Mexican security forces at facilities both in the United States and in Mexico for some time.
U.S. assistance will certainly enhance Mexico’s intelligence gathering capabilities against the cartels while also providing the United States with valuable on-the-ground intelligence from its Mexican partners. Nonetheless, trust remains an area of concern for both parties. Although the Mexican members of the particular units working closely with the Americans were likely thoroughly vetted to ensure they have not been corrupted (or as well vetted as can be done in Mexico), it is unlikely that the personnel of the entire base where the unit is stationed has been subjected to the same level of scrutiny. Out of concerns that U.S. intelligence sources, tactics or technology could make its way back to the cartels, the United States is probably exercising extreme caution in what it provides Mexican authorities. As for Mexico, U.S. assistance — however desperately needed — is always eyed warily due to historic sensitivities about U.S. military activity.
Involvement in intelligence gathering is still a far cry from deploying U.S. ground forces in Mexico, which is extremely unlikely in the foreseeable future. Only a major attack on U.S. soil by a cartel or significant spillover violence along the border would be likely to prompt such a move. Still, increased intelligence cooperation and training is an escalation of U.S. involvement in Mexico’s cartel war. Mexican cartels have been mindful of the example of the Guadalajara cartel which drew the ire of the United States with the 1985 torture and murder of DEA Special Agent Enrique Camarena. The United States took unilateral action that resulted in the decapitation and destruction of the Guadalajara cartel. However, retaliation by the cartels cannot be ruled out — particularly if they continue taking hits as Los Zetas did in Operation Northern Lynx.


Aug. 1


  • The Mexican military rescued five kidnapped individuals from a safe house in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. Three individuals were arrested during the rescue.
  • Moises “El Coreano” Montero Alvarez was detained by federal agents in Acapulco, Guerrero state. Police suspect Alvarez was responsible for the killing of 20 tourists from Michoacan in Acapulco on Sept. 30, 2010.
  • Hector “El Huicho” Guajardo Hernandez, a senior leader in the Sinaloa Federation, escaped from a hospital in Mexico City. Hernandez was injured during his arrest last May and was at the hospital for a check-up on his recovery. Two Federal Police who were watching Hernandez in the hospital are reported missing.

Aug. 2


  • A confrontation between the Mexican army and gunmen in Tiquicheo, Michoacan state, left one gunman dead. The Mexican army seized the gunmen’s arsenal after the confrontation.
  • Federal Police captured Valdemar Quintanilla Soriano, a finance operator for Los Zetas in Saltillo, Coahuila state. Soriano was the No. 2 finance operator for the cartel, possessing close ties to Los Zetas leader, Heriberto “El Lazca” Lazcano Lazcano.
  • Jorge Luis “El Pompin” de la Pena Brizuela, the Los Zetas’ plaza boss in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, was killed in a confrontation between Los Zetas and the Mexican military.

Aug. 3


  • Eleven Knights Templar members were detained in two separate operations in Mexico state. Among the arrests include Andres “El Mecanico” Garcia, the Knights Templar boss for Mexico state.

Aug. 4


  • The entire police force of Ascension, Chihuahua state, resigned over the casualties they have sustained over the last few months, including the death of their police chief. The resignations leave Ascension without any local police service.
  • The Mexican federal government released $4.8 million for security assistance in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. The funds were frozen by the federal government in July due to lack of improvement in the city’s police force.
  • The Mexican army discovered a training camp for the La Resistencia cartel in Tapalpa, Jalisco state. The camp included obstacle courses and a firing range.
  • The Mexican military concluded Operation Northern Lynx. The operation began July 16, and targeted Los Zetas in Coahuila, Tamaulipas, San Luis Potosi, and Nuevo Leon states.

Aug. 5


  • Two police officers were killed in an ambush by armed men traveling in a vehicle in Torreon, Coahuila state.

Aug. 6


  • Five individuals were gunned down in San Ignacio, Sinaloa state, while eating dinner at a hamburger stand.
  • Three Los Zetas members, including a 13-year-old girl, were arrested in Lagos de Moreno, Jalisco state. The members were detained after a firefight between Mexican authorities and cartel members.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 3, 2011
Police seized 1.2 tons of cocaine, worth 340 million euros ( $486 million), from a luxury yacht in Southampton, England, on Aug. 3, Euronews reported. The cocaine was originally packed in Venezuela, and this is the largest seizure in U.K. history.
August 3, 2011 | 1804 GMT
Mexican Military Battles Los Zetas in Nuevo Laredo
Mexican military troops stand guard outside the U.S. consulate in Nuevo Laredo in 2010
STRATFOR sources are reporting an Aug. 2 gunbattle in Nuevo Laredo between members of Los Zetas and the Mexican military, during which several gunmen and the alleged plaza boss for Nuevo Laredo were killed. According to the sources, the Mexican army confronted the Zetas convoy after receiving intelligence on its location and that Zetas gunmen opened fire on the soldiers. Subsequent media reports said gunmen in one of the Zetas vehicles launched grenades at the pursuing military convoy. Soldiers reportedly killed two gunmen and took three more into custody. Media reports also say that roadblocks were set up in several locations in the city. According to the sources, witnesses said a Mexican military helicopter fired upon fleeing cartel vehicles and that several people were killed in the incident.
While Mexican authorities of have yet to corroborate the account, the source’s report is plausible. Nuevo Laredo is controlled by Los Zetas, and the cartel has consistently used such a tactic — employing large commercial vehicles as roadblocks — to escape security forces.
Nuevo Laredo is a valuable point of entry into the United States because of its direct connection to the U.S. interstate highway system and, as such, is a vital piece of Zetas territory. If reports that a Nuevo Laredo plaza boss was killed in the incident prove to be true, then Mexican authorities achieved another victory in their battle against the cartels — a plaza boss in a key territory probably would be high on the cartel’s hierarchy. The incident is in keeping with STRATFOR’s current analysis of Los Zetas, which have been taking heavy losses in engagements with both the Mexican military and rival cartels, including the Gulf cartel.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

August 2, 2011
The federal prosecutors of 21 out of 32 Mexican states have resigned as part of a purging within the Mexican Attorney General’s Office designed to deliver results to citizens’ demands, Mexican Attorney General Marisela Morales said in a statement, AFP reported Aug. 2. The federal prosecutors for Mexico City, Michoacan, Tamaulipas and Coahuila states are among those who resigned. Mexican state office coordinator Rosa Elena Torres said the resignations were submitted on July 29.
August 2, 2011 | 1223 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Underground Meth Labs in Sinaloa

The Capture of ‘El Diego’


Mexican authorities captured Jose Antonio “El Diego” Acosta Hernandez, the top leader of La Linea, on July 29 in Chihuahua state. La Linea is the enforcement arm of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (VCF), aka the Juarez cartel. Several media reports say Acosta was captured after a gunbattle in an upscale neighborhood of Chihuahua city, while others specified that he was caught at his house in Juarez following a gunbattle. Police seized several items from the house, including two handguns, one assault rifle and various communications and computer equipment.
Acosta, a former Juarez police officer, had previously been linked to the murder of two U.S. Consulate employees in Juarez and improvised explosive device attacks directed against Juarez police, as well as a Jan. 30, 2010, attack on teens at a party which killed 15. Mexican police say that since his capture, Acosta has confessed to ordering the killings of 1,500 people in the VCF’s ongoing struggle against the Sinaloa Federation for control of Juarez.
Acosta’s capture will deal a significant blow to La Linea’s operations, as well as those of the VCF. It also provides Mexican authorities a large volume of information to analyze that could lead to possible follow-up actions.
Acosta is believed to control all La Linea operations in Juarez and Chihuahua. His position in the VCF hierarchy as head of the cartel’s enforcement arm will make him difficult to replace. For the cartels, it is never a good time to lose an important figure, but the loss is felt even more acutely when the figure is the leader of the cartel’s armed wing and he is removed from the mix in the midst of a heated and prolonged battle for survival. Moreover, Sinaloa has been pressing its advantage in Juarez, making steady headway into VCF territory, and Acosta’s arrest likely will further weaken the VCF’s ability to combat Sinaloa encroachment. Acosta also reportedly was the pivotal link between the VCF and a key Juarez street gang, Los Aztecas. Acosta’s arrest thus could provide an opportunity for the Aztecas to switch allegiance to Sinaloa, which would further weaken the VCF.
Acosta’s capture may assist Mexican authorities in a number of ways. Admissions he makes during interrogations could be used in follow-on raids against his key lieutenants and contacts and other high-level La Linea and VCF leaders. Acosta was indicted in the Western District of Texas on March 9 for his alleged involvement in the killings of the U.S. Consulate employees, and Mexican authorities may use the possibility of extradition to the United States as an incentive to encourage his cooperation. His statements also could corroborate those of his reputed lieutenant, Marco Antonio “El Brad Pitt” Guzman Zuniga, who was captured in June. The computer equipment seized from Acosta’s house also will be heavily mined for information (though the amount of actionable intelligence it contains is unknown).
Authorities also benefit from the timing of Acosta’s capture. On July 27, just two days prior, “narcomantas” — banners containing messages from drug-trafficking organizations — appeared in Juarez and Chihuahua signed with the name “El Diego” making explicit threats against the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, the U.S. Consulate in Juarez and border crossings. The arrest is likely to mitigate any potential follow-through on those threats, as well as send a message to cartel leaders that authorities will not take such threats lightly.
Acosta’s capture likely will lead to the continued erosion of the VCF’s control over the important smuggling corridor of Juarez, especially if statements from Acosta produce actionable intelligence that leads to the arrest of other high-ranking cartel members. Also, because La Linea is largely made up of former Juarez police and corrupt active-duty officers, the arrest could lead to the identification and removal of corrupt police who have been supporting the VCF. This could be a pivotal point in the battle for control of Juarez, and developments there must be watched very carefully in the coming days and weeks.


July 25


  • Mexican authorities in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, rescued 12 kidnapped migrants, including eight Central Americans, three Brazilians and one Iranian.
  • Police in Zacacoyuca, Guerrero state, engaged armed men in a firefight, leaving nine gunmen dead. The police pursued the armed men after spotting them traveling in suspicious vehicles.
  • Unidentified gunmen killed two police officers in Acapulco, Guerrero state.

July 26


  • Fighting between rival prison gangs the Mexicles, affiliated with the Sinaloa Federation, and the Aztecas, affiliated with the Juarez cartel, erupted into a riot at a Juarez prison July 26, leaving 17 dead. Federal Police and the Mexican military were called to the prison to quell the violence. No prisoners were reported escaped due to the riot.
  • Yolanda Ordaz de la Cruz, a journalist with the newspaper Notiver, was found dead behind the offices of Imagen de Veracruz periodical in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state. The journalist was reported missing 48 hours prior to her body being discovered.
  • Hector Murguia, mayor of Juarez, Chihuahua state, announced that thousands of Federal Police will withdraw from the city in September. The Federal Police, initially deployed to Juarez in April 2010, will turn over security responsibility to the local police.

July 27


  • The remains of 12 individuals were discovered in Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. Two decomposing bodies were discovered in a trench along a dirt road. Bones belonging to 10 individuals were discovered nearby.
  • Five individuals were killed when the truck they were traveling in was ambushed by armed men in San Lucas Camotlan, Oaxaca state.
  • Los Zetas leader Oscar Tiul was arrested in Guatemala City, Guatemala.
  • Narcomantas left in Juarez and Chihuahua, Chihuahua state, made threats against the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, the U.S. Consulate in Juarez and border crossings. The messages were signed “El Diego.”

July 28


  • The body of Fortino Cortes, the kidnapped mayor of Florencia de Benito Juarez, Zacatecas state, was discovered.
  • The Mexican military engaged in a firefight with armed men in Ixtlan del Rio, Nayarit state. The armed men used roadblocks during the confrontation.

July 29


  • The Mexican military arrested 15 armed men traveling in three separate vehicles in San Miguel Totolapan, Guerrero state. The arrested individuals were discovered by ground reconnaissance and were found in possession of high-powered weapons, including eight grenades.
  • A shipment of approximately 22 tons of chemical precursors used to produce illicit drugs from Shekou, China, was seized in Manzanillo, Colima state.
  • Mexican authorities arrested Jose Antonio “El Diego” Acosta Hernandez, leader of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization enforcement arm La Linea in his home after a gunbattle.

July 31


  • Five individuals were killed in a gunfight between Federal Police and armed men along the Uruapan-Los Reyes highway in Michoacan state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 2011
July 30, 2011
Mexican police arrested alleged Juarez drug cartel leader Jose Antonio Acosta Hernandez, known as “El Diego,” Reuters reported July 30. An arrest was made but the identity was not confirmed, according to a spokeswoman for the federal police in Mexico City.
July 27, 2011 | 1055 GMT
Mexican Government Using Interrogation as Propaganda
A screenshot of Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon from an interrogation video
Summary
Senior Los Zetas drug cartel member Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon was arrested July 3, and an interview conducted as a part of the interrogation process was videotaped and released for public consumption two days later. The video shows Rejon cooperating with Mexican authorities. However, it did not contain actionable intelligence, and it is very clearly a propaganda tool for Mexican authorities struggling to convince a disgruntled public of the utility of the war against drug cartels.
Analysis
Mexican authorities released the video interrogation July 5 of Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon, a former member of the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group and a founding member of Los Zetas who had been arrested two days prior. This is the latest in a string of videos featuring a high-value cartel leader’s interrogation after being arrested.
The release of the video is part of an ongoing public relations strategy demonstrating Mexico’s success in the war against the drug cartels, most notably with the arrest of Beltran Leyva Organization top enforcer Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal in August 2010. These video interrogations are a way for the Mexican government to show the captured crime bosses in a way that is accessible to all strata of Mexican society. Such a move is a clear propaganda ploy for a government that is suffering greatly from public disapproval of the ongoing violence.

The Interrogation Process


These videos portray a typical interrogation: a subject, held for questioning against his will, being asked questions on topics of information that have intelligence value. Interrogations of a prisoner of war or a criminal are not always conducted in a hostile manner. Most interrogations consist of more than one round of questioning, so it is highly unlikely the video was the only interaction between Rejon and the authorities. The interview is but one step in a larger interrogation process that Rejon and other captured leaders must undergo.
For any captured criminal or prisoner of war, an interrogation is a delicate process of negotiation. For the prisoner, self-preservation is of paramount importance. Interrogation resistance strategy — whether guided by ideology or by fear of reprisal — is the process by which the detainee minimizes his or her answers to the authorities. At the same time, the detainee must find ways to work with the interrogating authorities to incentivize leniency. In doing so, the detainee has three options. He or she can provide a detailed-enough response to barely answer a given question, lie to distract the interrogator from the truth, or provide harmless nuggets of truth in hopes of persuading the interrogators that he or she is fully cooperating. Without further insight into Rejon’s overall investigation, the disclosure of an interrogation designed specifically for public consumption does not tell us much about which option Rejon chose during the interrogation and deal-making process.
Notably, the video indicates that Mexican authorities did more than capture a high-profile criminal; they acquired his cooperation. Rejon very clearly admits his own guilt and association with criminal activities in the video, and for every direct question the interrogator asks, Rejon immediately responds with an answer satisfying the query. Indeed, it is clear that some sort of deal was made prior to the recording in which both sides received concessions from the other. The concessions have not been made public, so STRATFOR can only speculate as to what they were, but he was likely offered anything from lighter sentencing to immunities and guarantees of protection from criminal reprisal in exchange for his testimony to the Mexican Federal Police.
While it is unknown what Rejon may have offered to the police in return for his cooperation, we do know that Rejon’s statements in the video did not offer actionable intelligence to his interrogators (such intelligence would likely be withheld from the public by Mexican authorities). Because the video of Rejon’s interrogation is a propaganda tool for Mexican authorities, it was likely rehearsed to some extent. It also showed clear signs of editing. The video did, however, provide insight into the leadership of one of the country’s most notorious criminal organizations and insight into cartel dynamics.

The Government’s Public Relations Strategy


In releasing the video of Rejon’s post-capture interrogation, the Mexican authorities are not so much disclosing intelligence on the operations of the cartels as they are using the opportunity provided by capturing a high-value target to bolster the government’s public relations campaign in support of the war on drug cartels. Though the public release of an interrogation is an unusual method for states to prove their successes in a campaign against criminal organizations, such a move is in keeping with Mexico’s general strategy of publishing photographs and videos after successful busts. Typically after high-profile arrests, Mexican authorities will line up the arrestees in front of the media in a controlled environment.
The interrogation videos serve the same purpose, but give a more intimate perspective on the detainees. They show the government in complete control of the criminal and give the government a chance to have cartel members confirm information that has been published in the media. With a responsive interrogation subject, the video also demonstrates that the authorities can further capitalize on their arrest. Past videos have included statements from cartel leaders praising the government and the federal police. The obvious edits in the interview may have excluded omissions of information that the government does not deem fit for public consumption. This would include actionable intelligence, which the government would need to retain for its own uses, as well as for the protection of the prisoner.
Presenting captured high-ranking cartel operatives to the public is important for the Mexican government. With elections approaching in 2012, and the ruling National Action Party having lost the lead in public opinion to the Institutional Revolutionary Party, the administration of Mexican President Felipe Calderon is struggling to justify a war that has left thousands dead, with little in the way of tangible results. Accordingly, Calderon’s government has been experimenting with a number of strategies to tackle the issue of public opinion. In addition to the real life examples provided by captured cartel members, the government has sponsored the launch of a television show called “El Equipo” (The Team), which glorifies the activities of the federal police and shows drug cartels as having an increasingly difficult time doing business because of police activity.
However, despite significant successes and an increasingly sophisticated propaganda machine, the Mexican government still struggles against endemic corruption and the ingenuity and wealth of the drug cartels. This is a fight that will continue beyond the Calderon administration, and it will last until some sort of credible detente with the cartels can be found.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 26, 2011 | 1823 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Jan. 28, 2008

Stumbling Upon a Second Lab?


On July 20, Mexican soldiers found a large methamphetamine lab built 3.5 meters (11 feet) below ground in La Cruz de Elota, Sinaloa state. According to Mexico’s Secretariat of National Defense (SEDENA), the underground space was 20 meters by 10 meters (about 2,153 square feet), with a tunnel that was 1.5 meters wide and 35 meters long leading to the lab from the surface. The entrance to the tunnel was concealed under a large pile of shredded wood, the kind that might be used for garden mulch.
Beneath the ground, the walls and ceiling appear to be made of cinderblock (the ceiling probably is rebar-reinforced), and two of the rooms were reportedly still under construction. A generator provided electricity and powered three complete production lines. SEDENA reports indicate that the structure contained two forklifts, probably for moving large quantities of precursors and finished product into and out of the lab via the tunnel. The lab reportedly was found during a land survey, though there are no further details regarding the type of survey or who was conducting it. It is not clear whether a surveyor stumbled across the lab or it was detected from the air with high-tech tools like ground-penetrating radar.
The second subterranean meth lab is the second found in Sinaloa; the first was discovered June 28 in San Antonio, 235 kilometers (146 miles) northwest of this latest find. The La Cruz de Elota lab appears to be more professionally constructed, though the lab in San Antonio had two levels, including living space and a bathroom, and was equipped with electricity, a ventilation system and air conditioning. Both labs were found in the home territory of the Sinaloa cartel, which specializes in methamphetamine production and smuggling, and both were found in inland towns that are near seaports and were apparently capable of producing large volumes of meth.
The Sinaloa cartel appears to be taking great pains to increase its methamphetamine production while improving the security and concealment of its production facilities. Following the discovery of these labs the cartel’s security efforts will only intensify. It is worth noting that the ownership of the land on which the two labs were found is unknown, but it seems unlikely that facilities of such strategic value would be built on land not owned by the cartel running the operation. Underground labs constructed in the future will likely be even more carefully concealed in remote areas still accessible by vehicle where third-party encounters can be minimized.

Luxury Prison Cells in Sonora


The state penitentiary in Hermosillo, Sonora state, evidently has accommodations for wealthy cartel members willing to pay for them. On July 20, Mexican media reported that an inmate was raffling three “luxury” cells for 200 pesos ($17) per ticket. It is not clear how long the winners would be able to spend in the cells, but photos of the upgraded spaces show cabinetry, tile floors, colorful sheets and bedspreads, and small framed pictures and crucifixes on the walls. Upon discovering the raffle and the three upgraded cells, prison authorities dismantled them.
Then on July 21, Mexican media reported that the same prison in Hermosillo had 130 “luxury suites” for housing high-value or VIP inmates. These suites reportedly include comfortable furniture, air-conditioning, televisions and kitchens. According to several reports, inmates in Mexican prisons will often pay guards to allow them to keep certain amenities in their cells, but the amenities are removed when the inmates are released. And cartel bosses have long been known to enjoy better accommodations in Mexican prisons. What makes this development interesting is the sheer scale of the upgraded accommodations. That there are such “luxuries” in a Mexican penitentiary does not necessarily equate to direct cartel involvement. But the quantity of these amenities at Hermosillo and the apparent fact that they remain in place point to some level of organizational influence, not just individual sway.
We do not yet know the cartel affiliations of the inmates occupying these cells, but the number of cells and the extent of the renovations — not to mention the cost involved — point to the Sinaloa cartel as the likely benefactor. Sonora state, and Hermosillo in particular, is nominally controlled by the Sinaloa cartel, but that control is regularly contested by the Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS). The latter cartel is an offshoot of the Beltran Leyva Organization, which was once a part of the Sinaloa cartel. This suggests possible CPS involvement in the Hermosillo prison upgrades.
Many of the guards certainly knew about the luxury cells, but higher-level prison authorities may not have been in the loop. As the investigation continues, it may lead to higher levels of Sonora state government, and we will continue to monitor media reports and seek additional information from STRATFOR sources about the Hermosillo facility.



July 18


  • A lieutenant of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman, leader of the Sinaloa cartel, was arrested in the Dominican Republic. The interrogation of Luis Fernando Bertulucci Castillo by Dominican authorities confirmed the Sinaloa cartel’s attempt to use the Dominican Republic as a drug trafficking route.
  • Gunmen attacked a municipal police officer and his family in Rosales, Chihuahua state, while the family was traveling in a truck. The police officer and his wife were killed in the attack while one of the children was seriously injured.
  • An alleged boss of the Knights Templar, Faustino “El Pariente” Pacheco Torres, was arrested in Apatzingan, Michoacan state. Pacheco Torres is thought to have participated in the Dec. 9, 2010, confrontation in which Nazario Moreno Gonzalez, former leader of La Familia Michoacana (LFM), was killed.
  • The Mexican army seized approximately 840 tons of chemical precursors in Benito Juarez, Queretaro state.

July 19


  • Two decapitated bodies were found in a car parked along a street in Torreon, Coahuila state.
  • The warden in charge of the prison in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, where 61 inmates escaped July 15, has been arrested along with six other prison officials, Mexican media reported.
  • An investigation by Mexican authorities revealed Pablo Magana Serrato (aka La Morsa) as another leader of the Knights Templar.

July 20


  • The Tamaulipas state government called for the transfer of 700 state prisoners to federal penitentiaries. The announcement came after the prison escape of 61 prisoners in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state.
  • Federal police arrested 25 individuals thought to have been responsible for an attack April 28 on the police headquarters in Tula de Allende, Hidalgo state. The individuals were detained in the Hidalgo municipalities of Zempoala, Tepeapulco and Apan.
  • Thirteen members of La Familia Michoacana were detained in Valle de Chalco, Mexico state. The group included a military deserter and two police officers.
  • A soldier and a police officer were killed when Mexican security forces engaged in a firefight with armed men in Petatlan, Guerrero state. The security forces were in charge of safeguarding the family of slain environmentalist Javier Torres.

July 21


  • The Mexican army shut down an underground drug lab in La Cruz de Elota, Sinaloa state, that reportedly was found during a land survey.
  • The son of the news director of El Debate was found dead in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. The body of Fermin Rosas Quezada was discovered in a car with a bullet wound in his head.
  • One hundred thirty prison cells described as luxury suites were found in a prison in Hermosillo, Sonora state. The prisoners occupying the suites were able to bribe officials for amenities such as refrigerators, televisions and air-conditioning.
  • U.S. authorities arrested 35 LFM members in Austin, Texas. Police said the cartel uses Austin as a drug trafficking hub connected to 11 other states.

July 22


  • Six gunmen were killed in a firefight between an armed group and a military unit in Teul de Gonzalez Ortega, Zacatecas state.
  • Mexican authorities discovered three drug labs in Izucar de Matamoro, Puebla state. Chemical precursors and manufactured drugs were seized along with five individuals.

July 23


  • Mexican authorities arrested 1,030 people in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, for links to human trafficking. About half of the individuals were male. Twenty female minors were released.
  • Two Mexican police officers assigned to a security detail for the U.S. Consulate were killed in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 22, 2011 | 2259 GMT
Mexico: Public Protest and Meth-Precursor Shipments in Michoacan
Mexican marines at a security checkpoint in Apatzingan, Michoacan state
Summary
The July 17 seizure of a large quantity of methamphetamine precursor chemicals in Queretaro, four days after a public protest was organized by the Knights Templar (KT) in Apatzingan, could point to an emerging diversionary tactic in Michoacan. STRATFOR remains curious about the sequence of events, and we expect to see more instances when attention is drawn to a particular city off the beaten path, followed closely by the discovery of valuable commodities in some other part of the KT area of operations.
Analysis
As we discussed in our July 19 Mexico Security Memo, a protest orchestrated by the Knights Templar (KT) cartel in Apatzingan, Michoacan state, was set in motion July 13 with some urgency and with the arranged presence of Mexican national media. The question STRATFOR posed at the time was why such a large demonstration, heavily covered by the press, was being held in that particular place at that particular time?
That question may have just been answered. Our working theory that the protest was a diversionary tactic received some supporting evidence July 21 when the Mexican government announced the seizure of a record-breaking quantity of methamphetamine precursor chemicals at a warehouse in Queretaro, Queretaro state. The seizure occurred July 17, four days after the KT-engineered protest in Apatzingan. The quantity of precursor chemicals found at the warehouse — 839.5 metric tons — was a very large stockpile that must have been accumulated from several different shipments. This reinforces the theory that the protest in Apatzingan was staged to divert attention away from some kind of cartel activity somewhere else, probably a shipment of precursors that was being moved through Michoacan state from a port on the west coast to the warehouse in Queretaro.
Apatzingan is approximately 120 kilometers (75 miles) inland from the Pacific coast. It is not on a main highway but is situated between two highways that move all manner of industrial shipments from the two primary seaports in the region — Manzanillo in Colima state and Lazaro Cardenas in Michoacan state. As we discussed in our April 12 and July 12 Mexico Security Memos, large shipments of methamphetamine precursor chemicals from Asia are known to be received at both ports, based on the large shipments authorities occasionally seize in either location. What is not known is the total volume being shipped into those ports or the frequency.
As cartels operating near the U.S.-Mexico border try to aggressively protect their cross-border drug shipments, cartels in southern Mexico appear to be employing similar tactics. Losses are mounting in their shipments of precursor chemicals for methamphetamine production, which provides the primary revenue stream for both La Familia Michoacana (LFM) and the KT.
Whether the assets involved are drugs being smuggled across the U.S. border headed to the target market, or bulk shipments of meth-precursor chemicals from Asia, all of the cartels appear to be looking for ways to mitigate the losses. An already sizable military force in Michoacan state has been conducting operations specifically against LFM and the KT and interdicting significant precursor shipments at the ports. If the KT had precursor shipments due into port last week from its suppliers in Asia, it is logical that the group would have attempted to pull federal troops away from the route the shipment had to take to get to KT warehousing and production facilities.
KT gunmen shot up an office July 2 serving as a federal police base in the Michoacan city of La Piedad de Cavadas, which is on the main highway between the cities of Guadalajara and Queretaro. During the firefight, KT gunmen expended more than 5,000 rounds of ammunition in an hour, killing seven police officers and wounding three while three KT gunmen were killed (it is unknown if any were wounded). This may also have been a diversion, but if the KT’s goal had been to pull attention away from a big drug shipment, it was a counterproductive one. A diversion involving violence would prompt the military and federal police to place roadblocks throughout the area to catch fleeing cartel gunmen. A relatively peaceful public protest, on the other hand, would have created more of media event than a security crackdown.
The July 13 protest in Apatzingan was not the first time a Mexican cartel organized a public protest — Los Zetas and the Tijuana and Juarez cartels have been known to use similar tactics — but it may have been the first one orchestrated by the KT. And there could well have been a connection between the KT small-arms attack July 2 in La Piedad de Cavadas and the protest in Apatzingan more than a week later. Whether intentionally or not, the violent action July 2 helped focus attention on a subsequent event in a more distant, out-of-the-way place as the precursors were being readied for transport.
STRATFOR remains curious about this sequence of events, and we expect to see more instances when attention is drawn to a particular city off the beaten path, followed closely by the discovery of highly valued commodities in some other part of the KT area of operations.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 21, 2011
Mexican soldiers seized 839.5 tons of chemical precursors for the manufacture of chemical drugs from a warehouse July 17 in Queretaro, Queretaro state, El Universal reported July 21. Approximately 1,700 barrels of chemical precursors were also seized from a warehouse in the Benito Juarez industrial park in the northern sector of Queretaro.
July 21, 2011 | 1211 GMT
Mexican Drug War 2011 Update
Editor’s Note: Since the publication of STRATFOR’s 2010 annual Mexican cartel report, the fluid nature of the drug war in Mexico has prompted us to take an in-depth look at the situation more frequently. This is the second product of those interim assessments, which we will now make as needed, in addition to our annual year-end analyses and our weekly security memos.
As we suggested in our first quarterly cartel update in April, most of the drug cartels in Mexico have gravitated toward two poles, one centered on the Sinaloa Federation and the other on Los Zetas. Since that assessment, there have not been any significant reversals overall; none of the identified cartels has faded from the scene or lost substantial amounts of territory. That said, the second quarter has been active in terms of inter-cartel and military-on-cartel clashes, particularly in three areas of Mexico: Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas and Veracruz states; southern Coahuila, through Durango, Zacatecas, San Luis Potosi and Aguascalientes states; and the Pacific coast states of Nayarit, Jalisco, Michoacan and Guerrero.
There are three basic dimensions of violence in Mexico: cartel vs. cartel, cartel vs. government and cartel vs. civilians. It is becoming increasingly clear that the Mexican government has focused its efforts (and the bulk of its military forces) on defeating cartel groups that it considers the most violent — especially those that are the most violent toward civilians. We believe this is why three major military campaigns have been launched over the past three months against Los Zetas and the Knights Templar. We can expect to see these campaigns continue over the next three months, although we doubt that the government will be able to destroy either of these well-entrenched groups in the short term, and certainly not in the next quarter. Still, we will need to look for evidence that the government’s efforts are having an impact.



In the northern states, conditions remained fairly unchanged over the last quarter, though cartel-related deaths in Juarez did not reach the severe level anticipated by regional law enforcement. STRATFOR’s sources in the region say there has been a diminishing military presence in Juarez and that there have been fewer cartel-related deaths as a result. This is not to say that the Sinaloa Federation and the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (VCF, aka the Juarez cartel) have let up in their battle for the Juarez plaza, only that the lessening of military pressure on those cartels has reduced overall friction. In any given area of Mexico, cartel-on-cartel violence is caused by the dynamics among cartels and is entirely separate from whatever the government presence may be, but the introduction of military forces into this environment exacerbates existing hostilities. This happened when Mexican troops moved into the Juarez area in 2009, at which point the already heated battle between cartel elements rose to a boil. While violence has trended downward in Juarez, we can expect to see the Sinaloa Federation continue its efforts to advance and consolidate control over Juarez. The severity of the violence will depend on the VCF’s ability to resist Sinaloa’s advances.
STRATFOR expects a similar escalation of violence in Tamaulipas state, where the military suddenly replaced municipal (and some state) law enforcement personnel with federal troops in 22 cities in mid-June. The same sort of dynamics are in play in Tamaulipas as were seen in Juarez in 2009, and we anticipate a similar long-term reaction over a much larger region encompassing the urban areas of Nuevo Laredo, Reynosa, Rio Bravo, Matamoros, Valle Hermoso, San Fernando and the state capital Ciudad Victoria. We expect to see increasing violence in all of these cities for as long as the military presence remains, with larger escalations in Nuevo Laredo, Reynosa and Matamoros because they sit astride the most valuable smuggling corridors along the easternmost 1,600 kilometers (1,000 miles) of U.S. border. While federal troops have not replaced municipal police in neighboring Nuevo Leon state, violence will also likely escalate in Monterrey and the surrounding region given its key location and strategic importance. Here the Zeta presence is being challenged by the Gulf cartel, which seeks to enlarge its foothold in the city and expel the entrenched Zetas.
The cartels across Mexico continue to become more fractured and numerous, particularly in the central and Pacific regions. As we discussed in the last quarterly update, the Beltran Leyva Organization (BLO) no longer exists as it once did. The newer cartels, which began as factions of the BLO, continue to fight each other as well as the Sinaloa Federation and, in most cases, Los Zetas. (Cartel Pacifico Sur [CPS] is actually aligned with Los Zetas.) From Durango and Zacatecas south to Nayarit, Jalisco and Michoacan states and into Guerrero’s coastal port of Acapulco, seven different groups of varying sizes and organizational cohesion are fighting to the death for the same overlapping regions.
Looking ahead to the next three months, STRATFOR expects to see increased violence in northeast Mexico as the Gulf-Zeta battle for the region becomes more complicated by the presence of the Mexican military in Tamaulipas. Added to that are the out-of-work former police officers, many of whom were on cartel payrolls in more passive roles and now may become cartel gunmen to maintain their income. This, combined with the material losses Los Zetas have suffered over the past quarter, will likely cause the cartel-vs.-civilian violence to remain high, and we anticipate that crimes such as kidnapping, extortion and carjacking will proliferate.
With the military also becoming heavily involved in Michoacan, we can expect to see a phenomenon in that state similar to the one in Tamaulipas. We also do not anticipate that the violence that has plagued the Pacific coast will let up during the next quarter.
With the Atlantic/Gulf hurricane season now coming into full swing, the fighting could be slowed by major storms that roar into the Rio Grande Valley. At the same time, torrential rains would significantly increase cross-border smuggling activity, since shallow water in the flood plain increases the number of locations where smugglers can meet and load vehicles on the U.S. side. Cartels are known to take advantage of flooding conditions to insert drug loads as much as 1.5 kilometers north of the border with fast, shallow-draft boats and jet skis, which U.S. riverine patrols using deeper-draft boats cannot pursue.

Current Status of the Mexican Cartels


To assist in navigating the fractured cartel landscape — as much as conditions in Mexico currently allow — we have arranged the discussion below into three camps: the Sinaloa Federation and other cartels aligned with it, Los Zetas and their associated groups, and the independent cartels that have declared war on all other cartels and are determined to go it alone.

The Sinaloa Federation and Associates


The Sinaloa Federation continues to be the largest and most cohesive of the Mexican cartels. Run by Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, Sinaloa continued its expansion into Durango state, Mexico D.F. and Guerrero and Michoacan states over the last three months as well as its fight to take over the plazas in Juarez and Chihuahua City. The cartel has also clashed occasionally with CPS in the city of Hermosillo in Sonora state and in parts of Durango state; with Los Zetas in Torreon, Coahuila state; and with both CPS and Los Zetas in Culiacan, Sinaloa state. On May 27 in Nayarit state, Sinaloa conducted a major ambush of Zeta forces in which Sinaloa fighters apparently utilized Zeta defensive positions close to a Zeta camp.
During the second quarter of 2011, three significant Sinaloa leaders were captured. In early April federal forces arrested Jesus Raul Ochoa Zazueta, a former Baja California ministerial police officer who, at the time of his arrest, was Sinaloa’s operations boss for the Mexicali plaza. Then in mid-April, Bruno “El Gato” Garcia Arreola was captured in Tepic, Nayarit state. The following month, Martin “The Eagle” Beltran Coronel, nephew of Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal (a top Sinaloa leader killed in a gun battle in July 2010), was arrested in the Zapopan neighborhood of Guadalajara, Jalisco state. With Guzman Loera’s approval, Beltran Coronel had taken over Coronel Villarreal’s operations, overseeing cocaine importation from South America through the Pacific ports in Jalisco and Colima states. Coronel Villarreal’s operations included very substantial methamphetamine production facilities and distribution networks, so much so that one of his nicknames was the “king of crystal.” That being the case, it is likely that Martin Beltran Coronel also took over his uncle’s methamphetamine operations, though that portion of his inherited operations has not been delineated.
These Sinaloa leadership losses could be significant, though Guzman Loera is believed to have removed high-level threats within his organization before via anonymous tips to federal authorities. That so many Sinaloa leaders were apprehended by federal authorities in the last quarter was just as likely the result of betrayal as it was of legitimate government investigations. Given Guzman Loera’s solid hold on the organization, we expect to see replacements elevated to the vacant positions, with the duration of their lives or their freedom predicated on their loyalty and service to Guzman Loera. STRATFOR does not anticipate any significant changes or instability within the Sinaloa Federation as a whole over the next quarter.

Gulf Cartel


The Gulf cartel has managed to hold Matamoros despite several large offensives by Los Zetas in May and June. We have also seen a string of retaliatory attacks by the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas against each other’s support networks. As we discussed in the last quarterly update, Matamoros is vital to the Gulf cartel’s survival, but control of Matamoros plaza alone is not enough. The organization may well survive over the long term, but it will likely do so as a minority partner with Sinaloa. In the last three months, Gulf’s cocaine supply chain was hit hard by Los Zetas in Guatemala’s Peten department, and the organization lost several plaza bosses when they were captured by Mexican troops. In May, federal forces captured Jose Angel “El Choche” Garcia Trujillo approximately 80 kilometers south of Monterrey. Garcia Trujillo led the Gulf cell tasked with hunting down and killing Zeta operatives in Montemorelos, Allende, and General Teran, Nuevo Leon state. Also captured in May was Gilberto “El Tocayo” Barragan Balderas, the Gulf plaza boss in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state, a vital point of entry across the border from Roma, Texas.
With federal forces occasionally entering the fray and Los Zetas seeking any weaknesses to exploit, the Gulf cartel remains stretched as it seeks to hold onto its territories and maintain its supply and revenue streams. The Gulf cartel has displayed increasing desperation regarding revenues and has ordered its smuggling groups on the U.S. border to protect the drug loads at all costs, as opposed to the previous practice of the groups’ abandoning their loads if pressed too closely by U.S. law enforcement. Hence there has been a significant upswing in aggression toward U.S. border protection and law enforcement officers. Rock throwing, attempts to run over or crash into U.S. personnel and their vehicles and gunfire from the Mexico side of the Rio Grande while drug loads are retrieved have increased in intensity and frequency in Gulf operational areas on the border. These are clear indicators that the Gulf cartel is under great pressure, and STRATFOR expects these conditions to continue through the third quarter.

Arellano Felix Organization


Fernando “El Ingeniero” Sanchez Arellano, nephew of the founding Arellano Felix brothers, continues to run the remaining operational cells of the Arellano Felix Organization (AFO, aka the Tijuana cartel). In effect, the AFO has become a minority partner with Sinaloa. While the AFO occupies Tijuana, STRATFOR sources indicate that it pays Sinaloa a piso (a tribute or fee) for the right to use the plaza. In the first six months of 2011 little changed in the AFO’s condition from what we reported in our 2010 annual cartel report.
While Sanchez Arellano has apparently worked out some sort of arrangement with Sinaloa to stay in place and in business, several STRATFOR sources report that he has been quietly aligned with Los Zetas for the last six to 12 months to train and strengthen his forces. To conduct this training, according to our sources, Zetas are known to travel to and from Tijuana on the IH-10 corridor north of the border in order to bypass Sinaloa-held territory. Sinaloa likely is aware of the Zeta association, and if this is the case we anticipate a restoration of open hostilities at some point between Sinaloa and the AFO, though we have seen no indication that it will occur in the next three months.

La Resistencia


There appear to be at least two different groups in Mexico using the moniker La Resistencia. In March we discussed one group, which is not a drug trafficking organization but rather an organized crime “brotherhood” based in the Tepito neighborhood of Mexico City. The other group calling itself La Resistencia is based in Guadalajara and appears to consist of followers of killed Sinaloa lieutenant “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal who have remained loyal to the Sinaloa Federation. This group is currently fighting for control of Guadalajara against Los Zetas/CPS, the Knights Templar and the Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG).

The Opposition


Los Zetas


Los Zetas continue to operate in the north-central, northeast, eastern coast, Yucatan and southern portions of Mexico, and on all of those fronts they have been waging a war against the Sinaloa and Gulf cartels. As far as we’ve been able to determine, none of the cartels successfully wrested any territory away from an opponent in the second quarter, though it is clear that Los Zetas (as we describe above) did put a dent in Gulf operations. In May and June it also became apparent that the Zetas had found it useful to manufacture their own steel-plated “troop transports.” While these vehicles are large, somewhat slow and very visible, they likely give Los Zetas a psychological advantage over municipal and state police and strengthen their ability to intimidate the civilian population.
Also during the last quarter several high-ranking Zeta leaders were captured. In April, federal forces arrested Martin Omar “Comandante Kilo” Estrada Luna, the leader of the Zeta cell in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state. He is believed to have been directly responsible for the mass killing of Central American migrants and the deaths of the San Fernando police chief and the state investigator last year and the killing of at least 217 people found in mass graves in the same city in April. In May, Jose Manuel “Comandante 7” Diaz Guardado, plaza boss for Hidalgo, Coahuila state, also was captured, and in early June Victor Manuel “El Siete Latas” Perez Izquierdo, the Zeta leader for Quintana Roo state, was arrested, only to have his replacement, Rodulfo “El Calabaza” Bautista Javier, captured later that same month.
Several of these captured leaders were former members of the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group (GAFE). Such men are hard to replace and while Los Zetas are known to have continued to recruit from the Mexican military and police, as well as foreign military elements such as the Guatemalan and Salvadoran special operations forces, it does not appear that the organization has been able to recruit quickly enough to replace their losses — a fact underscored by Los Zetas’ desperate efforts to recruit illegal immigrants passing through their territory as well as gang members. This means that the trend we have been seeing for the past few years of Los Zetas becoming less disciplined and more dangerous to the general public will continue.
Los Zetas have been engaged by the military on both the east side (Tamaulipas) and west side (Coahuila) of their core territory. They have also been attacked by their cartel opponents in critical locations like Monterrey. While they have damaged the Gulf cartel, at the same time Los Zetas have taken heavy losses in terms of leaders, fighters, weapons and other materiel. They have been forced to increase their other criminal activities to offset their losses in the cartel war. These losses will take their toll over time and we will need to watch carefully over the next quarter to see if the government’s push to eradicate Los Zetas, along with the efforts of the Sinaloa Federation and its allies, will combine to further weaken the group — or if Los Zetas are able to regroup and re-fit.

Cartel Pacifico Sur


This Zeta ally centers on leader Hector Beltran Leyva, who succeeded his brother Arturo as head of the Beltran Leyva Organization when Arturo was killed by Mexican marines in December 2009. The BLO then split into two primary groups and several splinter groups that went on to form other cartels or rejoin Sinaloa. Following that split, the larger faction under Hector re-established itself as CPS. The second quarter of 2011 found CPS continuing to fight for supremacy in the central and western coastal regions of Mexico, including areas northward into Sonora and Baja California states.
Regarding the capture of supposed CPS leaders, there is conflicting information about their actual cartel affiliation. Several Mexican media sources reported that Miguel Angel “El Pica” Cedillo Gonzalez, the CPS leader in Morelos state, was captured in April and that his replacement, Jose Efrain “El Villa” Zarco Cardenas, was captured in May. However, there also are references made to Cedillo Gonzalez being associated with Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal, who led the other faction that emerged from the BLO and that opposes CPS. The succession of Cedillo Gonzalez by Zarco Cardenas is the only thing that appears to be consistent. Nevertheless, whether CPS has lost leadership or not, it does not appear to be foundering. Its alliance with Los Zetas likely has helped it remain viable.
Overall the cartel dynamics on the Pacific coast continue to favor Guzman Loera and Sinaloa. As noted in our last cartel update, the Mexican government seems to be trying to defeat the most violent cartels rather than end the narcotics trade and, at present, seems to be focused on Los Zetas and the Knights Templar. We anticipate these two groups will remain firmly fixed in the government’s sights in the coming quarter.

Vicente Carrillo Fuentes Organization


The Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (VCF, aka the Juarez cartel) is holding on. Though STRATFOR previously reported that the VCF was hemmed in on all sides by the Sinaloa Federation and essentially confined to downtown Ciudad Juarez, STRATFOR sources have recently indicated that this is no longer quite the case. The VCF continues to control the border crossings in Juarez, from the Paso del Norte port of entry on the northwest side of town to the Ysleta port of entry on the west side. While the VCF’s territory has diminished, there has been a strong VCF resurgence since April in the city of Chihuahua in an effort to wrest it away from Sinaloa, with La Linea, the VCF’s enforcer arm, openly aligned with Los Zetas to remove Sinaloa from Chihuahua state. La Linea’s alliance with Los Zetas has been evident for at least a year, verified by STRATFOR’s sources within the law enforcement and federal government communities, but the two groups went public with the alliance only on June 2, probably with the aim of creating a psychological edge.
Theoretically, an operation by Los Zetas and La Linea/VCF forces, augmented by allied gangs in Juarez (recent reports indicate there could be as many as 8,000 fighters in such an amalgamated force), could be able to rout Sinaloa, but this will not happen anytime soon. Too many battles are being fought across too many fronts spread across vast areas. However, if Los Zetas manage to overcome the Gulf cartel in the northeastern states of Coahuila, Nuevo Leon and Tamaulipas, there will be more Zeta assets to deploy in Chihuahua state.

Independent Operators


The Knights Templar


Since April we have gained a much clearer understanding of the Knights Templar cartel. On May 31, Mexican security forces captured 36 members of the cartel La Familia Michoacana (LFM). Statements by several of the detained LFM operatives revealed that LFM had split into two separate elements, one headed by Jose “El Chango” Mendez Vargas and retaining the LFM name and the other coalesced around co-leaders Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez and Enrique “La Chiva” Plancarte Solis and calling itself the Knights Templar (Los Caballeros Templarios in Spanish). The split resulted from a disagreement following the December 2010 death of charismatic LFM leader Nazario “El Mas Loco” Moreno Gonzalez. Just before he was killed, Moreno reportedly sent word to Mendez Vargas that he and several others were surrounded by federal forces and asked Mendez Vargas to help them escape. Mendez Vargas supposedly refused to come to Moreno Gonzalez’s aid, resulting in the LFM leader’s death.
Emerging as a separate rival group, the Knights Templar has gone head to head with the much smaller LFM in a fierce fight for supremacy, which the Knights Templar appears to be winning. The group also can be expected to continue a war against the Sinaloa Federation that has been ongoing since the latter half of 2010, when the pre-fracture LFM tried to take over the territory of deceased Sinaloa lieutenant Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal.
Meanwhile, government operations against LFM and its remnants continue, though they are now focused primarily on the Knights Templar, which has responded with massive outbreaks of violence in Michoacan. We expect to see the Mexican military continue to press the group in the coming quarter and to continue its efforts to decapitate the group by killing or capturing Gomez Martinez and Plancarte Solis.

La Familia Michoacana


During the second quarter of 2011, LFM struggled to remain viable and relevant in the world of Mexican drug trafficking organizations while being a primary target of the Mexican military. Firefights, killings and narcomantas messages between LFM and the Knights Templar have been commonplace in Michoacan and Jalisco states over the last three months. In several instances, banners signed by the Knights Templar have accused LFM leader Mendez Vargas of being a traitor, most likely because of his alleged efforts to seek help from Los Zetas. That Mendez Vargas would turn to Los Zetas, an organization demonized in previous LFM propaganda, indicates his desperation and points to the successful attrition of LFM by Knights Templar and federal forces.
Following his capture by federal troops June 21 in Aguascalientes state, Mendez Vargas is now in a federal detention facility and the next phase of LFM’s evolution is unclear. Another as yet unknown LFM member could step up in the near future and assume leadership. Another possibility is the incorporation of some of the drifting LFM cells into the Knights Templar structure, a distinct possibility given their common histories and the apparent alienation of some of Mendez Vargas’s followers after he turned to Los Zetas for aid. A third potential outcome could be that Mendez Vargas’s LFM eventually disbands and fades away. A fourth is that the remnants of LFM could try to organize a smaller independent organization as some of their former LFM colleagues did when they helped form the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA).

The Independent Cartel of Acapulco


The CIDA consists of one small faction of the former BLO that was loyal to Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal and that joined with some local Acapulco criminals and LFM members to form their own independent cartel. Due to its heritage as a group, the CIDA is quite hostile to Los Zetas, a group Valdez Villarreal and his enforcers were at war with for many years, and the Sinaloa Federation, which they believe betrayed Alfredo and Arturo Beltran Leyva. In our last update we discussed the potential for the CIDA to fade from the scene within the year, but we saw no indication of that happening over the past three months, and the group appears to remain viable. But we are still receiving conflicting information about the group’s composition and alliances.
Currently, the CIDA is at war with Sinaloa, due to Sinaloa’s efforts to take control of the port of Acapulco. We anticipate that Sinaloa will continue its efforts to weaken the remnants of the CIDA, and Sinaloa will likely do this, as it has done in the past, by conducting armed operations and providing actionable intelligence on the CIDA to Mexican authorities.

Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion


Members of CJNG, which also is based in Guadalajara, are former Sinaloa members from Coronel Villarreal’s group who believe that he was betrayed by Sinaloa leader Guzman Loera. For that reason they are at war with the Sinaloa Federation. CJNG members also hate the Zetas because Coronel Villarreal’s son was killed by Los Zetas operatives. Indeed, the CJNG has basically declared war on everyone except the authorities, whom it has gone out of its way not to offend, and it remains at the center of the battle for the Guadalajara plaza.
Guadalajara is a large city, encompassing crossroads of transportation arteries running parallel to the Pacific coast and connecting that corridor with the port at Manzanillo, Colima state. Hence the Guadalajara plaza is immensely valuable to whoever can control it. Due to the proximity of the CJNG and La Resistencia factions, as well as the presence of Los Zetas, CPS and Sinaloa — all attempting to gain control of the plaza — we expect the violence in Guadalajara to continue and perhaps increase over the next three months.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 20, 2011 | 1400 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

STRATFOR’s Vice President of Intelligence Fred Burton explains how to gather intelligence from videos by analyzing four tapes from Mexican cartel interrogations.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


Videos are a very powerful intelligence tool for us at STRATFOR as well as for the intelligence community. In this week’s Above the Tearline, we’re going to break down four recent Mexican cartel interrogation statements with an eye towards their nonverbal cues and body language.
The first cartel individual we’re going to look at is El Mamito. Your first impression when you look at this videotape is the very high quality of the Mexican backdrop. As you can see, there’s a psychological ramification here that the Mexican government is trying to convey with the high value targets standing in front of the SSP (Secretariat of Public Security) logos and insignias. As you run the tape a little bit, you will notice that El Mamito appears to be in pretty decent shape, although it appears that he hasn’t slept. He’s making very good eye contact with the interviewer.
The next cartel high value target we’re going to look at is El Chango, same backdrop. As you’re looking at his eye movements, he’s showing signs of deception with the shifty eyes towards the left. One of the most interesting parts here is you will notice that the Mexican authorities are utilizing a female interrogator in this case. There’s probably a method to their madness with that course of action. It’s not unusual for the debriefing team ahead of time to think about the best person to ask questions. This very well may be on the part of the Mexican authorities in an effort to disarm the suspect to some degree or to throw him off balance.
The third suspect is El Huache, and he’s an individual that is linked towards human trafficking killings, and your first impressions as you compare and contrast him with the others is that he has the body language and demeanor, in my assessment, of a stone cold killer. As you look at him, you notice his eyes. As you take a look at his body language, he has that attitude you can see that’s conveying across the videotape. Notice the furrow on his brow. He’s making really good eye contact with the interviewer. It appears to me that in all probability, he’s handcuffed. You also notice the swallowing motion there before he asked certain questions, and as you can see, he is conveying, even in the videotape, this air of cockiness, in my assessment.
Lastly, we’re going to take a look at La Barbie. He’s an interesting individual. This is an American that went over to the cartel sides from Laredo. We have discussed him in the past in many of the major news networks as well as on our website, for those of you who would like more information about La Barbie. As we transition into this, keep in mind the previous suspect interviews. Take into account the general nervousness of La Barbie right from the beginning as we transition in. And then you will also notice that the Mexicans are utilizing a female interrogator. La Barbie was known as a ladies’ man, so there might be some degree of psychological reason for the use of the female. As you look at La Barbie, notice that he makes no attempt to establish or maintain good eye contact. He’s looking around. He’s giving off tremendous behavioral signals that indicate a high degree of nervousness. And notice him looking down and to the left. This is a survivor. This is an individual that traveled in the highest levels of the narco world. At one point in this you’ll see that he lifts his handcuffed hands up and actually wipes the sweat off his brow.
From an investigator’s perspective, as you compare and contrast these four videos, what you will notice are some similarities as well as some behavioral indications that indicate that perhaps the suspect is not being as truthful as he could be. The U.S. doesn’t like to release these kinds of videotapes before prosecution. In fact, the Department of Justice and the FBI do not typically videotape suspect debriefings. The Mexicans are clearly utilizing this videotape for a couple different reasons. The first is the psychological aspect of getting this out into the media, hoping that other cartel bosses will see this. Second, remember they are disseminating these videos for domestic consumption inside of Mexico, as well as to show the U.S. that there is a return on their investment based upon all the counter-narcotics aid that we have given the country.
The Above the Tearline aspect in this video is the extraordinary value of videotape as it pertains to intelligence assessments. Videotape is a tremendous value in your ability to go back to evaluate statements and to develop your follow-up questions. The other aspect from the suspect’s perspective is they’re going to be thinking about the ramifications of this videotape. For example, if they rat off one of their bosses, they’re thinking about “What happens to me when I get inside a Mexican prison?” You have the ability to closely examine videotape with an eye towards truthful statements versus signs of deception, as well as nervous behavior. It’s important to realize that in these kinds of custodial situations, the government in many ways holds all the cards, so the suspect that you’re watching is thinking of a thousand different things at the time, primarily geared toward survival.


Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 19, 2011 | 1947 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Seizing High-Value Commodities

Knights Templar-Orchestrated March in Michoacan


In Apatzingan, Michoacan state, a large protest materialized July 13 in which the drug-trafficking organization Los Caballeros Templarios (aka the Knights Templar or KT) figured prominently. Demonstrators carried signs supporting the cartel and protesting the presence of federal security forces in Michoacan. This was not the first time that a cartel has orchestrated a “popular protest” in Mexico. Los Zetas, the Sinaloa Federation and the Juarez cartel are known to have contrived public demonstrations to enhance their public image. What makes the KT-engineered protest in Apatzingan interesting is that the cartel leadership seemed so adamant about the turnout and timing.
In three recorded telephone conversations believed to have been released to the media a day after the march, a mid-level KT leader insisted that all residents and business owners in Apatzingan participate and warned that those who did not would be “fined.” The KT organizers arranged for food and drink to be served to the marchers and ensured that the Mexican press would cover the event. We find the recorded conversations interesting not so much for their content — which was revealing — but because of their sourcing. Who recorded them and put the tapes in the hands of the Mexican media outlet Milenio Television? What was the purpose?
However the recordings were obtained and whatever their intent, they do suggest two possible motives for the KT to organize the July 13 protest. First, there is a good possibility that the prearranged presence of the Mexican press made the march the kick-off event of a propaganda campaign in Michoacan to pressure the federal forces to leave. Another possible motive is misdirection. The federal forces have been targeting the Knights Templar as well as La Familia Michoacana, and the increased federal presence may be hampering KT smuggling activities; the group is reportedly having difficulties receiving shipments of methamphetamine precursors and moving the finished product north to the border to generate revenue.
In one of the recorded discussions, an apparent boss ordered an underling to mobilize all of the people in Apatzingan and march immediately. When the underling said arrangements had already been made for the protest to begin, the boss relented. Timing was obviously an issue, so the question arises: Why stage the protest now? It could be that the KT needed to create a diversion — make a lot of noise, protest the federal presence, require that every resident participate, ensure that the country’s national press would be present with cameras.
We may not end up developing all the facts, but a well-publicized public protest could be an effective way to ensure that the bulk of the federal forces in the state are focused on — or removed from — one particular area of Michoacan.

Prison Break in Nuevo Laredo


On July 15, 59 prisoners believed to be members of Los Zetas escaped from the federal prison in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state. Immediately before their escape, a large fight broke out that resulted in the deaths of seven inmates, all believed to be members of the Gulf cartel. Following the escape, it was determined that the prison’s warden was missing.
This was not the first time that a large group of inmates had broken out of the federal prison in Nuevo Laredo; the last major escape occurred in December 2010 and involved 151 escapees, all believed linked to Los Zetas. Nor is this particular prison an anomaly: A year ago in Gomez Palacio, Durango state, Zeta assassins left the prison in street clothes, driving official prison vehicles and armed with prison guards’ weapons. After killing 17 people attending a birthday party, the gunmen returned to the prison, gave the weapons back to the guards and re-entered their cells. It was later determined that they had conducted such operations from the prison on two previous occasions in 2010.
Mexican authorities have tried rotating prison staff and spending more money on training, but so far it has had little long-term effect. Many incarcerated cartel operatives, especially those who have leadership positions, seem to be able to get out of prison almost any time they wish. Until these problems are corrected, the federal effort in the cartel war can only be a qualified success.

Ambush in Sinaloa


On July 16, a convoy carrying members of Grupo Elite, a special operations unit of the Sinaloa state police, was ambushed on a highway near Guasave, Sinaloa state, in an area that has been hotly contested by cartels this year. The personnel were travelling in officially marked but unarmored trucks when they were attacked, and 10 members of the unit as well as one civilian were killed.
According to media reports, the convoy had just finished providing security for the chief of the Ministry of Public Security in Sinaloa state, Francisco Cordova Celaya, at an appearance in Los Mochis. (Cordova Celaya was not with the convoy, having departed Los Mochis by helicopter.) Though there is not yet any evidence to indicate this, the intent of the ambush may have been to kill Cordova Celaya.
Most notable about the ambush are the topographic features of the site. In other cartel ambushes seen over the past two years, geography has offered obvious tactical advantages for the ambush team such as high ground, roadblock-created kill zones, existing fighting positions, protective cover and limited visibility. In this case, the highway is in flat, level terrain, with two lanes in each direction separated by a “k-rail,” a low concrete partition common to many highways around the world. Other than the k-rail, which is high enough to prevent vehicles from crossing it and heading in the opposition direction, photographs and video of the scene show no other cover from which to conduct an effective ambush.
How, then, were cartel gunmen able to surprise a group of highly trained, well-armed law enforcement personnel traveling in multiple trucks and having excellent visibility and fields of fire? If a stationary roadblock were used, the Grupo Elite officers would have seen it well in advance and been able to take adequate measures to avoid or deal with the attackers. Similarly, a rolling roadblock, in which attacking vehicles box in the target vehicle while moving and force it to slow down, stop or crash, would have been easy to detect, and with multiple vehicles in the convoy such a tactic would have been difficult to pull off.
We suspect that a ruse was used to get the convoy to slow or stop voluntarily, such as a staged accident scene. Whatever it was that stopped the police convoy, it appears that security protocols were not followed and situational awareness was minimal at best. Even for well-trained security forces travelling in numbers, complacency can kill.



July 11


  • Thirteen individuals were charged in a July 8 shooting at a bar in Valle de Chalco, Mexico state, that left 11 people dead. The shooting was a result of fighting between the Knights Templar and La Familia Michoacana.
  • Five members of Los Zetas were arrested in Ixcan, Peten, Guatemala, including a Mexican national. The arrests were the result of an ongoing investigation of a massacre that killed 27 people in Peten.
  • A lieutenant of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman, Luis Fernando Bertolucci Castillo, was arrested in the Dominican Republic. During the lieutenant’s interrogation he revealed the Sinaloa Cartel’s attempt to use the Dominican Republic as a base for drug-smuggling operations.

July 12


  • Two police officers were killed by residents of San Crisobalito in the municipality of San Andres, Chiapas. The police were following a man who was accused of stealing a vehicle. When the police entered San Cristobalito they were detained by residents then thrown into a ravine that was more than 200 meters deep.
  • A grenade thrown from a moving vehicle exploded at an Institutional Revolutionary Party office in Saltillo, Coahuila.
  • The public security director in Tuzantla, Michoacan state, was reported missing. His vehicle was found empty in Benito Juarez.

July 13


  • Five police officers were arrested in Mexico state for the June 26 execution of eight individuals in Valle de Chalco, Mexico state.
  • Five minors were killed after playing a soccer game in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua. The bodies of the youth were found inside a truck.
  • Javier Beltran Arco, an alleged leader of Knights Templar also known as “El Chivo,” was arrested in Apatzigan, Michoacan.
  • A protest march organized by the Knight Templar was held in Apatzigan, Michoacan. A man identified as “Pantera” organized the march in response to federal troop deployments in the area.

July 14


  • Five vehicles that were replicas of typical police vehicles in the area were seized in San Luis Potosí.
  • Mexican authorities discovered a 300-acre marijuana plantation in Baja California, thought to be the largest cultivated marijuana operation ever found in Mexico.
  • Roadblocks and firefights involving the Mexican navy were reported in Matamoros, Tamaulipas.

July 15


  • A firefight between armed groups in Torreon, Coahuila, left four people dead and two injured.
  • Fifty-nine prisoners, many of whom were thought to be Los Zetas, escaped from a federal prison in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas. Seven inmates thought to be members of the Gulf cartel were killed before the escape.
  • A convoy made up of members of the state police unit Grupo Elite was ambushed while traveling along a highway in Guasave, Sinaloa. At least 10 police officers were killed.

July 16


  • Mexican soldiers discovered 114 kilograms of cocaine in a truck in Sonora.

July 17


  • A firefight between two groups in south Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, lasted for 45 minutes and included the use of high-powered rifles and grenades.
  • The Mexican army captured a Los Zetas leader, Cristobal “El Golon” Flores Lopez, in Anahuac, Nuevo Leon. El Golon is thought to have trafficked drugs from northern Mexico into the United States for the last eight years.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 12, 2011 | 1705 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Feb. 18, 2008

Economies of Scale


On July 6, 30.6 tons of monomethylamine, a liquid chemical compound used as an alternative to ephedrine in methamphetamine production, was seized at the Lazaro Cardenas container-ship terminal in southern Michoacan. STRATFOR has discussed large precursor shipments seized in Mexico over the last several months, and this latest seizure gives us an opportunity to describe how lucrative the synthetic-drug business can be for the Mexican cartels.
While marijuana continues to be the mainstay product of the Mexican cartels, methamphetamine is especially profitable for the three cartels that have large-scale production capabilities — the Sinaloa Federation, La Familia Michoacana (LFM) and Los Zetas. Upswings in high-value drug-smuggling activities (mainly meth and cocaine) tend to correspond with lulls in cartel battles and the need for large injections of revenue. But regardless of the tempo of fighting, meth production can continue in areas that are relatively secured, such as the large swath of territory controlled by the Sinaloa Federation. There is the added benefit of being able to keep meth production going and product stockpiled, as opposed to having to deal with the vicissitudes of weather and the marijuana growing cycle.
According to a January U.S. Department of Justice report on illicit drug prices, wholesale methamphetamine prices in the southern United States averaged approximately $22,000 per kilogram, while the wholesale price for marijuana in the same region is approximately $440 to $660 per kilogram. Marijuana is very low in value by weight and remains bulky even when highly compressed, making it a high-volume/low-value commodity. Methamphetamine’s much higher price and low-volume properties as a powder give it much higher value as a smuggled commodity. Given the space restrictions when concealing any contraband, either in stockpiles or during smuggling operations, methamphetamine provides a much higher return on investment for the cartels that specialize in that commodity.
At this point, the volume of LFM’s meth production is unclear, but both Sinaloa and Los Zetas do have the wherewithal to produce meth in large quantities — and the continued need for the revenue that it brings.

Developments in Monterrey


Late in the evening of July 8, approximately 15 gunman entered the Sabino Gordo bar on Villagran Street in the bar district of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, shooting and killing 20 people and wounding at least six. Two days later, narcomantas banners, reportedly hung by Los Zetas, appeared in a number of Mexican cities in addition to Monterrey, including San Luis Potosi, Juarez and Mexico City, claiming the Gulf cartel was behind the shooting at the Sabino Gordo bar.
Some of the narcomantas also stated the violence directed at civilians was meant to “heat up” the plaza in Monterrey, and the one hung in Juarez said the Gulf cartel was desperate and could not fight with Los Zetas. It said Gulf was simply trying to divert attention away from Reynosa and Diaz Ordaz in Tamaulipas state. Just as Los Zetas have engaged in random grenade attacks over the last month or two in Matamoros to destabilize the Gulf cartel’s footing in that city, it may be that Gulf intends to create problems for the Zetas in Monterrey. It is odd that Los Zetas would hang such narcomantas in distant cities and not just in the northeastern region, and these developments should be monitored to determine whether the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas are headed for a major confrontation in Monterrey.

Anomaly in Torreon


Over the past week in Torreon, Coahuila state, 10 decapitated bodies were found piled in an SUV. According to the Mexican attorney general’s office, the heads were not with the bodies but were scattered around the city. At least one message was found, reportedly with the bodies, but authorities have not released its contents. Mexican media say the message addressed “a rival gang,” but this has not been verified.
STRATFOR finds the event somewhat anomalous in terms of location, severity and timing. There may be a link to the recent captures of top cartel leaders Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon (Los Zetas) and Jose de Jesus “El Chango” Mendez Vargas (LFM). Also, the Mexican military is making a concerted effort to track down and capture or kill Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez, the leader of the Knights Templar, the former LFM faction that split from its parent cartel in early 2011 and has been attacking LFM relentlessly ever since.



July 5


  • Thirteen unidentified gunmen died in a firefight with the Mexican military in Rio Bravo, Tamaulipas state.
  • Nicolas Mora “El Nico” Ovando, the leader of the criminal group La Oficina, was killed during a shootout with the Mexican navy and police at his residence in Aguascalientes, Aguascalientes state.
  • Mexican police discovered 200 kilograms (about 440 pounds) of marijuana along with a cache of rifles, ammunition, camouflage uniforms and berets with symbols associated with Los Zetas in Vallecillo, Nuevo Leon state.

July 6


  • Mexican authorities seized approximately 30 tons of chemical precursors for synthetic-drug production in Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan state.
  • Police discovered a Los Zetas workshop in Fresnillo, Zacatecas state, used to manufacture armored vehicles.

July 7


  • The police chief of Sabinas Hidalgo, Nuevo Leon state, and eight other police officers were arrested for having ties to Los Zetas.
  • Seven people, including two minors, were killed by a group of armed men in San Dimas, Durango state.
  • Six dismembered bodies were discovered in the towns of Taxco, Guerrero and Tlacotepec in Guerrero state.

July 8


  • Four gunmen were killed in a confrontation with federal forces in Apatzingan, Michoacan state.
  • Eleven members of the Knights Templar were arrested in Mexico state, including the leader of the small group, Julio Cesar Garcia “El Chito” Hernandez.
  • Unknown attackers detonated a grenade in Coquimatlan, Colima state, but no one was injured.

July 9


  • Ten headless bodies were discovered in an SUV parked in Torreon, Coahuila state. Soon after the discovery, their heads were found in various locations throughout the city.
  • Gunmen opened fire on a rival gang at a bar in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, killing 20 people. The gunmen are thought to have targeted a rival gang but most of the victims were employees of the bar.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 10, 2011
Ten decapitated bodies were found in the northern Mexican city of Torreon on July 10, Reuters reported, citing local media. The bodies were placed in the back of a truck and their heads were scattered throughout the city. Authorities said the killers left a message directed at another gang.
July 9, 2011
Battles between Los Zetas and rival cartels killed more than 40 people in 24 hours, federal spokesman Alejandro Poire said July 9, AP reported. At least 20 died when gunmen attacked the Sabino Gordo bar in Monterrey. Eleven bodies shot by rifles were found July 8 near a well on the outskirts of Mexico City, where the gang is fighting the Knights Templar. Ten bodies were found July 9 in Torreon, where the Zetas are fighting the Sinaloa cartel.
July 9, 2011
Mexican marines fought alleged Zetas drug cartel members in northern Mexico on July 8, killing 15 suspected Zetas while six marines were wounded, AP reported. The troops were patrolling San Jose de Lourdes in northern Zacatecas when gunmen opened fire from a safehouse, the navy said in a statement, adding that 17 gunmen were detained.
July 6, 2011 | 1821 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: March 24, 2008

Zeta Leader Nabbed


On July 3 in Atizapan de Zaragoza, Mexico state, another founding member of Los Zetas was captured by Mexican Federal Police. Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon, a former member of the Mexican army’s Special Forces Airmobile Group (GAFE), deserted the army in 1999 and joined the core group that later became known as Los Zetas. He is known to have been third in the Zeta leadership hierarchy after Heriberto “El Lazca” Lazcano Lazcano and Miguel “Z-40” Trevino Morales, both of whom are still at large.
According to statements from the Federal Police, Rejon became responsible for Los Zetas operations in northeastern Mexico shortly after violence erupted in 2010 between the group and the Gulf cartel, its parent organization. Rejon reportedly was in San Luis Potosi when Zeta gunmen Stratfor ambushed two U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in February 2011 and killed agent Jaime Zapata. It is not clear whether Rejon ordered that attack or was aware at the time that it was being conducted, but his role in the Zeta organization in the region does link him to it. Rejon also is being investigated in connection with mass graves found in San Fernando in April and the execution of 72 Guatemalan migrants in August 2010 in the same area.
Los Zetas have taken hits to their leadership over the years, as cartel battles and Mexican military or law enforcement actions have resulted in the killing or capture of nearly three-fourths of the original group of 31 “Zetas Viejos.” But it is important to note that those losses have not diminished the organization’s reach or its operational principles, which are based on the original group’s military and special operations training. Certainly there has been evidence at the foot-soldier level of a reduced level of training, discipline and command and control, such as the Falcon Lake shooting in September 2010. Overall, however, the Los Zetas organization remains large, powerful, self-regenerating and self-correcting.
In other words, it would be a mistake to view El Mamito’s take-down as a significant weakening of Los Zetas, although if he chooses to be cooperative he would be quite a treasure-trove of actionable intelligence for the Mexican government. STRATFOR will follow this situation closely for signs that Mexico is indeed exploiting this resource.

Threats Against U.S. Citizens


Over the last week in northern Mexico, several threats that specifically target U.S. citizens came to light. After five banners appeared June 30 around the city of Juarez in Chihuahua state threatening Gov. Cesar Duarte and accusing his administration of protecting the Sinaloa Federation, graffiti was found in Chihuahua City, the capital of Chihuahua state, threatening to decapitate agents with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA). Other threats surfaced that prompted the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Webb County Sheriff’s Office in Laredo, Texas, to issue warnings against travel to Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, over the July 4 holiday weekend.
The narco-messages in Chihuahua state were explicitly worded threats, and while no evidence of written threats was reported in relation to the Nuevo Laredo travel warning, the security conditions in Tamaulipas indicate that extreme caution is warranted. Sources associated with U.S. law enforcement agencies have indicated that the threats are considered credible and specific enough to be taken very seriously. What STRATFOR finds significant about these threats is that a certain point may have been reached, particularly in Tamaulipas, in which the cost-benefit ratio of attacking U.S. citizens may have tipped in the cartels’ favor. When threats of this sort have been made in the past, the cartels have not followed through for fear of generating too much U.S. attention. But current conditions in Tamaulipas are such that targeting Americans could prove beneficial to the cartels — or at least they may perceive it to be so.
For one thing, the threat could force the Mexican government to reverse the recent military takeover of all law enforcement functions in 22 of the cities in Tamaulipas (including Nuevo Laredo). There are likely large numbers of local police officers who were on cartel payrolls and have been relieved of their official duties. While most of these cartel assets remain at large, they no longer are privy to government information or possess government-issued firearms. Regional news organizations, both north and south of the border, have indicated that the likely intent behind the threat in Tamaulipas is to create an overwhelming security condition that would force the government to reinstate the local police officers in the 22 cities in order to have the manpower to deal with the cartels. This would result in many of the police officers who had been co-opted by the cartels being brought back to their posts, which the cartels would obviously want.
Regarding the threats against U.S. DEA agents operating in Chihuahua state, two points should be made. First, while the narcomantas that threatened that state’s governor were signed by La Linea, the enforcer element of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes cartel (aka the Juarez cartel), the spray-painted graffiti aimed squarely at DEA “Gringos” was not signed. That message, translated, read: “[expletive deleted] Gringos (D.E.A.), we know where you are and we know who you are and where you go. We are going to chop off your [expletive deleted] heads.” Second, because the graffiti was not signed, it raises the question of who wrote it and why.
Our working theory is that the message threatening the DEA was left by La Linea. La Linea has been hit hard over the past few years by both aggression from the Sinaloa Federation and government pressure. However, while they are down they are not yet out and like a wounded animal, could still prove to be quite dangerous.
For these reasons, STRATFOR is taking these latest threats seriously and will continue to try to determine their veracity. We recommend that Americans living in or traveling to these areas err on the side of caution.


June 27


  • Eighty undocumented migrants from Central American countries were kidnapped in southern Mexico. On board a train heading from Oaxaca to Veracruz, the migrants were abducted by armed men wearing ski masks.
  • Approximately 700 municipal police officers protested the presence of the Mexican army in Nuevo Laredo.
  • Gunmen shot and killed two people after entering bar in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state. The gunmen escaped while engaging in a firefight with municipal police near the bar.
  • The alleged Los Zetas boss in Quintana Roo state, Javier Altamirano Terrones aka El Pelon, was detained in Cancun, Quintana Roo state, in a joint operation by the Mexican navy, army and Federal Police.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed Santa Catarina police chief German Perez at his office in Santa Catarina, Nuevo Leon state. Seven police officers near the scene at the time of the shooting were arrested June 28 in connection with the killing.

June 28


  • The Mexican military discovered an underground drug lab in San Antonio, Sinaloa state. The lab occupied two floors and was equipped with an elevator and a ventilation system. Military officials discovered 260 kilograms (about 573 pounds) of methamphetamine as well as chemicals and equipment for manufacturing the drug.
  • A federal court issued a 40-day curfew through the Office for Special Investigations on Organized Crime to be imposed against 24 police officers in Tarimbaro, Michoacan state. The officers are suspected of having links to La Familia Michoacana.

June 29


  • The Mexican military clashed with gunmen linked to organize crime in Villarin, Veracruz state. At least three gunmen were killed and five more were detained during the confrontation.

June 30


  • An elite police unit was ambushed by armed men along Highway 15 in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state. One police officer was killed and six were wounded in the ensuing firefight.
  • Five dead bodies were discovered by police on a street in Juarez, Chihuahua state. More than 20 spent shell casings were also found on the street.
  • The director of municipal police in Turicato, Michoacan state, was arrested by the Mexican army for extortion of the local population. The director was in possession of marijuana and firearms when he was detained.
  • The Mexican military killed a Los Zetas boss in Garcia, Nuevo Leon state, about 30 kilometers (18 miles) from Monterrey. Hernando Rodriguez Hernandez, aka El Fabuloso, was in charge of Zeta operations in several municipalities in Nuevo Leon.

July 1


  • A firefight erupted between the Mexican navy and as many as 250 gunmen likely linked to Los Zetas in Fresnillo, Zacatecas state, leaving at least 13 gunmen killed. The gunmen had used vehicles to establish roadblocks throughout the city.

July 2


  • At least 40 gunmen attacked a police headquarters in Morelia, Michoacan state, arriving in more than 10 vehicles and using grenades and small arms. Three of the gunmen were killed and two were detained while three policemen were wounded.

July 3


  • A founding member and third in command of Los Zetas, Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon, was detained by Mexican police in Mexico City. Rejon is linked to the killing of two U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers in February.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

July 4, 2011
Mexican police arrested top Zetas cartel lieutenant Jesus “El Mamito” Rejon in a Mexico City suburb July 3, according to a July 4 Security Ministery statement, Reuters reported. Rejon was linked to the murder of a U.S. immigration agent in February, the ministry stated, adding that police captured Rejon “without firing a shot.”
July 4, 2011 | 1402 GMT
Monster Trucks in Mexico: The Zetas Armor Up
Summary
Over the past year, six “up-armored” dump trucks and heavy-duty conventional trucks have been found in northern and southwestern Mexico, mainly in areas controlled by Los Zetas. The discoveries have suggested a trend in the drug war toward a more armored form of warfare, but this tactical evolution — if that’s what it is — is still in its most rudimentary phase. Their ingenuity notwithstanding, Los Zetas appear to be the only Mexican cartel experimenting with the platform, which has yet to prove its tactical worth. It does, however, suggest an ever-deepening cartel conflict, and may lead Mexican law enforcement and rival cartels to acquire equipment needed to counter the threat.
Analysis
The escalation of the drug war in Mexico has long been measured by body count, which has grown consistently each year since the conflict began to intensify. Most observers consider this turning point to have been in December 2006, when newly inaugurated President Felipe Calderon deployed federal troops to the state of Michoacan. But there have been other milestones in the drug war, mainly in the introduction of weaponry and tactics that have made the conflict look more and more like a Stratfor full-blown insurgency. Rocket-propelled grenades, improvised explosive devices, .50-caliber sniper rifles — all have represented transitions in the conflict, when innovative cartel tacticians have expended money, time and thought on new ways to move drugs or defend or seize territory.
Now we have “up-armored” vehicles, which are starting to show up in northern and southwestern Mexico, mainly in areas controlled by Los Zetas. Over the last year, six fully steel-clad dump trucks and heavy-duty conventional trucks have been found in Tamaulipas, Coahuila and Jalisco states, largely in the aftermath of cartel shootouts. The first was an armored Mack dump truck, dubbed “El Monstruo,” or The Monster, which was discovered in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state, on June 30, 2010. For 10 months, El Monstruo was the only known example of this tactical evolution until Mexican authorities found five more armored trucks in rapid succession in May and June 2011. Two monstruos discovered in Ciudad Mier, Tamaulipas state, and Santa Maria de Los Angeles, Jalisco state, built on Ford F-550 “Super Duty” truck chasses (or the equivalent class of truck from Dodge or Chevrolet), were smaller than the original El Monstruo. Then two more modified dump trucks were seized by the Mexican military during a raid on a large fabrication shop in Camargo, Tamaulipas state. The most recent discovery was a monstruo in Progreso, Coahuila state, built on another F-550-type chassis.



In analyzing the introduction of armored vehicles in the Mexican drug war, STRATFOR thought it worthwhile to identify the strengths, weaknesses and potential value of these vehicles in cartel operations. Not surprisingly, the cartel monstruos that have appeared so far are neither stealthy, swift nor agile, but they can withstand more punishment than unarmored vehicles and they do reflect a certain level of ingenuity. And while there are no cartels other than Los Zetas and their associates, as far as we can tell, that are going to such lengths in deploying armored vehicles, other cartels will likely follow suit.
Traditional “armored cars” such as limousines, Jeeps and Suburbans typically associated with executive or dignitary protection are nothing new in Mexico. Many are also used by cartels to transport high-ranking leaders with a certain degree of anonymity. The armored trucks we’re discussing here, however, are much more unusual in appearance, size and purpose. The discovery of these vehicles over the past year, virtually all in the last couple of months, indicates that the cartels are increasingly using such vehicles in their tactical operations.
The fact remains that no amount of armor, however sophisticated, will protect the occupants of a vehicle if something stops it in the kill zone (“on the X”). In the case of these Zeta vehicles, they would protect their occupants from lightly armed municipal and state law enforcement personnel or rival cartel gunmen, and this is not insignificant; the better-armed military units are few and far between compared to the local police. Still, there are many variables that could stop these vehicles in their tracks, including rough terrain, mechanical malfunction and heavier armor-piercing munitions.
Before we dive into the details, it’s important to note that we began our comparative analysis almost a year ago by gathering and reviewing photographs and specifications from government sources and using the first El Monstruo found in Miguel Aleman as our benchmark prototype. STRATFOR has not obtained any actual measurements of the Zeta trucks in question nor have we had direct access to them. Our analysis is based solely on media reports, input from STRATFOR sources, government information, educated estimates and informed extrapolations.

Strengths


The first known example of the Mexican monstruo, the modified Mack dump truck found in Miguel Aleman last summer, is a tandem-axle dump truck with a 10-cubic-yard dump box. The primary prerequisite of any armored vehicle is that it must be capable of handling the extra weight of the armor, and a dump-truck chassis is very well suited to this. Elements added to the manufactured design include closeable firing ports with hinged or sliding steel plates and plates welded in place inside the engine compartment and surrounding the external fuel tanks. On the two Camargo dump trucks, fabricators took the extra step of placing the tanks in the interior compartment. All three of the dump-truck variants have steel slats or louvers shielding the radiators, providing a level of protection from most small-caliber bullets while allowing air to flow through the radiators. Drivers are protected by windows made of ballistic glass rather than simple openings in the steel plate.
Efforts to protect the wheels and tires are also well thought-out. The entire undercarriage of the Miguel Aleman prototype is shielded with one-half-inch steel plate extending almost to the ground, with sliding plates hung at the bottom of the fixed plates on the outside of the tires, allowing the tires to be covered to the ground. This protects the lowest portions of the tires from smaller-caliber bullets while effectively “floating” over rough terrain. This solution was a good answer to a common tactical problem, though it was not repeated in any of the other monstruos found to date.
The two Camargo dump trucks seized in June 2011 have a new and very useful addition to the front bumper that was not found on the Miguel Aleman prototype. Rather than a stout but flat bumper for pushing or ramming, each of the two Camargo trucks has a heavy reinforced wedge added to the bumper, which provides more efficient breaching capabilities. We would expect this tool to be employed in breaking through barricades, checkpoints or building or perimeter walls and would come in handy during a prison break or the storming of a rival cartel compound.
The need for reliable communications was also a consideration in the monstruo modifications. As anyone with a cell phone knows, a weak cellular signal makes calls intermittent. The Miguel Aleman monstruo, in particular, displayed significant foresight in addressing the tactical need for effective communications among Los Zetas operatives. Four boxes are attached to the truck’s mirror brackets, two on each side, with an antenna on the passenger side. A STRATFOR source determined that the boxes are cell-signal booster/repeaters. Why four? Our research indicated that there are four main cellular-service providers in Mexico, which likely would correspond with the number of booster/repeaters on that truck. (It is not likely that all of the cartel foot soldiers and leaders would subscribe to the same service, if for no other reason than operational security.) The booster/repeaters amplify the cellular signal, giving occupants of the truck and anyone within line-of-sight more reliable communications for coordinating activities in remote areas where the cellular signal is spotty.

Weaknesses


Now we turn to the monstruos’ weaknesses, which so far seem to outweigh their strengths. With the exception of the original El Monstruo prototype, there was no other effort to protect the vehicles’ tires, nor is there evidence that any of the monstruos were fielded with tactical-grade “run-flat” tires. As manufactured, such tires have an internal structure that prevents them from being completely deformed if they are punctured, allowing the vehicle to retain mobility (in effect, the release of the tire’s air pressure does not result in a flat tire). There are several cost-effective ways to make standard tires more resistant to punctures by bullets or spikes, but these do-it-yourself retrofits will not retain their shape if the rubber is burned and melted. As indicated by the two F-550-type vehicles discovered in May in Ciudad Mier and Santa Maria de Los Angeles, flat conventional tires stopped both vehicles squarely in the kill zone, making them easy targets.
Even a steel plate well-positioned outside of the wheel wells only mitigates this vulnerability, for a .50-caliber round will efficiently perforate the steel plate and probably the tire as well. Furthermore, a true run-flat tire, even one shielded by a 2-inch-thick steel plate, will not remain in place, intact and functional, if it is hit by a rocket-propelled grenade (RPG), a 40 mm grenade or an improvised explosive device (IED) — all of which exist in cartel arsenals. And, of course, it does not take military-grade munitions to deflate conventional tires. U.S. law enforcement agencies report that drug smugglers known to work for the Gulf cartel often throw out dozens of small four-pointed spikes (called “caltrops”) on the U.S. side of the border when they are being pursued by the authorities, and these spikes are very effective at stopping vehicles. Caltrops are simple to make, light in weight and easy to deploy. Perhaps anticipating the caltrop potential, makers of the Progreso monstruo came up with an odd-looking solution: dual wheels on the front axle.
Even some of the monstruos’ strengths have weaknesses. The use of ballistic glass definitely offers more protection than ordinary glass. Because details on these specific vehicles remain spotty, we have technical information on the grade of ballistic glass for only the monstruo seized in Progreso. According to Mexican media reports, that vehicle has level 5 ballistic glass in a grade range from 1 to 7 (the higher the number, the greater the protection). While guarding against gunshots, however, ballistic glass is rendered opaque when it is hit by bullets, and an RPG will penetrate it without any difficulty at all. Regardless of the type of glass found in the Zeta armored trucks, it is apparent that there are significant blind spots in all of the vehicles found so far. Due to the small viewing/shooting ports on the sides and backs of the vehicles, occupants have severely degraded fields of view and therefore limited situational awareness, which can be a fatal flaw.
Regarding vehicle mobility, this is dictated by original vehicle type, transmission (how easily and quickly the gears can be shifted) and the weight of the armor. The three smaller F-550-type monstruos will have a higher acceleration rate, tighter turning radius and lower profile than the larger dump trucks. None of them, though, can be viewed as fast or particularly capable of navigating rough off-road terrain. The lower center of gravity and lighter weights of the smaller monstruos give them more maneuverability on steep or loose terrain (all three of the smaller monstruos are four-wheel drive), but this advantage is offset to some degree by their lower ground clearance. And while the wheel diameters and chassis configurations of the three dump trucks give them much higher ground clearance, they lack four-wheel drive and have a very high center of gravity, which makes them vulnerable to rollovers. With the weight of truck, armor and cargo, the dump truck monstruos would likely sink into sand or mud if forced off of pavement or compacted ground.
Another vulnerability of these vehicles is found in their undercarriages. Because the original vehicles were not designed or manufactured to be armor-shielded, the various components of the undercarriages — drive shaft, axles, tie rods, suspension — are not arranged closely enough together or tucked snugly enough within the trucks’ frames for the undercarriages to be armored and still provide sufficient ground clearance. For that reason, effective shielding beneath the vehicles is not possible — at least not without significantly more modifications than the Zeta fabrication shops apparently have been able to provide so far.
It is also important to note that the steel plate used to shield the monstruos is not military-grade armor but commercial-grade steel plate. The vehicular armor being installed in Zeta fabrication shops is not like that found on military armored vehicles such as tanks and personnel carriers, which are protected by sophisticated alloys with high-density ballistic resistance. The commercial-grade steel on the modified Zeta dump trucks appears to range from the 2-inch-thick steel plate reportedly used on some areas of the Miguel Aleman vehicle to the reported 1-inch plate on both Camargo vehicles. A rough estimate of the square footage of steel plate used to armor the more boxy Camargo dump truck comes to about 626 square feet, which includes the floor, the steel plate surrounding the engine compartment and the bumper and wedge. One-inch steel plate weighs 18 kilograms (about 40 pounds) per square foot, which means the armor cladding that particular dump truck would weigh about 11,350 kilograms.
As for the other Camargo vehicle, the dump box appears armored on the inside, and there is similar armor shielding within the engine compartment and interior of the cab, where it appears that somewhat less steel plate was used. A rough estimate on the weight of the armor for that truck, based upon approximately 553 square feet of steel used, came to 10,230 kilograms. That much weight is supported easily by the trucks’ originally engineered infrastructure, but the costs are high — painfully slow acceleration, minimal speed or maneuverability (relative to unarmored vehicles) and extremely limited utility off-road.
Industrial “heavy lift” chasses, such as those of the tandem-axle dump trucks retrofitted in Miguel Aleman and Camargo, are engineered to have a “working payload capacity” (meaning the quantity of cargo a dump truck can carry above the vehicle’s own weight and that of its fuel supply) of 13,600 to 19,000 kilograms. The wide range is accounted for by the manufacturers’ size and model variations. That means that the manufactured axles, suspensions and chasses of these trucks are perfectly capable of handling the estimated 11,350 kilograms of armor plus the added weight of up to 20 gunmen with weapons, ammunition and gear (another 1,800 to 2,200 kilograms).
Unlike the modified dump trucks, the three smaller monstruos are not capable of carrying the weight of 1-inch or thicker armor. Putting that much weight on an F-550-type chassis would negate its maneuverability and likely result in broken axles or suspension after traveling the first stretch of rough road. So the three armored F-550s, as the photographs suggest, are likely clad in half-inch plate, which weighs 9.2 kilograms per square foot. Half-inch steel is fairly effective in stopping 7.62x39 mm and 5.56x45 mm rounds, which is the common assault-rifle ammunition used by the Mexican cartels and military, and though that thickness will not stop those same calibers if they are armor-piercing rounds, the design of the smaller monstruos could deflect such rounds because the steel is angled rather than perpendicular. It is not known to what extent armor-piercing ammunition is issued to the Mexican military or available to the cartels, though cartel accessibility to that type of ammunition cannot be ruled out.
But the half-inch plate on the three smaller monstruos (with perhaps some 1-inch armor in certain critical places) is still good enough. These retrofitted armored trucks are not intended to be impervious or invincible. They are meant to move fairly quickly over roads and fairly smooth terrain and to protect their occupants against the small-arms fire commonly encountered in a typical firefight. A conservative estimate of the amount of steel used for each of these vehicles might be 350 to 375 square feet. If these vehicles were armored only with half-inch plate, that would put the weight of the armor alone in the range of 3,238 to 3,470 kilograms per vehicle. A full complement of shooters in one vehicle — 10 to 12 gunmen, say, plus a driver and maybe a navigator riding shotgun — as well as weapons and ammunition would add another 1,100 to 1,350 kilograms, which means that one of the smaller monstruos likely would be carrying a total payload of at least 4,350 to 4,800 kilograms. Certainly, the heavy-duty F-550 chasses can handle that much weight, since the manufacturer’s specifications indicate a maximum working payload of 5,400 pounds.

Conclusions


So is the advent of the monstruo a significant event in Mexico’s drug war? The short answer is yes. In Mexico, the vast majority of confrontations between these vehicles and security personnel would involve local cops with handguns. Even the smaller monstruos with thinner armor would offer more than sufficient protection in most cases. It is not clear whether any of the six highly modified steel-clad trucks were retrofitted for specific tasks or general-purpose use, but even in a clash with heavily armed military or cartel forces, all would offer distinct advantages over regular “street vehicles” (with certain trade-offs in speed and maneuverability, particularly for the larger dump trucks). Because all of the trucks offer both high passenger capacity and increased ballistic protection, it is possible that their most likely purpose was to insert gunmen as far into a target area as possible.
Given the design differences among the six monstruos, there are probably more fabrication shops in Zeta territory producing such vehicles than the one raided June 4 in Camargo. Based on the examples under discussion and three distinct types of configurations reflected by these examples, we believe there are at least two more fabrication shops producing armored vehicles for Los Zetas. However, while there seem to be some “lessons learned” evident from vehicle to vehicle, there are no signs of design or technology transfer from shop to shop.
The two Camargo trucks appear to have the ability to breach most walls with ease, due to the design of the wedge on their front bumpers and the massive weight and power behind that wedge. These trucks would be very useful in springing Zeta leaders from prison or pushing through Gulf cartel barricades, and they would offer effective protection in convoys (though not if subtlety is desired when traveling through enemy territory). Of course, as a tool for intimidating municipal police and civilian populations, the monstruos have a great deal of psychological value. But both the Mexican military and other cartels possess the weaponry and ability to stop them. There is also a negative psychological factor in play with these vehicles for their operators: If Los Zetas believe these armored trucks make them invincible, they could become overconfident and prone to tactical miscalculations that the Mexican military can exploit.
We fully expect to see more Zeta monstruos in Mexico, and evolving designs that mitigate initial weaknesses. We also expect to see other cartels develop monstruos of their own. When the first truck was found last year, it seemed to us to be an anomaly. The discovery of the second, last month, made it a trend. That trend became a pattern this month, with the existence now of six heavily modified armored vehicles. We believe there will be more. And as Los Zetas become better armed and more heavily armored, they will become an even more difficult to rein in by local — or even federal — law enforcement.
Another important aspect of the monstruo introduction is what it says about Mexico’s deteriorating security environment. It was already getting worse, and Los Zetas apparently made a strategic decision to raise the violence to even greater heights. Should more monstruos emerge, we anticipate that the Mexican government will try to acquire anti-armor weapons from the United States or any other government that will supply them. More monstruos will beget more powerful military-grade munitions to take them out, and the overall effect — whether it is part of the Zeta calculus or not — will be an intensifying arms race that will not be good for anyone.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

June 2011
June 28, 2011
Central Asian countries should set up special national departements to more efficiently fight drug trafficking from Afghanistan, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs William Brownfield said June 28, Interfax reported. Brownfield said that the Central Asian Regional Information and Coordination Center for Combating Illicit Trafficking of Narcotic Drugs could coordinate the departments.
June 27, 2011 | 2114 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Aug. 17, 2009

El Chango’s Arrest


The leader of a faction of La Familia Michoacana (LFM) — the faction that continues to use the LFM name — was arrested June 21 without incident in Stratfor Aguascalientes state in central Mexico. At the time of his arrest, Jose de Jesus “El Chango” Mendez Vargas and his branch of the LFM were under heavy pressure from the other LFM faction, known as the Knights Templar (KT) and led by Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez, as well as from Mexican authorities and the Sinaloa Federation.
Mendez Vargas’ arrest clearly is a Stratfor short-term blow to his faction of LFM, but it is too early to tell if it will result in the end of the group. More important, it is unclear what effect it will have on the battle for control of the drug flow through Michoacan state.
Mendez Vargas’ faction of the LFM is the weaker of the two currently fighting for control of the LFM territory and business. In fact, STRATFOR sources and media reports indicate that Mendez Vargas’ faction was losing the battle against the Knights Templar. Mendez Vargas’ forces had experienced some significant losses in the weeks prior to his arrest, and banners posted by the Knights Templar alleged that Mendez Vargas was so desperate that he had even reached out to his former enemies in Los Zetas for assistance.
Presently, it appears that the Knights Templar has placed itself in a position to assume control of the LFM empire. The Knights Templar is a local organization with local support, and many of its members have a long history of close ties to the community. However, after being weakened by the fight with Mendez Vargas’ faction, it is not altogether clear if the Knights Templar will have the strength to fend off a renewed push by its enemies in the Sinaloa Federation. It is also possible that the remnants of Mendez Vargas’ organization will become even more closely aligned with Los Zetas, which will allow the Zetas to expand their presence in Michoacan by working through locals. All this means that the capture of Mendez Vargas may have removed one cartel leader, but it will likely do little to quell the violence in the state.

Troops in Tamaulipas


Around 2,800 Mexican soldiers deployed during the week of June 19 to 22 cities in Tamaulipas state along the U.S.-Mexico border. The objective of the deployment is to put the military in charge of security operations in the state while stamping out corruption in local police forces. After relieving all officers of duty, the military will conduct interviews and drug tests on new officers to determine who will receive further training and continue in law enforcement. Many of the officers who are not rehired likely will begin working for the cartels.
The military has taken control in Reynosa, Nuevo Laredo, Matamoros and San Fernando, border towns that saw violence increase just last week, along with the state capital of Victoria. An audacious raid in Matamoros by Los Zetas on June 17 looked to be an indication that the violence was only going to get worse in Tamaulipas. In this context it is not surprising that the Tamaulipas state government felt the need to ask the federal government for help.
The government position is that the presence of the military in Tamaulipas will lead to a decrease in violence. However, statistics on murders in Juarez, Chihuahua state, where the military took control in early March 2009, are evidence that military deployments do not necessarily correlate with a reduction in violence. In 2008, prior to the deployment, there were 1,600 murders in Juarez attributed to organized crime, according to Spanish newspaper Diario Universal. In 2009, the number went up to 2,650. The attorney general’s office in the state’s northern zone reported 3,200 murders in 2010, and as of June 15 there were already 1,500 murders on record for 2011.
The military cannot be everywhere at once, and it would take far more than 2,800 soldiers to secure the entire state of Tamaulipas. Cartels know the military presence will not last forever, so while there occasionally can be direct conflicts, more often the cartels will hunker down and wait for the military to leave or simply strike where the military has no presence.
Also, the Mexican military cannot risk being in a location too long because it faces the same corruptive forces that continually destroy the police departments. The longer the military comes in contact with those forces, the harder it is to guarantee soldiers are not being corrupted. The value of the military is that it has long been kept separate from the drug war and therefore has not been the focus of the cartels’ corruption efforts. This is already changing, and authorities must be careful with using the military to fight the war.
Another issue is that populations tend to tire of the presence of soldiers, who lack the police skills and training necessary to manage a civilian population. An extended deployment increases the chances of an incident that could upset the locals, and at the very least it is a hindrance to civilians’ daily lives.
The arrival of the military in Tamaulipas state is not a guarantee of security and tranquility. Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel are currently locked in a brutal battle for control of the northeast. The way they fight their battle may be altered a bit due to the presence of the military, but we believe that based on the experience of past military deployments in places such as Juarez, the violence between the two groups will continue despite the deployment.



June 20


  • A journalist, his wife and son were found murdered in their house in Veracruz, Veracruz state. The journalist, the second murdered in the state this month, wrote about crime and politics for the newspaper Notiver.
  • Five bodies were found throughout Michoacan state with a narcomanta on each claiming responsibility on behalf of the Knights Templar.
  • The police chief in Morelia, Michoacan state, was detained for possession of drugs and weapons for military use only.
  • More than three tons of methamphetamine and precursor chemicals were found in an industrial area of El Marques, Queretaro state.

June 21


  • A cache of weapons and military tactical gear, including camouflage uniforms, were found in Coneto de Comonfort, Durango state.
  • The burned bodies of three traffic cops were found on the street in Guadalupe, Chihuahua state.
  • Eight suspected members of the Knights Templar were detained in Piedras de Lumbre, Michoacan state. Among the detained were the group’s leaders in Tuxpan and Zitacuaro, Michoacan state.

June 22


  • A man’s body was found in Jesus Maria, Aguascalientes state, with a narcomanta alluding to the detention of Mendez Vargas, the LFM head who was detained by police the previous day.
  • A group of marines was ambushed by unknown gunmen in Panuco, Zacatecas state, leaving one marine dead.
  • The police chief in Praxedis G. Guerrero, Chihuahua state, and her family were attacked and held at knifepoint during a robbery in the state of Chihuahua.
  • The municipal police chief of Ciudad Isla, Veracruz state, Ricardo Reyes Alvarez, was attacked by gunmen. The police chief was killed and three others were injured in the attack.
  • Three individuals working for the criminal organization led by Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal were detained in Tlaltizapan, Morelos state. The suspects were arrested with two kilograms (more than four pounds) of marijuana, one kilogram of cocaine and firearms.

June 23


  • A group of suspected extortionists opened fire on an escort vehicle in the convoy of Julian Leyzaola Perez, the municipal security chief in Ciudad Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. One attacker was injured in the ensuing firefight.
  • Seven individuals suspected of belonging to a gang of kidnappers operating in Pachuca and Mineral de la Reforma were detained in Hidalgo state. The individuals are responsible for at least two kidnappings and one murder.
  • Seventy-eight Central American migrants were detained at a railway station in Irolo, Hidalgo state. Among the migrants were Hondurans, Salvadoreans, and Guatemalans.

June 24


  • Ninety-one police officers were arrested in Tlaxcala, Tlaxcala state, on charges of robbery and collusion among public officials.
  • Four Salvadorans were arrested in San Salvador, El Salvador, in connection to the August 2010 massacre in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state, that left 72 immigrants dead. The Salvadorans were responsible for transferring undocumented migrants to Mexico.
  • Approximately 60 undocumented migrants were kidnapped by armed men in Veracruz. The migrants were on a freight train headed from Oaxaca to Veracruz when the train was stopped by three vehicles parked in its path.
  • Eleven graves containing human remains were found in Nuevo Leon by the Mexican army.
  • The Mexican government announced the deployment of around 2,800 Mexican troops to Tamaulipas to take charge of public safety and counter corruption within the police force.

June 25


  • Mexican Federal Police captured alleged Los Zetas leader Albert Gonzalez Pena, aka “El Tigre,” in Xalapa, Veracruz state. He was responsible for moving drugs farther into northern and central Mexico and was also linked to various other criminal activities in Veracruz state.
  • Nine women from the Institutional Revolutionary Party were assaulted and received death threats allegedly due to political affiliations in Pachuca, Hidalgo state. The attackers are allegedly working for the campaign of a rival candidate.
  • Seven bodies were found in the municipalities of Ixtapaluca and Valle de Chalco, Mexico state. A message from LFM was left with them.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

June 23, 2011
Mexican military authorities have deployed 2,290 soldiers to the 22 municipalities in Tamaulipas state to aid state security forces, Vanguardia reported June 23. Municipal mayors have established contact with military commanders and are prepared to officially introduce the soldiers to their law enforcement duties.
June 22, 2011
Recently arrested La Familia Michoacana (LFM) drug cartel leader Jose de Jesus Mendez Vargas sought an alliance with the Los Zetas drug cartel, Mexican Federal Police anti-narcotics chief Ramon Pequeno said, AP reported June 22. Pequeno said financial issues and internal fighting caused Mendez to seek the alliance before he was arrested.
June 22, 2011 | 1218 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: April 26, 2011

Zeta Raid or Rescue?


Around 5 a.m. on June 17, simultaneous firefights reportedly broke out between elements of the Gulf and Los Zetas cartels in several locations in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, a Gulf stronghold. The Mexican military has confirmed that a gunbattle did indeed take place in the Colonia Pedro Moreno area but has not confirmed media reports of additional firefights in the Mariano Matamoros, Valle Alto, Puerto Rico and Seccion 16 neighborhoods. The military also has not confirmed a reported gunbattle in the rural area of Cabras Pintas, where six Mexican soldiers are said to have been killed.
Details of the confirmed firefight remain unclear, but from all indications, a large movement of Zeta forces into a Gulf stronghold did occur, and it suggests a heightened operational tempo in the war between these two cartels. In the coming months, this increasing violence is likely to continue in Gulf-held Reynosa and Zeta-held Monterrey as well as Matamoros.
The Mexican military said the June 17 gunbattle in Matamoros’ Colonia Pedro Moreno neighborhood resulted in three deaths and nine arrests, while an unnamed U.S. law enforcement official said four Gulf cartel gunmen died in the exchange of fire. According to a Mexican army officer quoted in border media, a Mexican army “mechanized regiment” was patrolling in trucks in downtown Matamoros when the fighting erupted but did not participate. The media also quoted a U.S. law enforcement official confirming the presence of another mechanized regiment and claiming that this other regiment of soldiers traveling in trucks supported Los Zetas in an attempt to rescue 11 Zeta operatives, both male and female, who had been captured by the Gulf cartel June 16.
For its part, the Mexican military said a motorized army unit rescued 17 civilians who had been kidnapped, although it is uncertain how an army unit could have achieved this without being a part of the operation or participating in the firefight. At some point during the gunbattle, the leader of Los Zetas, Heriberto “El Lazca” Lazcano Lazcano, was reportedly killed, although STRATFOR doubts that he was present.
While reports of the Matamoros battle are conflicting, it is very likely that a large firefight did occur in the city between the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas and that it was initiated by the latter. Due to the conflicting information, we have been unable to determine the motive behind the Zeta assault, which reportedly involved a force of armed Zetas in 130 SUVs. However, we have seen several large Zeta raids into Gulf territory in recent months intended to undercut Gulf’s support network, and this raid into Matamoros would have been the largest one yet (at least that we are aware of).
Zeta leader El Lazca, a former member of the army’s Grupo Aeromovil de Fuerzas Especiales (GAFES), an elite special operations unit, is an “old Zeta.” He has good tactical and operational awareness and has proved himself to be a very rational decision-maker. Moving a convoy of 130 SUV’s nearly a half mile long (if they were bumper to bumper) into the heart of Gulf territory could not have achieved any element of surprise, which means Lazcano probably thought his force was large enough to accomplish the mission even if it was detected well in advance.
If the objective of this raid was to recover the 11 Zetas reportedly captured by Gulf forces, those prisoners must have been extremely valuable to the Zetas and possibly to Lazcano personally. Low-ranking members of an organization are typically not worth potential losses incurred in such an operation.
The reports that a motorized Mexican army regiment took part in the firefight alongside Zeta gunmen are likely untrue. While there is a corrupt element within the military, the chance of an entire regiment operating with cartel gunmen is quite remote. It is not uncommon for individual soldiers and smaller military units to be found in the employ of cartels, and perhaps a small element was working with Los Zetas, but it could not have been a Mexican army regiment, which would number some 1,000 to 3,000 troops.
Whether the Zeta Matamoros raid was a deliberate strike against the Gulf cartel’s power base or an attempt to rescue a group of Zeta prisoners, we have been expecting to see this type of Zeta offensive action for several months now. People and businesses should be aware of the probability of increasing violence in the coming months in Matamoros, Reynosa and Monterrey.


June 15


  • Gunmen killed two bodyguards of Nuevo Leon state Gov. Rodrigo Medina. Police found the bodies near a market in Monterrey with a written warning to the governor. At least 33 people with links to organized crime were murdered June 15, the bloodiest day in recent history in Monterrey.
  • The chief of police in Guantajuato, Guantajuato state, was arrested for the murder of three individuals at an inn. Four unidentified gunmen killed the three individuals the morning of June 15. Three hours later, Martin Rodriguez Olvera was arrested for a link to the killings.
  • The attorney general’s office in Colima state announced La Familia Michoacan had ordered the murder of the former Gov. Jesus Silverio Cavazos in November 2010.
  • Marco Antonio “El Brad Pitt” or “El Dos” Guzman Zuniga, the second in command of La Linea, was arrested, along with two other La Linea members in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state, on June 15 by Mexican police. The Juarez cartel created La Linea as an enforcer group, led by Jose Antonio Acosta Hernandez. Guzman Zuniga operated as a right-hand man for Acosta Hernandez and is responsible for coordinating drug trafficking and executing individuals who do not cooperate with the Juarez cartel. Another La Linea boss, Jose Guadalupe “El Zucaritas” Rivas Gonzalez, was detained in Chihuahua on June 17.

June 16


  • The State Investigation Agency of Nuevo Leon and the Mexican army arrested 26 police in Zuazua, Nuevo Leon state.
  • The director of tourism in Cosala, Sinaloa state, was shot and killed at his home in Cosala.

June 17


  • The Knights Templar posted narcomantas in cities throughout Michoacan state professing their commitment to serving the community and calling La Familia Michoacana and Los Zetas traitors to Mexico.
  • Gunbattles reportedly erupted between elements of the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas in several areas of Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, leaving at least 10 individuals dead. Some reports indicate that Los Zetas leader Heriberto “El Lazca” Lazcano Lazcano was killed in the fighting.
  • Jose Guadalupe Rivas Gonzalez aka “El Zucaritas” was arrested by Mexican authorities in Chihuahua City, Chihuahua state. Gonzales is a close associate of Jose Antonio Acosta Hernandez, a La Linea leader.
  • Edgar Huerta Montiel, a member of Los Zetas, was arrested in Zacatecas state. He allegedly participated in a killing of at least 72 migrants in Tamaulipas.

June 18


  • Eight bodies were found in Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan state, believed to have been individuals kidnapped by the Knights Templar. A message was attached to one of the bodies saying anyone associated with Chango Mendez, leader of La Familia Michoacan, will meet a similar fate.
  • Seven police officers were arrested for the murder of a Mexican marine in Tuxpan, Veracruz state. The marine was killed on June 10, one of three marines found dead whose bodies showed signs of torture.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

June 21, 2011
Mexican federal police officers arrested Jose de Jesus Mendez, the leader of drug cartel La Familia Michoacana (LFM), in the municipality of Cosio, Aguascalientes state, Milenio reported June 21. Mendez will be transferred to Mexico City by helicopter.
June 17, 2011
Washington is keeping the National Guard on the U.S.-Mexico border for at least three more months to help the Border Patrol prevent people sneaking across the border, AP reported June 17. In 2010, 1,200 soldiers were deployed to Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California to assist in border security. The Defense Department will spend $35 million to extend the deployment, originally set to end June 30, until the end of September.
June 16, 2011
Mexican federal police officers arrested Marco Antonio Guzman Zuniga, the suspected head of criminal organization La Linea, in Chihuahua, Chihuahua state, Milenio reported June 16. Guzman Zuniga is believed to be responsible for detonating an improvised explosive device in a vehicle in Ciudad Juarez on July 15, 2010.
June 16, 2011

Protective Intelligence Lessons from an Ambush in Mexico

By Scott Stewart
We talk to a lot of people in our effort to track Mexico’s criminal cartels and to help our readers understand the Stratfor dynamics that shape the violence in Mexico. Our contacts include a wide range of people, from Mexican and U.S. government officials, journalists and business owners to taxi drivers and street vendors. Lately, as we’ve been talking with people, we’ve been hearing chatter about the 2012 presidential election in Mexico and how the cartel war will impact that election.
In any democratic election, opposition parties always criticize the policies of the incumbent. This tactic is especially true when the country is involved in a long and costly war. Recall, for example, the 2008 U.S. elections and then-candidate Barack Obama’s criticism of the Bush administration’s policies regarding Iraq and Afghanistan. This strategy is what we are seeing now in Mexico with the opposition Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) and Democratic Revolutionary Party (PRD) criticizing the way the administration of Felipe Calderon, who belongs to the National Action Party (PAN), has prosecuted its war against the Mexican cartels.
One of the trial balloons that the opposition parties — especially the PRI — seem to be floating at present is the idea that if they are elected they will reverse Calderon’s policy of going after the cartels with a heavy hand and will instead try to reach some sort of accommodation with them. This policy would involve lifting government pressure against the cartels and thereby (ostensibly) reducing the level of violence that is wracking the country. In effect, this stratagem would be a return of the status quo ante during the PRI administrations that ruled Mexico for decades prior to 2000. One other important thing to remember, however, is that while Mexico’s tough stance against the cartels is most often associated with President Calderon, the policy of using the military against the cartels was established during the administration of President Vicente Fox (also of PAN), who declared the “mother of all battles” against cartel kingpins in January 2005.
While this political rhetoric may be effective in tapping public discontent with the current situation in Mexico — and perhaps obtaining votes for opposition parties — the current environment in Mexico is far different from what it was in the 1990s. This environment will dictate that no matter who wins the 2012 election, the new president will have little choice but to maintain the campaign against the Mexican cartels.

Changes in the Drug Flow


First, it is important to understand that over the past decade there have been changes in the flow of narcotics into the United States. The first of these changes was in the way that cocaine is trafficked from South America to the United Sates and in the specific organizations that are doing that trafficking. While there has always been some cocaine smuggled into the United States through Mexico, like during the “Miami Vice” era from the 1970s to the early 1990s, much of the U.S. supply came into Florida via Caribbean routes. The cocaine was trafficked mainly by the powerful Colombian cartels, and while they worked with Mexican partners such as the Guadalajara cartel to move product through Mexico and into the United States, the Colombians were the dominant partners in the relationship and pocketed the lion’s share of the profits.
As U.S. interdiction efforts curtailed much of the Caribbean drug flow due to improvements in aerial and maritime surveillance, and as the Colombian cartels were dismantled by the Colombian and U.S. governments, Mexico became more important to the flow of cocaine and the Mexican cartels gained more prominence and power. Over the past decade, the tables turned. Now, the Mexican cartels control most of the cocaine flow and the Colombian gangs are the junior partners in the relationship.
The Mexican cartels have expanded their control over cocaine smuggling to the point where they are also involved in the smuggling of South American cocaine to Europe and Australia. This expanded cocaine supply chain means that the Mexican cartels have assumed a greater risk of loss along the extended supply routes, but it also means that they earn a far greater percentage of the profit derived from South American cocaine than they did when the Colombian cartels called the shots.
While Mexican cartels have always been involved in the smuggling of marijuana to the U.S. market, and marijuana sales serve as an important profit pool for them, the increasing popularity of other drugs in the United States in recent years, such as black-tar heroin and methamphetamine, has also helped bring big money (and power) to the Mexican cartels. These drugs have proved to be quite lucrative for the Mexican cartels because the cartels own the entire production process. This is not the case with cocaine, which the cartels have to purchase from South American suppliers.
These changes in the flow of narcotics into the United States mean that the Mexican narcotics-smuggling corridors into the United States are now more lucrative than ever for the Mexican cartels, and the increasing value of these corridors has heightened the competition — and the violence — to control them. The fighting has become quite bloody and, in many cases, quite personal, involving blood vendettas that will not be easily buried.
The violence occurring in Mexico today also has quite a different dynamic from the violence that occurred in Colombia in the late 1980s. In Colombia at that time, Pablo Escobar declared war on the government, and his team of sicarios conducted terrorist attacks like Stratfor destroying the Department of Administrative Security headquarters with a huge truck bomb and bombing a civilian airliner in an attempt to kill a presidential candidate, among other operations. Escobar thought his attacks could intimidate the Colombian government into the kind of accommodation being in discussed in Mexico today, but his calculation was wrong and the attacks served only to steel public opinion and government resolve against him.
Most of the violence in Mexico today is cartel-on-cartel, and the cartels have not chosen to explicitly target civilians or the government. Even the violence we do see directed against Mexican police officers or government figures is usually not due to their positions but to the perception that they are on the payroll of a competing cartel. There are certainly exceptions to this, but cartel attacks against government figures are usually attempts to undercut the support network of a competing cartel and not acts of retribution against the government. Cartel groups like Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG) have even produced and distributed video statements in which they say they don’t want to fight the federal government and the military, just corrupt officers aligned with their enemies.
This dynamic means that, even if the Mexican military and federal police were to ease up on their operations against drug-smuggling activities, the war among the cartels (and factions of cartels) would still continue.

The Hydra


In addition to the raging cartel-on-cartel violence, any future effort to reach an accommodation with the cartels will also be hampered by the way the cartel landscape has changed over the past few years. Consider this: Three and a half years ago, the Beltran Leyva Organization (BLO) was a part of the Sinaloa Federation. Following the arrest of Alfredo Beltran Leyva in January 2008, Alfredo’s brothers blamed Sinaloa chief Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, declared war on El Chapo and split from the Sinaloa Federation to form their own organization. Following the December 2009 death of Alfredo’s brother, Arturo Beltran Leyva, the organization further split into two factions: One was called the Cartel Pacifico del Sur, which was led by the remaining Beltran Leyva brother, Hector, and the other, which retained the BLO name, remained loyal to Alfredo’s chief of security, Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal. Following the August 2010 arrest of La Barbie, his faction of the BLO split into two pieces, one joining with some local criminals in Acapulco to form the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA). So not only did the BLO leave the Sinaloa Federation, it also split twice to form three new cartels.
There are two main cartel groups, one centered on the Sinaloa Federation and the other on Los Zetas, but these groups are loose alliances rather than hierarchical organizations, and there are still many smaller independent players, such as CIDA, La Resistencia and the CJNG. This means that a government attempt to broker some sort of universal understanding with the cartels in order to decrease the violence would be far more challenging than it would have been a decade ago.
Even if the government could gather all these parties together and convince them to agree to cease hostilities, the question for all parties would be: How reliable are all the promises being made? The various cartels frequently make alliances and agreements, only to break them, and close allies can quickly become the bitterest enemies — like the Gulf cartel and its former enforcer wing, Los Zetas.
We have heard assertions over the last several years that the Calderon administration favors the Sinaloa Federation and that the president’s real plan to quell the violence in Mexico is to allow or even assist the Sinaloa Federation to become the dominant cartel in Mexico. According to this narrative, the Sinaloa Federation could impose peace through superior firepower and provide the Mexican government a single point of contact instead of the various heads of the cartel hydra. One problem with implementing such a concept is that some of the most vicious violence Mexico has seen in recent years has followed an internal split involving the Sinaloa Federation, such as the BLO/Sinaloa war.

From DTO to TCO


Another problem is the change that has occurred in the nature of the crimes the cartels commit. The Mexican cartels are no longer just drug cartels, and they no longer just sell narcotics to the U.S. market. This reality is even reflected in the bureaucratic acronyms that the U.S. government uses to refer to the cartels. Up until a few months ago, it was common to hear U.S. government officials refer to the Mexican cartels using the acronym “DTOs,” or drug trafficking organizations. Today, that acronym is rarely, if ever, heard. It has been replaced by “TCO,” which stands for transnational criminal organization. This acronym recognizes that the Mexican cartels engage in many criminal enterprises, not just narcotics smuggling.
As the cartels have experienced difficulty moving large loads of narcotics into the United States due to law enforcement pressure, and the loss of smuggling corridors to rival gangs, they have sought to generate revenue by diversifying their lines of business. Mexican cartels have become involved in kidnapping, extortion, cargo theft, oil theft and diversion, arms smuggling, human smuggling, carjacking, prostitution and music and video piracy. These additional lines of business are lucrative, and there is little likelihood that the cartels would abandon them even if smuggling narcotics became easier.
As an aside, this diversification is also a factor that must be considered in discussing the legalization of narcotics and the impact that would have on the Mexican cartels. Narcotics smuggling is the most substantial revenue stream for the cartels, but is not their only line of business. If the cartels were to lose the stream of revenue from narcotics sales, they would still be heavily armed groups of killers who would be forced to rely more on their other lines of business. Many of these other crimes, like extortion and kidnapping, by their very nature focus more direct violence against innocent victims than drug trafficking does.
Another way the cartels have sought to generate revenue through alternative means is to increase drug sales inside Mexico. While drugs sell for less on the street in Mexico than they do in the United States, they require less overhead, since they don’t have to cross the U.S. border. At the same time, the street gangs that are distributing these drugs into the local Mexican market have also become closely allied with the cartels and have served to swell the ranks of the cartel enforcer groups. For example, Mara Salvatrucha has come to work closely with Los Zetas, and Los Aztecas have essentially become a wing of the Juarez cartel.
There has been a view among some in Mexico that the flow of narcotics through Mexico is something that might be harmful for the United States but doesn’t really harm Mexico. Indeed, as the argument goes, the money the drug trade generates for the Mexican economy is quite beneficial. The increase in narcotics sales in Mexico belies this, and in many places, such as the greater Mexico City region, much of the violence we’ve seen involves fighting over turf for local drug sales and not necessarily fighting among the larger cartel groups (although, in some areas, there are instances of the larger cartel groups asserting their dominance over these smaller local-level groups).
As the Mexican election approaches, the idea of accommodating the cartels may continue to be presented as a logical alternative to the present policies, and it might be used to gain political capital, but anyone who carefully examines the situation on the ground will see that the concept is totally untenable. In fact, the conditions on the ground leave the Mexican president with very little choice. This means that in the same way President Obama was forced by ground realities to follow many of the Bush administration policies he criticized as a candidate, the next Mexican president will have little choice but to follow the policies of the Calderon administration in continuing the fight against the cartels.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
June 14, 2011 | 1741 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Sept. 7, 2010

Military Operations in Coahuila


Over the past week, military operations in Los Zetas-controlled areas of Coahuila state netted large caches of narcotics, firearms — even an armored “monstruo” truck. The first such vehicle found in Coahuila, the monstruo was discovered June 6 near Progreso, between Monclova and the border town of Piedras Negras. An army unit found it concealed in a wooden structure built into a hillside and partially buried. Two days later, a detachment of Mexican marines conducting a raid in Villa Union, just south of the Texas border town of Eagle Pass, reportedly seized 201 assault rifles, some 600 camouflage or black uniforms with boots, several grenade launchers, three sniper rifles (one of which was scoped) and 30,000 rounds of ammunition.
Also on June 8, soldiers seized 16 AK-47 and AR-15 assault rifles in Zaragoza. Then on June 10, an army unit patrolling near Castanos, just south of Monclova, came upon an area of ground that had recently been churned up. Further investigation revealed four underground cisterns in which soldiers found 11 kilograms (24 pounds) of heroin and almost 1,000 kilograms of methamphetamine.
Combined with a munitions cache found June 1 in Nadadores and a ton of cocaine seized May 24 near Monclova, last week’s trove represents a sizable chunk of Zetas inventory. As we discussed in the last Mexico Security Memo, Coahuila has been a relatively quiet front in the cartel wars, except for occasional battles in Torreon and the capital city of Saltillo. But a buildup of military forces is continuing in the state, and large-scale operations over the past two weeks appear to be making an impact.
This is probably due to the confluence of a significantly larger military force in the state and newly acquired actionable intelligence, which enabled the military to conduct more effective operations. And what these military actions are revealing is that Los Zetas apparently have been using the rural areas of the sparsely populated state for years as a secure caching zone. With few people and no major transportation arteries leading to the U.S. border, Coahuila is not a landscape hotly contested by competing cartels. This has no doubt led to some complacency on the part of Los Zetas, and it now appears that their security has been compromised by the Mexican military presence.
According to STRATFOR sources in the region, clashes between federal troops and Zetas operatives may flare up in the near term as direct military actions against Zetas forces and support networks increase. Should Zetas operatives find themselves cornered, their reaction may be full-scale combat, but we anticipate that Los Zetas will use hit-and-run tactics, such as ambushes, sniping attacks and explosive devices, at every opportunity to try to seize the advantage. It also is likely that Los Zetas will use some of those tactics to pull military patrols away from vital caches, so that the narcotics or munitions can be retrieved and relocated — possibly out of the state and perhaps to the Nuevo Laredo area, which also is Zetas territory.
For the most part, however, we believe Los Zetas will try to avoid direct confrontation with the Mexican military whenever possible. Zetas tactics elsewhere have shown that they may fade back when the military has the advantage of numbers or terrain. What is certain, given the organization’s known behavior, is that Zetas surveillance of the military will be vigilant. While we do not yet know the military’s ultimate objective in Coahuila state, we expect its intermediate goals include developing intelligence on Zetas weapons caches and seizing them to undermine Los Zetas’ ability to supply arms to their forces across northern Mexico.

Declaring War on All Rivals


The dismembered remains of three men were found June 7 in Lagunillas, Guanajuato state, with a message indicating they were killed because they were associated with Los Zetas, La Resistencia, the Sinaloa cartel and La Familia Michoacana (LFM). The following day, two more dismembered bodies were found in the same location accompanied by an identical message. In both cases, the messages were signed by Cartel de Jalisco Nueva Generacion (CJNG).
Then on June 9, outside of a bar in Apaseo el Grande, Guanajuato, a group of gunmen shot and killed one woman and two men, a shooting the state attorney general’s office initially attributed to LFM. It also has been reported that the shooting may have been tied to the CJNG, though it is not yet clear whether the gunmen or the victims were members of the cartel.
STRATFOR believes that CJNG consists of former followers of Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal, a high-ranking member of the Sinaloa Federation. In April 2010, Los Zetas executed Coronel’s son, Alejandro Coronel. Several months later, the Mexican army killed Ignacio Coronel himself — but the perception within his group was that Sinaloa leader Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera betrayed him. Five days after Coronel’s death, a video was released announcing that the CJNG was an independent organization operating in Jalisco state. CJNG surfaced again on Jan. 28, 2011, targeted by the Milenio cartel in narcomantas hung throughout Jalisco. A few days later, the cartel released a video in which a spokesman said the organization did not intend to attack municipal, state, federal or military authorities.
The video did, however, go on to list the names of specific law enforcement personnel who the spokesman claimed were known to be involved with La Resistencia and LFM. According to the video, the named individuals had until Feb. 10 to resign or CJNG would begin hunting them down. Little appeared in the media concerning CJNG from the time the video was released until this month, and we have seen no reports that CJNG has followed up on its ultimatum.
What STRATFOR finds significant in these events is the scope of CJNG’s hit list. The cartel appears to have declared war on virtually all of the other cartels operating in Mexico rather than align itself with either Los Zetas or Sinaloa, as most of the other cartels have done purely for survival’s sake. Another smaller regional cartel that appears to have taken the same step is the Cartel Independiente de Acapulco (CIDA). As for CJNG, its primary motive for going it alone (which may also be the case with CIDA) is probably its institutional distrust of both Sinaloa and Los Zetas.


June 6


  • Police in the municipality of Pabellon de Arteaga, Aguascalientes state, found the decapitated body of a man near the La Huerta ranch. The victim’s severed head was found near the body, along with an undisclosed message from an unidentified drug cartel.
  • Unidentified gunmen in the San Jeronimo neighborhood of Cuernavaca, Morelos state, shot and killed Ulises Martinez Gonzalez, a suspected associate of arrested cartel member Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal. It appears that Martinez Gonzalez was killed while trying to take over a house belonging to a rival cartel.
  • Soldiers in the municipality of Veracruz, Veracruz state, shot and killed eight suspected cartel gunmen during at least four separate firefights.

June 7


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed 13 people at a drug-addiction treatment center in Torreon, Coahuila state. Gunfire was reported at the scene for at least 30 minutes.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a federal police officer and a civilian male in the La Mancha neighborhood of Naucalpan, Mexico state.
  • Military authorities announced that soldiers on patrol in the municipality of Tancitaro, Michoacan state, discovered approximately 450 kilograms of methamphetamines at a suspected drug lab.
  • Unidentified gunmen reportedly kidnapped Marco Antonio Ortiz Lopez, news editor of the newspaper Novedades, in Acapulco, Guerrero state.

June 8


  • The bodies of 21 people were found in separate parts of Morelia, Michoacan state. The victims all bore signs of torture and had been shot to death.
  • Security personnel discovered the bodies of eight men and two women in a grave in El Veladero National Park near Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • Federal police officers arrested two suspected members of the Sinaloa cartel in Acapulco, Guerrero state. The suspects are believed to have participated in an attack on the Tabares II nightclub on May 28.
  • An unidentified drug cartel reportedly paid citizens of Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, 500 pesos (about $40) each to block two international bridges.

June 9


  • Nayarit state police officers arrested two suspected members of Los Zetas after a firefight in the Ojo de Agua neighborhood of Tepic.
  • Soldiers in Cuernavaca, Morelos state, arrested Kineret Orozco Gonzalez, the suspected successor to Jesus Radilla Hernandez, a Cartel Pacifico Sur chief believed to be responsible for the murder of poet Javier Sicilia’s son.

June 10


  • Soldiers arrested 20 police officers from Pesqueria, Nuevo Leon state, for their alleged cooperation with criminal groups.
  • Unidentified attackers threw a grenade at the State Investigative Agency headquarters in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. No injuries were reported.

June 11


  • The Mexican Prosecutor General’s office announced the seizure of 32 tons of ethyl phenyl acetate at the port of Manzanillo, Colima state. The seizure brought the total amount of chemical precursors seized at the port since June 1 to 145 tons.

June 12


  • Municipal police officers in El Cuchillo in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state, discovered the body of a soldier who had been stabbed to death.
  • Authorities discovered the severed heads of three suspected members of the Gulf cartel near a memorial at the entrance to the municipality of General Teran, Nuevo Leon state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

June 14, 2011
U. S. Senator Dianne Feinstein referenced a U.S. congressional report released June 13, saying new data from the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives reveals more than 70 percent of firearms recovered at crime scenes and traced by Mexican officials actually originated in the United States, Xinhua reported June 14. Feinstein is one of the three senators who issued the report.
June 10, 2011
Mexican security forces in Manzanillo, Colima state, seized approximately 32 tons of ethyl phenylacetate, a precursor chemical used to manufacture drugs, El Universal reported June 10. Approximately 145 tons of precursor chemicals have been seized at the port of Manzanillo since June 1, according to the Mexican prosecutor general’s office.
June 7, 2011 | 2043 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Casino Attacks in Monterrey

Money-Laundering Targets


Another significant facet of Monterrey’s strategic value to the cartels made the news May 25 when four casinos were robbed. Heavily armed gunmen reportedly emptied out the cashier cages at Casino Hollywood, Casino Royale, Casino Red and Casino Miravalle Palace, all in the same general area between Monterrey proper and the westside city of San Pedro Garza Garcia.
Los Zetas are currently fighting with the Sinaloa and Gulf cartels for Monterrey. The Zetas hold the city, but the Sinaloa and Gulf cartels want to take it because it sits astride intersecting smuggling corridors for drug and human trafficking. But that is only part of the story. The greater Monterrey area has about three dozen casinos, most of the more than 40 casinos in northeast Mexico. To an extent that no other business sector can be, large casino operations are essential to laundering the billions of dollars generated by Mexico’s cartels. Clearly, the tit-for-tat operations in which Gulf and Zetas elements target each other’s vital support networks appear to have been elevated to a higher level with bigger stakes.
Mexican media have indicated that “millions” were taken in the heists, but no source has quantified how much money was taken or whether the currency was in pesos or U.S. dollars. Furthermore, the reports have offered confusing or conflicting information about the order in which the heists occurred, so much so that a sequence may not be easily determined. In this situation, however, such tactical details are less important than the larger implications of the apparently well-coordinated heists.
Last January, the Casino Royale was the scene of an apparent effort to eliminate two high-profile members of the Juarez cartel who were gambling in the casino. Gunmen entered the establishment and started firing hundreds of rounds, but the reported targets got away — and later were apprehended by authorities. Almost as an afterthought, one online report mentioned in its last sentence that “in the confusion” the casino’s cashier cage was robbed and all of the casino’s security-camera tapes disappeared. STRATFOR has found no direct link in the media between the January shooting-robbery and the May robbery at Casino Royale. But we find the events more than coincidental. In all likelihood, the first heist in January was a test run for the coordinated multi-casino robberies conducted May 25.
Certainly, U.S. interdiction efforts have put a financial strain on all of the Mexican cartels, making casino robberies a tempting proposition, but the successful theft of millions of dollars or pesos may only have been a bonus on top of the larger reward of hitting a rival cartel at a vulnerable spot: its money-laundering operations.
Two years ago, Monterrey was something of a neutral zone where all top cartel families made use of the affluent stability and superior schools and medical care. In late January 2010, however, Los Zetas started consolidating their hold on the city after declaring open war on their former parent organization, the Gulf cartel. Last summer, after taking losses on the border at Reynosa and Matamoros, Los Zetas retreated to Nuevo Laredo and Monterrey. In Monterrey, the Zetas forces were entrenched for about two weeks when Hurricane Alex roared into the Rio Grande Valley and catastrophic flooding demolished huge sections of the city’s transportation arteries — effectively pulling up the drawbridge behind the Zetas.
Despite the heavy Zetas presence, Monterrey’s longer history as relatively neutral ground means that the casinos robbed May 25 were likely laundering funds for any number of drug trafficking organizations. The Zetas’ control of the Monterrey metropolitan area does not equate to exclusive use of its black market infrastructure, and dozens of large casinos have far more strategic worth as money-laundering operations than they do as extortion targets.

On the Quiet Coahuila Front


With the exception of Torreon and Saltillo, Coahuila state has been fairly quiet in Mexico’s cartel wars. The state is sparsely populated, lacks high-volume interstate highway arteries and remains largely undisputed Los Zetas territory. But several recent events along with an increasing Mexican military presence could point to a coming change in Coahuila’s security conditions.
According to official government news releases and confirmed by STRATFOR sources in the region, there has been a gradual increase in the deployment of military assets to Coahuila and in military activities in 2011. Mexican marines seized just over a ton of cocaine at a ranch northwest of Monclova on May 24. Then on June 1, Mexican army personnel found 38 narcofosas, or hidden graves, in the village of Guerrero, 50 kilometers (30 miles) southeast of Piedras Negras. It is not yet clear how many victims were disposed of at the Guerrero site — the meter-deep pits contained thousands of bits of charred human bones, metal buckles, buttons, and other personal items, and three 55-gallon drums also were found in which human bodies had been cremated. Also on June 1, the Mexican military uncovered a large cache of firearms and munitions on a farm in Nadadores, including 161 weapons and 92,039 rounds of ammunition of various calibers.
By no means are these recent events in Coahuila unique for Mexico, but the increase in military personnel and operations in the sparsely populated state is notable. As that military presence grows, STRATFOR expects significant clashes between Los Zetas and Mexican troops over the next few months. In Mexico, cartels have demonstrated that they will absorb a low level of losses as “the cost of doing business.” However, losses can reach a point where they are no longer acceptable to an organization, and violent countermeasures tend to result. In the quieter areas of Coahuila, particularly in the western and northern parts of the state where the Sinaloa and Gulf cartels have not bothered to contest Zetas control, Los Zetas may soon respond to the Mexican government’s inroads with direct and violent action against the military.


May 31


  • Unidentified people asphyxiated a man and abandoned his body in a vacant lot near the Francisco Madero avenue in Cancun, Quintana Roo state. The victim was tortured and beaten before being killed.
  • Soldiers arrested four men in Acapulco, Guerrero state, for transporting a dismembered body in the trunk of a car. A fifth suspect managed to escape. The men had been stopped at a military roadblock but attempted to flee and crashed into another car.

June 1


  • Unidentified gunmen in the Dale neighborhood of Chihuahua, Chihuahua state, shot and killed Fernando Oropeza, the former deputy director of a low-risk prison. Oropeza had resigned from his post after a clandestine bar was discovered at the prison.
  • Two people were killed and one was injured in a firefight between suspected members of drug trafficking gangs in the Region 233 neighborhood of Cancun, Quintana Roo state. The incident reportedly began when six members of a criminal gang arrived at a food vendor’s stall and opened fire on several members of a rival group identified only as “LGD.”
  • Relatives of journalist Noel Lopez identified his body among those found in a mass grave in Chinameca, Veracruz state. Lopez had last been seen headed to Soteapan on March 8.

June 2


  • Unidentified gunmen in the Jardines de Oriente neighborhood of Chihuahua, Chihuahua state, opened fire on a municipal police vehicle, killing a police officer.
  • Federal police officers arrested Candido Ramos Perez, the suspected head for Cartel Pacifico Sur of the Cuernavaca “plaza” in Morelos state, during vehicle inspections on the Cuernavaca-Mexico City highway near the southern boundary of the Federal District. A suspected cartel lookout riding in Ramos Perez’s vehicle also was arrested.

June 3


  • Military authorities announced the seizure of 161 firearms and 92,039 rounds of ammunition reportedly belonging to Los Zetas in the municipality of Nadadores, Coahuila state.
  • Security guards at the Sinaloa state government palace in Culiacan discovered a severed head and hands on the building’s exterior stairs. A preliminary report stated that the victim could be a state police officer.
  • The Mexican prosecutor general’s office announced the seizure of two large containers holding 80 barrels of monomethylamine, a precursor used to manufacture chemical drugs, at container-ship facilities in Manzanillo, Colima state. Another 80 barrels were seized from a separate ship, bringing the total amount of precursors seized to 34,848 kilograms.

June 4


  • Soldiers arrested Jorge Hank Rhon, a former mayor of Tijuana, Baja California state, during a raid in response to a citizen complaint. Approximately 50 firearms were seized from Rhon’s house.
  • Federal police announced the arrest of Victor Manuel Perez Izquierdo, the head of Los Zetas in Quintana Roo state, during an operation in Cancun. Ten other members of Los Zetas were arrested along with Perez Izquierdo. Authorities said the operation resulted from the arrests of 10 Zetas in Cancun on May 28.

June 5


  • Military authorities announced the seizure of four armored vehicles and 23 tractor-trailers during raids on vehicle workshops in Reynosa and Camargo, Tamaulipas state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed the municipal police commander of Mazatlan, Sinaloa state, in the San Angel neighborhood as he headed to his house.
  • Police in the Mitras Norte neighborhood of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, discovered the bodies of two men hanging from a pedestrian bridge. Signs bearing undisclosed messages to members of a criminal group were found near the bodies.
  • Unidentified people abandoned a taxi with a dismembered body outside a police station in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state. A message found in the vehicle included a threat to the mayor of Guadalupe, warning that she would be next.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

June 2, 2011

The Bin Laden Operation: Tapping Human Intelligence

By Scott Stewart
On the afternoon of May 27, a convoy transporting a large number of heavily armed gunmen was 2 ambushed on Mexican Highway 15 near Ruiz, Nayarit state, on Mexico’s Pacific coast. When authorities responded they found 28 dead gunmen and another four wounded, one of whom would later die, bringing the death toll to 29. This is a significant number of dead for one incident, even in Mexico.
According to Nayarit state Attorney General Oscar Herrera Lopez, the gunmen ambushed were members of Los Zetas, a Mexican drug cartel. Herrera noted that most of the victims were from Mexico’s Gulf coast, but there were also some Guatemalans mixed into the group, including one of the wounded survivors. While Los Zetas are predominately based on the Gulf coast, they have been working to provide armed support to allied groups, such as the Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS), a faction of the former Beltran Leyva Organization that is currently battling the Sinaloa Federation and other cartels for control of the lucrative smuggling routes along the Pacific coast. In much the same way, Sinaloa is working with the Gulf cartel to go after Los Zetas in Mexico’s northeast while protecting and expanding its home turf. If the victims in the Ruiz ambush were Zetas, then the Sinaloa Federation was likely the organization that planned and executed this very successful ambush.


Photos from the scene show that the purported Zeta convoy consisted of several pickup trucks and sport utility vehicles (two of which were armored). The front right wheel on one of the armored vehicles, a Ford Expedition, had been completely blown off. With no evidence of a crater in the road indicating that the damage had been caused by a mine or improvised explosive device (IED), it would appear that the vehicle was struck and disabled by a well-placed shot from something like a rocket-propelled grenade (RPG) or M72 LAW rocket, both of which have been seen in cartel arsenals. Photos also show at least one heavy-duty cattle-style truck with an open cargo compartment that appears to have been used as a troop transport. Many of the victims died in the vehicles they were traveling in, including a large group in the back of the cattle truck, indicating that they did not have time to react and dismount before being killed.
Unlike many other incidents we have examined, such as the ambush by CPS and Los Zetas against a Sinaloa Federation convoy on July 1, 2010, near Tubutama, Sonora state, the vehicles involved in this incident did not appear to bear any markings identifying them as belonging to any one cartel. In the Tubutama incident, the vehicles were all marked with large, highly visible “X”s on the front, back and side windows to denote that they were Sinaloa vehicles.
Most of the victims were wearing matching uniforms (what appear to be the current U.S. Marine Corps camouflage pattern) and black boots. Many also wore matching black ballistic vests and what appear to be U.S.-style Kevlar helmets painted black. From the photos, it appears that the victims were carrying a variety of AR-15-variant rifles. Despite the thousands of spent shell casings recovered from the scene, authorities reportedly found only six rifles and one pistol. This would seem to indicate that the ambush team swept the site and grabbed most of the weapons that may have been carried by the victims.
Guns may not have been the only things grabbed. A convoy of this size could have been dispatched by Los Zetas and CPS on a military raid into hostile Sinaloa territory, but there is also a possibility that the gunmen were guarding a significant shipment of CPS narcotics passing through hostile territory. If that was the case, the reason for the ambush may have been not only to kill the gunmen but also to steal a large shipment, which would hurt the CPS and could be resold by Sinaloa at a substantial profit.
Whether the objective of the ambush was simply to trap and kill a Zeta military team conducting a raid or to steal a high-value load of narcotics, a look at this incident from a protective intelligence point of view provides many lessons for security professionals operating in Mexico and elsewhere.

Lesson One: Size Isn’t Everything


Assuming that most of the 29 dead and three wounded gunmen were Zetas, and that most of the 14 vehicles recovered at the scene also belonged to the convoy that was attacked, it would appear that the group believed it was big enough to travel without being attacked, but, as the old saying goes, pride goeth before destruction.
In an environment where drug cartels can mass dozens of gunmen and arm them with powerful weapons like machine guns, .50-caliber sniper rifles, grenades and RPGs, there is no such thing as a force that is too big to be ambushed. And that is not even accounting for ambushes involving explosives. As evidenced by events in places like Iraq and Afghanistan, even convoys of heavily armored military vehicles can be ambushed using large IEDs and smaller, sophisticated explosive devices like explosively formed projectiles.
There are people in both the private and public sectors who cling to the erroneous assumption that the mere presence of armed bodyguards provides absolute security. But this is simply not true, and such a misconception often proves deadly. Indeed, there are very few protective details in all of Mexico that employ more than two dozen agents for a motorcade movement — most are smaller and less well-equipped than the Zeta force that was destroyed May 27. Most protective details do not wear heavy raid vests and Kevlar helmets. This means that government and private-sector protective details in Mexico cannot depend on their size alone to protect them from attack — especially if the attackers are given free rein to conduct surveillance and plan their ambush.
In an environment where the threat is so acute, security managers must rely on more than just big men carrying guns. The real counter to such a threat is a protective detail that practices a heightened state of situational awareness and employs a robust surveillance-detection/countersurveillance program coupled with careful route and schedule analysis.
Indeed, many people — including police and executive protection personnel — either lack or fail to employ good observation skills. These skills are every bit as important as marksmanship (if not more) but are rarely taught or put into practice. Additionally, even if a protection agent observes something unusual, in many cases there is no system in place to record these observations and no efficient way to communicate them or to compare them to the observations of others. There is often no process to investigate such observations in attempt to determine if they are indicators of something sinister.
In order to provide effective security in such a high-threat environment, routes and traveling times must be varied, surveillance must be looked for and those conducting surveillance must not be afforded the opportunity to operate at will. In many cases it is also far more prudent to maintain a low profile and fade into the background rather than utilize a high-profile protective detail that screams “I have money.” Suspicious events must be catalogued and investigated. Emphasis must also be placed on attack recognition and driver training to provide every possibility of spotting a pending attack and avoiding it before it can be successfully launched. Proper training also includes 1 immediate action drills in the event of an attack and practicing what to do in the event of an ambush.
Action is always faster than reaction. And even a highly skilled protection team can be defeated if the attacker gains the tactical element of surprise — especially if coupled with overwhelming firepower. If assailants are able to freely conduct surveillance and plan an attack, they can look for and exploit vulnerabilities, and this leads us to lesson two.

Lesson Two: Armored Vehicles Are Vulnerable


Armored vehicles are no guarantee of protection in and of themselves. In fact, like the presence of armed bodyguards, the use of armored vehicles can actually lead to a false sense of security if those using them do not employ the other measures noted above.
If assailants are given the opportunity to thoroughly assess the protective security program, they will plan ways to defeat the security measures in place, such as the use of an armored vehicle. If they choose to attack a heavy target like the Los Zetas convoy, they will do so with adequate resources to overcome those security measures. If there are protective agents, the attackers will plan to neutralize them first. If there is an armored vehicle, they will find ways to defeat the armor — something easily accomplished with the RPGs, LAW rockets and .50-caliber weapons found in the arsenals of Mexican cartels. The photographs and video of the armored Ford Excursion that was disabled by having its front right wheel blown off in the Ruiz ambush remind us of this. Even the run-flat tires installed on many armored vehicles will not do much good if the entire wheel has been blown off by an anti-tank weapon.
Armored vehicles are designed to protect occupants from an initial attack and to give them a chance to escape from the attack zone. It is important to remember that even the heaviest armored vehicles on the market do not provide a mobile safe-haven in which one can merely sit at the attack site and wait out an attack. If assailants know their target is using an armored vehicle, they will bring sufficient firepower to bear to achieve their goals. This means that if the driver freezes or allows his vehicle to somehow get trapped and does not “get off the X,” as the attack site is known in the protection business, the assailants can essentially do whatever they please.
It is also important to recognize that high-profile armored vehicles are valued by the cartels, and the types of vehicles usually armored generally tend to be the types of vehicles the cartels target for theft. This means that the vehicle you are riding in can make you a target for criminals.
While armored vehicles are valuable additions to the security toolbox, their utility is greatly reduced if they are not being operated by a properly trained driver. Good tactical driving skills, heightened situational awareness and attack recognition are the elements that permit a driver to get the vehicle off the X and to safety.

Lesson Three: Protect Your Schedule


Even for an organization as large and sophisticated as the Sinaloa Federation, planning and executing an operation like the Ruiz ambush took considerable time and thought. An ambush site needed to be selected and gunmen needed to be identified, assembled, armed, briefed and placed into position. Planning that type of major military operation also requires good, actionable intelligence. The planner needed to know the size of the Zeta convoy, the types of vehicles it had and its route and time of travel.
The fact that Los Zetas felt comfortable running that large a convoy in broad daylight demonstrates that they might have taken some precautionary measures, such as deploying scouts ahead of the convoy to spot checkpoints being maintained by Mexican authorities or a competing cartel. It is highly likely that they consulted with their compromised Mexican government sources in the area to make sure that they had the latest intelligence about the deployment of government forces along the route.
But the route of the Zeta convoy must have been betrayed in some way. This could have been due to a pattern they had established and maintained for such convoys, or perhaps even a human source inside the CPS, Los Zetas or Mexican government. There was also an unconfirmed media report that Los Zetas may have had a base camp near the area where the ambush occurred. If that is true, and if the Sinaloa Federation learned the location of the camp, they could have planned the ambush accordingly — just as criminals can use the known location of a target’s home or office to plan an attack.
If an assailant has a protectee’s schedule, it not only helps in planning an attack but it also greatly reduces the need of the assailant to conduct surveillance — and potentially expose himself to detection. For security managers, this is a reminder not only that routes and times must be varied but that schedules must be carefully protected from compromise.
While the Ruiz ambush involved cartel-on-cartel violence, security managers in the private and public sectors would be well-served to heed the lessons outlined above to help protect their personnel who find themselves in the middle of Mexico’s cartel war.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
June 1, 2011 | 1808 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Jan. 25, 2010

Escalating Violence in Acapulco


Cartel violence and law enforcement operations spiked in Acapulco, Guerrero state, during the last week of May. On May 23, the severed head and decapitated body of a man were found in an abandoned vehicle next to the Malibu Hotel in the heart of Acapulco’s tourism district. Several body parts, including ears, were reportedly missing from the scene. The next day, federal police raided a condominium in the city’s Joyas Del Marquez neighborhood and arrested eight members of a cell of Sinaloa hit men operating in Acapulco.
On May 29, a firefight broke out when gunmen in a convoy opened fire on an Acapulco municipal police car, reportedly killing two officers and two bystanders. Federal police responded to the scene and then tracked down the convoy, resulting in a second shootout in which three gunmen were killed. On the same day the body of a gunshot victim was found in one of Acapulco’s residential areas. Verifiable information is scant, but it appears that at least 30 killings were attributed to cartel activities in the greater Acapulco area between May 26 and May 30.
The battle for Acapulco and its vital seaport is escalating. As we have discussed, the seaport is the primary asset being fought over in Acapulco and would translate into control of methamphetamine production in Mexico — bulk shipments of the necessary ingredients originate in China, India and Bangladesh. The Sinaloa cartel has been in the business of large-scale methamphetamine production and distribution and already controls the ports at Colima and Mazatlan. It is therefore likely that, with La Familia Michoacana (LFM) busy battling the Knights Templar, Sinaloa expects at some point to be able to corner the methamphetamine market — a market in which LFM has been the dominant supplier.

LFM and the Knights Templar


Information came to light over the weekend that alters STRATFOR’s take on the Knights Templar. Initially discussed in our first quarterly update this year, the emergence of the Knights Templar was seen as a reinvention or rebranding effort by LFM following the death of charismatic leader Nazario “El Mas Loco” Moreno Gonzalez and the organization’s apparently swift disintegration. When we wrote the quarterly update, however, the Knights Templar were new on the scene, hanging narcomantas banners of the same style and tone as those previously hung LFM. In light of new information, we have been able to gain a more accurate understanding of the Knights Templar and the remnants of LFM.
According to reported statements by an LFM operative captured May 24 in Las Lomas, Jalisco state, along with 35 other LFM members, there was a significant split in the organization when Moreno died and Enrique “La Chiva” Pancarte Solis and Jose Jesus “El Chango” Mendez Vargas could not agree either on a succession plan or an evolution strategy. To some extent, Mendez had been a “co-leader” with Moreno, but following the Moreno’s demise Pancarte and several other senior leaders collaborated with Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez to create the Knights Templar.
Thus, the leadership struggle between Pancarte and Gomez thus was not strictly successional, contrary to STRATFOR’s initial take. Rather, the two parted ways and formed separate factions — one retaining the LFM name and the other calling itself the Knights Templar. We now understand that these two main factions are opponents in the battle for control of Michoacan state and their respective territories in neighboring states. This alters our perception of the two groups’ dynamics in the region, which will be decidedly more contentious and violent than we originally thought, and we will be following this evolution closely.


May 23


  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on police vehicles responding to a reported car accident near La Ferreria, Durango state. One police officer was killed in the ambush and five others were injured.
  • Police discovered the body of a woman inside an abandoned vehicle with Texas license plates in the municipality of Salinas Victoria, Nuevo Leon state. The victim had been shot once in the head.
  • Several firefights between members of unidentified criminal groups were reported in the municipality of Buenavista Tomatlan, Michoacan state. The incidents caused as many as 1,000 people to flee to temporary shelters in Buenavista Tomatlan and Apatzingan.
  • The Mexico state prosecutor general’s office announced that 21 people, including 16 police officers, were arrested in the city of Huixquilucan for allegedly aiding the criminal group La Mano con Ojos.

May 24


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a prison guard from Apodaca prison, Nuevo Leon state, as he was driving from the prison on the way to Laredo after his work shift.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on a group of ministerial police officers in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state, as they checked a vehicle that had been reported stolen. One police officer was killed in the attack.
  • Soldiers arrested five men during a patrol near Colombia, Nuevo Leon state, including Jose Manuel Diaz Guardado, the chief of Los Zetas in Hidalgo, Coahuila state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured an agent from the Directorate of Criminal Investigation in Durango, Durango state.
  • A federal police helicopter landed in the municipality of Apatzingan, Michoacan state, after being fired upon by suspected cartel gunmen. Two officers aboard the helicopter were injured.
  • Seventeen inmates escaped from a prison in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, through a hidden tunnel.

May 25


  • Groups of unidentified gunmen stole cash from the registers at the Royale and Red casinos in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. No injuries were reported during the robberies.
  • Police discovered the severed head of a woman inside an abandoned taxi near a police headquarters in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Soldiers in Coatzacoalcos, Veracruz state, arrested Julio de Jesus Radilla Hernandez, a suspected member of the Cartel Pacifico Sur who is believed to be responsible for the March 27 murder of the son of poet Javier Sicilia.
  • Twenty-nine people were killed and two were injured in a firefight between Los Zetas and the Sinaloa cartel in the municipality of Ruiz, Nayarit state.

May 26


  • Soldiers in the municipality of Florencia de Benito Juarez, Zacatecas state, shot and killed three gunmen after being attacked.
  • Security forces discovered the bodies of two men and two women inside an abandoned car near a night club in the Zona Diamante area of Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • Military authorities announced the arrest of Romeo Ramses Cota Lopez in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state. Cota allegedly was associated with the Sinaloa cartel and had links to several businesses acting as cartel fronts in Honduras.
  • A group of unidentified gunmen shot and killed six people and injured five others in at least four separate attacks in northern Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.

May 27


  • Federal police officers in the municipality of Mineral de la Reforma, Hidalgo state, arrested Esteban Javier Reyes Hernandez, a former police commander who allegedly provided protection for Los Zetas. Reyes attempted to flee in a vehicle but was apparently drunk at the time of his arrest.
  • Unidentified gunmen in Tlalchapa, Guerrero state, shot and killed three people, including a local municipal commissioner and his son.

May 28


  • Federal police officers arrested 36 members of La Familia Michoacana after a firefight at a meeting of cartel members in the municipality of Jilotlan de los Dolores, Jalisco state. Eleven suspected gunmen were killed and two police officers were injured during the incident.
  • The bodies of two people who appeared to have been strangled were found at separate locations in the 20 de Noviembre and San Luis neighborhoods of Durango, Durango state.
  • The dismembered bodies of a man and a woman were found inside an abandoned taxi near a police headquarters in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Security forces found the body of a man bearing signs of torture and wrapped in a blanket in China, Nuevo Leon state. The victim’s hands and feet were bound and a message (the contents of which was undisclosed) was found near the body.

May 29


  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on a bus belonging to Grupo Senda in Hidalgo, Tamaulipas state. No injuries were reported in the attack.
  • Around 20 gunmen traveling in several vehicles opened fire on a group of vehicles in Cojumatlan de Regules, Michoacan state, killing one person — the cousin of a state lawmaker’s wife — and injuring another.
  • State police officers in Atotonilco El Alto, Jalisco state, arrested five suspected members of the Millenium cartel.
  • Unidentified attackers threw a grenade at the offices of the La Vanguardia newspaper in Saltillo, Coahuila state, but no one was injured.

May 30


  • Unidentified attackers threw an improvised explosive device at the Institutional Revolutionary Party offices in Nezahualcoyotl, Mexico state, damaging the building. No injuries were reported in the attack.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

May 2011
May 28, 2011
The La Familia Michoacana cartel is not allied with Los Caballeros Templarios group, Mexico’s Federal Police (PF) learned after a raid that killed 11 and netted 36 arrests, Borderland Beat reported May 28. Detainees told PF there had been a rupture within La Familia involving leaders Enrique Plancarte Solis (La Chiva) and Jose de Jesus Mendez Vargas (El Chango). Since the rupture, La Familia has been in a territorial dispute with Los Caballeros.
May 27, 2011 | 1915 GMT
Implications of the Peten Massacre
Guatemalan soldiers patrol the streets of Flores, Peten department, May 17
Summary
On the night of May 14-15, some 30 Guatemalan laborers were murdered on a farm in the southwestern corner of Peten department, Guatemala’s northernmost province. The mass killing appears to be the work of Mexico’s Los Zetas, a cartel known to have a presence in the region and to control the three Mexican states that border Peten — Campeche, Tabasco and Chiapas. Although information has emerged since the massacre that suggests different scenarios, the one we believe is the most logical is the opening of a second front in Los Zetas’ war with the Gulf and Sinaloa cartels.
Analysis
In our first discussion of the mass killing of some 30 farm workers May 14-15 in Guatemala’s Peten department, STRATFOR examined the available information, anomalies and apparent inconsistencies in media reporting of the event. Since then, details of the massacre have continued to emerge, but there have also been conflicting reports from a wide range of sources. From events on the ground, including the May 23 kidnapping, execution and dismemberment of a Guatemalan prosecutor in Coban, Alta Verapaz department, it appears that the Mexican cartel Los Zetas are about to engage in a major offensive against the Gulf cartel in Guatemala.

What We Know Now


On May 15, a group of Guatemalan laborers were found murdered in Peten department on the Los Cocos farm, which is owned by a man named Otto Salguero. The location initially was reported incorrectly as being “near the village of San Benito,” in central Peten. Salguero’s Los Cocos property is in the southwestern corner of Peten, near the Mexican border state of Chiapas and situated on a main transnational roadway. STRATFOR’s sources in the region have indicated that the reports of 27 victims of the massacre may not be entirely accurate. According to our sources, 27 bodies were recovered, 26 of whom were beheaded, but elsewhere on the property the decapitated bodies of two children were found. That discovery was not broadly reported, but it may account for the discrepancy in the totals mentioned in several Latin American media outlets immediately following the event. Another detail that emerged recently is that three of the decapitated heads were missing from scene. Though the Zetas often place heads and other body parts some distance away from the rest of the body, we have not seen them carry away heads or other parts as trophies or for other purposes. It has also recently been reported that Los Cocos landowner Salguero, the apparent focal point of the massacre, is in hiding.
There were several survivors of the massacre, and though we were under the initial impression there were four, the correct number appears to be three: one man who was stabbed but managed to slip away before the attackers returned to remove his head, and a pregnant woman with her daughter. The woman’s statement included her observation that when the attackers spoke they had Mexican accents — whether she was instructed to say that is not known. As of May 25, 16 individuals reportedly had been arrested in Guatemala who are suspected of involvement in the killings, seven of whom have been identified as Mexican nationals.


Making Sense of it All


It is important to remember that the only things really clear on the ground in northern Guatemala are that facts are limited, rumors abound and mistrust and fear are endemic — and there is a very real possibility that the full truth about the mass killing may never be known. Given that caveat, it is appropriate to discuss implications that can be drawn from the Peten massacre by examining how they fit into the larger picture.

A Two-Front War


It is clear that the killing of the farm workers was intended to spread fear and send a distinct message: If you cross the Zetas you will pay. From past events and reliable sources, we know that the Zetas — both Mexican and Guatemalan nationals — essentially have free rein over as much as 75 percent of Guatemalan territory. This is not to say that the cartel controls the Guatemalan government, only that, at ground level, Zeta human- and drug-smuggling operations are conducted without interference from the government along the country’s interior and eastern transportation corridors. (Guatemala’s highways that run the length of its Pacific coastline are controlled by the Sinaloa Federation.) We also know that the initial rumor relayed by the press that Salguero was targeted due to theft of 2,000 kilograms of Zeta cocaine is false and that there may be a much more strategic goal for Los Zetas.
STRATFOR has learned that Salguero has been associated with a regional Guatemalan drug-trafficking organization, the Leon family (Los Leones), which is associated with the Gulf cartel. If Salguero is connected to the Gulf cartel via Los Leones, it is likely that the association predates the initial 2008 split between the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas, Gulf’s former enforcement arm, and the war that erupted between them in February 2010. And these pre-existing relationships could explain the dynamics behind the May 15 Peten massacre. A bloody message to Salguero was left at the scene promising that he would be next, and numerous narcomantas (banners) were hung in the city of Quetzaltenango in Quetzaltenango department on May 21 tying Salguero to the Gulf cartel as one of its main cocaine conduits. This makes sense given his drug-trafficking association with Los Leones.
Viewed from the perspective of the Zeta war against the Gulf cartel in northeastern Mexico — in which strength or vulnerability is directly linked to revenue, and revenue is directly linked to supply flow — there is a very good possibility that the Zeta strategy is to sever the Gulf cartel’s high-value supply lines. A collateral point here is that the trusted conveyors of cartel inventory also serve as procurers of cartel weapons. It is not yet known whether Salguero funneled munitions to the Gulf cartel, but there is that distinct possibility, and by taking him out Los Zetas could land a double blow on the Gulf’s forces in northeastern Mexico, impacting the flow of both money and munitions.
As STRATFOR has reported over the last year, Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel are engaged in a protracted war for northeastern Mexico. In that region, the Gulf cartel is weaker than it has been in past years and a fraction of its size and power in 2006, in large part because of the war with the Zetas. But Gulf is not entirely alone in the fight. The alliance of former opponents Sinaloa and Gulf in the newer construct called the New Federation has bolstered Gulf’s forces and firepower (not in huge amounts, perhaps, and sporadically when convenient for Sinaloa, but it has been assistance nonetheless). On the other hand, Los Zetas, with apparent superiority in firepower, battle tactics and strategic planning, have been going it alone in the northeast, though they have partnered with the Cartel Pacifico del Sur and other groups to fight against the Sinaloa cartel in other parts of Mexico. Presently feeling the pinch in the northeast, it appears that Los Zetas have opted for an alternative plan — open warfare on the Gulf and Sinaloa cartels on a vulnerable front: Guatemala.
Los Zetas possess a number of potential assets — the ability to attack the Gulf cartel on another front, large numbers of foot soldiers already in place in the south and access to large allied organizations. Given the heavy Zeta presence in Guatemala and on Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula (it is necessary to hold this territory in order to conduct smuggling operations in the region), Los Zetas have both internal manpower and the ability to request significant backup from their Guatemalan allies, such as groups of former Kaibiles and members of Mara Salvatrucha. The latter group has a substantial presence in Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, and with both of these Zeta allies already in the region, Los Zetas could raise their numbers quickly, easily and significantly if they indeed are opening a second front in Guatemala.
If that is the idea, Gulf may be forced to pull resources away from the battle in northeastern Mexico and/or request significant assistance from Sinaloa in order to protect both its flank and its drug-supply lines. Gulf does have its Guatemalan allies in Los Leones, and that group may be pulled into the fight as well, but their priorities more likely will center on protecting their own operations in a war between the Mexican cartels. Whether Gulf pulls some or all of its enforcement arm Nueva Gente away from its current operations or asks for (and receives) assistance from Sinaloa, the net effect would likely be a reduction in the pressure on Zeta forces in Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas and Coahuila states. If this is the Zeta goal, and it would be a logical strategy, the opening salvo may have been a surprise attack May 15 against the Gulf supply train, coupled with a clear message to the population that getting in the way will be fatal.

Government Reaction


Peten always has been an uncontrollable department for the Guatemalan government. During the civil war that raged from 1960 to 1996, the jungles and swamps of Peten sheltered rebels, training camps and refugees. One stated element of President Alvaro Colom’s plan to restore control over the Peten is to increase the army’s presence in the region and on the Franja Transversal del Norte (FTN), a major trucking route through northwestern Guatemala. Statements by Colom late in 2010 indicated that armed forces had control of the FTN area and it was expected that by the end of 2010 the military “should have gained complete control of northeast Peten and the Laguna del Tigre area…” Obviously, this prediction has not come true.
That lack of government control likely is due to resistance and distrust of the military by the people of Peten department, an area that suffered greatly when the military committed many atrocities during the 36-year civil war. Now, despite the intentions of the Colom administration, Peten and neighboring regions remain uncontrolled. The wholesale killing of the laborers on Salguero’s farm, regardless of the perpetrators’ identities, created a condition in which the military may be asked to come in and protect the people. There are some who hold to conspiracy theories that the massacre was an event engineered by the military in order to justify its declaration of a state of siege in Peten. These theories are understandable given Guatemala’s history, but given the course of events, the Zetas’ previous activities in the region and the target of the attack — an alleged Gulf ally — these rumors appear to be ill-founded. Nevertheless, according to STRATFOR sources, the Guatemalan army will seek to use the situation to increase its presence in the area by declaring a state of siege.
There could also be an expansion of the state of siege beyond Peten. Although the department has long been a haven for smugglers, drug traffickers and other violent elements, the Guatemalan government will have little success in subduing the region if it does not include Quiche and Alta Verapaz departments in any operations associated with a declared siege. As it stands, the conditions exist in which the people are thankful to have the military there in force and want them to stay. In all likelihood, the end state will more closely resemble the regular running battles seen in Mexico’s Tamaulipas and Nuevo Leon states, where the fight between cartels is further complicated by a third force: the military.
There are still some outstanding questions related to these events, but STRATFOR believes the most rational explanation is that the Peten massacre was indeed part of an intentional Zeta offensive to damage their Gulf rivals. This theory could be confirmed if there are more Zeta attacks against Gulf smuggling networks in Guatemala and a Gulf counteroffensive.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

May 25, 2011
Mexican police said May 25 that one of their Russian-made MI-17 helicopters was forced to land after drug cartel gunmen opened fire on the craft, wounding two officers, AP reported. The police statement says the pilot decided to land about 3.5 miles from the scene of the attack in the state of Michoacan. The attack occurred early on May 24 near the city of Apatzingan, one of the main territories of the La Familia Michoacana drug cartel.
May 25, 2011
More than 1,000 residents in Buenavista Tomatlan municipality, Michoacan state, fled to temporary shelters after firefights between unidentified gunmen began May 22, Milenio reported May 25. Approximately 200 people fled to the nearby municipalities of Aguililla and Apatzingan.
May 23, 2011
Colombian authorities on May 23 seized 12 metric tons of cocaine in a container in the Cartagena de Indias port, DPA reported. The shipment had left the southwestern Colombian city of Cali a few days before and was awaiting transport to Veracruz, Mexico. The Colombian navy chief admiral said the shipment was estimated at 12-16 tons and may have belonged to Los Rastrojos, El Espectador reported, citing AFP. Separately, DPA reported that Colombian police seized $2.8 million in cash in El Dorado airport in Bogota. The cash was taken from a Mexican citizen who was attempting to enter Colombia, and it is believed to have been payment for cocaine previously sent to the Sinaloa cartel.
May 24, 2011 | 1531 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Massive Vehicle Theft

Smuggling People


Just after midnight on May 16, two semi-trailer rigs were stopped at a checkpoint outside the city of Tuxtla Gutierrez in Chiapas state. State police conducted X-ray scans of the trailers and discovered human cargo inside: a total of 513 migrants, including 32 women and four children — 273 people crammed in one trailer and 240 in the other. Images from the X-ray scans show many people standing and holding onto ropes above their heads. According to a statement released by Mexico’s National Immigration Institute, 410 of the migrants were from Guatemala, 47 from El Salvador, 32 from Ecuador, 12 from India, six from Nepal, three from China and one each from Japan, the Dominican Republic and Honduras.
The mountainous region of Chiapas where the trucks were stopped is known to be controlled by Los Zetas, for whom human smuggling is a primary revenue stream. It is also a booming business. Other cartels are known to guide migrants across the U.S. border — typically for a fee of $2,000 or more per person — while requiring their clients to carry marijuana bundles on their trek (human smuggling is not regularly conducted by the larger cartels).
Los Zetas, on the other hand, tend to specialize in a form of human smuggling that is both high volume and high value. Statements made by several of the detained Guatemalan migrants indicate that they paid their smugglers $7,000 each to be transported to the U.S. border and smuggled into the United States. The fee for the Asian migrants may have been as high as $10,000 each, and it is likely that all of the migrants packed into the two trucks had already paid their smugglers.
The discovery of the Guatemalans heightened diplomatic criticism of the Mexican government by the government of Guatemala, which took issue with the Mexican authorities for not having immediately notified their consulate after the migrants were identified. Such an official complaint is not unusual, since relations between the two countries are known to be testy on occasion, but following closely on the heels of the May 14-15 mass killing of Guatemalan farm workers in Guatemala’s Peten department, reportedly by Mexican Zetas, the event may contribute to the larger geopolitical picture shaping up in Guatemala surrounding the upcoming presidential election.

Weapons and Cocaine in Chiapas


Later in the day on May 16 in Chiapas, federal troops intercepted an all-terrain vehicle operating along the Suchiate River near Frontera Hidalgo. The river in that area delineates the border between Mexico and Guatemala. The soldiers arrested four male Guatemalan nationals and seized eight magazines of various calibers, four handguns, five hand grenades (three fragmentation, two smoke), three AK-47 variants, a grenade launcher and one AR-15 outfitted with a scope and bipod. Then on May 17, three other seizures were conducted by federal authorities in different locations in Chiapas, including Comitan, where soldiers arrested five people for transporting weapons (the quantity and types were not reported).
The Comitan arrests did lead soldiers to a safe-house in the city, where they discovered 200 kilograms (440 pounds) of cocaine, an unreported amount of currency, more weapons and equipment and materials presumed to be for packaging cocaine. All five people arrested reportedly were from Sinaloa state. Also on May 17, at a checkpoint between the Chiapas coastline and the city of Huixtla, Federal Police discovered 80 kilograms of cocaine in packages mingled with a shipment of mangoes. Police arrested the truck’s driver, identified as being from Tamaulipas state, who indicated that the shipment was bound for Monterrey in Nuevo Leon state.
The locations and routes related to these arrests point to several potential connections. The weapons and cocaine discovered in Comitan are interesting because that particular region of Chiapas state is heavily controlled by Los Zetas and the five operatives arrested are reportedly from Sinaloa state. This does not prove an absolute connection to the Sinaloa Federation, but the likelihood that five Zetas all came from Sinaloa state is rather remote. Because of the area’s proximity to the coast, the cocaine mingled with a mango shipment probably means the shipment was destined either for the Sinaloa or Gulf cartels’ smuggling operations on the U.S. border. If the reported statement of the driver is correct, a connection to the Gulf cartel is likely. Finally, the presence of a weapons shipment barely across the river — and the Guatemalan border — and only about 32 kilometers (20 miles) upriver from the coast points to the Sinaloa Federation due to that group’s control of the Mexican and Guatemalan coastal regions.
The likely sourcing of Gulf cartel cocaine and weapons shipments via Guatemala, combined with the known presence of Zetas operating in the region, raises the possibility that Los Zetas may be using the military in an effort to choke off Gulf cartel supply lines. Taken together, all of these seizures may indicate a coordinated Zeta effort to dry up the weapons and revenue that have been supplying the Gulf/New Federation side of the fight for control of northeastern Mexico.


May 16


  • Banners signed by the Beltran Leyva Organization were hung in the cities of Cuernavaca, Tetecala, Jojutla and Jiutepec, all in Morelos state. The banners blamed Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS) and the Mexican government for the death in March of Mexican poet and journalist Javier Sicilia.
  • A group of unidentified gunmen opened fire on a vehicle carrying the police commander of Altar neighborhood in the municipality of Caborca, Sonora state. The commander was injured in the attack and was transferred to a hospital in Hermosillo.
  • Authorities discovered the burned body of an unidentified man among rubble and discarded tires in Tlalnepantla, Mexico state.
  • A group of gunmen traveling in at least two vehicles shot and killed seven suspected drug dealers and addicts near a vacant lot in the Riberas de la Silla neighborhood in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state.
  • A group of armed gunmen opened fire near the walls of the state prison in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state. No injuries were reported in the attack.
  • Chiapas state police operating a checkpoint outside of Tuxtla Gutierrez discovered 513 migrants crowded into two semi-trailers when they conducted X-ray scans of the trailers. The migrants were detained and four suspects were arrested.
  • Federal troops intercepted an all-terrain vehicle operating along the Suchiate River near Frontera Hidalgo, Chiapas state. The soldiers arrested four male Guatemalan nationals and seized eight magazines of various calibers, four handguns, five hand grenades, three AK-47 variants, a grenade launcher and one scoped rifle with a bipod.

May 17


  • Police officers discovered the bodies of four people abandoned in a garbage dump in the Prolongacion Primo de Verdad neighborhood in Durango, Durango state. The victims were blindfolded with packing tape.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed the brother of the Michoacan state police academy director in Tanhuato. The gunmen chased the victim as he drove through Tanhuato and killed him after forcing him out of his car. His wife was also in the vehicle but was not injured.
  • A group of gunmen shot and killed eight people and injured two others at a sheet metal workshop in the Melchor Ocampo neighborhood of Cardenas, Tabasco state.
  • Mexican marines chased an unidentified car and were involved in a firefight with unidentified gunmen along Harold Pape Boulevard in Monclova, Coahuila state. No injuries or deaths were reported in the incident, which lasted approximately 30 minutes.
  • Federal troops arrested five people, including one woman, for transporting weapons in Comitan, Chiapas state. The arrest led to the search of a safe-house in the city, where troops seized 200 kilograms of cocaine.
  • Inspecting a truck load of mangoes, Federal Police operating a checkpoint between the Pacific coast and the city of Huixtla, Chiapas state, discovered and seized 80 kilograms of cocaine mingled with the cargo.

May 18


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed four youths and injured three others in the Unidad Pedreras neighborhood of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Military authorities announced the seizure of a methamphetamines lab capable of producing approximately 10 kilograms of methamphetamines per day in Etchojoa, Sonora state. No arrests were made during the raid.
  • Ministerial police officers arrested the police commanders of Uriangato and Moroleon in Guanajuato state and four other police officers for alleged links to organized criminal groups. Three suspected members of La Familia Michoacana were also arrested during the same operation. The suspects are allegedly linked to 23 kidnappings and 12 murders.
  • Nine inmates were killed during a riot at the Durango state prison. Hundreds of police officers were brought in to subdue the rioters.

May 19


  • Soldiers in Cuernavaca, Morelos state, arrested Victor Manuel Valdez, the suspected second-in-command of CPS. During an interrogation, Valdez claimed that Cuernavaca ministerial police chief Juan Bosco Castaneda Matias provided protection for CPS for 15,000 pesos per month. Soldiers arrested Castaneda Matias later in the day.
  • One person was killed and two others were injured when unidentified gunmen opened fire on attendees at the Mazatlan Cattle Fair in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on a Renault car dealership in the Villas de Lux neighborhood in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state. No injuries were reported at the dealership, which was closed at the time of the attack.

May 20


  • The decapitated body of a woman was found near the municipal government headquarters in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state. Four police officers assigned to the headquarters were arrested in connection with the abandoned body.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured the police commander of Cihuatlan, Jalisco state, as he drove to police headquarters. The commander was transferred to a hospital at an undisclosed location.
  • Federal police officers in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, arrested Gilberto Barragan Balderas, the suspected Gulf cartel chief in the city of Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state. Suspected cartel member Romeo Eduardo Mejia, who is the brother of Gulf cartel member Juan Reyes “R1” Mejia , was also arrested.

May 21


  • Soldiers killed five suspected Los Zetas gunmen during a firefight in Boca del Rio, Veracruz state. Rolando Veytia Bravo, the suspected leader of Los Zetas in Boca del Rio, was killed in the firefight, which reportedly began when a group of Zetas traveling in a car refused to stop after being ordered by soldiers to do so.
  • Soldiers in the municipality of Temascaltepec, Mexico state, seized a suspected methamphetamine lab reportedly belonging to La Familia Michoacana. No arrests were made during the seizure.
  • State authorities released 26 police officers from Jerecuaro and Coroneo, Guanajuato state, who had been arrested for alleged links to La Familia Michoacana.
  • Unidentified gunmen in the Satelite neighborhood of Tlalnepantla, Mexico state, shot and killed retired army Gen. Jorge Juarez Loera as he was driving his vehicle.

May 22


  • Soldiers in the Paseo Santa Fe neighborhood of Juarez, Nuevo Leon state, shot and killed five suspected cartel gunmen after a vehicle chase. The gunmen tried to escape after the soldiers spotted them as part of a cartel convoy, but their vehicle crashed into a wall and caught fire.
  • Military authorities announced the seizure of six aircraft at the El Crucero airport in Ciudad Obregon, Sonora state. The aircraft were reportedly used by the Beltran Leyva Organization to smuggle drugs.
  • Soldiers discovered a 70-meter tunnel thought to be used for smuggling drugs from San Luis Rio Colorado, Sonora state, to San Luis in the U.S. state of Arizona. The tunnel began in the kitchen of a house on the Mexican side of the border and ended on the U.S. side of the border in a San Luis residence.
Give us your thoughts on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on other reports

Reader Comments

Content 7
May 23, 2011
Colombian authorities on May 23 seized 12 metric tons of cocaine in a container in the Cartagena de Indias port, DPA reported. The shipment had left the southwestern Colombian city of Cali a few days before and was awaiting transport to Veracruz, Mexico. The Colombian navy chief admiral said the shipment was estimated at 12-16 tons and may have belonged to Los Rastrojos, El Espectador reported, citing AFP. Separately, DPA reported that Colombian police seized $2.8 million in cash in El Dorado airport in Bogota. The cash was taken from a Mexican citizen who was attempting to enter Colombia, and it is believed to have been payment for cocaine previously sent to the Sinaloa cartel.
May 23, 2011
Two explosive devices went off at banks in Mexico City on May 23, Reuters reported. The city’s top prosecutor said windows were shattered but no one was injured. No arrests have been made but authorities suspect youth gangs are behind the explosions, Attorney General Miguel Mancera said. The explosive devices appeared to use small butane tanks, he said. The explosions occurred at a BBVA Bancomer bank office on the west side of the city and at a Santander Serfin branch, Reforma newspaper reported. A third device at another Santander Serfin branch did not explode.
May 19, 2011
Mexican soldiers arrested suspected drug boss Victor Valdez and the police chief accused of protecting him on May 19 in Cuernavaca, Reuters reported. Valdez is believed to be the second-in-command of Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS) led by Hector Beltran Leyva. Valdez told reporters that local police chief Juan Bosco helped the cartel evade capture. Bosco received about $1,290 a month for tipping off the cartel, Valdez said. Bosco was later arrested by soldiers, according to the Mexican army.
May 19, 2011
Unidentified gunmen used stolen vehicles to block roads in Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state on May 19, Terra reported. Roadblocks were reported in the Nueva Era and Villas de San Miguel neighborhoods and near a shopping center in Carrizo. Several vehicles were also reportedly stolen by gunmen near the Quetzalcoatl International Airport.
May 19, 2011

Bin Laden's Death and the Implications for Jihadism

By Scott Stewart
As one studies Mexico’s cartel war, it is not uncommon to hear Mexican politicians — and some people in the United States — claim that Mexico’s problems of violence and corruption stem largely from the country’s proximity to the United States. According to this narrative, the United States is the world’s largest illicit narcotics market, and the inexorable force of economic demand means that the countries supplying the demand, and those that are positioned between the source countries and the huge U.S. market, are trapped in a very bad position. Because of this market and the illicit trade it creates, billions of dollars worth of drugs flow northward through Mexico (or are produced there) and billions of dollars in cash flow back southward into Mexico. The guns that flow southward along with the cash, according to the narrative, are largely responsible for Mexico’s violence. As one looks at other countries lying to the south of Mexico along the smuggling routes from South America to the United States, they too seem to suffer from the same maladies.
However, when we look at the dynamics of the narcotics trade, there are other political entities, ones located to Mexico’s north, that find themselves caught in the same geographic and economic position as Mexico and points south. As borderlands, these entities — referred to as states in the U.S. political system — find themselves caught between the supply of drugs flowing from the south and the large narcotics markets to their north. The geographic location of these states results in large quantities of narcotics flowing northward through their territory and large amounts of cash likewise flowing southward. Indeed, this illicit flow has brought with it corruption and violence, but when we look at these U.S. states, their security environments are starkly different from those of Mexican states on the other side of the border.
One implicit reality that flows from the geopolitical concept of borderlands is that while political borders are clearly delineated, the cultural and economic borders surrounding them are frequently less clear and more dynamic. The borderlands on each side of the thin, artificially imposed line we call a border are remarkably similar in geographic and demographic terms (indeed, inhabitants of such areas are often related). In the larger picture, both sides of the border often face the same set of geopolitical realities and challenges. Certainly the border between the United States and Mexico was artificially imposed by the annexation of Texas following its anti-Mexico revolution as well as the U.S. annexation of what is now much of the U.S. West, including the border states of Arizona, California and New Mexico, following the Mexican-American War. While the desert regions along the border do provide a bit of a buffer between the two countries — and between the Mexican core and its northern territories — there is no geological obstacle separating the two countries. Even the Rio Grande is not so grand, as the constant flow of illicit goods over it testifies. In many places, like Juarez and El Paso, the U.S.-Mexico border serves to cut cities in half, much like the Berlin Wall used to do.
Yet as one crosses over that artificial line one senses huge differences between the cultural, economic and security environments north and south. In spite of the geopolitical and economic realities confronting both sides of this borderland, Texas is not Mexico. The differences run deep, and we thought it worthwhile this week to examine how and why.

Same Problems, Different Scope


First, it must be understood that this examination does mean to assert that the illicit narcotics market in the United States has no effect on Mexico (or Central America, for that matter). The flow of narcotics, money and guns, and the organizations that participate in this illicit trade, does have a clear and demonstrable impact on Mexico. But — and this very significant — that impact does not stop at the border. This illicit commerce also impacts the U.S. states north of the border.
Certainly the U.S. side of the border has seen corruption of public officials, cartel-related violence and, of course, drug trafficking. But these phenomena have manifested themselves differently on the U.S. side of the border.
In the United States there have been local cops, sheriffs, customs inspectors and even FBI agents arrested and convicted for corruption. However, the problem is far worse on the Mexican side, where entire police forces have been relieved of their duties due to their cooperation with the drug cartels and where systematic corruption has been traced all the way from the municipal mayoral level to the Presidential Guard, and even to the country’s drug czar. There have even been groups of police officers and military units arrested while actively protecting shipments of drugs in Mexico — something that simply does not occur in the United States. And while Mexican officials are frequently forced to choose between “plata o plomo” (Spanish for “silver or lead,” a direct threat of violence meaning “take the bribe or we will kill you”), that type of threat is extremely rare in the United States. It is also very rare to see politicians, police chiefs and judges killed in the United States — a common occurrence in Mexico.
That said, there certainly has been cartel-related violence on the U.S. side of the border with organizations such as Los Zetas conducting assassinations in places like Houston and Dallas. The claim by some U.S. politicians that there is no spillover violence is patently false. However, the use of violence on the U.S. side has tended to be far more discreet on the part of the cartels (and the U.S. street gangs they are allied with) than in Mexico, where the cartels are frequently quite flagrant. The cartels kill people in the United States but they tend to avoid the gruesome theatrics associated with many drug-related murders in Mexico, where it has become commonplace to see victims beheaded, dismembered or hung from pedestrian walkways over major thoroughfares.
Likewise, the large firefights frequently observed in Mexico involving dozens of armed men on each side using military weapons, grenades and rocket-propelled grenades have come within feet of the border (sometimes with stray rounds crossing over onto the U.S. side), but these types of events have remained on the south side of that invisible line. Mexican cartel gunmen have used dozens of trucks and other large vehicles to set up roadblocks in Matamoros, but they have not followed suit in Brownsville. Cities on the U.S. side of the border are seen as markets, logistics hubs and places of refuge for cartel figures, not battlefields.
Even when we consider drug production, it is important to recognize that the first “super labs” for methamphetamine production were developed in California’s Central Valley, not in Mexico. It was only pressure from U.S. law enforcement agencies that forced the relocation of these laboratories south of the border. Certainly, meth production is still going on in many parts of the United States, but the production is being conducted in mom-and-pop operations that can produce only relatively small amounts of the drug, usually of varying quality. By contrast, Mexican super labs can produce tons of meth that is of very high (almost pharmacological) quality. Additionally, while Mexican cartels (and other producers) have long grown marijuana inside the United States in clandestine plots of land, the quantity of marijuana the cartels grow inside the United States is far eclipsed by the industrial marijuana production operations conducted in Mexico.
Even the size of narcotics shipments changes at the border. The huge shipments of drugs that are shipped within Mexico are broken down into smaller lots at stash houses on the Mexican side of the border to be smuggled into the United States. Then they are frequently broken down again in stash houses on the U.S. side of the border. The trafficking of drugs in the United States tends to be far more decentralized and diffuse than it is on the Mexican side, again in response to U.S. law enforcement pressure. Smaller shipments allow drug traffickers to limit their losses if a shipment is seized, and using a decentralized distribution network allows them to be less dependent on any one link in the chain. If one distribution channel is rolled up by the authorities, traffickers can shift their product into another sales channel.

Not Just an Institutional Problem


Above we noted that the same dynamics exist on both sides of the border, and the same cartel groups also operate on both sides. However, we also noted the consistent theme of the Mexican cartels being forced to behave differently on the U.S. side. The organizations are no different, but the environment in which they operate is very different. The corruption, poverty, diminished rule of law and lack of territorial control (particularly in the border-adjacent hinterlands) that is endemic to the Mexican system greatly empowers and emboldens the cartels in Mexico. The operating environment inside the United States is quite different, forcing the cartels to behave differently. Mexican cartels and drug trafficking are problems in the United States, but they are problems that can be controlled by U.S. law enforcement. The environment does not permit the cartels to threaten the U.S. government’s ability to govern.
A geopolitical monograph explaining the forces that have shaped Mexico can be found here. Understanding the geopolitics of Mexico is very helpful to understanding the challenges Mexico faces and why it has become what it is today. This broader understanding is also the key to understanding why the Mexican police simply can’t be reformed to solve the problems of violence and corruption. Certainly, the Mexican government has aggressively pursued police reform for many years now, with very little success. Indeed, it was the lack of a trustworthy law enforcement apparatus that led the Calderon government to turn to the military to counter the power of the Mexican cartels. This lack of reliable law enforcement has also led Calderon to aggressively pursue police reform. This reform effort has included unifying the federal police agencies and consolidating municipal police departments (which have arguably been the most corrupt institutions in Mexico) into unified state police commands, under which officers are subjected to better screening, oversight and accountability. Already, however, there have been numerous instances of these “new and improved” federal- and state-level police officers being arrested for corruption.
This illustrates the fact that Mexico’s ills go far deeper than just corrupt institutions. Because of this, revamping the institutions will not result in any meaningful change, and the revamped institutions will soon be corrupted like the ones they replaced. This fact should have been readily apparent; the institutional approach has been tried in the region before and has failed.
Perhaps the best example of this failure was the “untouchable and incorruptible” Department of Anti-Narcotics Operations, known by its Spanish acronym DOAN, which was created in Guatemala in the mid-1990s. The DOAN was almost purely a creation of the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration and the U.S. Department of State’s Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs. The concept behind the creation of the DOAN was that corruption existed within the Guatemalan police institutions because the police were undertrained, underpaid and underequipped. It was believed that if police recruits were carefully screened, properly trained, well paid and adequately equipped, they would not be susceptible to the corruption that plagued the other police institutions in the country. So the U.S. government hand-picked the recruits, thoroughly trained them, paid them generously and provided them with brand-new uniforms and equipment. However, the result was not what the U.S. government expected. By 2002, the “untouchable” DOAN had to be disbanded because it had essentially become a drug trafficking organization itself and was involved in torturing and killing competitors and stealing their shipments of narcotics.
The example of the Guatemalan DOAN (and of more recent Mexican police reform efforts) demonstrates that even a competent, well-paid and well-equipped police institution cannot stand alone within a culture that is not prepared to support it and keep it clean. In other words, over time, an institution will take on the characteristics of, and essentially reflect, the environment surrounding it. Therefore, significant reform in Mexico requires a holistic approach that reaches far beyond the institutions to address the profound economic, sociological and cultural problems that are affecting the country today. Indeed, given how deeply rooted and pervasive these problems are and the geopolitical hand the country was dealt, Mexico has done quite well. But holistic change will not be easy to accomplish. It will require a great deal of time, treasure, leadership and effort. In view of this reality, we can see why it would be more politically expedient simply to blame the Americans.

Give us your thoughts on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
May 17, 2011 | 1936 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: Massive Vehicle Theft

Attack and Vehicle Theft in Reynosa

A large group of heavily armed gunmen assaulted a vehicle exposition at a Toyota dealership May 7 in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state. While the employees were preparing to open the event to the public that morning, the gunmen rounded up the employees at gunpoint and demanded the keys for at least 40 SUVs and pickups. The attackers apparently confined the employees and drove the new vehicles away. This attack likely involved preplanning, choosing escape routes and the coordinated use of a heavily armed force that likely consisted of more than 50 members in order to provide drivers for both the vehicles that transported the gunmen to the dealership and for the stolen vehicles as well as security along the escape routes. The swift and efficient execution of the event points to the possibility that the gunmen had an “inside man” at the dealership, but such an asset certainly is not necessary to be successful. The event’s location would be very easy to scout in advance by cartel gunmen posing as potential customers, as would the identification of egress routes and the establishment of secure corridors before the operation.
Although there have been other scattered events over the last five years in which a few vehicles were taken from dealerships along the border, this event was unique in its scope and bold execution during daylight hours. It is known that the cartels in Mexico conduct daylight operations; what is striking about this attack is the combination of numbers (the size of the group and the number of vehicles stolen), obvious preplanning, and the location — and that such an operation is easily replicable.
Reynosa is Gulf cartel territory but, although it cannot be ruled out, it is unlikely that Gulf operatives would conduct such a large robbery on their own turf. Given past tactical practices, it is more likely that Los Zetas conducted the operation for the dual purposes of acquiring vehicles for tactical operations and and undercutting the presumed support network of the Gulf cartel.
Though such a large-scale operation likely would not occur on the U.S. side of the border, follow-on operations are expected in the coming months as the summer smuggling season gains momentum and load vehicles are acquired. It is possible that the theft is directly related to an imminent clash between Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel. The May 7 operation was a success, and the cartels have a long history of replicating what works and redesigning what does not. Thus, STRATFOR expects to see repeats of this operation elsewhere in northeastern Mexico. Given this evolution beyond the typical (and numerous) carjackings and single-vehicle thefts, it is possible that Mexican car and truck dealerships will not be the only targets. Many U.S. and multinational companies maintain fleets of vehicles in centralized locations in Tamaulipas and Nuevo Leon states, and those fleets could be seized en masse in a similar fashion.

Methamphetamine on the Gulf Coast

The state prosecutor general’s office announced May 15 that a very large stockpile of methamphetamine was seized recently in the municipality of Ursulo Galvan, Veracruz state. Approximately 1.24 tons of methamphetamine was seized, as well as 200 liters (52.8 gallons) of liquid methamphetamine, 825 kilograms (1,818.8 pounds) of sodium hydroxide, 5,600 liters of ethanol, 4,000 liters of methylamine, 1,200 liters of acetic anhydride, 1,410 liters of acetone and 1,600 liters of hydrochloric acid. The quantities in this inventory indicate that a very large lab was dismantled in this event.
The location of the seizure also is of significant interest. Ursulo Galvan is located about 30 kilometers (20 miles) up the coast from Veracruz and about 5 kilometers upriver from the coast on the Rio Actopan. Los Zetas control the Veracruz plaza and a great deal of the surrounding region. Though it is possible that the Gulf cartel ran the lab, it is more likely to have been a Zeta operation due to that cartel’s larger presence in the region. The lab’s placement in Ursulo Galvan, proximate to the coast and on a navigable river, indicates well-thought-out logistics for both bringing precursors in and moving finished product out clandestinely either by boat or vehicle. It also is likely that movement of the finished product north and through the U.S. border zone may have been by water rather than overland. STRATFOR has not yet been able to determine the duration of the lab’s operations there, but given the recent upswing in large methamphetamine seizures by U.S. law enforcement in the Rio Grande Valley region, the presence of this lab may explain the source of those shipments. STRATFOR will continue tracking the quantities and frequency of methamphetamine seizures with interest, as a drop in seizure quantities and frequency after the dismantling of this methamphetamine lab would support that theory.


May 9

  • Authorities discovered the severed heads of six people outside a high school in the Azcapotzalco neighborhood of Durango, Durango state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed three people at a bar in the Altamira neighborhood of Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. A person driving past the scene of the attack was injured.
  • State police officers arrested suspected Sinaloa cartel drug trafficker Hector Eduardo Guajardo Hernandez in Mexicali, Baja California state. Guajardo Hernandez and an associate identified only as “El Lupis” were injured in a firefight with police officers.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a prison guard in the Hector Mayagoitia neighborhood of Durango, Durango state. The guard was the sixth prison official killed by gunmen in Durango in 2011.
  • Local residents discovered the severed head of a man in the Libertadores neighborhood of Acapulco, Guerrero state. A message addressed to “Melon, Victor Aguirre, El Eden, El Coreano and Betito” was found near the head, as was another signed by “C.S.”

May 10

  • Unidentified gunmen traveling in eight vehicles entered Taxco de Alarcon, Guerrero state, and shot and killed five people. Five other people were injured in the attack, which occurred near the city bus terminal.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on a convoy of vehicles transporting the police director of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state. The attack, which occurred in the Rincon de Guadalupe neighborhood, left at least one gunman dead and four police officers injured.
  • A local resident discovered the bodies of three men in Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. The three victims had their hands bound and might have been beaten to death.

May 11

  • Police officers in Zacatepec, Morelos state, rescued a kidnapped businessman and arrested five suspected kidnappers as they attempted to flee with the victim bound inside a vehicle.
  • A ministerial police officer from the Michoacan state anti-kidnapping directorate was found dead in the Villas del Pedregal neighborhood of Morelia. The victim died from a single gunshot to the head.
  • One prisoner was shot to death and four others were injured during a riot at a prison in Cancun, Quintana Roo state. The riot was reportedly due to a power struggle at the prison between members of Los Zetas and criminal group Los Pelones.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed an off-duty agent from the Sinaloa state ministerial police Elite Group during an ambush in Los Mochis. Two other officers were injured in the attack.

May 12

  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed five members of the same family as they drove in a vehicle near Choix, Sinaloa state. One of the victims was reportedly a nine-month-old child.
  • Soldiers arrested 12 suspected members of the Gulf Cartel during a raid on a ranch in Montemorelos, Nuevo Leon state. A Salvadoran and a Guatemalan citizen were among those arrested. The group reportedly operated near General Teran.
  • Police officers in the San Rafael neighborhood of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, arrested eight men suspected of acting as lookouts for an unidentified drug cartel.
  • Authorities discovered the decapitated bodies of six men, including Durango prison guard chief Gerardo Galindo Meza, in Durango, Durango state. Two other decapitated bodies were found in Pueblo Nuevo, Durango state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured Ricardo de Jesus Larralde Ramos, the head of the Criminal Investigation Directorate, as he drove through the Juan Lira neighborhood in Durango, Durango state. A group of gunmen later entered the hospital where Larralde Ramos was being treated and killed him.

May 13

  • Military authorities announced the arrest of Martin Beltran Coronel, the nephew of deceased Sinaloa cartel member Ignacio Coronel Villarreal. Beltran Coronel was arrested in Zapopan, Jalisco state, with four other people.
  • Two federal police officers were killed and four others were injured in a firefight with unidentified gunmen traveling in three vehicles in Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • A group of gunmen attacked the convoy of the director of roads police on the Cuauhtemoc Avenue in Acapulco, Guerrero state, killing a taxi driver. Police officers at the scene repelled the attackers.

May 14

  • Authorities in Janos, Chihuahua state, discovered the bodies of the police chief and two officers of Ascencion. The three men had been kidnapped on May 13 as they returned to Ascencion from Casas Grandes.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on the municipal headquarters of Gran Morelos, Chihuahua state. No injuries were reported in the attack, which damaged parts of the building and some computers inside.
  • Twelve people were killed and three police officers were injured during a firefight between three groups of federal police special forces and unidentified gunmen near the Barra de Potosi tourism project in Zihuatanejo, Guerrero state.

May 15

  • The bodies of three dismembered men were discovered in the municipality of Montemorelos, Nuevo Leon state. A sign, the contents of which were not revealed, was discovered nearby.
  • The bodies of nine men were discovered at the bullfighting arena in the San Ignacio neighborhood of Durango, Durango state. The victims were found naked and piled up near the ticket booths and had apparently been strangled.
  • Authorities from the state prosecutor general’s office announced the seizure of approximately 1.24 tons of methamphetamines in the municipality of Ursulo Galvan, Veracruz state.
Give us your thoughts on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on other reports

Reader Comments

May 13, 2011
Mexican soldiers May 12 arrested suspected Sinaloa cartel operative Martin Beltran Coronel, the successor to Ignacio Coronel Villarreal, a Sinaloa cartel operator killed by Mexican troops in July 2010, in Zapopan, Jalisco state, El Universal reported May 13. Coronel reportedly controlled shipments of drugs through Colima and Jalisco states.
May 12, 2011
Five hundred Mexican soldiers will be sent to the state of Tamaulipas for one year to support state police, El Universal reported May 12, citing Mexican national security spokesman Alejandro Poire. The deployment will end when a review of state police for possible crimes has been completed, Poire said.
May 10, 2011 | 1455 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: March 29, 2011

Gunbattles in Matamoros


A series of gunbattles flared up May 5 in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, resulting in the emplacement of several cartel roadblocks in and around the city. This is a tactic not typically employed by the Gulf cartel, which controls that territory. One of the battles started in the street in front of the Tamaulipas state police building just before 7:30 a.m. and continued for almost an hour.
According to the state attorney general’s office, the firefights involved federal troops and unidentified cartel gunmen, but there is conflicting information and evidence of a third significant element: Los Zetas. Posts on Internet forums and Twitter describe gunfire and explosions that morning in several areas of Matamoros and along the 50 kilometers (30 miles) of highway between Matamoros and Valle Hermoso. The series of roadblocks included one blockade very near the Matamoros side of the Veterans International Bridge point of entry, which caused a temporary closure of the southbound lanes of the point of entry by U.S. authorities.
What is significant about these events is the use of trailers and vehicles to block roads after the gunbattles, which is a tactic regularly employed by Los Zetas. Matamoros is home turf for the Gulf cartel, and the presence of roadblocks indicates the possibility that the fighting was a significant probe by Los Zetas. Information posted on the Internet by possible witnesses indicated that the battles involved two cartel groups — gunmen connected to Gulf cartel leader Osiel Cardenas Guillen (incarcerated in a U.S. federal penitentiary but known to still be running many Gulf operations via proxies) and a contingent of Zetas gunmen. The placement of the roadblocks after the main battle and the running gunbattle from southern Matamoros to Valle Hermoso make it likely that Zetas gunmen were involved.
Judging from the reported events, and what is known of Zetas tactics, it appears they successfully penetrated the Gulf’s outlying surveillance posts surrounding the city and pushed into central Matamoros, nearly to the U.S. border. Last February, in the last major round of Zetas incursions into Matamoros, the violence remained at a sustained level for a couple of weeks. It is likely that this latest probing action will be followed by a series of battles in the next week or two, and extreme caution should be exercised by anyone conducting business in the region.

Arrests in Mexico City


Federal authorities arrested Jose Efrain Zarco Cardenas and another suspect May 7 in Mexico City. Zarco Cardenas was the latest leader of the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA), and according to Mexican media reports he was restructuring CIDA and working to forge alliances with the Gulf cartel and the hybrid group La Familia Michoacana/Knights Templar. Media reports also suggest that Zarco Cardenas may have been headed to Reynosa, Tamaulipas, to acquire weapons, drugs and/or money from the Gulf cartel.
Despite its name, CIDA’s area of influence stretches beyond the local Acapulco area. STRATFOR sources recently indicated that CIDA has as many as 180 gunmen in Morelos state distributed in three groups and covering a triangular region about 65 kilometers south of Mexico City, with the triangle’s corners centered on the cities of Cuernavaca, Cuautla and Amacuzac.
The arrest and possible incarceration of CIDA’s leader could further destabilize the cartel, but not enough is known about its membership to rule out the possibility that it can withstand the loss. Given the group’s shaky footing in the Pacific coast areas of Guerrero and southern Michoacan states, where it has been marginalized, CIDA’s apparently strong presence in the triangular area south of Mexico City may be the result of an effort to rebuild its membership and strength. This could mean a CIDA resurgence over the next three to six months, and if that occurs we will expect to see the group try to re-establish itself in strength in the Acapulco seaport area.

Firefight on Falcon Lake


A firefight reportedly occurred the afternoon of May 9 on Falcon Lake, which straddles the U.S.-Mexico border between Laredo and McAllen, Texas. Although few details have emerged about the incident, a Mexican navy patrol on the lake apparently encountered a group of Zetas gunmen on an island about 3.5 kilometers from Nueva Ciudad Guerrero. A gunbattle began, and marines reportedly were called in to reinforce the navy patrol. It is unclear whether any gunmen were captured, though 12 gunmen and one marine reportedly were killed. Mexican forces seized 19 firearms, including a Barrett .50-caliber sniper rifle and a 5.56 mm light machine gun.
STRATFOR’s initial take on the significance of this event is that Los Zetas appear once again to have ramped up their marijuana-smuggling operations across Falcon Lake. Following the shooting of David Hartley in September 2010, there was an increase in law enforcement and military patrolling of the lake on both sides of the border, and it was apparent that Zetas operations had withdrawn while the organization lay low. Now Los Zetas appear to be using the islands again, in the same area of the lake where they were last summer when they encountered the Hartleys (who reportedly were sightseeing at the Old Guerrero church ruins). The area is remote, with few residents, and Los Zetas need more smuggling routes to increase revenue in order to buy more weapons and train more gunmen. With hot weather setting in, the increasing number of U.S. citizens plying the lake in watercraft should heed the warnings and stay well away from border buoys and not venture anywhere near the Mexican side.


May 2


  • Soldiers in the La Hacienda neighborhood of Apodaca, Nuevo Leon state, chased and killed two suspected cartel gunmen in a car. A third gunman reportedly escaped, leaving behind a suitcase full of ammunition.
  • Security forces arrested nine suspected members of the Cartel Nueva Generacion in the municipality of Tequila, Jalisco state. The men were arrested with 17 firearms, four bulletproof vests, 14 radios and approximately 4,140 rounds of ammunition.
  • Local residents found the body of a man wrapped in a blanket in the Jardines de la Silla neighborhood of Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. The victim had been shot in the head.
  • A group of unidentified gunmen shot and killed a police officer, injured two others and stole seven firearms from municipal police officers during three separate incidents in the municipality of Acapulco, Guerrero state.

May 3


  • Police found four decapitated bodies in an abandoned car in the San Antonio neighborhood of Cuautitlan Izcalli, Mexico state. A message was left near the victims’ severed heads saying they were murdered for “working with the H and the CC.” In the place of a signature on the message were three question marks. Reports indicated that the message came from Cartel del Centro.
  • Police found the bodies of four men who had been shot to death in the town of Tablillas San Dimas, Durango state.

May 4


  • Unidentified gunmen kidnapped three highway patrol officers in Linares, Nuevo Leon state. Three gunmen were reportedly killed in the incident.
  • Workers at a department store in Chilpancingo, Guerrero state, discovered a dismembered body in the store parking lot. A message attributing the crime to “El Sapo Guapo,” an alleged local leader of La Familia Michoacana, was found near plastic bags containing the body parts.
  • The Public Security Secretariat announced that federal police officers freed 16 migrants being held hostage in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.
  • Unidentified gunmen in Nezahualcoyotl, Mexico state, shot and killed two police officers in a drive-by shooting. The content of a message found near the officers’ bodies was not reported.

May 5


  • Unidentified gunmen in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, used stolen vehicles to block several roads, including Pedro Cardenas, Sendero Nacional, Canales, Sexta, Portes Gil and the Ignacio Zaragoza International Bridge.
  • The decapitated body of a man wrapped in plastic bags was found in the Ciudad Cuauhtemoc neighborhood of Ecatepec, Mexico state. The victim’s head was found a short distance from the body.
  • Unidentified gunmen wearing uniforms similar to those worn by federal police officers shot and killed two men and two women travelling in a car in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state. The victims were shot after a brief chase.
  • Police in Pachuca, Hidalgo state, arrested 20 people, including five police officers, for alleged links to Los Zetas.
  • Soldiers arrested 23 police officers in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, for alleged links to organized crime.

May 6


  • Unidentified gunmen travelling in two vehicles shot and killed six people outside a taco stand in the municipality of Ebano, San Luis Potosi state.
  • Soldiers in the Nuevo Leon Estado de Progreso and Agropecuario neighborhoods of Escobedo, Nuevo Leon state, freed nine people held hostage and killed one suspected cartel gunman. Two other suspects were arrested during the raid. The soldiers had been searching for gunmen believed to be responsible for a firefight in Escobedo earlier in the day.
  • Authorities found the decapitated body of a man wrapped in a blanket in the El Refugio neighborhood of Durango, Durango state. The victim’s head was found in a different location.
  • Federal police arrested Jose Efrain Zarco Cardenas, the leader of the Independent Cartel of Acapulco, in Mexico City along with another suspect.

May 7


  • Soldiers in the municipality of Poncitlan, Jalisco state, seized approximately 720 kilograms (1,600 pounds) of methamphetamine and more than 3,000 liters (800 gallons) of chemicals at a drug lab.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire in a seafood restaurant in Mazatlan, Sinaloa state, killing a man and injuring a woman.
  • Federal police officers in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state, stopped a pickup truck for speeding and discovered that two Guatemalans traveling in the vehicle had no identity documents. The people in the vehicle led police to a house from which 16 migrants were seized.

May 8


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed the former deputy director of prevention and social re-adaptation in Acapulco, Guerrero state.
  • Unidentified gunmen traveling in two vehicles shot and killed a prison guard in the San Ignacio neighborhood of Durango, Durango state.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

May 9, 2011
A gunbattle broke out May 8, killing 13 people, when marines found a Los Zetas camp on an island in Falcon Lake along the Texas border, according to a statement from the Mexican navy, AP reported. One marine and 12 Zetas gunmen were killed, the statement said, adding that marines collected more than 20 guns, including assault rifles, after the battle. The Zetas were smuggling marijuana by speedboat into Texas from the lake, the statement said.
May 8, 2011
Thousands of Mexican citizens marched in Mexico City to protest the government’s war on drugs, Reuters reported May 8. There were reportedly 20,000 protesters gathered at Zocolo square, though AFP reported that police counted asm many as 24,000 at midday.
May 6, 2011
STRATFOR sources report that suspected Venezuelan drug kingpin Walid Makled will be extradited from Colombia to Venezuela by May 8. The information has not been confirmed.
May 5, 2011
Suspected Venezuelan drug trafficker Walid Makled will not be extradited to Venezuela on May 6, contrary to media reports, Colombian Interior and Justice Minister German Vargas Lleras said May 5, El Espectador reported. Vargas Lleras said that the Colombian government has not yet received guarantees requested from the Venezuelan government concerning Makled’s extradition.
May 5, 2011
Unidentified gunmen used vehicles to set up roadblocks in Matamoros, Tamaulipas state, on May 5, following a firefight between Mexican naval forces and a group of gunmen at 7:00 a.m. local time, Milenio reported. Roadblocks were reported on Pedro Cardenas, Sendero Nacional, Canales, Sixth and Portes Gil streets. Roadblocks were also reported on the Ignacio Zaragoza International Bridge between Brownsville, Texas, and Matamoros.
May 3, 2011 | 1536 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: April 26, 2011

Possible VCF Weapons Seizure in Juarez


While acting on an anonymous tip April 30 on kidnapping victims being held in a house in Juarez, Chihuahua state, Mexican Federal Police instead found a large cache of weapons and ordnance inside a secret room. The house was located in an affluent neighborhood just south of the Instituto de Ingenieria y Tecnologia in northeast Juarez, and, given the location, the cache was most likely owned by a upper-level member of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes Organization (VCF), aka the Juarez cartel, as the house is in an area known to be controlled by that cartel.
The secret room was found in the basement gym, but, according to STRATFOR sources, the room was well concealed, with the mirrored wall in the gym designed to open when a button near the floor was pressed. Because the room was discovered despite being well hidden, it is likely that either the Federal Police may have already known what they would find and how to access it (they may otherwise be protecting a source), or someone may have informed on the owner of the house and given the authorities specific information as to where to look for the “kidnapping victims.” The latter scenario may involve a disenfranchised or compromised VCF insider.
The arsenal is a significant find; it included over 26,000 rounds of ammunition, two dozen AK-47 rifles, a belt-fed .30-caliber Browning machine gun, two .50-caliber Barrett sniper rifles, several miscellaneous rifles and handguns, 39 fragmentation grenades and 9 smoke grenades, 294 rifle and pistol magazines (including 10 high-capacity drum magazines), 19 bayonets for AK-47s, 13 ballistic vests, 53 military uniforms, three gas masks, as well as three currency-counters, a scale, and vacuum packaging machines. This is not the first time that .50-caliber sniper rifles have been seized in large weapons caches. However, also found in the cache, (if the inventory provided by Mexican authorities is accurate) were three “ghillie” suits, a heavier type of camouflage used by scout/sniper teams taking up positions for lengthy periods — and these paired with the two Barrett sniper rifles and a third .30-caliber sniper rifle are a significant combination. At present it is unclear whether the weapons and ghillie suits would have found their way into hands capable of utilizing them effectively, though it is notable that the .50-caliber sniper rifles did not have optics mounted on them, indicating they were being held in the cache but not being actively used.
The VCF has been steadily losing ground in Juarez to their rivals in the Sinaloa Federation over the past two years. Losing a long-established safe-house and a significant weapons cache will contribute to the erosion of the VCF’s control of Juarez. We can anticipate seeing more VCF safe-houses and weapons caches being seized and key figures from the VCF or its enforcement arm, La Linea, arrested or killed as Sinaloa continues to encroach on their home territory.

Migrants Rescued in Reynosa


Mexican authorities on April 25 freed 51 migrants being held hostage in a house in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state. Information obtained during a raid on a group of kidnappers the previous week led to their release. In a separate incident April 29, Mexican army troops turned over to immigration authorities 52 Central American migrants held at a house in Reynosa, after receiving an anonymous tip.
Despite the Mexican government’s pledge to prevent the kidnapping of migrants, these events indicate that the practice continues unabated. The Gulf cartel was likely responsible in these particular cases, given its control over Reynosa. The possibility of another cartel’s involvement cannot be ruled out, however.
It is not yet clear whether the migrants were being held for ransom, or to coerce their labor or cartel membership, though the forced gang membership of migrants is not typical behavior for the Gulf or Sinaloa cartels. (Over the last year this has been employed extensively by Los Zetas.) The 51 hostages released by authorities during the first event were from El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala but also included 27 Mexican citizens and six Chinese citizens. The 52 captives in the second event on April 29 were from Guatemala, Nicaragua, Honduras and El Salvador — 34 of them from Honduras.



April 25


  • Visiting tourists discovered a severed head in the municipality of Poncitlan, Jalisco state.
  • Soldiers shot and killed four suspected cartel gunmen during a firefight in Zihuatanejo, Guerrero state.
  • Mexican police freed 51 migrants held hostage at a house in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state. There were 14 Guatemalans, two Hondurans, two Salvadorians, six Chinese and 27 Mexicans in the group. The individuals were freed based on intelligence gained from a raid on a group of migrant kidnappers the previous week.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed three police officers in the Minerva residential neighborhood in the municipality of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state.

April 26


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed an employee of the Nuevo Leon state Public Security Secretariat at a gas station in northern Monterrey.
  • Five dismembered bodies were found in an abandoned lot in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state.
  • The Federal Investigative Agency announced the seizure of approximately 7.7 tons of marijuana in Tijuana, Baja California state. The drugs were seized during a raid on a warehouse in the Las Mesas neighborhood.
  • Soldiers in the municipality of Durango, Durango state, seized 8.1 tons of marijuana from a warehouse.

April 27


  • Four suspected gunmen were killed by soldiers in Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. The victims were all traveling in the same car, which reportedly failed to stop when ordered to do so by soldiers.
  • Authorities discovered four decapitated bodies in Zihuatanejo, Guerrero state. The victims bore signs of torture and had their hands and feet bound.
  • The National Defense Secretariat announced that soldiers freed three hostages and arrested six suspected kidnappers during a raid in Allende, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on people inside a house in the Tierra Nueva neighborhood of Ciudad Juarez, Nuevo Leon state. Two people were killed and three others were injured in the attack.
  • Unidentified gunmen used two buses and a taxi to block roads near the Monterrey municipal palace. No injuries or firefights were reported during the incident.

April 28


  • Soldiers shot and killed six suspected cartel gunmen during a six-hour firefight in Arcabuz, Tamaulipas state. The soldiers were responding to reports of a firefight involving up to 50 trucks carrying unidentified gunmen.
  • Authorities found the decapitated bodies of three men and the body of a woman shot to death inside an abandoned vehicle in the Sauceda neighborhood of Zamora, Michoacan state.
  • Municipal police officers found three bodies — one of them dismembered — in a grave in San Miguel el Alto, Jalisco state. The discovery was made in response to an anonymous tip to police about grave.
  • Three people were killed when unidentified gunmen opened fire on the prosecutor general’s headquarters in Tula de Allende, Hidalgo state.
  • Soldiers freed 52 immigrants held hostage in Reynosa, Tamaulipas state. There were 34 Hondurans, 12 Guatemalans, five Salvadorians and one Nicaraguan in the group.

April 29


  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured two police officers during a routine patrol in Santa Catarina, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Two police officers reportedly kidnapped by Los Zetas in Mezquitic, Jalisco state, were found alive in Monte Escobedo, Zacatecas state. The victims had been kidnapped April 27 during a firefight
  • The bodies of three men were found in a condominium in Acapulco, Guerrero state. The victims’ throats had been slit.

April 30


  • Police found the body of a man in Playa del Carmen, Quintana Roo state, and arrested a suspected member of Los Zetas who was transporting containers of diesel to allegedly burn the body.
  • The National Defense Secretariat announced that soldiers freed four hostages and arrested four suspected kidnappers in the municipality of Pesqueria, Nuevo Leon state.

May 1


  • Soldiers in the municipality of Santiago Papasquiaro, Durango state, found nine plastic bags containing human bones.
  • Security forces arrested 26 members of the police force in Tarandacuao, Guanajuato state, for allegedly cooperating with La Familia Michoacana.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

May 2, 2011
Nilton Alvarado Rojas, the police chief of Apodaca, Nuevo Leon state, has been missing since he responded to a report of three missing police officers, Nuevo Leon state Gov. Rodrigo Medina de la Cruz said May 2, El Universal reported. Six other police officers who accompanied Alvarado Rojas are also missing.
April 2011
April 29, 2011
The Merida Initiative High-Level Consultative Group, led by U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Mexican Foreign Affairs Secretary Patricia Espinosa, held its third meeting April 29, according to a statement issued by the U.S. and Mexican governments. The meeting focused on four areas of cooperation previously highlighted by U.S. President Barack Obama and Mexican President Felipe Calderon: weakening criminal organizations’ capabilities, strengthening public institutions to fight organized crime, developing a secure border that allows efficient legitimate travel and commerce while disrupting the flow of illicit goods, and addressing the root causes of violence in both countries.
April 29, 2011
Authorities in Hidalgo state, Mexico, on April 28 arrested 29 suspected members of Los Zetas, including 10 police officers, that are suspected of participating in an attack on the Tula security coordinator’s office and in firefights in Pachuca and Zempoala, El Universal reported April 29.
April 29, 2011 | 0132 GMT
Mexican drug cartels continue to war with one another and with the government. While the situation has long been fluid, the past eighteen months have seen the Sinaloa Federation rapidly expand at the expense of other groups. The following are key events in the evolution of Mexico’s cartel landscape over the last four and a half years:

  • December 2006: Mexican President Felipe Calderon takes office, promising to fight back against drug cartels. His first two years in office show strong successes against the cartels, with large drug seizures and the capture of several organizations’ leaders. The government’s chief target is the Gulf cartel, the most powerful in Mexico.

  • December 2008: A two-year-long campaign by the Calderon government against the Gulf cartel has left it crippled. The cartel’s enforcement arm, Los Zetas, splintered off in spring 2008 and now controls much of what used to be Gulf territory. The government’s success is a double-edged sword, however: The decline of the Gulf cartel has left a large power vacuum, encouraging other organizations — and factions within those organizations — to fight to increase their influence.

  • December 2009: As the government pressures powerful cartels, the situation in Mexico becomes more volatile and two distinct but interconnected wars begin to emerge: the government’s fight against the cartels, and the cartels’ fights between and among themselves. The geography of cartel influence does not change significantly, though one notable exception to this is the rise of the infamous La Familia Michoacana (LFM), which has captured media attention by marrying drug-trafficking activities to a pseudo-religious ideology.

  • May 2010: A major rift emerges in the Beltran Leyva Organization (BLO) after the death of leader Arturo “El Jefe de Jefes” Beltran Leyva. Two factions emerge, one under Arturo’s brother, Hector, and the other made up of elements of the BLO’s brutal enforcement wing and run by Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal.

  • December 2010: Tensions between the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas also have boiled over into open war in the country’s east, with the Gulf cartel reaching out to its former rivals in Sinaloa as well as LFM to align under the name “New Federation” and pushing Los Zetas from one of their traditional strongholds, Reynosa, though not out of Nuevo Laredo or Monterrey. In its weakened state, Los Zetas began increasing operations outside the normal scope of drug trafficking, such as kidnapping for ransom, and giving rise to a trend that STRATFOR eventually would dub Mexico’s third war: that of the cartels on the Mexican public. Cartel-related violence in the country reaches new heights, with more than 11,000 deaths on record.

  • April 2011: Violence continues to rise in all parts of the country. The Sinaloa Federation continues to expand its territory north and east, taking over areas formerly under the influence of the Carrillo Fuentes Organization and the Arellano Felix Organization. With the help of Sinaloa, the Gulf cartel has been able to repel offenses from Los Zetas in Reynosa and Matamoros, though the Zetas are proving resilient. LFM appeared to implode in January, but now a large subset of the former LFM seems to have simply rebranded itself as the “Knights Templar.” Its size and capabilities remain unclear.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

April 28, 2011
Mexico’s Senate unanimously approved a law against money laundering April 28, El Universal reported. The law was approved in a record 30 minutes. It directs the attorney general’s office to create a unit to monitor money laundering and deliver an annual report to the Mexican Congress. Violators can be fined up to 4 million pesos and face up to 16 years in prison.
April 27, 2011
Unidentified men set up two roadblocks near the municipal palace in Monterrey following a reported firefight April 27, Milenio reported. Authorities responded after the men used buses and a taxi to set up the roadblocks.
April 27, 2011
Alleged drug gang leader, Waldemar Lorenzana, was detained after driving into the town of El Jicaro, Guatemala, Interior Minister Carlos Menocal said, adding that the capture was very important because he is related to the Sinaloa drug cartel, Xinhua reported April 27.
April 26, 2011
Mexico’s Federal Investigative Agency seized weapons and an estimated 7.7 tons of marijuana from a warehouse in the Magana neighborhood of Tijuana on April 26, Milenio reported. The cache had a street value of more than $10 million on the U.S. market.
April 26, 2011 | 1502 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: April 19, 2011

A Change in Cartel Dynamics


Various drugs are smuggled more intensely in different regions along the U.S.-Mexico border, and some cartels are known to specialize in the production and distribution of certain drugs. Drug seizures can thus indicate much about the degree of influence and control the cartels have in a given area.
For example, most Mexican cartels have produced methamphetamine to an extent, but the Sinaloa Federation and La Familia Michoacana both have histories of large-scale methamphetamine production in the western states of Sinaloa, Durango, Jalisco, Colima, Michoacan and Guerrero. Most of the methamphetamine produced by these cartels is smuggled north across the border into California and Arizona, the logical route for the cartels most heavily involved in the drug’s production, given the geographic areas and highways the they control.
Along the Texas border, long-term trends for methamphetamine seizures indicate the drug is moved less frequently and in smaller amounts than other drugs moved through the area, with occasional spikes being reported. STRATFOR sources have said spikes in seizures do not necessarily indicate a meaningful trend. Recently, however, there has been a consistent upswing in the size and frequency of methamphetamine shipments seized along the Texas border, specifically in the section of the border from Laredo to Brownsville, a section controlled mainly by the Gulf cartel and Los Zetas.
Projections of the amount of drugs smuggled across the border, based on collected drug-seizure statistics, are approximations at best. Too many unknowns make precise projections impossible, but STRATFOR sources have estimated that between 8 and 10 percent of drugs smuggled into the United States in the border region is seized by law enforcement.
Since mid-February, 661 kilograms (1,457 pounds) of methamphetamine have been reportedly seized by U.S. law enforcement between Laredo and Brownsville, while the reported total seized in the same area for the final three months of 2010 was 137 kilograms, indicating nearly a five-fold increase. With this area controlled mainly by two cartels not typically linked to methamphetamine distribution, STRATFOR believes that such a significant increase may indicate a change in cartel dynamics in the area. The Sinaloa cartel has a presence in the region in support of the Gulf cartel. We are inclined to believe that Sinaloa has benefited substantially from the association and has routed much larger quantities of their high-value commodity to the lower Rio Grande Valley. Whether this is the result of an agreement with the Gulf cartel or an overt takeover remains to be seen.
It should be noted that the Nuevo Laredo “plaza” has been a Zetas stronghold for several years (a plaza is a cartel’s territory that comprises parts the city itself, its adjacent highways and ports of entry), and with about 256 kilograms of methamphetamine seized since mid-February, we begin to wonder whether Sinaloa has co-opted some Zetas assets in the area — or if the Zetas have ramped up one or more superlabs to boost revenues for the area. The upswing also may be an indication that the Gulf and Zetas cartels are having difficulty getting cocaine from South America, and have had to diversify their product lines in order to keep cash flowing. In the case of Nuevo Laredo, there is also the possibility that the Zetas’ allies from the Pacific Coast, such as the Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS), are now moving product through Zetas territory.
In any case, the increase in methamphetamine traffic is indisputable, and it indicates a change in cartel dynamics in the region that merits continued observation.

A Mass Grave in Durango


A mass grave was found April 21 in Durango, Durango state. While a great deal of attention has been focused on mass graves discovered in San Fernando attributed to the Zetas, we believe the Durango discovery is important, too, because it is a reminder that the Zetas are not the only Mexican drug-trafficking organization that engages in mass murder.
As of April 26, 58 decomposed bodies had been found in Durango. The state of decomposition indicates that the grave sites had been occupied for many months, longer than the mass graves in San Fernando. There are no reports attributing responsibility, but given the location in Durango state, we believe Sinaloa or the CPS are the most likely candidates.
It is unlikely a Zetas dumpsite. Their ruthlessness and violence notwithstanding, the Zetas are not the only cartel to dispose of bodies en masse. One method pioneered by the “El Teo” faction of the Arellano Felix Organization (aka the Tijuana cartel) involved the use of lye or acid to dissolve the bodies of their victims. In Mexico, people have been dying in the drug war in ever-increasing numbers, and the body count tabulated by the Mexican government and by Mexican and U.S. news agencies will never be accurate or complete. The mass graves found over the past few weeks are likely indications of things to come; as the violence in Mexico spreads, many of the dead will likely never be found.



April 18


  • Unidentified gunmen attacked two fuel stations in the municipality of Canatlan, Durango state. The attackers used small arms and grenades to damage the two stations, but no injuries were reported.
  • Unidentified attackers shot and injured the deputy director for the State Security Agency for Tejupilco, Mexico state, as he drove with a bodyguard in Temascaltepec, Mexico state.
  • Unidentified people left two decapitated bodies near a gas station in the Valle del Sur neighborhood of Durango, Durango state. The victims’ heads were found several blocks away.
  • Soldiers arrested two suspected cartel lookouts in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state. The suspects were detained after their car crashed into a utility pole while they were attempting to escape.

April 19


  • Soldiers in the Infonavit Rio Medio neighborhood of Veracruz, Veracruz state, killed 10 suspected cartel gunmen in a firefight. Ten other alleged gunmen were arrested.
  • Unidentified attackers threw two improvised explosive devices at the Tultitlan Polytechnic University in Tultitlan, Mexico state. One device exploded, injuring one man. The other device failed to detonate and was deactivated by police.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on a police station in Culiacan, Sinaloa state, killing two people. The attackers fired more than 700 rounds at the building.

April 20


  • Police in the Los Olivos neighborhood of Leon, Guanajuato state, found the body of a man reportedly killed by the La Familia Michoacana cartel. The victim’s head had been wrapped in packing tape. A message was found near the body, but authorities did not disclose its contents.
  • Unidentified gunmen attacked a prison transport convoy in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua state, killing one guard and injuring four others. Three prisoners were freed in the attack.
  • Residents of the municipality of Tecamac, Mexico state, found the bodies of two unidentified men. The victims bore signs of torture but had apparently not been shot.
  • Police found the burned bodies of two men in the municipality of Pueblo Nuevo, Durango state.

April 21


  • Authorities freed 40 police officers arrested April 19 in Cadereyta, Nuevo Leon state, for alleged links to Los Zetas, Mexican media reported.
  • Unidentified gunmen attacked several car dealerships and other businesses in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state, with grenades and small arms. No injuries were reported in the attacks, which were unofficially attributed to the Gulf cartel.
  • Unidentified gunmen in the Santa Teresa, Jalisco and Colinas del Saltito neighborhoods of Durango, Durango state, set three houses on fire. No injuries were reported in the attacks.
  • One soldier and one suspected cartel gunman were killed during a firefight in Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state. Eleven other people were arrested after the incident. According to a military news release, gunmen from Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel were involved in the firefight.

April 22


  • Unidentified attackers damaged a car dealership in southern Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state, with two grenades. No injuries were reported.
  • Soldiers in the municipality of General Bravo, Nuevo Leon state, freed two people reportedly kidnapped April 9. One person was arrested in connection with the kidnappings. The raid occurred at a ranch on the highway to Reynosa, Tamaulipas state.

April 23


  • Police found the bodies of five women at separate locations in Acapulco, Guerrero state. The victims’ throats had been slit, and a message was found near one of the bodies.
  • The decapitated body of a man was found near a gas station in Durango, Durango state.
  • Unidentified gunmen traveling in two vehicles shot and killed five men in the Riberas del Sacramento neighborhood of Chihuahua, Chihuahua state.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on three buses in separate incidents in the municipality of Hidalgo, Tamaulipas state. Three people were injured in the attacks.
  • Residents of the Chapultepec neighborhood of Mexico City discovered the dismembered body of a woman inside a cardboard box and two suitcases.

April 24


  • One police officer was reported injured and three people were arrested after a firefight between police and unidentified criminals in Ecuandureo, Michoacan state. Five police officers had previously been injured in an ambush by unidentified gunmen in Ecuandureo.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on police stations in Hualahuises and Linares, Nuevo Leon state. No injuries were reported in either attack.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

April 21, 2011
Mexican authorities arrested Marco Antonio Gomez, an alleged Zetas drug cartel lawyer who is charged with managing ransom and extortion payments, AP reported April 21. The suspect was detained in Cancun, federal police said. Gomez participated as a go-between in negotiating ransom payments from relatives of kidnapping victims, sometimes handing over payments in the form of property deeds, authorities stated.
April 21, 2011 | 1214 GMT
Mexican Drug War 2011 Update
Editor’s Note: Since the publication of STRATFOR’s 2010 annual Mexican cartel report, the fluid nature of the drug war in Mexico has prompted us to take an in-depth look at the situation more frequently. This is the first product of those interim assessments, which we will now make as needed, in addition to our annual year-end analyses and our weekly security memos.
In the first three months of 2011, overall violence across Mexico continued to rise. The drug cartels are fighting for control of lucrative ports of entry along the U.S. border and strategic choke points in the interior of Mexico — urban crossroads on both major and minor smuggling routes. These crossroads include cities like Ciudad Victoria, San Luis Potosi, Mexico City, Monterrey, Guadalajara, Durango, Torreon, Saltillo and Chihuahua. Some of them are important because they straddle vital north-south routes running along the coastlines. Others have strategic value because they sit on major highways that serve as direct routes through the interior of the country, from various points on the Pacific coast to ports of entry on the Texas border. And along that border, the control of plazas that have border crossings is being hotly contested from Juarez to Matamoros on the Gulf of Mexico.


The Gulf cartel, still battling its former enforcer arm Los Zetas, is holding on to Matamoros, a vital Gulf asset. With the Sinaloa Federation’s help, the Gulf cartel has repelled Zeta offensives both at Matamoros and Reynosa but has not displayed the force necessary to push Los Zetas out of Monterrey. Los Zetas, suffering the loss of 11 mid- to upper-level leaders and plaza bosses, continue to fight their primary war with the Gulf cartel while training and assisting allied cartels in Juarez, Tijuana and Acapulco.
The Vicente Carrillo Fuentes (VCF) cartel is managing to keep Sinaloa forces at bay in Juarez but has lost its outlying territories in Chihuahua state as well as its primary drug supply line from Chihuahua City. Sinaloa’s effective blockade of Juarez has begun to choke off VCF’s supply and revenue flow. VCF is not yet out of the game, but it is limping noticeably. Another cartel on the decline — a shadow of its former self — is the Arellano Felix Organization (AFO, aka the Tijuana cartel). AFO has very little territory left that it holds alone and is now subservient to the Sinaloa Federation, to which it pays for the right to access the California ports of entry.
The Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS) and the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA), both of which comprise splinter factions of the former Beltran Leyva Organization, are battling each other for control of Acapulco’s seaport. CPS is the more successful of the two, with its territorial control stretching north along the Gulf of California coast into Sonora state, though smuggling corridors up the coastline are regularly disputed by the Sinaloa Federation.
After what seemed to be the sudden death of La Familia Michoacana (LFM) in January, it is now apparent that a portion of LFM of undetermined size has rebranded itself as the Knights Templar, which emerged on the scene in mid-March. Other members of LFM continue to operate under that name. This development is very new and it is not clear yet who the Knights Templar leaders are, how many are in the new group, what kind of relationship they have with their former brethren in LFM and what, if any, relationship either group has with the Sinaloa Federation. A great deal likely depends on the willingness of Sinaloa and Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera to allow LFM or the Knights Templar to re-establish their former infrastructure and smuggling routes.
As for the Sinaloa Federation, it is now the regional hegemon in the western half of Mexico and is actively expanding its territory. Currently there are Sinaloa forces helping the Gulf cartel battle Los Zetas in the northeast, slowly strangling the VCF in Juarez, running the show in Tijuana and fighting for supremacy in Acapulco. Wherever there is a conflict in Mexico between or among a cartel’s current or former factions, you will find Sinaloa’s helpful hand. And in every case Sinaloa is gaining territory. While internal strife and external pressure from the Mexican military and federal law enforcement agencies have weakened all of the other cartels, the Sinaloa Federation has proved impervious to the turmoil — and it is growing.
In the next three to six months, STRATFOR expects Sinaloa to lead the pack in the fights for Acapulco and Durango. However, Sinaloa has so much going on around Mexico that Guzman may redeploy some of his fighters — from regions already solidified under his control, such as Tijuana — to Durango and Acapulco to facilitate quicker, more decisive victories there. STRATFOR anticipates an even greater level of violence in Juarez as Sinaloa’s chokehold tightens, and we expect to see a major push by Los Zetas to recover control of Reynosa, where the Gulf cartel will lose its hold if Sinaloa pulls fighters from there to fight elsewhere. Los Zetas are highly likely to hold onto Monterrey in the near term, absent a major government push or a massive effort by Gulf and Sinaloa, which is unlikely at this point but cannot be ruled out.
The CIDA may fade out completely in the next three to six months, with its remaining territory and assets likely split between the CPS, aided by Los Zetas, and Sinaloa. As for the Knights Templar, STRATFOR expects to see it pick up where LFM left off in December, though re-establishment of its methamphetamine production probably will be gradual.

Current Status of the Mexican Cartels


Los Zetas


Los Zetas have had setbacks over the last three months — reduced territory, captured or killed regional leaders, internal control issues — but the organization appears to be able to absorb such losses. Los Zetas have maintained control of their strongholds in Monterrey and Nuevo Laredo as well as the key Gulf of Mexico port of Veracruz, despite the best efforts of the Gulf cartel and elements of the New Federation. STRATFOR sources indicate that the Gulf cartel maintains constant surveillance of all roads leading to Matamoros, making a Zeta move in that direction difficult at best and at this point unlikely. It is more likely that Los Zetas will make a concerted effort to retake Reynosa in the coming months.
Since the beginning of 2011, actions by the Mexican military and federal police have resulted in the loss of at least 11 mid- to upper-level Los Zetas leaders, including Flavio “El Amarillo” Mendez Santiago, one of the original founding members, captured by federal police in Oaxaca on Jan. 18. One of seven Zeta gunmen killed Jan. 25 by Mexican soldiers during a running gunbattle through the Monterrey metropolitan area was identified only as “Comandante Lino,” who is believed to have been the top Zeta leader in Nuevo Leon state.
STRATFOR has heard rumors of a split between Los Zetas leader Heriberto “El Lazca” Lazcano Lazcano and No. 3 leader Miguel “Z-40” Trevino Morales. However, we have not been able to confirm this or determine if the attrition of secondary leaders was affected — or caused — by such a division.
One of the most significant events involving Los Zetas since December 2010 was the Feb. 15 Mexican Drug War 2011 Update attack against two U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. The motivation for the attack remains unclear, but viewed against documented Zeta operational behaviors and priorities, it clearly was not consistent with the top leadership’s doctrine and past practices. There has been much speculation regarding the attackers’ motives, but a planned and sanctioned attack against U.S. officials would be certain to bring the full weight of the U.S. government onto the perpetrators, and that is not something the top Zeta leadership would want to invite. This suggests the possibility that lower-level regional leaders either lost control of their operational cells or actually condoned and/or ordered the attack.
Regarding the possibility of neglected control, the erosion of Zeta forces through battle, targeted assassination and capture has been high over the past year. There have been numerous indications that recent Zeta recruits have tended to be younger and less experienced than those who joined prior to 2010. The attrition in leadership has also resulted in leaders who are themselves younger and less experienced. Such a mix may be creating conditions in which young men equipped with vehicles and weapons but with little discipline or oversight are left to their own devices.
A number of mid-level Zeta leaders came from military and law enforcement backgrounds and had received some level of institutional training and education. But many of them likely do not grasp the gravity — or even know about — an incident 26 years ago, when the Guadalajara cartel kidnapped, tortured and killed Enrique “Kiki” Camarena, a special agent with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration. In response, the U.S. government orchestrated the annihilation of the Guadalajara cartel in a massive offensive called Operation Leyenda. It is possible that certain midlevel Zetas, lacking knowledge or appreciation of that operation, may not be aware of the potential repercussions of an attack on known U.S. government personnel.
If that is the case, there may be a few sporadic attacks on U.S. government agents in the coming months. But unless such events go unanswered by U.S. agencies, thereby lending the cartels a sense of impunity, it is doubtful that more than a handful of such attacks will occur.
To some extent, out-of-control gunmen within Los Zetas are a self-solving problem. Rash actions by low-level Zetas can and do trigger the occasional harsh “house cleaning,” in which the transgressors, on the orders of top-level leaders, are either killed or betrayed to authorities to send a message to the rest of the organization. Either way, the internal problem weakens the cartel and reduces both its numbers and its organizational efficacy, and it is unlikely that the internal punishment of wayward Zetas protects the organization as a whole from the consequences of their actions.
Los Zetas’ current organizational dynamics suggest that we are likely to see more unsanctioned operations such as the ICE and Falcon Lake shootings. This obviously has implications for U.S. law enforcement personnel and innocent bystanders. Such operations also will continue to induce internal culling of the elements responsible for such attacks. In all likelihood, this internal pressure, when combined with external pressures brought against Los Zetas by their cartel rivals, the Mexican government and American authorities, will continue to take a heavy toll on the cartel. And as losses are replaced with younger and less-experienced operatives, ongoing violence and destabilization will likely erode Los Zetas’ power.

Gulf Cartel


Since late January, the Gulf cartel has been solidifying its hold on Matamoros. As both a northbound smuggling route into the United States and an inbound supply port for receiving waterborne shipments, Matamoros is vital to the Gulf cartel’s survival. The organization is not down for the count, but it continues to be weakened and dependent on its allies in the Sinaloa Federation to protect it from Los Zetas. With Los Zetas in control of the port of Veracruz, Matamoros serves as the cartel’s primary resupply point for Colombian cocaine, Central American arms shipments and other logistical operations. Certainly, Gulf cartel logistics are not constricted solely to that corner of Mexico, but seaport access enables large-volume resupply that minimizes the losses inherent in land routes through hostile areas.
Though Gulf cartel control encompasses Matamoros and Reynosa, both smuggling plazas with vital ports of entry on the border, the ownership of that territory has been contested. On Jan. 29, Los Zetas launched a sizable offensive that they had prepared in advance by placing resupply caches in and around Matamoros shortly after Antonio “Tony Tormenta” Cardenas Guillen was killed last November. Several weeks of heavy fighting flared up in Matamoros and to the south and west, as Zeta fighters hit Gulf cartel groups and Mexican military units took on both cartels. Smaller fights broke out along the border northwest to Nuevo Laredo as well as southward between Matamoros and Monterrey.
The fighting died down toward the end of February, and the Gulf cartel took the opportunity to ramp up revenue streams and restock. According to STRATFOR sources, cocaine seizures by U.S. law enforcement agencies rose steadily from mid-February to late March in the Rio Grande Valley portion of the south Texas border zone — a significant increase of high-value/low-volume contraband. To offset losses from the early February Zeta offensive, the Gulf cartel tried to bring in substantial revenue very quickly.
The upswing in cocaine smuggling corresponded with the lull in cartel battles and the need for quick cash. According to a Jan. 11 U.S. Department of Justice report on illicit drug prices, wholesale cocaine prices in the area were approximately $25,000 per kilogram (more than $11,000 per pound) versus $440 to $660 per kilogram for marijuana. There is no way to calculate the ratio of contraband seized to the total contraband smuggled in any given area at any given time, but various STRATFOR sources have made conservative estimates of 1:10 to 1:12 (seized to total smuggled). Since approximately 348 kilograms (767 pounds) of cocaine were seized between the last week of February and April 1, a reasonable extrapolation of the expected revenues — after the loss of the seized cocaine — would be $87 million.
The Gulf cartel leadership does not appear to have taken as big a loss as the Los Zetas leadership did in the first quarter. On March 4, however, authorities arrested Gustavo “El 85” Arteaga Zaleta and Pablo Jesus “El Enano” Arteaga Zaleta in Tampico, Tamaulipas. The brothers were wanted on charges of kidnapping, extortion, and arms and drug trafficking for the Gulf cartel in the states of Tamaulipas and San Luis Potosi. Secretariat of Public Security intelligence reports indicate that Gustavo Arteaga Zaleta is a former municipal policeman from Ciudad Madero, Tamaulipas, and was the “jefe de plaza” (plaza boss) in El Ebano, San Luis Potosi.
The loss of two Gulf cartel leaders over the past few months does not appear to have adversely affected the organization, though as a whole the cartel continues to be stretched thin. With federal forces occasionally entering the fray and Los Zetas seeking any weaknesses to exploit, the Gulf cartel is engaged in a large, bloody game of “whack-a-mole” in which its dual opponents further stretch its resources — augmented though it may be by Sinaloa elements.
While the Gulf cartel has held its territory and successfully repelled a Zeta offensive this past quarter, it has not been able to wrest Monterrey, Veracruz or Nuevo Laredo away from Zeta control. In northeast Mexico, the battle lines have not shifted, there are no clear winners and the violence will continue for the foreseeable future.

Sinaloa Federation


The Sinaloa Federation remains the largest and most cohesive of the Mexican cartels. Under the leadership of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman Loera, Sinaloa has been steadily making inroads into the territories of other cartels, friend and foe alike. This expansion has been seen in Durango, Guerrero (specifically Acapulco and its vital seaport) and Michoacan states as well as Mexico City. Because it has remained a cohesive organization and maintained widely diversified revenue streams — from narcotics to avocados — the Sinaloa Federation stands to benefit most from the chaos across Mexico.
Only two significant members of the Sinaloa leadership were captured during the first quarter of 2011. The first was Cesar “El Placas” Villagran Salazar, arrested by army troops on Feb. 12. Villagran Salazar is alleged to be a key operator for Guzman in northern Sonora and coordinator of Sinaloa drug shipments for distribution across the border into Arizona. The second, on March 18, was Victor Manuel “El Senor” Felix, who is presumed to be a relative and confidante of Guzman and runs one of the cartel’s financial networks.
According to a STRATFOR source, the Mexican government’s current priority is getting the violence under control, not eliminating the cartels. It is a pragmatic approach. While some of the cartels may be breaking up or in the process of being absorbed, it is not possible at this point to eliminate them all — or to stop the trafficking of narcotics. Systemic corruption at all levels of government, well-entrenched for many years, turns a blind eye to cartel activities at best and enables them at worst. Apparently, the Mexican government has decided that the best course of action in this environment is to wage a war of attrition, taking out the low-hanging fruit and letting Sinaloa do the rest.
Extreme levels of violence are not in the best interests of cartels, whose primary goal is to make money. When violence goes up, revenue goes down. As the largest and most widespread Mexican cartel — incapable of being eliminated in the current environment — the Sinaloa Federation likely will continue to be relatively impervious to government efforts. It also is the organization most likely to assume the dominant position in the cartel landscape, which would enable it ultimately to impose a forced reduction in the cartel violence. Sinaloa could use its dominance to keep weaker groups in line, which would suit the government’s purposes.
As Sinaloa has steadily gained influence and territory over the past several years, its competition has been fragmenting. The destabilization that began in 2006 with Mexican President Felipe Calderon’s anti-cartel campaign thoroughly upset the cartel equilibrium and created power vacuums. With the possible exception of Los Zetas, the fragmentation and power vacuums have weakened or destroyed cartels while Sinaloa has either been unaffected or strengthened as the primary beneficiary. Even those elements within the Sinaloa Federation that were neutralized — the Beltran Leyva brothers and Ignacio “El Nacho” Coronel Villarreal — were elements that posed a potential challenge to the leadership of Sinaloa head Guzman.
In the case of the Beltran Leyva Organization (BLO), once a part of the Sinaloa Federation, the remaining Beltran Leyva brother Hector (see section on Cartel Pacifico Sur below) believes that Guzman betrayed his brothers and used the government to remove a potential challenger — the BLO. This was borne out by events in the first quarter of 2011, when Sinaloa expanded into the territories of cartels that were fragmented or floundering such as its New Federation allies La Familia Michoacana (LFM) and the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (CIDA). “Divide and conquer” works, even when a third party causes the fragmentation, and Guzman knows this well.

Knights Templar


As was discussed in STRATFOR’s 2010 annual cartel report, the death of Nazario “El Mas Loco” Moreno Gonzalez in a shootout with federal authorities on Dec. 9, 2010, was a blow to LFM. Moreno was a charismatic and compelling leader, around whom grew a curious blend of religious cult, merciless killing machine and highly specialized drug-trafficking organization. Without Moreno’s centrally focused leadership, the bands of LFM killers fractured and seemed to engage in directionless violence in late December and into January.
LFM continued to devolve with the loss of its methamphetamine labs to government takedowns (and probably efforts by other cartels as well). As with the territorial grabs in other parts of Mexico, LFM’s leaderless cells did not hold onto the bulk of the cartel’s smuggling routes but likely lost them to regional hegemon Sinaloa. At this point in the degeneration of the organization, it is likely that the faithful core of Moreno’s followers saw the need to reorganize or rebrand the group in order to reunify its scattered elements. Such an effort at organizational self-preservation would require a particular sort of leader to fill the void left by Moreno’s death.
As with most charismatic pseudo-religious organizations and their inherent strongman leadership, there was a fiercely loyal cadre of lieutenants who surrounded Moreno. From that group alone will be found a successor who will be followed, since most of the LFM rank and file will align themselves only with someone who has complete faith in Moreno’s teachings. In the chaos of last December, following Moreno’s death, the two top members of his inner circle were rumored to have fled the country. STRATFOR has been unable to confirm the rumor (or, if it is true, whether they have returned), but the two — Servando “La Tuta” Gomez Martinez and Jose Jesus “El Chango” Mendez Vargas — are the prime candidates to replace Moreno and bring the elements of LFM back together. They fit the mold for being the most likely to succeed in the reconstitution and rebranding of the group.
LFM announced its dissolution in January. Authorities and analysts dismissed the announcement and waited to see what evolved. The wait was not very long. On March 17, banners appeared in multiple cities and villages in Michoacan that proclaimed the presence of a previously unknown group — Los Caballeros Templar, aka the Knights Templar.
The new name may have triggered a few chuckles in some agencies — and objections from members of the Sovereign Military Order of the Temple of Jerusalem, which traces its origins to the original Knights Templar, an order of Christian knights formed to protect pilgrims traveling to the Holy Land during the First Crusade. There is some parallel to the religion-centric LFM, with its stated goals of protecting the people of Michoacan from criminal elements, including corrupt government officials.
Banners announcing the emergence of the Knights Templar in Michoacan read: “To the people of Michoacan, we inform you that starting today we will be carrying out here the altruistic activities previously realized by La Familia Michoacana. We will be at the service of the people of Michoacan to attend to any situation that threatens the safety of Michoacanos. Our commitment is to: keep order; avoid robberies, kidnappings, extortion; and protect the state from possible (interventions) by rival organizations. — The Knights Templar.”
The Knights Templar banners bore the same type of message and tone as previous LFM banners, which suggests that the activities of the Knights Templar in the next few months will likely be consistent with documented LFM activities. This development is recent, and information regarding the composition of the group, its leadership and its relations with remnant LFM cells and the Sinaloa Federation is very sparse. STRATFOR will continue to monitor events in Michoacan over the next quarter, paying particular attention to the emergence of the Knights Templar leadership and the reconstitution of LFM alliances and business, enforcement and smuggling operations. It is too soon to know whether the former LFM partnership with the Sinaloa Federation will be reinstituted.

Cartel Pacifico Sur


The groups that evolved from the factions of the BLO no longer are recognizable as such. The BLO split into two separate groups, with an unknown number of BLO operatives electing to return to the Sinaloa Federation rather than join either of the two new drug-trafficking organizations.
The first of these two independent groups, Cartel Pacifico Sur (CPS), centers around Hector Beltran Leyva and is allied with Los Zetas. During the first quarter of 2011, CPS demonstrated an addition to its skill set: the use of an improvised explosive device (IED) placed in a car in Tula, Hidalgo state, with an anonymous call to local law enforcement to lure victims to the booby trap. The small device detonated on Jan. 22 when one of the vehicle’s doors was opened, injuring four police officers.
Though no one claimed responsibility for the IED, a connection can be made that suggests CPS involvement. Last summer, STRATFOR discussed the use of an IED in a car in Juarez in which the first responders were targeted and killed following an anonymous call regarding a wounded police officer. That IED is believed to have been detonated by members of the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes cartel (VCF, aka the Juarez cartel). In both the Juarez and Tula bombings, the devices used were small, composed of industrial hydrogel explosives and placed in vehicles to which local police were lured by some ruse.
The common denominator is likely Los Zetas. Though the cities of Juarez and Tula are about 1,600 kilometers (1,000 miles) apart, and the Juarez cartel and CPS do not share assets, both organizations are allied with Los Zetas — and Los Zetas have members with military demolitions training. In the coming months, STRATFOR will be watching for any other indicators that this connection has led to other permutations in CPS tactics previously not associated with the BLO.

Independent Cartel of Acapulco


The second group that broke off from the BLO is the Independent Cartel of Acapulco (Cartel Independiente de Acapulco, or CIDA). This group is still evolving and information about it remains rather muddled. At this point, STRATFOR has identified CIDA as a large part of the BLO faction loyal to Edgar “La Barbie” Valdez Villarreal. Since Valdez Villarreal was arrested in September 2010, his faction has apparently become somewhat marginalized. Some CIDA members came from La Barbie’s faction, some did not. There are also some former LFM elements in the CIDA as well as a handful of miscellaneous Acapulco street thugs and miscreants. There continues to be sporadic violence attributable to, or claimed by, the CIDA, but there is mounting evidence that the organization is fading from the picture in some areas.
That said, the CIDA is not giving up without a fight. STRATFOR sources recently indicated that the group is locked in a battle with CPS for control of the city of Cuernavaca, Morelos state. Sources say CPS gunmen currently control the east side of Cuernavaca and CIDA operatives control the city’s west side. Particularly dangerous areas are the Jiutepec sector on the city’s southeast side and the Carolina neighborhood on the west side.
According to Mexican media reports, federal police arrested Benjamin “El Padrino” Flores Reyes, one of the suspected top CIDA leaders, on March 6 in Acapulco, Guerrero state. Flores Reyes reportedly controlled the distribution of drugs, managed the cartel’s lookout groups and is said to have reported directly to cartel chief Moises “El Koreano” Montero Alvarez.
The CIDA was aligned with LFM and the Sinaloa Federation, and until late last year it was most likely in control of the Acapulco plaza and seaport. The disbanded LFM, reincarnated into the Knights Templar, probably has not provided any help to the weakened CIDA, and Sinaloa has likely taken full advantage of the chaos and helped itself to the Acapulco plaza. STRATFOR has asked its sources which cartel controls the Acapulco seaport itself, and while conditions are sufficiently murky to prevent any definitive answers, the working hypothesis is that the port is also in the hands of Sinaloa.
Currently, the CIDA is at war with former ally Sinaloa, likely triggered by Guzman’s move to take CIDA territory after the arrest of Valdez Villarreal. The CIDA appears to be taking a beating on that front. During President Calderon’s visit to Acapulco last month, five dismembered bodies were found in front of a department store on Farallon Avenue in Acapulco. The discovery was made about an hour after Calderon opened the 36th Tourist Marketplace trade fair in the International Center of Acapulco. Pieces of two of the bodies were scattered on the ground near an abandoned SUV, and body parts from the other three were found in plastic bags inside the vehicle. Messages left at the scene said the victims were police officers killed by the Sinaloa Federation because they worked with the CIDA.
The outlook for the CIDA over the next three to six months is not promising. Unless something occurs to revitalize the group, such as a successful escape from prison by Valdez Villarreal, the CIDA may fade into obscurity within the year. Certainly the next three months will be telling.

Arellano Felix Organization


Fernando “El Ingeniero” Sanchez Arellano, nephew of the founding Arellano Felix brothers, is still in control of the Arellano Felix Organization (AFO, aka the Tijuana cartel), though the group is only a shadow of its former self. Little changed in the cartel’s condition in the first quarter of 2011 from how it was described in the 2010 annual cartel report. Sinaloa’s “partnership agreement” with the AFO has relegated the once-mighty Tijuana cartel to vassal status, with the bulk of its former territory and all of its smuggling avenues across the border now controlled by the Sinaloa Federation. The AFO now pays Sinaloa for access to its former territory.

Vicente Carrillo Fuentes Organization


The Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization (VCF, aka the Juarez cartel) is holding on. Though STRATFOR has previously reported that the VCF was hemmed in on all sides by the Sinaloa cartel, and essentially confined to the downtown area of Ciudad Juarez, recent reports from STRATFOR sources indicate that this is not quite the case. The VCF retains control of the plaza and the border crossings in Juarez, from the Paso Del Norte port of entry on the northwest side to the Ysleta port of entry on the west side of town. However, the VCF’s territory is significantly diminished to the extent that it no longer controls the city of Chihuahua, which is now held by Sinaloa, as is the rest of Chihuahua state and the border zone on both sides of Juarez/El Paso.
As we have discussed in previous cartel reports, VCF second-in-command Vicente Carrillo Leyva has been in Mexican federal custody since his arrest in Mexico City in 2009. He is the son of Amado Carrillo Fuentes, founder of the cartel, and nephew of the current leader (and cartel namesake) Vicente Carrillo Fuentes. On March 15, Carrillo Leyva was formally charged with money laundering, which diminishes the possibility of his eventual release. Given how long he has been detained and the foibles of the Mexican legal system, Carrillo Leyva may yet be released, but it seems doubtful at present.
In the absence of Carrillo Leyva, his right-hand man, Juan “El JL” Luis Ledezma, has been acting as the No. 2 in the organization, running the cartel’s operations and those of its enforcement arm, La Linea. But one of the other high-ranking VCF leaders has been taken out of the mix. On Feb. 22, Luis Humberto “El Condor” Peralta Hernandez was killed during a gunbattle with federal police in Chihuahua City, which removed the leader of the network holding open the cartel’s supply lines. As it stands now, STRATFOR sources indicate that most of the contraband seized by law enforcement on the U.S. side of the border with Chihuahua state is owned by Sinaloa, not the VCF, though the percentage remains unclear.
The VCF is surrounded by Sinaloa-held territory. Barring an unlikely reversal of Sinaloa’s fortunes, such as a massive operation by Los Zetas/VCF with all their allied gangs that successfully routs Sinaloa, the VCF is facing slow strangulation as its supply lines close and its revenue streams dry up. This will not happen overnight or even within the next three months, but as the noose tightens we can expect violence in Juarez to skyrocket beyond its current record-breaking level because the VCF will not go quietly.
In the short term, the inability to move narcotics will cause the VCF to continue to seek operational funding through other means, such as kidnapping, extortion, alien smuggling and cargo theft. We have seen indications of that with a couple of recent nightclub shootings that are thought to have been associated with VCF extortion rackets. As hard as it might be to imagine, the violence in Juarez may actually get worse.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

April 19, 2011 | 1612 GMT
Mexico Security Memo: April 12, 2011

Mass Graves in Tamaulipas


At least 173 bodies have been found in mass graves in Sinaloa, Durango and Tamaulipas states over the past week, though there is little information available on the graves discovered in Sinaloa and Durango. The last official body count available to STRATFOR for the mass graves in San Fernando, Tamaulipas, stands at 145, but that tally may increase as recovery efforts continue.
On April 13, the Mexican government announced a reward of up to 15 million pesos ($1.28 million) for information leading to the capture of Omar Martin “El Kilo” Estrada Luna, an offer that apparently was effective — three days later, Mexican marines arrested the Los Zetas plaza boss and 11 other Zeta operatives. Estrada Luna is believed to be responsible for at least 217 murders in the vicinity of San Fernando, including the 145 people whose bodies were recovered from mass graves over the past week and the 72 migrants killed Aug. 24, 2010, on a ranch outside of San Fernando.
According to the Mexican marines, Estrada Luna has also been implicated in the murders of Juan Carlos Sanchez Suarez, the secretary of public security for San Fernando, and Public Ministry agent Roberto Jaime Suarez Vazquez, the lead investigator of the Aug. 24 mass murder.
In both mass-murder events, migrants headed to northeast Mexico — either to relocate to Tamaulipas state or to cross the border into the United States — were taken at gunpoint by Los Zetas operatives. According to an Ecuadorian survivor of the massacre last summer, the migrants were being press-ganged into working for the cartel and, when they refused, the migrants were killed. The same appears to have been the case with those in the mass graves found last week. Fifty-seven Mexican migrants recently were reported missing by their families after the migrants left Guanajuato state. Their destination was not released, but reportedly the office of the Guanajuato state prosecutor expressed concern that the missing migrants were killed by Los Zetas in San Fernando.
It has been reported that many of the Mexicans forced from cross-country buses at gunpoint on the highways of Tamaulipas since the end of January have been found in graves in San Fernando. A STRATFOR source indicated that all but one of the bodies recovered to date at the San Fernando grave sites were Mexican citizens. Further confirmation has not been made available.
The current conditions in Tamaulipas and Nuevo Leon states are tied to the Mexican government’s deployment of troops there last November. The influx of 3,000 troops led to the attrition of cartel assets and a new reality for Los Zetas, which has had to rebuild its foot-soldier ranks in northeastern Mexico. Still, even though Los Zetas is wounded it remains a formidable force, and the violence between Los Zetas and the Gulf cartel — with its Sinaloa partners — will continue in Mexico’s northeast for the foreseeable future.

Methamphetamine Lab in Baja California


On April 13, a large methamphetamine lab was found 15 kilometers (9.3 miles) south of Ensenada, Baja California state, and dismantled by military forces. Included in the reported inventory were 11.1 kilograms (24.5 pounds) of crystal methamphetamine, 214 kilograms of an unidentified white liquid in nine plastic bags, 2,880 liters (761 U.S. gallons) of precursor chemicals and 51 kilograms of caustic soda.
Given its location, the lab was likely run by elements of the Sinaloa cartel, which controls that part of Mexico. The presence of a sophisticated “super lab” that close to the border is somewhat unusual; such valuable facilities typically are placed farther south to avoid military operations in the border zone. At the same time, the location of the lab so close to the border may explain the large quantities of the synthetic drug seized in the area over the last two months: 928 kilograms of methamphetamine discovered just south of Tijuana the first week of March and 658 kilograms of methamphetamine seized between Mexicali and Tijuana the first week of April.
As we have noted before, cartels typically do not risk such huge losses so close to the border zone, where they tend to ship methamphetamine and cocaine in much smaller quantities. Cartels also tend to protect their labs by isolating them in out-of-the-way places. But the expanding Mexican military and federal police operations on the south side, combined with successful interdiction by U.S. law enforcement north of the border and increased cartel violence in the interior, may have influenced the decision to set up super labs close to the border for expediency, security and logistical simplicity.
Of particular interest in the inventory seized from the lab is the large quantity of white liquid. It is possible that it was liquid methamphetamine, though reports have not yet identified it as such. Though seen less often than the powder or crystallized form of the drug, liquid methamphetamine allows smugglers to conceal and transport the product in different ways. It has been smuggled, for example, in the windshield washer reservoirs or radiators of vehicles and in juice or water bottles. The possibility that such a large quantity of the drug may have been found in liquid form at the Ensenada lab suggests that the lab operators may have been responding to the recent bulk-drug seizures by choosing an alternate method of transport.



April 11


  • Soldiers seized a suspected methamphetamine lab in Zapotitlan, Jalisco state. No arrests were made during the raid.
  • Unidentified gunmen opened fire on several members of a family traveling in a car in the Base Tranquilidad neighborhood of Cuernavaca, Morelos state. The attackers shot the victims as they pulled over, killing one and injuring another.
  • Security forces in Jaltenco, Mexico state, found the bodies of two men in a vacant lot. The victims had been shot in the head and bore signs of torture. A sign containing unspecified threats was found near the bodies.
  • Soldiers and federal police in the Las Fuentes neighborhood of Durango, Durango state, discovered a grave containing the bodies of four people. The bodies were found after an anonymous phone call made to a federal police station.
  • Soldiers in the Los Lermas neighborhood of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, shot and killed Juan Carlos Cordoba Ocana, the suspected leader of Los Zetas in that municipality. Eight kidnapping victims were freed during the operation, which led to roadblocks in Guadalupe and surrounding municipalities by suspected Los Zetas gunmen. Three people were arrested in connection with the roadblocks.

April 12


  • Unidentified gunmen traveling in two vehicles shot and injured a female passenger in a vehicle in the Dos Rios neighborhood of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a prison guard from the Topo Chico prison as he rode his motorcycle in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.

April 13


  • Soldiers arrested three suspected kidnappers and freed four kidnapping victims during a raid in the Cumbres neighborhood in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a lawyer in Minas Viejas, Guerrero state, as he was driving to Iguala de la Independencia. The victim was shot at least 15 times.
  • Military authorities announced the arrest of Victor Hugo Martinez Morales, a suspected financier for Los Zetas, in Saltillo, Coahuila state. Martinez Morales was arrested with eight other suspected members of Los Zetas.
  • The bodies of three men were discovered in Nopaltepec, Mexico state. Two of the victims had their throats slit, while the third had been shot in the head.
  • Mexican Attorney General Marisela Morales said 16 policemen from the municipality of San Fernando, Tamaulipas state, have been arrested for allegedly protecting Los Zetas in San Fernando, including those responsible for the murders of people discovered in mass graves in the city.

April 14


  • Eight bodies were discovered in Cojumatlan de Regules, Michoacan state. The victims had been bound and tortured and each was shot in the head.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured Leonarda Flores Estrada, the commander of the state investigative police operational base in Ciudad Obregon, Sonora state. Flores Estrada was shot as she left her house.
  • Soldiers in Hermosillo, Sonora state, arrested Raul Sabori Cisneros, who is believed to be the second-in-command for the Sinaloa cartel in Sonora state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed three people and injured two others in the San Rafael Chamapa neighborhood of Naucalpan, Mexico state.

April 15


  • Police in Cali, Colombia, arrested Hector Efren Meneses Yela, a suspected former head of the Norte del Valle cartel and associate of the Sinaloa cartel. He was considered the deputy of Colombian cartel leader Javier Antonio Calle Serna.
  • Soldiers shot and killed three suspected cartel gunmen in Montemorelos, Nuevo Leon state, and freed one kidnapped person. The firefight began after the gunmen reportedly opened fire on the soldiers and took refuge in a house.
  • Unidentified people abandoned three dismembered bodies near a church in Hualahuises, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and injured a police officer in the Miravalle neighborhood of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.
  • Soldiers in Tepic, Nayarit state, arrested Bruno Garcia Arreola, who is wanted in the United States for alleged money laundering, arms trafficking and narcotics distribution for the Tijuana and Sinaloa cartels.

April 16


  • The Mexican military announced the arrest of Omar Martin Estrada Luna, a suspected regional chief for Los Zetas who is believed to be responsible for 217 murders in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state. Estrada Luna was arrested along with 11 other suspects in Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas state.
  • Unidentified gunmen shot and killed a man and a woman outside a residence in the Progreso neighborhood of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state.

April 17


  • A dozen human bones were found in an abandoned suitcase near a house being remodeled in the Americana neighborhood of Guadalajara, Jalisco state.
  • Soldiers seized four camps and a clandestine runway reportedly belonging to a drug trafficking cartel in the municipalities of Panuco de Coronado, Oro and Rodeo, Durango state.
  • Construction workers in Pesqueria, Nuevo Leon state, discovered a hidden grave containing the bones of several people.
Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments

April 18, 2011
Mexican security forces arrested 32 people April 16-17 during raids in Tula and Tulancingo, Hidalgo state, including 28 suspected members of Los Zetas, El Universal reported April 18. The suspects are reportedly linked to a Jan. 22 vehicle explosion in El Carmen.
April 15, 2011 | 2156 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor

Vice President of Tactical Intelligence Scott Stewart looks at the potential for an escalation of violence as Mexican drug cartels fight for power and control.

Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


Colin: More than 230 American cities have now been affected by the presence of Mexican drug cartels. This weekend, Australia’s Crime Commission reported that the cartels have taken ahold of organized crime syndicates in cities like Sydney and Melbourne. In Mexico, the seemingly unstoppable violence continues. A few days ago we had the gruesome discovery of at least 116 bodies in mass graves near the city of San Fernando, just 100 miles away from the Texan border. And, perhaps as evidence of more violence to come, we have the erection of concrete car-bomb barriers outside the busy United States consulate in Monterrey.
Welcome to Agenda. Joining me this week to discuss Mexican security is Scott Stewart. Scott, let’s start with this latest security measure. Has this building been targeted before, and is there intelligence that it’s about to be hit by a large car bomb?
Scott: Well first of all yes, the U.S. consulate general in Monterrey has been targeted before by attacks but these have been attacks using hand grenades and small arms, and that’s something different from a large car bomb attack. At this point we don’t believe there is any imminent car bomb threat to that facility, or any other U.S. facilities in Mexico for that matter.
Colin: Why would a cartel want to escalate the battle and invite the further wrath of the United States?
Scott: The Mexican cartels certainly don’t shy away from violence. We see them regularly beheading and dismembering people. However they tend to try to target most of their violence against opponents of the fellow cartels or against government employees, and a lot of times the government employees that they target are actually working for opposition cartels. So there’s really a relation there between the targeting. We have not seen the Mexican cartels really get into widespread attacks against the public at large. They have really tried to target their violence. And in times where we have seen them have incidents where there’s been indiscriminate violence, or violence that has impacted negatively on their public image - things like the Falcon Lake shooting - we have seen the cartels come down hard on operatives that made those mistakes and that brought the heat down upon the cartel.
One thing to remember is that these cartels are not terrorist groups. They are really businesses, and they’re organized crime organizations. So their end is making money. That is their objective. And anything that gets in the way of that objective, bringing down massive heat upon them, is bad for business, and they try to shy away from that sort of activity.
Colin: Are the authorities making any progress in their fight against the cartels?
Scott: Well, I think it depends on how one defines progress. Certainly, they have been arresting the heads of certain cartels and they have been disrupting the operations of some of these cartels. For example, over the last five or six years, organizations such as the Arellano-Felix organization, which is also known as the Tijuana cartel; another organization, the Juarez Cartel or the VCF, Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization; they’ve both been decimated. Likewise, we’ve seen the Beltran Leyva organization decapitated and split up. So, they’re making headway against certain organizations, but at the same time, the largest cartel, Sinaloa cartel, that is headed up by a gentleman by the name of El Chapo, “the short one,” Sinaloa has been getting stronger and stronger. And they are really becoming more of a regional hegemon in the cartel landscape. And right now, they control the border from Tijuana all the way over to Juarez, for the most part. And they are acting to increase their control over that area. So while certain cartels have been weakened, other cartels, like Sinaloa, have become stronger.
Of course, one other measure of progress against the cartels would be violence. And indeed, we have not seen violence come down at all. This fracturing, this splintering of these cartel organizations, has really led to more fighting. What happens is, when a cartel organization has very good control of an area - or what we call a plaza, a smuggling corridor - there’s generally peace in that area. But when they become weakened and another organization comes in and tries to take over there territory, that’s when you see the violence, that’s when you see the fighting. And of course the death toll then will increase. So as some of these organizations have been weakened, others have tried to move in. And that has escalated the violence.
Colin: How safe is it for a businessperson to go to Mexico now, and where should they avoid?
Scott: There are certain hotspots right now. Indeed, in Acapulco at this present time we have a three-way struggle for control of that city between three factions of the former Beltran Leyva organization. One that now calls itself the Cartel del Pacifico Sur, the South Pacific Cartel; another faction has gone on to form this independent cartel of Acapulco; and still another little faction has gone and they’re working with Sinaloa. And so you have these three organizations fighting each other for control of Acapulco, which generally in the past had been a very popular tourist resort.
Likewise, in the Northeast we see a lot of violence right now in places like Monterrey. And one of the reasons that Monterrey is so concerning is because it is really the industrial heart of Mexico. You have not only large Mexican corporations that are headquartered there, but also U.S. companies have gone down into Monterrey in order to manufacture. The things that make Monterrey attractive to businesses, the fact that they have good lines of communication and roads, and then of course lines of communication to the U.S. border to ship stuff, also makes it an ideal place to control as a drug organization. If you can control Monterrey, you can control the flow of a lot of goods and a lot of contraband to the border. So we really expect to see a lot of continued violence in the Northeast in the coming months.
Colin: Scott, thank you. Scott Stewart there, ending Agenda for this week.


Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


This report may be forwarded or republished on your website with attribution to www.stratfor.com
April 13, 2011

Pakistan and the Naxalite Movement in India

By Scott Stewart
On April 5, Mexican newspaper El Universal reported that a row of concrete Jersey barriers was being emplaced in front of the U.S. Consulate General in Monterrey, Mexico. The story indicated that the wall was put in to block visibility of the facility, but being only about 107 centimeters (42 inches) high, such barriers do little to block visibility. Instead, this modular concrete wall is clearly being used to block one lane of traffic in front of the consulate in an effort to provide the facility with some additional standoff distance from the avenue that passes in front of it.
Due to the location and design of the current consulate building in Monterrey, there is only a narrow sidewalk separating the building’s front wall from the street and very little distance between the front wall and the building. This lack of standoff has been long noted, and it was an important factor in the decision to build a new consulate in Monterrey (construction began in June 2010 and is scheduled to be completed in January 2013).
The U.S. Consulate in Monterrey has been targeted in the past by cartels using small arms and grenades. The last grenade attack near the consulate was in October 2010. However, the Jersey barriers placed in front of the consulate will do little to protect the building against small arms fire, which can be directed at portions of the building above the perimeter wall, or grenades, which can be thrown over the wall. Rather, such barriers are used to protect facilities against an attack using a car bomb, or what is called in military and law enforcement vernacular a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device (VBIED).
That such barriers have been employed (or re-employed, really, since they have been used before at the U.S. Consulate in Monterrey) indicates that there is at least a perceived VBIED threat in Mexico. The placement of the barriers was followed by a Warden Message issued April 8 by the U.S. Consulate General in Monterrey warning that “the U.S. government has received uncorroborated information Mexican criminal gangs may intend to attack U.S. law enforcement officers or U.S. citizens in the near future in Tamaulipas, Nuevo Leon and San Luis Potosi.” It is quite possible that the placement of the barriers at the consulate was related to this Warden Message.
The Mexican cartels have employed improvised explosive devices (IEDs) in the past, but the devices have been small. While their successful employment has shown that the cartels could deploy larger devices if they decided to do so, there are still some factors causing them to avoid using large VBIEDs.

Some History


The use of IEDs in Mexico is nothing new. Explosives are plentiful in Mexico due to their widespread use in the country’s mining and petroleum sectors. Because of Mexico’s strict gun laws, it is easier and cheaper to procure explosives — specifically commercial explosives such as Tovex — in Mexico than it is firearms. We have seen a number of different actors use explosive devices in Mexico, including left-wing groups such as the Popular Revolutionary Army and its various splinters, which have targeted banks and commercial centers (though usually at night and in a manner intended to cause property damage and not human casualties). An anarchist group calling itself the Subversive Alliance for the Liberation of the Earth, Animals and Humans has also employed a large number of small IEDs against banks, insurance companies, car dealerships and other targets.
Explosives have also played a minor role in the escalation of cartel violence in Mexico. The first cartel-related IED incident we recall was the Feb. 15, 2008, premature detonation of an IED in Mexico City that investigators concluded was likely a failed assassination attempt against a high-ranking police official. Three months later, in May 2008, there was a rash of such assassinations in Mexico City targeting high-ranking police officials such as Edgar Millan Gomez, who at the time of his death was Mexico’s highest-ranking federal law enforcement officer. While these assassinations were conducted using firearms, they supported the theory that the Feb. 15, 2008, incident was indeed a failed assassination attempt.
Mexican officials have frequently encountered explosives, including small amounts of military-grade explosives and far larger quantities of commercial explosives, when they have uncovered arms caches belonging to the cartels. But it was not until July 2010 that IEDs began to be employed by the cartels with any frequency.
On July 15, 2010, in Juarez, Chihuahua state, the enforcement wing of the Juarez cartel, known as La Linea, remotely detonated an IED located inside a car as federal police agents were responding to reports of a dead body inside a car. The attack killed two federal agents, one municipal police officer and an emergency medical technician and wounded nine other people. Shortly after this well-coordinated attack, La Linea threatened that if the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration and Federal Bureau of Investigation did not investigate and remove the chief of the Chihuahua state police intelligence unit — who La Linea claimed was working for the Sinaloa Federation — the group would deploy a car bomb containing 100 kilograms (220 pounds) of explosives. The threat proved to be an empty one, and since last July, La Linea has deployed just one additional IED, which was discovered by police on Sept. 10, 2010, in Juarez.
The Sept. 10 incident bore a striking resemblance to the July 15 Juarez bombing. The device was hidden in a vehicle parked near another vehicle that contained a dead body that was reported to police. The Sept. 10 device appears to have malfunctioned, since it did not detonate as first responders arrived. The device was noticed by authorities and rendered safe by a Mexican military explosive ordnance disposal team. This device reportedly contained a main charge of 16 kilograms of Tovex, and while that quantity of explosives was far smaller than the 100-kilogram device La Linea threatened to employ, it was still a significant step up in size from the July 15 IED. Based upon the amount of physical damage done to buildings and other vehicles in the area where the device exploded, and the lack of a substantial crater in the street under the vehicle containing the device, the July 15 IED appears to have contained at most a couple of kilograms of explosives.
Seemingly taking a cue from La Linea, the Gulf cartel also began deploying IEDs in the summer of 2010 against law enforcement targets it claimed were cooperating with Los Zetas, which is currently locked in a heated battle with the Gulf cartel for control of Mexico’s northeast (see the map here for an understanding of cartel geographies). Between August and December 2010, Gulf cartel enforcers deployed at least six other IEDs against what they called the “Zeta police” and the media in such cities as Ciudad Victoria in Tamaulipas state and Zuazua in Nuevo Leon. However, these attacks were all conducted against empty vehicles and there was no apparent attempt to inflict casualties. The devices were intended more as messages than weapons.
The employment of IEDs has not been confined just to the border. On Jan. 22, a small IED placed inside a car detonated near the town of Tula, Hidalgo state, injuring four local policemen. Initial reports suggested that local law enforcement received an anonymous tip about a corpse in a white Volkswagen Bora. The IED reportedly detonated when police opened one of the vehicle’s doors, suggesting either some sort of booby trap or a remotely detonated device.
The damage from the Tula device is consistent with a small device placed inside a vehicle, making it similar to the IEDs deployed in Juarez and Ciudad Victoria in 2010. The setup and the deployment of the IED in Tula also bear some resemblance to the tactics used by La Linea in the July 2010 Juarez attack; in both cases, a corpse was used as bait to lure law enforcement to the scene before the device was detonated. Despite these similarities, the distance between Tula and Juarez and the makeup of the cartel landscape make it unlikely that the same group or bombmaker was involved in these two incidents.

Car Bombs vs. Bombs in Cars


The IEDs that have been detonated by the Mexican cartels share a very common damage profile. The frames of the vehicles in which the devices were hidden remained largely intact after detonation and damage to surrounding structures and vehicles was relatively minor, indicating the devices were rather small in size. The main charges were probably similar to the device found in a vehicle recovered from an arms cache in Guadalajara, Jalisco state, on Sept. 10, 2010 — a liquor bottle filled with no more than a kilogram of commercial explosives.
In fact, most of the devices we have seen in Mexico so far have been what we consider “bombs in cars” rather than “car bombs.” The difference between the two is one of scale. Motorcycle gangs and organized crime groups frequently place pipe bombs and other small IEDs in vehicles in order to kill enemies or send messages. However, it is very uncommon for the police investigating such attacks to refer to these small devices as car bombs or VBIEDs. As the name implies, “vehicle borne” suggests that the device is too large to be borne by other means and requires a vehicle to convey it to the target. This means the satchel device that prematurely detonated in Mexico City in February 2008 or the liquor-bottle charge recovered in Guadalajara in September 2010 would not have been considered VBIEDs had they been detonated in vehicles. None of the devices we have seen successfully employed in Mexico has been an actual VBIED, as defined by those commonly used in Iraq, Pakistan or Afghanistan — or even Colombia in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
The only explosive device we have seen that even remotely approached being considered a VBIED was the 16-kilogram device discovered in Juarez in September 2010. This means that those who are referring to the devices deployed in Mexico as VBIEDs are either mistaken or are intentionally hyping the devices. Claiming that the cartels are using “car bombs” clearly benefits those who are trying to portray the cartels as terrorists. As we’ve discussed elsewhere, there are both political and practical motives for labeling the Mexican drug cartels terrorists rather than just vicious criminals.
That said, the Vicente Carrillo Fuentes organization and the Gulf cartel have demonstrated that they can construct small devices and remotely detonate them using cellphones, Futaba radio-control transmitters and servos (as have the still unidentified groups responsible for the Tula attack and the radio-controlled device recovered in Guadalajara in September 2010). Once an organization possesses the ability to do this, and has access to large quantities of explosives, the only factor that prevents it from creating and detonating large VBIED-type devices is will.
In the late 1980s and early 1990s in Colombia, powerful Colombian drug trafficking organizations such as the Medellin cartel used large-scale terrorist attacks in an effort to get the Colombian government to back off on its counternarcotics efforts. Some of the attacks conducted by the Medellin cartel, such as the December 1989 bombing of the Colombian Administrative Department of Security, utilized at least 450 kilograms of explosives and were incredibly devastating. However, these attacks did not achieve their objective. Instead, they served to steel the will of the Colombian government and also caused the Colombians to turn to the United States for even more assistance in their battle against the Colombian cartels.
A U.S. government investigator who assisted the Colombian government in investigating some of the large VBIED attacks conducted by the Medellin cartel notes that Medellin frequently employed Futaba radio-control devices in its VBIEDs like those used for model aircraft. A similar Futaba device was recovered in Guadalajara in September 2010, found wired to the explosives-filled liquor bottle inside the car. This may or may not provide the Mexican authorities with any sort of hard forensic link between the Mexican and Colombian cartels, but it is quite significant that the Futaba device was used in an IED in Mexico with a main explosive charge that was much smaller than those used in Colombia.
On April 1, 2011, the Mexican military discovered a large arms cache in Matamoros. In addition to encountering the customary automatic weapons, grenades and rocket-propelled grenade launchers, the military also seized 412 chubs (plastic sleeves) of hydrogel commercial explosives, 36 electric detonators and more than 11 meters of detonation cord. (The Mexican government did not provide photos of the explosives nor the weight of the material recovered, but chubs of gel explosives can range in size from less than half a kilogram to a couple of kilograms in weight.) This means there were at least a hundred kilograms of explosives in the cache, enough to make a sizable VBIED. Given that the cache was located in Matamoros and appears to have been there for some time, it is likely that it belonged to the Gulf cartel. This, like other seizures of explosives, indicates that the reason the Gulf cartel has used small explosive devices in its past attacks is not due to lack of explosives or expertise but lack of will.

Assessing the Threat


When assessing any threat, two main factors must be considered: intent and capability. So far, the Mexican cartels have demonstrated they have the capability to employ VBIEDs but not the intent. Discerning future intent is difficult, but judging from an actor’s past behavior can allow a thoughtful observer to draw some conclusions. First, the Juarez cartel has been hard-pressed by both the Mexican government and the Sinaloa Federation, and it is desperately struggling to survive. Despite this, the leaders of that organization have decided not to follow through with their threats from last July to unleash a 100-kilogram VBIED on Juarez. The Juarez cartel is not at all squeamish about killing people and it is therefore unlikely that the group has avoided employing VBIEDs for altruistic or benevolent reasons. Clearly, they seem to believe that it is in their best interests not to pop off a VBIED or a series of such devices.
Although the Juarez cartel is badly wounded, the last thing it wants to do is invite the full weight of the U.S. and Mexican governments down upon its head by becoming the Mexican version of Pablo Escobar’s Medellin cartel, which would likely happen should it begin to conduct large terrorist-style bombings. Escobar’s employment of terrorism backfired on him and resulted not only in his own death but also the dismantlement of his entire organization. A key factor in Escobar’s downfall was that his use of terrorism not only affected the government but also served to turn the population against him. He went from being seen by many Colombians as almost a folk hero to being reviled and hated. His organization lost the support of the population and found itself isolated and unable to hide amid the populace.
Similar concerns are likely constraining the actions of the Mexican cartels. It is one thing to target members of opposing cartels, or even law enforcement and military personnel, and it is quite another to begin to indiscriminately target civilians or to level entire city blocks with large VBIEDs. While the drug war — and the crime wave that has accompanied it — has affected many ordinary Mexicans and turned sentiment against the cartels, public sentiment would be dramatically altered by the adoption of true terrorist tactics. So far, the Mexican cartels have been very careful not to cross that line.
There is also the question of cost versus benefit. So far, the Mexican cartels have been able to use small IEDs to accomplish what they need — essentially sending messages — without having to use large IEDs that would require more resources and could cause substantial collateral damage that would prompt a public-opinion backlash. There is also considerable doubt that a larger IED attack would really accomplish anything concrete for the cartels. While the cartels will sometimes conduct very violent actions, most of those actions are quite pragmatic. Cartel elements who operate as loose cannons are often harshly disciplined by cartel leadership, like the gunmen involved in the Falcon Lake shooting.
So while the U.S. Consulate in Monterrey may be erecting Jersey barriers to protect it from VBIED attacks, it is likely doing so based on an abundance of caution or some bureaucratic mandate, not hard intelligence that the cartels are planning to hit the facility with a VBIED.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
April 12, 2011
Mexican soldiers shot and killed Juan Carlos Cordoba Ocana, the suspected head of Los Zetas in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, during a firefight April 11 in the San Sebastian Los Lerma neighborhood, El Universal reported April 12. The soldiers were reportedly fired upon by members of Los Zetas while responding to an unspecified citizen’s complaint in the neighborhood.
April 12, 2011
The Mexican cartel Los Zetas is responsible for the murders of approximately 120 people found in several mass graves in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state, Mexican Prosecutor General Marisela Morales said April 12, El Universal reported. Seventeen people have been arrested in connection with the murders.
April 11, 2011
Unidentified gunmen set up approximately 12 roadblocks using stolen vehicles following a firefight that left one dead, one injured and one arrested in the Los Lerma neighborhood of Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, El Universal reported April 11. The first roadblocks were set up at approximately 2:30 p.m. local time and extended to the municipalities of Apodaca, Guadalupe and Monterrey. An unconfirmed Twitter report indicated that three people were arrested in Apodaca for participating in the roadblocks.
April 11, 2011
Unidentified gunmen on April 11 used several vehicles to block at least four roads in Guadalupe, Nuevo Leon state, Milenio reported. At least one of the roadblocks was cleared after several minutes.
April 7, 2011
Mexican authorities seized approximately 38 tons of ethyl phenyl acetate, a precursor for chemical drug manufacturing, in Manzanillo, Colima state, El Universal reported April 7. The chemicals were located on a ship from Shanghai and were allegedly bound for Mexico City.
April 7, 2011
Mexican authorities arrested 14 people in connection with the discovery of 59 bodies in eight mass graves in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state, according to a security spokesman, El Universal reported April 7. The suspects were arrested in raids on April 1 and April 6, the spokesman said
April 6, 2011
A mass grave containing 43 bodies was found in San Fernando, Tamaulipas state, according to Mexican military authorities, El Universal reported April 6.
April 6, 2011
Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos said if there are no judicial inconveniences, suspected drug trafficker Walid Makled will be extradited to Venezuela, Globovision reported April 6. Santos said the planned extradition to Venezuela would go on if the Interior Ministry does not see a problem with it.
April 5, 2011
Mexican federal police officers arrested suspected Los Zetas member Jose Manuel Garcia Soto on April 2 for allegedly being linked to the death of a U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement Agent in February, El Universal reported April 5. Garcia Soto was arrested with five suspected criminals. Four kidnap victims were freed during the raid.
April 4, 2011
U.S. prosecutors identified two U.S. citizens that were shot to death in their vehicle April 4 as they waited to enter the United States at a Tijuana-area border crossing, AP reported. A gunman approached the line of vehicles waiting at the San Ysidro border crossing and fired into the men’s pickup truck, according to witnesses, prosecutors in Baja California state said.
April 4, 2011
Soldiers in the Loma Dorada neighborhood of Tijuana, Baja California state arrested two men in possession of approximately 658 kg of methamphetamine, El Universal reported April 4. The men also had 75 kilograms of cocaine and approximately 3.6 million pesos.
March 2011
March 30, 2011
U.S. and Guatemalan agents arrested Juan Ortiz-Lopez, Guatemala’s top drug trafficker, in his Quetzaltenango home March 30, Reuters reported. Two men “lightly guarded” the Ortiz-Lopez home, the Guatemalan Interior Ministry stated. The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration considers Ortiz-Lopez as Guatemala’s most important drug smuggler, according to a U.S. prosecutor indictment. Ortiz-Lopez and his associates may be extradited to the United States.
March 29, 2011
An engineer for Mexican state-run energy firm Petroleos Mexicanos was kidnapped by a group of armed men in San Agustin Tlaxiaca, Hidalgo state, Milenio reported March 29. Security forces continued to search for the alleged kidnappers after the worker was freed.
March 23, 2011
Mexican authorities have detained Victor Manuel Felix, an in-law of Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman, who allegedly ran a transnational drug operation that reached as far as Ecuador, AP reported March 23, citing Mexican federal police. Felix allegedly ran a financial network for the Sinaloa cartel. Eight other people were arrested at the same time as Felix in raids in three Mexican states. Authorities in Ecuador have conducted raids on six properties after being provided information by Mexican authorities, leading to the arrest of nine additional suspects. Those arrested are suspected of being in an organization that was responsible for buying and storing cocaine and exporting it to Mexico, Ecuadorian police said.
March 22, 2011
Jose Maria Leal Pantoja, the suspected head of Los Zetas in San Luis Potosi, San Luis Potosi state, was arrested on March 12, according to Mexico’s National Defense Secretariat, La Jornada reported March 22. Leal Pantoja was arrested in the Rivas Guillen neighborhood of Soledad de Graciano Sanchez municipality. He is believed to be the successor to Julian Zapata, the previous local head of Los Zetas and alleged participant in a Feb. 15 attack that killed U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement Agent Jaime Zapata.
March 22, 2011
Federal police officers in Leon, Guanajuato state, arrested Jose Natividad Cortes Balcazar, also known as Ricardo Gomez Segoviano, a top leader of drug trafficking cartel La Familia Michoacana (LFM) in Leon, Milenio reported March 22. Cortes Balcazar was arrested on the Paseo del Jerez Boulevard in Leon.
March 19, 2011
Gunmen stormed a nightclub in Mexico’s Pacific resort city of Acapulco early March 19 and opened fire, killing 10 people and wounding four more, Mexican police said, AFP reported. Guerrero state’s Ministry of Public Security said the victims were men between the ages of 25 and 45.
March 18, 2011
Mexican gunmen killed U.S. citizen Josue Reyes Castro late March 17 while he was visiting a relative’s home in a low-income neighborhood of Ciudad Juarez, AP reported March 18. Two family members were wounded in the attack.
March 16, 2011
The Mexican government is under control of U.S. unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) operations to fly over Mexico to gather intelligence on drug traffickers, AP reported March 16, citing a Mexican National Security Council statement. The UAVs have flown at the request of the Mexican government, and have mainly been done along the U.S.-Mexico border, the statement said. The operations are being done with the authorization, oversight and supervision of Mexican national agencies, including the Mexican air force, the statement said, adding that Mexico defines the objectives, the information to be gathered and the tasks for which the UAVs will be used.
March 16, 2011
Soldiers in the Mexcian municipality of Miguel Aleman, Tamaulipas state, seized approximately 5 tons of marijuana from an abandoned building during an operation March 14, El Universal reported March 16.
March 16, 2011
In February 2011, the United States began sending high-altitude unarmed Global Hawk unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) deep into Mexican territory to gather intelligence on major drug traffickers and their networks and the information was turned over to Mexican law enforcement agencies, according to American and Mexican officials, The New York Times reported March 16. U.S. President Barack Obama and Mexican President Felipe Calderon formally agreed to the UAV surveillance flights March 3, as the flights had previously been kept secret due to Mexican legal restrictions and political sensitivities about sovereignty. Obama administration officials said a U.S. Homeland Security UAV helped Mexican authorities locate several suspects linked to the Feb. 15 killing of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agent Jaime Zapata. Obama and Calderon agreed to open a counternarcotics “fusion” center to facilitate coordination between U.S. and Mexican law enforcement agencies.
March 10, 2011
Eleven people were arrested in a drug and weapons raid in Columbus, New Mexico, AP reported March 10. The arrested include Mayor Eddie Espinoza, Police Chief Angelo Vega and councilman Blas Gutierrez. The raid included agents from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives and the Drug Enforcement Administration.
March 10, 2011
Banners appearing in Morelia, Zitacuaro and Apatzingan, Michoacan state, announced the presence of a new gang calling itself the Knights Templar, AP reported March 10. The signs said that the Knights Templar will replace La Familia Michoacana (LFM) and prevent other gangs from taking over the state. The signs said the group offers its services to defend Michoacan residents and will take on the role previously performed by LFM. It also said it is committed to keeping order; preventing robberies, kidnappings and extortions; and protecting the state from rival gangs.
March 9, 2011
Mexican authorities arrested Mario Jimenez Perez, suspected finance chief of the Los Zetas cartel in San Luis Potosi state, on March 5 in connection with the killing of a U.S. agent, AP reported March 9. Sixteen other suspects were arrested and no further details were given about Jimenez’s alleged involvement in the killing.
March 8, 2011
18 people were killed in Mexico’s Tamaulipas state on March 7 when two criminal groups in the Abasolo town center opened fire on each other, a government representative said, AFP reported March 8. Meanwhile, some cartels have entered a non-aggression pact, according to Marcos Carmona, aka “El Cabrito,” an alleged leader of the Zetas cartel in Oaxaca state, the Public Safety Ministry said. Carmona told authorities Los Zetas, run by former elite soldiers, have a non-aggression pact with Juarez, Tijuana and the Beltran Leyva brothers’ cartels.
March 7, 2011
Mexican federal police have arrested suspected Independent Cartel of Acapulco head Benjamin Flores Reyes (aka El Padrino) and six other suspects in Acapulco, Guerrero state, on March 6, El Universal reported March 7. Flores Reyes reportedly controlled the distribution of drugs and managed the cartel’s lookout groups and allegedly reported directly to cartel chief Moises Montero Alvarez (aka El Koreano).
March 4, 2011
The Mexican army has ordered three junior officers and 10 soldiers to stand trial on drug trafficking and organized crime charges, AP reported March 4. The suspects were arrested at a military checkpoint south of Tijuana after it was found they were possessing 928 kilograms (2,042 pounds) of methamphetamine and 30 kilograms of cocaine.
March 2, 2011
Mexican authorities are continuing investigations at a mass grave in the municipality of San Miguel Totolapan, Guerrero state, and discovered three more bodies on March 2, El Universal reported. At least 18 bodies had been discovered at the grave on March 1 and some March 1 military reports indicated that 70-100 bodies might be located at the grave and in surrounding areas, Milenio reported.
March 1, 2011
Unidentified gunmen used five stolen vehicles on March 1 to block roads in the metropolitan area of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon state Milenio reported. The roadblocks were reported on the Ruiz Cortines and Churubusco avenues between San Nicolas and Monterrey, on the Miguel Aleman and Acapulco roads between San Nicolas and Guadalupe in Apodaca and on the Juarez avenue in Guadalupe.
March 1, 2011
Mexican military forces and police freed former Tierra Blanca Mayor Alfredo Osorio from kidnappers holding him in Cuitlahuac, Veracruz state, AP reported March 1, citing Veracruz Gov. Javier Duarte de Ochoa. The kidnappers fled the raid, and security forces are searching for them in the nearby city of Cordoba. Osorio had been kidnapped Feb. 28.
March 1, 2011
The United States arrested 678 gang members and associates, including 421 foreign nationals, tied to foreign drug traffickers in an operation dubbed “Project Southern Tempest,” Immigration and Customs Enforcement Director John Morton said, Bloomberg reported March 1. The operation ran from December 2010 to February 2011, during which federal and local law enforcement in 168 U.S. cities arrested people from 13 gangs linked to Mexican drug organizations, Morton said. Authorities also arrested 164 people for criminal and administrative immigration violations, Morton added. CBS/AP reported that the arrested gang members are allegedly associated with drug trafficking organizations in Mexico, South America, Central America, the Caribbean and Asia. During the arrests, agents seized 86 firearms, eight pounds of methamphetamine, 30 pounds of marijuana, one pound of cocaine, more than $70,000 in U.S currency and two vehicles.
February 2011
February 24, 2011
Mexican authorities confirmed the death of Luis Humberto “El Condor” Peralta Hernandez, a leader of La Linea, the enforcement arm of the Juarez cartel, La Jornada reported Feb. 24. Peralta was killed Feb. 22 during a confrontation with Mexican Federal Police in the city of Chihuahua.
February 24, 2011
Federal, state and local authorities conducted a sweep of suspected Mexican drug cartels in the United States on Feb. 24 following the killing of a U.S. agent in Mexico, AP reported. The move is intended to send a message to the cartels that the murder of a U.S. agent will not be tolerated, according Drug Enforcement Administration official Chris Pike. The raids will likely continue and will target suspected criminals with ties to Mexican drug cartels. Agents have so far seized more than $4.5 million in cash, 10.4 kilograms (23 pounds) of methamphetamine, 107 kilograms of cocaine, 2.27 kilograms of heroin, 136 kilograms of marijuana and nearly 20 guns, and have arrested more than 100 people in150 different locations. Pike said many of those arrested were already suspects in other investigations.
February 23, 2011
The U.S. Treasury Department has designated Colombian national Jorge Milton Cifuentes Villa and more than 70 other individuals and entities in Cifuentes Villa’s drug-trafficking and money laundering organization, prohibiting U.S. citizens from conducting financial or commercial transactions with those individuals and entities, a U.S. Treasury press release said Feb. 23. Any assets belonging to the designees under U.S. jurisdiction have been frozen. Cifuentes Villa leads a drug-trafficking organization with operations in Colombia, Mexico, Ecuador, Panama and Spain that is closely allied with the Sinaloa cartel.
February 23, 2011
Mexican soldiers have arrested one person suspected of participating in the murder of U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement agent Jaime Zapata in San Luis Potosi state on Feb. 15, El Universal reported Feb. 23.
February 23, 2011
U.S. President Barack Obama has made plans to meet with Mexican President Felipe Calderon, AFP reported Feb. 23, citing a White House statement. El Universal, citing unnamed sources, reported that the meeting is scheduled for March 3.
February 22, 2011
Mexican President Felipe Calderon denied that a lack of coordination was undermining the fight against drug cartels, instead blaming the rivalry between U.S. intelligence agencies, according to El Universal, Reuters reported Feb. 22. The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, CIA, and Immigration and Customs Enforcement constantly attempt to outdo one another while refusing to take responsibility, Calderon said. U.S. Ambassador to Mexico Carlos Pascual has demonstrated “ignorance” about events in the country and distorted reality, Calderon added.
February 17, 2011
Rep. Michael McCaul said that new information suggests that the killing of U.S. Immigration agent Jaime Zapata was a hit by the Zetas drug cartel, CNN reported Feb. 17. Federal immigration officials briefed McCaul, saying that Zapata and U.S. Immigration agent Victor Avila were returning to Mexico City from a meeting with U.S. officials in Monterrey and stopped at a Subway restaurant in San Luis Potosi. Afterward, as they were driving, two vehicles believed to be carrying members of the Zetas forced the officers off the road by braking in front of them. According to reports, the agents’ doors automatically unlocked when they put the car in park. In the struggle to lock the doors, the vehicle’s window was partially rolled down. Zapata and Avila told the 10-15 gunmen that they were American diplomats, and the gunmen opened fire through the cracked window. Investigators recovered 83 shell casings at the scene.
February 16, 2011
Mexican Prosecutor General of the Republic Arturo Chavez Chavez said that 13 suspected members of the Los Zetas cartel had been arrested and bank accounts containing more than 16 million pesos ($1.3 million) seized, El Universal reported Feb. 16. The group is suspected of exporting more than 3,519 metric tons of natural gas condensate illegally to the United States from 2007-2008, which provided the cartel with 508.54 million pesos.
February 16, 2011
Mexican security forces arrested two police officers for alleged involvement in the death of Homero Salcido Trevino, Mexico’s Public Security Secretariat C-5 center commissioner, Milenio reported Feb. 16. One of the officers arrested had been a member of Salcido Trevino’s security detail.
February 16, 2011 | 1642 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor Update

Vice President of Tactical Intelligence Scott Stewart examines the attack on two Immigration and Custom agents in Mexico on Feb. 15 and explains why the case is not likely to cause a strong response from the U.S. Government.
Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.
Here at STRATFOR we’re closely watching an incident that happened on Feb. 15 in which two special agents of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency, or ICE, were shot in an incident in San Luis Potosi, Mexico.
The incident occurred yesterday afternoon as the two agents were traveling in a late-model suburban north of Mexico City in the state of San Luis Potosi, very close to the city by that same name. the reports that we’ve received so far indicate that the two agents were stopped at what they thought was a military checkpoint along the road, and as they pulled their armored vehicle over to the side of the road and rolled down their window, one of the gunmen who was manning the checkpoint opened fire on them, killing the driver and wounding the second agent.
Many people and the press are going to make parallels between this case and the case of Kiki Camarena, a DEA agent who was killed back in 1985. However the circumstances surrounding these two incidents are quite different. The Camarena case was very intentional and the bosses of the Guadalajara cartel had Camarena specifically targeted and kidnapped. Once he was kidnapped then they tortured him, revived him using a medical doctor, and tortured him some more in order to try to get information pertaining to the source network he was running in Mexico. The Camarena case was very brutal, very intentional and of course raised a lot of ire on the American side of the border. The DEA launched a huge operation called Operation Leyenda, or legend, to go after the jefes of the Guadalajara cartel.
Now in this current case it appears that what we had, were two ICE agents who were traveling in a vehicle that was very attractive for the cartels. We know really that the vehicles the cartels covet the most for their operations are the large crew cab pickup trucks. Indeed we saw some missionaries attacked a couple weeks ago, as they were traveling on a highway and they tried to escape a carjacking attempt by the cartels who wanted that vehicle.
As we look at the circumstances surrounding this case it really appears that it was a case of being in the wrong place at the wrong time for the agents and that it was really a case of cartel, low-level cartel gunmen responding to encountering two U.S. law-enforcement agents inside that vehicle when they stopped at the checkpoint. Therefore we don’t think that it was an intentional case planned by high-level cartel planners. Certainly there’s always more that the U.S. government can do in Mexico, but they’re restrained by the sovereignty of Mexico and really the sensibilities of the Mexican people to American incursion, they really see Americans as a threat. So the bottom line is while the U.S. will respond to this case, we really don’t think we will see the urgency and severity of the U.S. response that we did in the Camarena case.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


This report may be forwarded or republished on your website with attribution to www.stratfor.com
February 15, 2011
Two U.S. Immigration and Customs officers were shot in Mexico on Feb. 15, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano stated, adding that one died after being critically wounded and one was wounded and remains in stable condition, CNN reported. The agents’ names were not immediately released.
February 15, 2011
Suspected members of Los Zetas hung three banners in Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas state, blaming the Gulf cartel for attacks in Padilla that killed 18 people, Reforma reported Feb. 15. The banners’ text claimed that the Gulf cartel took out its frustrations on civilians because it felt defeated. Eleven civilians and 7 suspected gunmen were killed in Padilla on Feb. 13.
February 15, 2011
Two U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents have been shot in Mexico, said an anonymous spokeswoman from the U.S. Embassy in Mexico City, AP reported Feb.15. The agents were attacked while driving between Mexico City and Monterrey, the spokeswoman added. El Universal reported that the agents were shot and seriously injured by alleged thieves, citing a U.S. diplomatic source. The agents were treated at an unidentified hospital.
February 15, 2011
On two occasions in late 2010, gunmen claiming to represent a powerful drug cartel threatened to attack isolated natural gas well drillers if they did not pay to operate in parts of northern Mexico, two industry sources said, Reuters reported Feb. 15. Men carrying automatic weapons reportedly drove onto work sites in the Burgos basin in Tamaulipas and Nuevo Leon where new gas wells were to be constructed. According to a senior executive of the company overseeing the construction of the wells, the gunmen threatened to kill the workers unless their employer paid protection money to the Zetas.
February 14, 2011
Unidentified gunmen shot and killed at least 18 people Feb. 13 in Padilla, Tamaulipas state, Milenio reported Feb. 14. The gunmen attacked an intercity bus, killing one person and five members of a family traveling in a vehicle. At least seven people were killed in the town’s central plaza. The attackers also shot at the local courthouse and the city hall.
February 12, 2011
Armed men opened fire and threw a grenade at a nightclub called Butter in Guadalajara, Mexico, killing six and wounding 37, local law enforcement officials said Feb. 12, AP reported. The assailants reportedly drove up in a Jeep Cherokee and a taxi, after which they exited the vehicles and began the attack. Medical Services Director Yannick Nordin confirmed the deaths.
February 10, 2011

Fanning the Flames of Jihad

By Scott Stewart
For several years now, STRATFOR has been closely watching developments in Mexico that relate to what we consider the three wars being waged there. Those three wars are the war between the various drug cartels, the war between the government and the cartels and the war being waged against citizens and businesses by criminals.
In addition to watching tactical developments of the cartel wars on the ground and studying the dynamics of the conflict among the various warring factions, we have also been paying close attention to the ways that both the Mexican and U.S. governments have reacted to these developments. Perhaps one of the most interesting aspects to watch has been the way in which the Mexican government has tried to deflect responsibility for the cartel wars away from itself and onto the United States. According to the Mexican government, the cartel wars are not a result of corruption in Mexico or of economic and societal dynamics that leave many Mexicans marginalized and desperate to find a way to make a living. Instead, the cartel wars are due to the insatiable American appetite for narcotics and the endless stream of guns that flows from the United States into Mexico and that results in Mexican violence.
Interestingly, the part of this argument pertaining to guns has been adopted by many politicians and government officials in the United States in recent years. It has now become quite common to hear U.S. officials confidently assert that 90 percent of the weapons used by the Mexican drug cartels come from the United States. However, a close examination of the dynamics of the cartel wars in Mexico — and of how the oft-echoed 90 percent number was reached — clearly demonstrates that the number is more political rhetoric than empirical fact.

By the Numbers


As we discussed in a previous analysis, the 90 percent number was derived from a June 2009 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report to Congress on U.S. efforts to combat arms trafficking to Mexico (see external link).
According to the GAO report, some 30,000 firearms were seized from criminals by Mexican authorities in 2008. Of these 30,000 firearms, information pertaining to 7,200 of them (24 percent) was submitted to the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) for tracing. Of these 7,200 guns, only about 4,000 could be traced by the ATF, and of these 4,000, some 3,480 (87 percent) were shown to have come from the United States.

Mexico's Gun Supply and the 90 Percent Myth
This means that the 87 percent figure relates to the number of weapons submitted by the Mexican government to the ATF that could be successfully traced and not from the total number of weapons seized by Mexican authorities or even from the total number of weapons submitted to the ATF for tracing. In fact, the 3,480 guns positively traced to the United States equals less than 12 percent of the total arms seized in Mexico in 2008 and less than 48 percent of all those submitted by the Mexican government to the ATF for tracing. This means that almost 90 percent of the guns seized in Mexico in 2008 were not traced back to the United States.
The remaining 22,800 firearms seized by Mexican authorities in 2008 were not traced for a variety of reasons. In addition to factors such as bureaucratic barriers and negligence, many of the weapons seized by Mexican authorities either do not bear serial numbers or have had their serial numbers altered or obliterated. It is also important to understand that the Mexican authorities simply don’t bother to submit some classes of weapons to the ATF for tracing. Such weapons include firearms they identify as coming from their own military or police forces, or guns that they can trace back themselves as being sold through the Mexican Defense Department’s Arms and Ammunition Marketing Division (UCAM). Likewise, they do not ask ATF to trace military ordnance from third countries like the South Korean fragmentation grenades commonly used in cartel attacks.
Of course, some or even many of the 22,800 firearms the Mexicans did not submit to ATF for tracing may have originated in the United States. But according to the figures presented by the GAO, there is no evidence to support the assertion that 90 percent of the guns used by the Mexican cartels come from the United States — especially when not even 50 percent of those that were submitted for tracing were ultimately found to be of U.S. origin.
This point leads us to consider the types of weapons being used by the Mexican cartels and where they come from.

Types and Sources of Guns


To gain an understanding of the dynamics of the gun flow inside Mexico, it helps if one divides the guns seized by Mexican authorities from criminals into three broad categories — which, incidentally, just happen to represent three different sources.

Type 1: Guns Legally Available in Mexico


The first category of weapons encountered in Mexico is weapons available legally for sale in Mexico through UCAM. These include handguns smaller than a .357 magnum such as .380, .38 Super and .38 Special.
A large portion of this first type of guns used by criminals is purchased in Mexico, or stolen from their legitimate owners. While UCAM does have very strict regulations for civilians to purchase guns, criminals will use straw purchasers to obtain firearms from UCAM or obtain them from corrupt officials. It is not uncommon to see .38 Super pistols seized from cartel figures (a caliber that is not popular in the United States), and many of these pistols are of Mexican origin. Likewise, cartel hit men in Mexico commonly use .380 pistols equipped with sound suppressors in their assassinations. In many cases, these pistols are purchased in Mexico, the suppressors are locally manufactured and the guns are adapted to receive the suppressors by Mexican gunsmiths.
It must be noted, though, that because of the cost and hassle of purchasing guns in Mexico, many of the guns in this category are purchased in the United States and smuggled into the country. There are a lot of cheap guns available on the U.S. market, and they can be sold at a premium in Mexico. Indeed, guns in this category, such as .380 pistols and .22-caliber rifles and pistols, are among the guns most commonly traced back to the United States. Still, the numbers do not indicate that 90 percent of guns in this category come from the United States.
Additionally, most of the explosives the cartels have been using in improvised explosive devices (IEDs) in Mexico over the past year have used commercially available Tovex, so we consider these explosives to fall in this first category. Mexican IEDs are another area where the rhetoric has been interesting to analyze, but we will explore this topic another time.

Type 2: Guns Legally Available in the U.S. but Not in Mexico


Many popular handgun calibers, such as 9 mm, .45 and .40, are reserved for the military and police and are not available for sale to civilians in Mexico. These guns, which are legally sold and very popular in the United States, comprise our second category, which also includes .50-caliber rifles, semiautomatic versions of assault rifles like the AK-47 and M16 and the FN Five-Seven pistol.
When we consider this second type of guns, a large number of them encountered in Mexico are likely purchased in the United States. Indeed, the GAO report notes that many of the guns most commonly traced back to the United States fall into this category. There are also many .45-caliber and 9 mm semiautomatic pistols and .357 revolvers obtained from deserters from the Mexican military and police, purchased from corrupt Mexican authorities or even brought in from South America (guns made by manufacturers such as Taurus and Bersa). This category also includes semiautomatic variants of assault rifles and main battle rifles, which are often converted by Mexican gunsmiths to be capable of fully automatic fire.
One can buy these types of weapons on the international arms market, but one pays a premium for such guns and it is cheaper and easier to simply buy them in the United States or South America and smuggle them into Mexico. In fact, there is an entire cottage industry that has developed to smuggle such weapons, and not all the customers are cartel hit men. There are many Mexican citizens who own guns in calibers such as .45, 9 mm, .40 and .44 magnum for self-defense — even though such guns are illegal in Mexico.

Type 3: Guns Not Available for Civilian Purchase in Mexico or the U.S.


The third category of weapons encountered in Mexico is military grade ordnance not generally available for sale in the United States or Mexico. This category includes hand grenades, 40 mm grenades, rocket-propelled grenades, automatic assault rifles and main battle rifles and light machine guns.
This third type of weapon is fairly difficult and very expensive to obtain in the United States (especially in the large numbers in which the cartels are employing them). They are also dangerous to obtain in the United States due to heavy law-enforcement scrutiny. Therefore, most of the military ordnance used by the Mexican cartels comes from other sources, such as the international arms market (increasingly from China via the same networks that furnish precursor chemicals for narcotics manufacturing), or from corrupt elements in the Mexican military or even deserters who take their weapons with them. Besides, items such as South Korean fragmentation grenades and RPG-7s, often used by the cartels, simply are not in the U.S. arsenal. This means that very few of the weapons in this category come from the United States.
In recent years the cartels (especially their enforcer groups such as Los Zetas, Gente Nueva and La Linea) have been increasingly using military weaponry instead of sporting arms. A close examination of the arms seized from the enforcer groups and their training camps clearly demonstrates this trend toward military ordnance, including many weapons not readily available in the United States. Some of these seizures have included M60 machine guns and hundreds of 40 mm grenades obtained from the military arsenals of countries like Guatemala.
But Guatemala is not the only source of such weapons. Latin America is awash in weapons that were shipped there over the past several decades to supply the various insurgencies and counterinsurgencies in the region. When these military-grade weapons are combined with the rampant corruption in the region, they quickly find their way into the black arms market. The Mexican cartels have supply-chain contacts that help move narcotics to Mexico from South America and they are able to use this same network to obtain guns from the black market in South and Central America and then smuggle them into Mexico. While there are many weapons in this category that were manufactured in the United States, the overwhelming majority of the U.S.-manufactured weapons of this third type encountered in Mexico — like LAW rockets and M60 machine guns — come into Mexico from third countries and not directly from the United States.
There are also some cases of overlap between classes of weapons. For example, the FN Five-Seven pistol is available for commercial purchase in the United States, but the 5.7x28 armor-piercing ammunition for the pistol favored by the cartels is not — it is a restricted item. However, some of the special operations forces units in the Mexican military are issued the Five-Seven as well as the FN P90 personal defense weapon, which also shoots the 5.7x28 round, and the cartels are obtaining some of these weapons and the armor-piercing ammunition from them and not from the United States. Conversely, we see bulk 5.56 mm and 7.62 mm ammunition bought in the United States and smuggled into Mexico, where it is used in fully-automatic AK-47s and M16s purchased elsewhere. As noted above, China has become an increasingly common source for military weapons like grenades and fully automatic assault rifles in recent years.
To really understand Mexico’s gun problem, however, it is necessary to recognize that the same economic law of supply and demand that fuels drug smuggling into the United States also fuels gun smuggling into Mexico. Black-market guns in Mexico can fetch up to 300 percent of their normal purchase price — a profit margin rivaling the narcotics the cartels sell. Even if it were somehow possible to hermetically seal the U.S.-Mexico border and shut off all the guns coming from the United States, the cartels would still be able to obtain weapons elsewhere — just as narcotics would continue to flow into the United States from other places. The United States does provide cheap and easy access to certain types of weapons and ammunition, but as demonstrated by groups such as the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, weapons can be easily obtained from other sources via the black arms market — albeit at a higher price.
There has clearly been a long and well-documented history of arms smuggling across the U.S.-Mexico border, but it is important to recognize that, while the United States is a significant source of certain classes of weapons and ammunition, it is by no means the source of 90 percent of the weapons used by the Mexican cartels, as is commonly asserted.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


Reprinting or republication of this report on websites is authorized by prominently displaying the following sentence at the beginning or end of the report, including the hyperlink to STRATFOR:
"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"
February 9, 2011
Mexican federal police Feb. 5 in Queretaro state arrested Adan Salazar Zamorano, a Sinaloa cartel associate accused of controlling the production and trafficking of drugs in the states of Durango, Chihuahua and Sinaloa, Milenio reported Feb. 9.
February 7, 2011
Federal police officers in Mexico’s Sonora state seized an estimated 3.9 tons of marijuana and 18 kgs of methamphetamine from a truck transporting oil on the PGLV-Tijuana highway, El Universal reported Feb. 7. The driver was arrested.
February 4, 2011
A Warden Message was issued by the U.S. Consulate General in Guadalajara Feb. 4 to announce a marked escalation of criminal activity in the Guadalajara metropolitan area. In light of the changing security situation, the consulate has now prohibited U.S. government officials from traveling after dark between Guadalajara and the Guadalajara International Airport and recommends that U.S. citizens consider similar precautions. The consulate’s prohibition on intercity travel for U.S. government officials after dark remains in force.
February 4, 2011
The United States has arrested 21 people for allegedly helping the Colombian North Valley cartel collect proceeds from cocaine shipped to Puerto Rico and the United States, AP reported Feb. 4. The suspects were arrested in Colombia, Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, New York, Miami and the U.S. Virgin Islands, a statement from the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement office said. One of the suspects arrested in Colombia was the network’s main money broker, the statement said. U.S. Attorney Rosa Emilia Rodriguez said the suspects will be extradited to Puerto Rico.
February 3, 2011 | 2132 GMT
Click on image below to watch video:
Stratfor Update

Vice President of Intelligence Fred Burton examines the tactics and implications of the Feb. 2 killing of a high-ranking Nuevo Laredo official.
Editor’s Note: Transcripts are generated using speech-recognition technology. Therefore, STRATFOR cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.
At STRATFOR we’ve noticed a recent uptick in cartel violence in Nuevo Laredo. Yesterday on February 2, at around midnight, the director for citizen security, Manuel Farfan Carriola, was assassinated on his route from the office to home. Also killed were four bodyguards and numerous police officers were also shot and wounded.
Unfortunately for those of you who have been following the STRATFOR analysis on cartels in Mexico, this should come as no surprise. The cartels are very skilled at carrying out these kinds of attacks. They learn of routes and schedules through corruption and compromise. They also are very detailed in their ability to execute the plan on the street. They utilize multiple vehicles, they block intersections, they at times can also muster corrupt cops to help them with the attacks. They use taxicabs for surveillance platforms and they wait for the target to come into the kill zone and have a complete command and control over how the operation goes down. And in essence, the VIP’s protective detail are stuck with their inability to escape. Our intelligence indicates that the most likely perpetrator of this attack, last night, was the Zeta organization.
It also tracks with our analysis from a tactical perspective on how the Zetas carry out assassinations. As we’ve seen with previous attacks by the Zetas, their operations are very complex and very violent and, in essence, they have absolutely no problem targeting senior public safety officials and police chiefs. The symbolism of attacking and killing a very senior public safety official resonates not only through the Mexican government, but U.S. law enforcement and inside the beltway in Washington, D.C. It raises serious protective security concerns on the ability of the Mexican government to be able to adequately protect public officials.

Give us your thoughts
on this report

For Publication

Not For Publication

Read comments on
other reports

Reader Comments


This report may be forwarded or republished on your website with attribution to www.stratfor.com
February 3, 2011
Members of an unidentified armed group shot and killed retired Mexican Gen. Manuel Farfan Carriola, the municipal director of citizen security for Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas state, Reforma reported Feb. 3. Farfan Carriola was shot in the Matamoros neighborhood Feb. 2 after leaving the public security headquarters. Two members of his security detail were also killed and six police officers were injured in the attack, Hoy Laredo reported.
February 1, 2011
Federal police in Mexico’s Acapulco, Guerrero state, arrested on Jan. 31 Miguel Lopez Vasquez, the suspected chief of gunmen from the Independent Cartel of Acapulco, for his alleged involvement in the murders of 20 Michoacan state tourists in September 2010 and 15 decapitations in Acapulco in January.
February 1, 2011
The U.S. Treasury Department on Feb. 1 designated Los Gueros, a Mexican drug trafficking organization that is part of the Sinaloa Federation, as a Specially Designated Narcotics Trafficker, according to a statement released by the department. The designation targets key figures of both groups, including brothers Luis Rodriguez Olivera and Esteban Rodriguez Olivera of the Sinaloa Federation, as well as their brothers in Los Gueros, Daniel Rodriguez Olivera and Miguel Rodriguez Olivera.
January 2011
January 26, 2011
Venezuelan Interior and Justice Minister Tareck El Aissami met with Colombian Defense Minister Rodrigo Rivera on Jan. 26 and signed an agreement to share intelligence in order to identify and disband drug trafficking organizations, counter money laundering activities, coordinate drug interdiction efforts, and conduct joint criminal investigations, El Espectador reported.
anuary 25, 2011
The Mexican Defense Ministry announced Jan. 25 one of the main regional leaders of Los Zetas drug-trafficking organization was shot and killed in Nuevo Leon state during a series of clashes with Mexican soldiers, BNO News reported. The leader, known as “Comandante Lino,” was killed in Escobedo municipality, along with two others Los Zetas members.
January 25, 2011
La Familia announced that is disbanding in Michoacan state, Mexico, because it has been “unjustly blamed,” Reforma.com reported Jan. 25. It called for Mexican President Felipe Calderon to investigate members of his Cabinet, including Public Security Secretary Genaro Garcia Luna, for giving him bad advice. The cartel said it has fought rapists and kidnappers in recent years. Banners appeared early Jan. 25 in Patzcuaro, Tzintzuntzan, Quiroga, Santa Clara del Cobre and Apatzingan. The government had not issued a statement, although the banners were being removed almost immediately after they appeared.
January 24, 2011
Police in the Melchor Ocampo neighborhood of Tepeji, Hidalgo state, discovered a suspected improvised explosive device under a vehicle, El Universal reported Jan. 24. The device, which consists of a cylinder with a fuse, was covered in masking tape, authorities said.
January 22, 2011
Four Mexican police officers were injured Jan. 22 when a small IED exploded in a car in the Tula Hidalgo municipality, El Universal reported. Police received a call reporting that a body was found in an abandoned car. The explosion occurred when police attempted to open the vehicle’s door.
January 21, 2011
Mexican soldiers confiscated 245 kilos (540 pounds) of opium from a home in the town of Chilpancingo in Guerrero state, AFP reported Jan. 21, citing the Secretariat of National Defense.
January 20, 2011
A suspected top operative, Leonardo Vazquez, aka “El Pacis,” of the Zetas drug cartel died on Jan. 19 during a confrontation with Mexican military, federal, state and local police forces in Poza Rica in the state of Veracruz, AP reported Jan. 20, citing Veracruz Governor Javier Duarte de Ochoa.
January 19, 2011
Nuevo Leon state prosecutor Alejandro Garza y Garza said that the separate attacks that destroyed two cars outside police stations in Linares and San Nicolas de los Garza, Nuevo Leon state, were not vehicle-borne improvised explosive devices and were likely smaller explosive devices, El Universal reported Jan. 19. Garza y Garza said that an explosive device composed of a tube with a fuse was used in the attack in San Nicolas de los Garza and that witnesses to both attacks observed smoke coming out of the vehicles prior to the explosions.
January 19, 2011
Soldiers in the Leon Moderno neighborhood of Leon, in Mexico’s Guanjuato state, defused an improvised explosive device outside a Red Cross post, La Policiaca reported Jan. 19. No arrests were made.
January 19, 2011
Two vehicles exploded outside police stations in Linares and San Nicolas de los Garza, Nuevo Leon state, Mexico, on Jan. 18, Milenio reported Jan. 19. A police officer was injured in the Linares explosion and a patrol car was damaged. A Nuevo Leon state public security spokesman said that the explosions were not caused by improvised explosive devices within the vehicles and suggested that they might have been grenades.
January 18, 2011
Mexican security forces arrested Flavio Mendez, alias “El Amarillo,” a suspected leader and founding member of drug-trafficking cartel Los Zetas, and his alleged bodyguard in Oaxaca state, W Radio reported Jan. 18.
January 14, 2011
Unconfirmed reports indicated that at least 16 people were killed in a firefight between soldiers and suspected cartel gunmen in Xalapa, Veracruz state, El Universal reported Jan. 14. The incident began late Jan. 13 in the Higueras neighborhood and lasted approximately five hours.
January 14, 2011
Mexican military authorities announced that 12 suspected cartel gunmen and two soldiers were killed in a firefight in Xalapa, Veracruz state, Milenio reported Jan. 14. The incident began when unidentified people opened fire on police and soldiers from a house in the Casa Blanca neighborhood.
January 13, 2011
Unidentified gunmen killed Luis Jimenez Mata, the mayor of Santiago Amoltepec, Oaxaca state, Mexico, at his residence, El Universal reported Jan. 13. The attackers reportedly arrived at the mayor’s house and shot him as he answered the door.
January 12, 2011
Mexico’s National Defense Secretary identified a suspect arrested four days ago in Tijuana, Baja California state, as Rigoberto Andrade Renteria, a principal drug trafficker for cartel La Familia Michoacana (LFM), El Universal reported Jan. 12. Andrade Renteria acted under direct orders from LFM leaders Servando Gomez Martinez and Jesus Mendez Vargas and was responsible for trafficking drugs into the United States from clandestine laboratories in Michoacan state, according to El Universal.
January 7, 2011
The Mexican government is expected to announce Cabinet changes Jan. 7, El Universal reported. Communications and Transport Secretary Juan Molinar Horcasitas will be replaced by Deputy Treasury Secretary Dionisio Perez Jacome, and Energy Secretary Georgina Kessel will be designated head of the Bank of Works and Public Services and replaced by Deputy Treasury Secretary Jose Antonio Meade.
January 7, 2011
Mexican authorities discovered the body of Saul Vara Ribera, the mayor of Zaragoza, Coahuila state, in the municipality of Galeana, Nuevo Leon state, Milenio reported Jan. 7. Vara Ribera was shot to death and had been reported missing since Jan. 5.
January 5, 2011
Mexican police and soldiers arrested suspected Sinaloa cartel leader Jesus Israel de la Cruz Lopez in Tijuana, Baja California state, El Universal reported Jan. 5. Lopez is believed to have been one of the cartel’s leaders in Tijuana after the arrest of Teodoro Garcia Simental.
January 4, 2011
Mexican drug cartel Los Zetas set up a base in the Guatemalan border province of Alta Verapaz, where the government has been waging a military offensive since Dec. 19, 2010, AP reported Jan. 4, citing Guatemalan Interior Minister Carlos Menocal. Menocal said the offensive is making progress, and authorities have seized $40,000 in cash as well as airplanes from Los Zetas.
January 3, 2011
The Sinaloa Federation has two armed groups totaling 40 to 60 people that are dedicated to marijuana and cocaine production in the Piura region of Peru, La Republica reported Jan. 3, citing a report by a Peruvian regional district attorney’s office. The groups are reportedly from Guayaquil and Cariamanga, Ecuador, and are led by a Colombian citizen.

For Intel Archives prior to January 2011, please email info@sjsci.org or call 505-599-1492 to request copies